Back to California Paid Family Leave

Yuki Tanaka

Paid family leave paid while on SDI — do I have to pay back the overlap?

So I think I messed up and I'm trying to figure out how bad the damage is. I was on a disability claim for my own health issue, and somewhere in the middle of it I also filed a PFL bonding claim because my partner and I had a baby. I didn't realize you couldn't collect both at the same time — I honestly thought they were two separate buckets of money that could run together. Now I'm seeing some notices from EDD and I'm worried this is going to turn into an overpayment situation where I have to pay back one of them. Has anyone been through this? What actually happens when paid family leave is paid while on SDI and you end up with an overlap like that? Do they always make you pay it back, or is there any grace here?

Intermittent days reporting tripped me up in a way that could have gone the same direction! I was mixing up which weeks I'd worked and which I hadn't, and I was scared EDD would see it as an overlap and flag my PFL claim for overpayment. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me talking to an actual EDD agent after the phone line had shut me out for days. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my DE 2580GF and confirmed which days had been reported and which were still showing open — she said I'd need to report the three days I'd gone back part-time before EDD could process those weeks, so I went into SDI Online and got that sorted the same afternoon.

0 coins

Wait, what even is Claimyr? I've been redialing that 877 number since Tuesday and getting cut off every single time.

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD so you don't have to, then your phone rings once a live agent picks up — that's basically the whole thing. What would you even ask them about?

0 coins

Oh interesting. Mine is about whether my proof of relationship document got matched to my bonding claim, because SDI Online just says pending and I uploaded the birth certificate four days ago.

0 coins

To add some context to my original question — the DI claim was for me, not for a family member, and it ended before I realized PFL had already kicked in for a week of overlap. So it's not like I was on both for months, just one week where both were technically active. Does that change anything?

0 coins

The rule as I understand it is that PFL and Disability Insurance can't pay for the same days — EDD is pretty clear that you get one at a time. If there's a week where both issued payments, EDD will typically ask for one of them back through an overpayment notice.

0 coins

That tracks with what's on EDD's site. The Paid Family Leave guide says PFL is not paid for the same days as DI. One week of overlap would still generate a notice even if the rest of the claim was clean.

0 coins

So the notice I got IS the overpayment notice then. I was hoping it was something else. How do I know which payment they want back — the DI one or the PFL one?

0 coins

The notice itself will say which program and which week is in question. Read it carefully — it also comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) and you have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal if you think the amount is wrong.

0 coins

EDD sent me an overpayment notice once for a week I genuinely didn't work at all, and fighting it was a nightmare. If yours is a real overlap though, they're not going to let it go — that's just not how they operate.

0 coins

That's what I figured. Did you end up appealing yours?

0 coins

I did. Filed the DE 1000A within the 30 days, explained the situation in writing. It took a while but they corrected it. If you actually owe it though, appealing just delays the inevitable.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something — are DI and PFL really that separate? I thought PFL was part of SDI. So how can you be on both if one is part of the other?

0 coins

They're in the same SDI program but they cover different things. DI pays when you can't work because of your own illness or injury. PFL pays when you're bonding with a new child or caring for a sick family member. They're funded the same way but they're separate claims and EDD won't pay both for the same day.

0 coins

Oh that makes so much more sense. So the CASDI on my check funds both but I can only use one at a time. Got it. I was about to file both simultaneously for my husband who just came home from a hospital stay and I'm so glad I read this first.

0 coins

Filing both at once would definitely have caused you a headache. Good catch.

0 coins

You owe the week. Pay it. Easier than fighting it and losing anyway.

0 coins

Yeah I'm leaning that way too. It's one week, not a fortune. I just wanted to understand what I was paying back before I did it.

0 coins

Read the notice, pay the amount on it, done. Don't let it sit or they'll start collecting it off future payments.

0 coins

Can I ask something kind of related? I'm on PFL right now for my mom who's been having some health issues and I'm terrified of accidentally creating an overpayment. Like what even triggers one? Is it just the overlap thing or are there other ways to accidentally end up owing EDD?

0 coins

The most common ones I've seen come up here are the DI and PFL overlap like the original post, and also not reporting wages when you go back to work part time. If you work any days while on PFL and don't report them on the Continued Claim Certification, EDD can come back later and call that an overpayment.

0 coins

I haven't gone back to work at all, I'm fully out right now. But I didn't know about the reporting requirement for part-time — I was going to try to pick up a couple of shifts next week without telling EDD because I figured it wouldn't matter.

0 coins

Please report those days. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, and you fill in what you worked and what you earned. Not doing it is exactly what causes overpayments.

0 coins

Thank you. I had no idea. I genuinely thought only full going-back-to-work needed to be reported.

0 coins

Overpayment notices aren't always worth fighting unless the math is wrong or EDD made the error. If you caused the overlap, the appeal will just confirm you owe it.

0 coins

I appreciate the honesty. I think I caused it by not understanding the rules when I filed. So my plan is just to pay the week back and move on.

0 coins

Sensible. Check the amount on the notice matches what you actually received for that week before you pay.

0 coins

Got a DE 2514 in the mail last month on my bonding claim and totally panicked. Used Claimyr to reach EDD because three mornings of trying that phone line got me nowhere. Agent looked up the determination and explained it was because my proof of relationship hadn't been received when they processed the claim — once I sent in the birth certificate it got cleared up.

0 coins

Oh man, Claimyr worked for me too and I am still relieved about it. I called because I wasn't sure about the payment method on my PFL — I'd set up direct deposit but SDI Online didn't seem to show it was active. Agent confirmed direct deposit was on file and told me my first payment had already been issued to it. I just had to wait for it to clear.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether the deposit had a date attached to it, or just that it was issued?

0 coins

She said it was issued on a specific date — I didn't write it down but it was two days before I called, so I knew to watch for it in my account. It did come through.

0 coins

Glad that worked out. The DE 2514 scared me because I didn't know it was a denial until I looked it up. I thought it was just another form they send everyone.

0 coins

both at the same time is wild lol. i did a bonding claim right after my partners disability claim wrapped up and edd was pretty clear they couldnt run together. we staggered them

0 coins

That's the smart way to do it. I didn't know to stagger them at the time, so here I am sorting out the aftermath.

0 coins

yeah edd doesnt really warn you upfront. you just kind of have to know

0 coins

The appeal window is 30 days from the notice date, not 30 days from when you receive it. Watch for that if you're considering it.

0 coins

Is that written on the notice itself or do you have to look it up?

0 coins

It's on the notice. The Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, is attached to it. The date the notice is issued is what starts the clock.

0 coins

I'm going to read mine a lot more carefully tonight. I glanced at it and got scared and put it down.

0 coins

Pay attention to whether the notice asks for the DI payment back or the PFL one. Sometimes people assume wrong and send the wrong amount.

0 coins

That's a really good point. I'll check which program the overpayment is attributed to before I do anything.

0 coins

Exactly. It'll be in the first paragraph. Keep the notice after you pay too.

0 coins

Sent in my partner's bonding claim birth certificate weeks ago and the status still wasn't updating. Used Claimyr to ask EDD about it — the agent said the proof of relationship had been received and was matched to the claim but the status in SDI Online just hadn't refreshed yet. Payment issued the next business day.

0 coins

Honestly that sounds like it could just be an ad. I've been skeptical of anything that promises to get you through EDD's line because that line is impossible.

0 coins

I had the same doubt, tried it anyway after two weeks of not getting through. Agent looked up my receipt number and confirmed EDD had everything they needed — I just had to wait out the standard processing. It wasn't magic, it was just actually getting a person on the phone.

0 coins

Two weeks of not getting through would do it for me too. I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

Just to be precise about the overlap question: EDD says you can't receive PFL and DI for the same calendar days. The overlap amount comes out of whichever claim paid for those days second. The notice will show the exact days and the daily amount, which is one seventh of the weekly benefit.

0 coins

One seventh per day — I didn't know that's how they break it down. So for one week of overlap it would be seven days times one seventh of my weekly rate, which is basically just the weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Exactly. If you have your Notice of Computation you can see your weekly benefit amount there, and that's what the overpayment for one full week of overlap would equal.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of similar where she was collecting PFL for her dad and then he passed away and EDD kept paying for a few days after. She got an overpayment notice for those days. She just paid it.

0 coins

That's such a painful situation on top of an already terrible time. Glad she was able to just pay it and not have to fight.

0 coins

Yeah she said fighting it felt like too much. The amount was small so she just took care of it.

0 coins

My first PFL payment was three weeks late according to what I'd expected and I could not get anyone on that phone to explain why. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask, and the agent pulled up the payment date — turns out it had been issued on time but I'd given SDI Online an old bank account number for direct deposit so it bounced back.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything specific to redirect the payment to the right account, or did EDD just hold it until you corrected the banking info?

0 coins

Agent told me to update the direct deposit info in SDI Online and EDD would reissue to the corrected account. I went straight in and fixed it after the call.

0 coins

been trying that line since monday. four mornings, same result — gets busy and cuts off. maybe ill actually try what youre describing

0 coins

Does California EDD ever waive overpayments or is it always pay it back no matter what?

0 coins

You can appeal and explain your circumstances, but promising a waiver isn't something anyone here should do — EDD decides those. The DE 1000A is the form and you have 30 days from the notice date.

0 coins

Okay. So the appeal form doubles as a waiver request sort of?

0 coins

Not exactly — the appeal is to dispute the overpayment itself. If you agree you owe it but can't pay, that's a separate conversation with EDD. But the specifics of how they handle hardship cases are really something to ask them directly.

0 coins

EDD doesn't forget about overpayments, in my experience. I've seen people say they'd just ignore the notice and it went nowhere good.

0 coins

Yep. They'll take it out of future payments if you don't deal with it.

0 coins

Or they'll pursue it other ways. Just handle it.

0 coins

If you're not sure the amount is right, the appeal is worth it. If you know the overlap happened and the math checks out, just pay the notice. Contesting what you know you owe wastes everyone's time.

0 coins

The math looks right to me. One week, the amount on the notice matches what I think one week of benefits was. I'll pay it.

0 coins

Good. Keep a record of the payment and the notice together.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the staggering question — if a birth mother's DI claim ends on a Friday, can the PFL bonding claim start the very next day?

0 coins

Adjacent days are fine as long as they don't overlap. The DI claim ends on its last day, PFL starts the day after — no gap required, just no same-day double payment. The birth mother gets the DE 2501FP form and has 41 days from when bonding starts to file it.

0 coins

That's what I figured. We were going to push the bonding claim start to Monday just to be safe but maybe that's unnecessary.

0 coins

No requirement for a gap, so starting the day after DI ends is fine. Just don't let the bonding start date go unrecorded — the 41-day clock starts from that date.

0 coins

Update from me: I read the notice all the way through tonight. It's one week of PFL they want back because DI was paying for those same days. The amount matches my weekly benefit from the Notice of Computation. I'm going to pay it. Thank you all for talking me down from the panic and explaining what actually happened here.

0 coins

Glad you got clarity on it. One week is very manageable.

0 coins

Pay by the method on the notice so there's a paper trail.

0 coins

There's a remittance stub attached. I'll use that.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure