Paid family leave denied insufficient earnings base period recomputation appeal process — what actually works?
I filed a PFL care claim for my dad back in October, taking time off to drive him to his treatments and stay with him during the hard days. The denial letter came about two weeks later, a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, and it said I didn't have enough qualifying wages in the base period. I was honestly blindsided because I've been working steadily, just not always at the same job. I had a gap between positions earlier this year where I did some freelance work, and I think that's what messed up my earnings picture for whatever quarter they looked at. The letter mentions something about a base period recomputation and says I can appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A form. Has anyone actually gone through the appeal process after getting denied for insufficient earnings? Did the recomputation help? I don't even fully understand what quarters they used to calculate my base period in the first place. I just need to know if fighting this is worth it or if I'm just going to hit another wall.
78 comments

Liam Fitzgerald
Payment method on my care claim was the reason I ended up on the phone with EDD, and I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get there after three mornings of that line ending before anyone answered. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed my direct deposit information was attached correctly and that my first payment had been issued. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
The DE 2514 on my own claim had the same insufficient earnings language, and once EDD's agent answered I asked her to read me exactly what base period quarters they had on file. She found that one quarter was showing zero wages even though I had a W-2 for it. That detail went straight into my appeal letter.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
The line ending mid-hold is brutal. I tried six mornings in a row before I found another way. Good that you got the payment sorted.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
41 days is what most people focus on when filing, but the base period window is what trips people up on a denial like yours. EDD looks at wages from roughly five to eighteen months before your claim started, in four quarters, and they take the highest quarter to figure your weekly amount. If your freelance income wasn't reported with CASDI withheld, it won't show up in their wage records at all, which is a separate problem from the recomputation.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorThe freelance work was all 1099, so yeah, no CASDI withheld. I had no idea that mattered for PFL eligibility. So would the recomputation even help me if those wages just aren't in the system?
0 coins
NebulaNinja
Recomputation shifts the quarters they look at, so if you had a different window where your W-2 wages were higher, it could help. But 1099 earnings with no SDI withheld won't count in any quarter. The at-least-$300-with-CASDI-withheld requirement is the floor to qualify at all.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorOkay that's actually clarifying even if it's not what I wanted to hear. So I need to look at whether my W-2 wages in a shifted window would clear $300 with CASDI withheld.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
EDD denied me for insufficient earnings two years ago and I appealed. The recomputation moved my base period back one quarter and my wages in that window were enough. Took about six weeks to hear back after I mailed the DE 1000A. It's worth filing if you have W-2 wages they might not be looking at.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorSix weeks is a long time when you're not getting paid and your dad still needs care. But I'll file it. Did you have to submit any wage documents with the appeal or just the form?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
I attached my W-2 and two pay stubs to explain the gap. Gave them something concrete to look at. The instructions on the DE 1000A say to include any evidence that supports your position.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Six weeks sounds about right for an administrative appeal. Mine was closer to eight.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
That 30-day clock on the appeal starts from the date on the determination notice, not from when you got it in the mail. Check the date printed on the letter and count from there.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorMine is dated October 28, so I'm still inside 30 days but not by a lot. I need to get that form in this week.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
Don't wait on it. Mail it certified so you have proof of when it went out.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
Certified mail is exactly right. Keep the receipt until this is closed.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
I went through almost this exact thing last year with my care claim for my mom. I had a job change mid-year and one of my quarters looked really thin. What helped me was writing a clear explanation of my work history in the appeal, like a timeline, so the reviewer could see what happened without having to piece it together themselves.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorA timeline is a good idea. I've been trying to figure out how to explain the freelance gap without it sounding like I was hiding something.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
Just be straightforward. Explain what the work was, that it was 1099, and that CASDI wasn't withheld, so those quarters look low even though you were working. Then point them to whatever W-2 wages you do have. Reviewers have seen every situation.
0 coins
StarSailor}
Insufficient earnings denials get appealed every day. Some win on recomputation, some don't. File the DE 1000A, attach your wage evidence, explain the gap plainly. EDD mails the decision.
0 coins
Miguel Silva
short and to the point lol. exactly what i needed to read too
0 coins
StarSailor}
That's the whole process.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
Curious whether EDD ever uses an alternate base period automatically, or if you have to specifically request it in the appeal. My understanding is that the recomputation isn't something EDD triggers on their own.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
You have to request it. The appeal is how you raise it. The DE 1000A is where you state that you're asking for a base period recomputation and explain why you believe a different window would show qualifying wages.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
That's what I figured. So the appeal letter needs to actually say the words 'base period recomputation' and not just 'I think you got my wages wrong.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
Exactly. Be specific in what you're asking for so the reviewer doesn't have to guess what relief you want.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Receipt number on my care claim went missing when I switched browsers in SDI Online, and I ended up calling EDD about it. I tried Claimyr after a week of mornings where the line either cut off or put me on hold for over an hour before disconnecting. The agent found my claim by my Social Security number and read me the receipt number directly so I could keep filing Part D through my dad's doctor.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
That line has never once stayed connected when I've called. I've tried probably nine or ten mornings over the past month. Sounds too easy to actually get through, honestly. How did you not just get the same hold music and then nothing?
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
I mean, I was skeptical too, that's fair. It's not EDD getting better, it's the service staying on the line in your place. I ended up talking to an actual EDD employee who had access to my claim. I didn't do anything special except not be the one waiting.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
Agent confirmed Part D was received and matched to my claim, which my doctor's office had submitted online with the receipt number. That's the step I'd been panicking about for two weeks. Anyway, glad the receipt number came through for you.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
Okay. I might try it for my own situation, which is figuring out whether EDD actually got the Part D my mom's pulmonologist submitted.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
PFL doesn't have a waiting period, to be clear. If someone tells you to expect seven unpaid days at the start, that's the disability insurance waiting period, not PFL. Your care claim, once approved, pays from day one.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorI actually thought there was a waiting period, so I'm glad you said that. One less thing to subtract from whatever I might eventually get.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
yeah i thought the same thing. found out the hard way with my first claim that pfl is different from sdi on that.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
Different programs, different rules. PFL is part of SDI but the waiting period belongs only to DI.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
Base period recomputation saved my claim about eighteen months ago. I had taken a semester off school to work full time and then went back to part-time, so my wages bounced around a lot by quarter. When EDD shifted the window one quarter earlier my highest earning period came into view and that was enough to qualify.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorThat's really encouraging to hear. My situation is different but the principle is the same, I need them to look at a window where my W-2 wages are actually visible.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
Put the specific quarter you want them to look at in the appeal letter. Don't make them guess which window works better for you.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
Is the appeal done online or does it have to be mailed? I'm asking for my own claim but seems relevant here too, anyway.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
The DE 1000A can be submitted online through SDI Online or by mail. The determination notice should say where to send it if you're mailing.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
Got it, online is easier. Thanks for the quick answer.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Does freelance income ever count if the person voluntarily paid into SDI on their own? I know some self-employed people elect SDI coverage.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
If a self-employed person elected SDI coverage through the Elective Coverage program and paid into it, those wages can count. The key is that CASDI had to be withheld, by whatever mechanism. If the freelance work was straight 1099 with no election and no withholding, it won't be in EDD's wage records.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorMine was straight 1099, no election. I didn't even know voluntary SDI coverage was a thing. Too late for this claim but good to know going forward.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Yeah, it's one of those things nobody tells you until after it matters.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
September 30 is usually the end of a quarter, so if your claim started in October, your base period likely ran from roughly July of last year through June of this year, in four quarters. If your strongest W-2 wages were before that window, that's what the recomputation could fix.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorMy heaviest W-2 period was actually the second half of last year, so a recomputation might pull that in. I'm going to map this out tonight.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
Bring that wage documentation to the appeal. A W-2 and your pay stubs from that period should be enough to show what you earned and that CASDI was withheld.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
DE 429DF on my care claim confused me because it showed up before I knew if I was approved. I tried Claimyr after two weeks of never getting a person on the line. The agent looked up my claim and told me the weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation and confirmed it was based on my highest quarter wages, so at least I knew what to expect while the eligibility decision was still pending.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
Wait, what is Claimyr exactly? I've seen the name a few times now.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
It's a service that waits on EDD's line in your place until an agent picks up, then your phone rings. That's about all there is to it.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
Honestly I would use that just to ask whether my own base period recomputation request was received after I mailed the appeal. I've been wondering if EDD even has the letter.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
The agent on my call could see documents received on my claim. That's probably something they could check for you.
0 coins
Miguel Silva
edd denied my care claim too, same reason. i just refiled thinking i could pick different dates but that doesnt fix the base period problem. wish i had read something like this first
0 coins
NebulaNinja
Refiling won't change the base period if the claim start date is the same or similar. The appeal with the DE 1000A and a request for recomputation is the right path, not a new claim.
0 coins
Miguel Silva
ugh. okay. is it too late for me to appeal my original denial
0 coins
NebulaNinja
The 30-day window runs from the date on your determination notice. If you're still inside that, file the appeal. If you've passed it, call EDD and explain the situation. They may still consider it depending on your circumstances.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Which weeks were paid and when the next payment would come in were the two things I couldn't figure out from SDI Online alone. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who went through my payment history line by line and told me my second payment had been issued on a specific date and that I had four weeks of the eight remaining in my 12-month window.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
Agent on my call confirmed a payment date too. Mine showed as issued but I hadn't seen it on the debit card yet, and she told me the exact date it was sent so I knew what to watch for.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
How long between when she said it was issued and when it actually showed up for you?
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
About two business days after the issued date. Showed up without me doing anything else.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
Good to know there's usually a gap between issued and arrived. I was about to panic over the same thing.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
Something people miss on care claim appeals, the physician's certification, the Part D, has to reach EDD within 41 days of when the leave started. If your appeal succeeds and shifts the base period but Part D was never received or came in late, the claim can still run into problems on the medical certification side. Make sure that piece is in order while the appeal is in progress.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorPart D was submitted by my dad's doctor online with my receipt number. I uploaded nothing, they handled it. But I should probably call and confirm EDD actually received it and matched it to my claim.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
That's worth verifying. The 41-day clock doesn't pause while the appeal is pending.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
My doctor's office submitted Part D online too and it matched fine, but I did confirm with EDD before I stopped worrying about it. Glad you're on top of it.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
If the appeal gets approved, does EDD automatically recalculate the weekly benefit amount based on the new base period, or do you have to ask for a new Notice of Computation?
0 coins
NebulaNinja
EDD issues a new determination and updated Notice of Computation if the recomputation changes your qualifying wages. You don't have to ask separately for the recalculation, it comes with the appeal decision.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
That's a relief. I was worried it would be two separate fights.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
Filing the appeal the same week you get the denial is the move. Most people sit on it because they're stressed and then realize on day 28 they have two days left.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorI'm filing this week, definitely. I've been stressed but reading through all of this helped me understand what I'm actually asking for.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
Get the W-2s and pay stubs together tonight if you can, so the form isn't what's holding you up.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
what happens if 30 days passes and the appeal wasn't filed in time, is it just over
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
You can still contact EDD and explain why the appeal was late. There's no guarantee, but good cause for missing the deadline is something reviewers can consider.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
ok so it's not automatically a closed door. good to know
0 coins
StarSailor}
Don't test it. If you have a denial letter with a date on it, file now.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
To bring it back to where this started, the base period recomputation is a real option and people do win on it. The appeal form is the DE 1000A, it asks what you're appealing and why, and you attach any wage documents that support your case. EDD mails the decision. The 30 days from the date on the notice is a hard deadline so that's the one thing to protect.
0 coins
Mei Lin
AuthorThank you for pulling it together like that. I have the DE 1000A, I know which quarter I need them to look at, and I have my W-2 from that period. Filing it this week certified mail.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
That's exactly the right set of things. Good luck with your dad's care in the meantime.
0 coins