Back to California Paid Family Leave

Sean Murphy

Paid family leave denied employer top up wages how to appeal — what actually works

I'm kind of panicking and not sure if I'm handling this right. My employer gives us a top-up where they pay the difference between my PFL benefit and my full salary, so I'm still getting 100% of my pay while on bonding leave. But EDD just denied my claim and I think it's because they saw the wages my employer reported? Or maybe because I reported them wrong? I'm not totally clear on what happened. I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) in the mail and there's an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) attached. It says I have 30 days to appeal. I haven't touched the form yet because I'm scared I'll mess it up. Has anyone dealt with a paid family leave denied employer top up wages how to appeal situation like this? Do I just fill out the DE 1000A and explain the situation, or is there something I need to gather first? I genuinely don't know if my employer's top-up is what caused the denial or if EDD thinks I earned too much during the leave itself.

okay so first, breathe. the 30 days to appeal is from when the determination was mailed, so check that date on the DE 2514 and don't sit on it too long. the DE 1000A is not complicated, you just explain what you think EDD got wrong and send it in. did the determination letter say specifically why they denied it?

0 coins

the letter says something about wages exceeding the benefit amount but I don't totally understand it. my employer was paying the top-up on top of whatever EDD would have paid, so combined I was getting my full salary. does that count as earnings that EDD would deny for?

0 coins

the EDD rule on this is that your wages plus PFL together can't be more than what you normally earn. so if the top-up brings you to exactly 100% of your regular wages, that's supposed to be fine. if your combined total went over your normal pay even by a little, that's where the problem starts. the determination letter should spell out the amount EDD calculated.

0 coins

it didn't exceed my salary, they were topping me up to exactly my salary, not over. so maybe EDD just calculated it wrong? that's what I need to appeal then.

0 coins

appeal it. fill out that DE 1000A and write exactly what you said here. wages plus PFL equaling your normal pay is allowed. get a pay stub showing what your employer paid during leave so you have something to hand over.

0 coins

does the appeal go by mail or can you do it online?

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be submitted online or by mail. The form itself tells you where to send it if you go by mail. Online appeals go through SDI Online in myEDD. Either way, keep a copy of everything you submit.

0 coins

thank you, didn't realize you could do it online through SDI Online

0 coins

Forty-one days on my bonding claim had me worried too. The start date on my claim was off by a few days from when my leave actually began, and I wasn't sure if EDD had it right. I tried the PFL line a bunch of mornings starting around eight and kept getting the "we can't take your call" recording, so I finally tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone. Here's the video if you want to see what reaching a live person looks like: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file, which turned out to be one day off, and she told me to submit a Request Claim Update in SDI Online noting the correct date so the record matched my actual first day of leave.

0 coins

Claimyr, what is that exactly?

0 coins

it basically sits on hold with EDD so your phone rings when a live agent picks up. you don't have to keep redialing. i'd had no luck with the line for three straight mornings before i tried it.

0 coins

huh. i've been getting that same recording every time I try before nine. I'd want to ask about why my claim still says pending after two weeks.

0 coins

i've had a denial before for different reasons and what actually helped was writing a clear one-page explanation with the appeal form. don't just check the box, explain the math. like, "my regular wages are X, employer top-up was Y, PFL benefit would have been Z, total was X" and show it doesn't exceed normal pay.

0 coins

that's really useful. so I should put the actual numbers in the appeal letter?

0 coins

yes. EDD is not going to assume anything in your favor. spell it out.

0 coins

should I attach pay stubs to the appeal form or just describe it? I'm in a similar situation and I'm scared of sending the wrong thing.

0 coins

attach whatever backs up your numbers. pay stubs showing what your employer paid during leave, anything showing your regular salary. the more concrete the better when you're appealing a denial.

0 coins

one thing I want to double-check on what was said above: the rule is wages plus PFL can't exceed what you'd normally earn, but overtime doesn't count in that normal wages figure. so if your employer is basing the top-up on your base salary only, that's the number to compare against.

0 coins

my employer tops up to base salary, no overtime in the calculation. so that lines up.

0 coins

that's right, the EDD rule excludes overtime from the normal wages figure for this comparison. base salary is the right number to work with.

0 coins

the denial is not the end. plenty of people get denied and win on appeal when the math actually works out. file the form before the 30 days runs.

0 coins

how firm is that 30-day window? like if I miss it by a day or two is it completely over?

0 coins

don't test it. the determination says 30 days. treat it like a hard deadline.

0 coins

also double-check that your employer's HR reported the top-up correctly to EDD. sometimes the issue isn't that you earned too much, it's that the wages were coded in a way EDD read as regular work wages during leave, lol. HR might be able to clarify what they reported.

0 coins

that actually hadn't even occurred to me. so HR might have submitted something that made it look like I was working full hours during my leave?

0 coins

yeah it happens. get a letter from HR explaining the top-up is a supplement, not pay for hours worked, and include that with the appeal.

0 coins

the HR letter idea is really good, that kind of documentation makes the appeal a lot clearer.

0 coins

To be clear about what the form asks: the DE 1000A is straightforward. It asks for your name, your EDD case number which is on the determination letter, and a brief statement of why you disagree. You don't need legal language. Write plainly what happened, attach your documentation, and sign it.

0 coins

is there a way to track whether EDD received the appeal after I send it?

0 coins

If you submit through SDI Online, you'll see it in your claim history. If you mail it, certified mail gives you a delivery confirmation. Keep the tracking number.

0 coins

okay certified mail it is then, thank you

0 coins

been through appeals before. the people deciding it are not your EDD agent, it's a separate appeals board. so the appeal letter is actually read. worth writing something coherent.

0 coins

didn't know it went to a different board. that actually changes how I think about it.

0 coins

yeah it's not just the same person looking at it again. write it like you're explaining to someone who hasn't seen your file before.

0 coins

Payment method on my bonding claim took longer to sort out than the claim itself. I'd set up direct deposit but the confirmation screen in SDI Online showed a pending status for days. Eventually I used Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line, and the agent told me EDD had the routing number on file correctly but the payment method hadn't been confirmed yet on their end. She walked me through what step was pending.

0 coins

I used Claimyr for my own claim too and was relieved to actually reach someone. The agent confirmed EDD had received my DE 2580GF for the intermittent days I'd reported, and told me which weeks were marked as pending payment. I'd been unsure if filing intermittent meant I had to do anything else.

0 coins

what did the agent say about whether you needed to send another DE 2580GF after each intermittent period or just once?

0 coins

she said EDD sends the Continued Claim Certification form out each time, and I just needed to return it promptly. if I didn't return it the payments would stop. that made it much clearer than the website did.

0 coins

edd denials are so frustrating bc you dont even know what triggered it half the time. appeal it tho def dont just let it go

0 coins

yeah I'm definitely not letting it go, just trying to make sure I do the appeal right

0 coins

you got this, just be real specific about the numbers

0 coins

sent my appeal in on day 28. cut it close but it went through. don't wait.

0 coins

that's nerve-racking. glad it made it.

0 coins

just so it's clear for the numbers side: when you're documenting the top-up, show your normal biweekly gross, what PFL would have paid, and what your employer paid as supplement. if those three numbers add up to exactly your normal pay, that's your argument in one line.

0 coins

that's exactly the format I'll use. three numbers, clean and simple.

0 coins

and label each line clearly. don't make whoever reads the appeal do math.

0 coins

file the appeal, attach the docs, keep copies. 30 days goes fast.

0 coins

noted. I'm going to do it this week.

0 coins

Receipt number on my bonding claim kept coming back as not found when I tried to check status. Tried redialing the PFL line across two different days with no luck. I ended up trying Claimyr to reach an agent. The agent found the claim in the system using my SSN and confirmed the receipt number I'd written down had a digit transposed. She gave me the correct number and I could see the claim right away in SDI Online after that.

0 coins

That does sound like it could be marketing for a service rather than a real situation. I don't quite trust these kinds of recommendations in forums.

0 coins

i thought the same thing the first time i saw it mentioned. tried it anyway when i couldn't reach EDD for a week straight and the agent told me my DE 2514 had been mailed three days earlier. was a real EDD agent, not a recording.

0 coins

Alright, that is reassuring. I might look into it for my own claim. I have a question about whether my proof of relationship document was received that I haven't been able to get answered.

0 coins

can I ask something that's related? my employer also does a top-up and I'm about to file for bonding. should I be reporting the top-up wages when I first file or only if EDD asks?

0 coins

when you file, EDD asks about wages you'll receive during the leave period. report what your employer is paying, including any top-up. don't leave it out, that's what can cause a denial later or an overpayment notice.

0 coins

yes please report it upfront. leaving wages out and having EDD find them later is so much harder to fix than just being transparent at the start.

0 coins

okay I'll report everything. I really don't want to end up in the same appeal situation.

0 coins

the waiting period people keep mentioning is worth clearing up too. PFL doesn't have one. there's no seven-day wait before benefits start. I thought there was and filed my claim timing wrong because of it. that's a disability insurance thing, not PFL.

0 coins

genuinely confused people on that one including me before my first claim. glad you brought it up.

0 coins

I told my coworker the same wrong thing last year. good catch.

0 coins

DE 429DF on my care claim came through but the weekly benefit amount looked really low to me and I didn't understand the base period it was using. I'd had a gap in work the year before and thought that might be dragging the number down. Tried calling multiple times over several mornings, no one ever picked up. I went with Claimyr and got through to an EDD agent who told me which four quarters made up my base period and confirmed the wage amounts EDD had pulled from each. Turned out the gap quarter had a zero, which pulled the average down.

0 coins

what did the agent say about whether you could do anything to adjust which quarter they used?

0 coins

she said the base period is set by when the claim starts, not something I could pick. she suggested I check EDD's benefit calculator online if I wanted to run different scenarios before deciding on a start date. I ended up moving my start date out by a few weeks to shift the base period by one quarter.

0 coins

been trying to reach the PFL line since Tuesday. four attempts, same result every time.

0 coins

DE 429DF on my bonding claim showed a lower amount than I expected too. I'd taken a few months of unpaid leave before the baby and I suspected that quarter was dragging the base period average down. Three days of redialing the PFL line and I kept hitting dead ends. I tried Claimyr and an agent pulled up my claim and read me exactly which quarters and amounts made up my base period. She confirmed which quarter had the lower wages and told me the Notice of Computation reflects that figure directly.

0 coins

did you ask the agent whether you could do anything if you disagreed with the base period amount?

0 coins

she said if I thought the wage amounts were wrong I could appeal the Notice of Computation using the DE 1000A the same way you'd appeal a denial. she told me what to include.

0 coins

four mornings I've tried that line. never once got past the first recording.

0 coins

update: I filed the appeal online through SDI Online today, 11 days before the deadline. attached pay stubs, an HR letter explaining the top-up structure, and a one-page breakdown showing regular wages, employer supplement, and what PFL would have paid. all three numbers, clearly labeled. now I wait I guess.

0 coins

that sounds like a solid appeal packet honestly. everything they'd need is right there.

0 coins

now it's out of your hands. that's the right spot to be in.

0 coins

the EDD determination letter said you have 30 days, and the DE 1000A is what starts the formal appeal. you did it right. check SDI Online to confirm it shows in your claim history.

0 coins

it does show up in claim history. relief to see it there.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure