Back to California Paid Family Leave

Margot Quinn

Paid family leave zero benefit amount — employer not withholding SDI

So I finally filed my PFL bonding claim through SDI Online last week after my daughter was born, uploaded her birth certificate the same day, and now I'm looking at a Notice of Computation that shows zero as my potential weekly benefit amount. I'm completely lost. I've been at this job for about 14 months and I genuinely had no idea my employer wasn't taking SDI out of my checks this whole time. I went back through my pay stubs and there's no CASDI deduction anywhere. Does this mean I just don't get anything? Is there any way to fix this or am I completely out of luck for PFL? I feel sick about this because we were counting on that money.

The zero on the Notice of Computation almost certainly comes down to no SDI wages in your base period. To qualify for PFL you need at least $300 in wages with CASDI withheld. If those deductions never happened, EDD sees no eligible wages and the weekly benefit calculates as zero. The question you need to put to EDD is whether your employer was classified correctly and whether you were misclassified as exempt. That's not something you can fix by uploading anything to SDI Online.

0 coins

Thank you, so do I call EDD directly about this or is this more of a situation where I'd go after my employer somehow?

0 coins

Both, honestly. Phone EDD to confirm exactly what base period wages they see on your record, and separately talk to the Labor Commissioner's office about the withholding issue. Those are two different fights.

0 coins

Ok I didn't realize they were separate. I'll start with EDD tomorrow morning.

0 coins

Eleven days after my bonding claim went in, the payment date still wasn't showing anywhere in SDI Online, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my first payment had been issued on a specific date I hadn't expected, and that my debit card would arrive separately. What you're describing is a different problem, but getting an agent on the line to look at your actual wage record is exactly the kind of thing that's hard to sort out any other way.

0 coins

The wage record piece is what I'd want to ask about. I'm going to try Claimyr for my own claim. What should I have ready when I get on with an agent?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your employer's name and address, and the dates of your pay periods. The agent will want to know what quarters they're looking at.

0 coins

I've been trying that EDD number most mornings this week and it disconnects every single time before I get through. Good to know there's another route.

0 coins

Your employer was supposed to withhold CASDI from every paycheck. If they didn't, that's on them, not you, but EDD still calculates your benefit from whatever wages show up with that withholding, so the zero is real for now. The Labor Commissioner handles employer violations of the withholding requirement. It's a whole mess but it's not unsolvable.

0 coins

So there's actually a path to making this right, it's just not through EDD itself?

0 coins

The withholding enforcement goes through the Labor Commissioner. EDD's side is the benefit calculation. You'd need the employer issue resolved before EDD could recalculate anything.

0 coins

This happened to someone I know in a different context, the employer misfiled their status. It took a while but it did eventually get corrected. Keep all your pay stubs.

0 coins

Have you verified what base period EDD is looking at? The base period for a PFL claim is based on a 12-month period of four quarters, using wages earned roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. If you started this job 14 months ago and filed last week, some or all of your quarters might have little to no CASDI wages even if the deductions had been correct. Worth confirming before you assume it's entirely the employer's fault.

0 coins

Honestly I hadn't even thought about that angle. How do I figure out exactly which quarters EDD looked at?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation should give you enough to work backward, or you can ask EDD directly. They can tell you exactly which quarter showed wages with CASDI and what that quarter totaled.

0 coins

The base period explanation is on EDD's site under the PFL benefit amount section. EDD's calculator there can also give you an estimate if you plug in your wages, though with zero CASDI wages it'll confirm the same thing.

0 coins

You got ripped off by your employer plain and simple. 14 months and not one CASDI deduction. File the complaint with the Labor Commissioner and document everything, every stub, every deposit.

0 coins

Yeah I'm pretty angry about it honestly. I'll pull every stub I have.

0 coins

Keep the original stubs or PDFs, don't just screenshot them. You'll want the actual documents if this goes anywhere official.

0 coins

I want to make sure you know that PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way some people think, so once the wage issue gets sorted there's no extra unpaid week sitting in front of your benefits. That's one less thing to stress about. The bigger problem is still the employer withholding situation.

0 coins

Wait, does that mean if I had normal CASDI on my stubs I'd already be getting paid?

0 coins

Pretty much, yeah. No waiting period for PFL. Benefits would start from the first day of leave if EDD approved the claim.

0 coins

my coworker thought there was a week wait for pfl and i told him he was mixing it up with disability

0 coins

Eight weeks on the clock and I've used four of them already with my son. I wasn't sure if the remaining weeks could carry over past his first birthday, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about how many of the eight weeks I still had in my 12 months. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed I had exactly four weeks left and that they had to be used before the date 12 months after his birth. That 12-month window is strict.

0 coins

The 12-month window matching my situation was what caught my eye there. I've used Claimyr too, and once the agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and what date the next one was due, I went into SDI Online and saw the same payment lined up. It matched exactly what she said.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that line for three days now. mornings, afternoons. nothing.

0 coins

Three days is brutal. I tried for about a week before I found another way through.

0 coins

There's something important here for anyone reading who might be in a similar spot: being misclassified as an independent contractor when you should be an employee is one of the more common reasons CASDI never gets withheld. If that's what happened, the AB5 employee classification rules in California might be relevant. The Labor Commissioner's office and the EDD itself have processes for misclassification complaints. It's worth asking your employer directly first whether they classified you as exempt or as a contractor.

0 coins

I am definitely a W-2 employee, so the contractor thing isn't it. I genuinely think they just made an error or skipped it.

0 coins

If you're a W-2 employee and no CASDI was withheld, that's a cleaner case for the Labor Commissioner. The withholding was legally required.

0 coins

Payroll errors like this do happen. I've seen it in my office. Usually a payroll vendor misconfigures something and no one catches it for months.

0 coins

EDD sees what's in their wage records. Zero wages with CASDI withheld, zero benefit. That's not a judgment, it's math. The fix lives upstream at the employer level.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD isn't going to bend the formula because someone's employer dropped the ball.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate. The employer problem has to be addressed first.

0 coins

Had an issue with my payment method on my PFL bonding claim showing the wrong setup in SDI Online, and I talked to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it. The agent confirmed my payment was set for the debit card and that I could update to direct deposit right inside SDI Online if I wanted to switch before the next payment issued!

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on EDD's phone line in your place, so when a live agent picks up your phone rings and you're the one talking to them. I wanted to ask EDD about whether my payment method was going to cause a delay, and that's what the agent answered.

0 coins

Got it. I'd want to ask about why my own claim is still pending 11 days in. Might give it a shot.

0 coins

Fourteen months is enough time to have wages in the base period if the deductions had been there, so I think the core problem really is the missing CASDI line on your stubs. My wife's claim went through fine and her base period only needed one good quarter, anyway.

0 coins

Right, that's what makes me so frustrated. The wages were there, the deduction just never happened.

0 coins

That's the employer's problem to fix. Document the conversation when you bring it up with them, anyway.

0 coins

Ask EDD to confirm in writing, through the Request Claim Update in SDI Online, exactly which quarters they reviewed and what CASDI wages appeared. Having that on record helps when you go to the Labor Commissioner.

0 coins

I didn't know I could get that in writing through SDI Online. That's a good idea.

0 coins

In SDI Online you pick your claim, then Request Claim Update, choose the type and write your question. They respond through the system.

0 coins

Getting the wage record confirmed in writing is smart. The Labor Commissioner will want specifics.

0 coins

my boss tried to tell me once that the casdi wasnt required because we were part time. thats wrong right

0 coins

Part-time doesn't exempt wages from CASDI. The requirement is based on the type of employment, not the hours. If you're a regular W-2 employee your wages should have that deduction regardless of how many hours you work.

0 coins

yeah figured he was just making stuff up. ill check my stubs

0 coins

Always worth checking. A lot of people assume part-time changes things and it doesn't for CASDI.

0 coins

Two weeks after filing my care claim for my dad, I still wasn't sure if I'd started the 41-day clock on the right date. I tried the EDD line probably six or seven times before I used Claimyr to get through. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file, which matched what I had entered, so my Part D was still within the window.

0 coins

Six or seven times is a lot before getting through. Honestly I'm not sure I believe any service actually gets you a live person on that line. I tried for two weeks on my own care claim and never got past the recorded message.

0 coins

I thought the same thing before I tried it. The agent I spoke with knew exactly what was on my claim and answered the start date question directly. She was EDD's own staff.

0 coins

My cousin's claim had a question about the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification timing and an agent confirmed the DE 2500E date that was on file. It was a real EDD conversation.

0 coins

Alright, two people saying it worked is enough for me to try. My Part D situation is still unresolved.

0 coins

Update from me: I called my payroll department today and apparently they've been using an old classification code that marked me as exempt. They said it was a payroll vendor error. They're going to issue corrected W-2s and work with EDD to get the CASDI remitted. I'm still not sure how long this takes but at least there's a path.

0 coins

That's a real development. Corrected wage reports going to EDD can eventually update your base period record, which could change that zero on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Keep every email and document from payroll. You'll want the paper trail if EDD needs to verify the correction later.

0 coins

An actual error they're fixing is a much cleaner situation than a deliberate misclassification. That's genuinely good news.

0 coins

While you wait for the employer correction to go through, make sure you're not missing the 41-day filing window for your bonding claim. The claim has to be in no later than 41 days after your leave started or you lose benefits. If you already filed, you're fine, but if the pending zero notice made you think there's nothing to file, that clock is still running.

0 coins

I did already file, it's just showing zero right now. Good to know the deadline still matters even in this situation.

0 coins

Right, the claim is in and the deadline is met. You'd just be waiting for the wage record to get corrected on the employer's end.

0 coins

The 41-day rule is in EDD's own guide and it doesn't pause for employer errors. Filing was the right move regardless of the zero.

0 coins

Does the 12-month window for using bonding benefits get affected at all if the original claim shows zero because of the wage issue? Like does the clock still start from the birth date?

0 coins

The 12-month window is tied to the birth date regardless of what the claim shows now. If the wage record gets corrected and EDD recalculates, the bonding weeks still have to be used within 12 months of the birth. So the correction needs to happen sooner rather than later.

0 coins

This is something I hadn't even thought to ask. So basically I need this resolved within the year or the weeks expire anyway.

0 coins

That's the practical reality, yes. The birth date is the anchor for the 12-month window.

0 coins

Employer made an error that costs you months of family leave pay and their fix is 'we'll work on it.' I'd put the Labor Commissioner complaint in writing today, not after you see whether payroll follows through.

0 coins

This. Don't wait to see if they actually do it. File the complaint now and let the fix happen in parallel.

0 coins

Filing the complaint while also accepting their correction sounds like the right move. I'll do both.

0 coins

The original question here about the zero benefit amount from an employer not withholding SDI is something a lot of people don't even realize can happen until they file. Your situation is actually helping a lot of people reading this understand to check their stubs before they ever need to file a claim.

0 coins

checked mine after reading this thread. casdi is there every check. relieved.

0 coins

Same, I went right to my last stub. Never actually looked at that line before.

0 coins

If the corrected W-2s and employer remittance go through, EDD should eventually send a new Notice of Computation reflecting the updated wages. That's the document you'd want to watch for in SDI Online or by mail. It's not an approval, just the revised calculation.

0 coins

So I'd be looking for a new Notice of Computation once the correction processes? Good to know what to watch for.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you disagree with anything on it once it arrives, you have 30 days to appeal with the DE 1000A form.

0 coins

The appeal window being 30 days from the notice is worth flagging. Easy to let that slip by while you're waiting on the employer side of things.

0 coins

I'm in a different situation but this thread answered something I'd been confused about too. I thought each type of leave, bonding and care, got its own separate eight weeks. So if I took eight weeks bonding I'd have another eight available for a care claim later?

0 coins

That's actually not how it works. The eight weeks is one shared limit across bonding, care and military assist together within any 12-month period. If you used eight weeks bonding, you've used your full allotment for that 12-month stretch.

0 coins

Oh wow, I had that completely wrong. So I need to be a lot more careful about how I use the weeks I have left.

0 coins

A lot of people assume there's a separate bank for each claim type. EDD's own guide is clear that it's one combined pool of eight weeks per 12-month period.

0 coins

Just to close the loop on the job protection piece since someone might wonder: PFL pays the benefit but EDD itself says it doesn't protect your job. If you need job protection while you're out, that's a CFRA or FMLA question for your employer, not EDD. I learned that the hard way.

0 coins

I actually did ask my HR about this already and they said I'm covered under CFRA. So at least that piece is handled separately.

0 coins

Good that you asked HR directly. CFRA is your employer's territory, EDD only handles the payment side.

0 coins

CFRA and PFL running at the same time is really common but people don't always realize they have to ask the employer about the job protection part separately.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure