Back to California Paid Family Leave

Oliver Schulz

Paid family leave denied due to application mistake — appeal or reapply?

So I'm kind of panicking here. I filed a PFL bonding claim on SDI Online about three weeks ago for my daughter, who was born in October, and I think I made an error on the application. I may have put the wrong dates for when my leave started, and I'm pretty sure I uploaded the wrong document for proof of relationship — I uploaded a photo of the hospital discharge paperwork instead of the birth certificate. EDD sent me a denial notice, the DE 2514, and now I have an Appeal Form DE 1000A sitting on my kitchen table and I genuinely don't know if I should appeal this or just try to refile entirely. The notice says I have 30 days to appeal. If I refile, do I lose the original start date? And if I appeal, can I actually fix the document issue that way? I don't want to do the wrong thing and lose all the benefits for the weeks I've already missed.

Before touching that appeal form, pull out your DE 2514 and read the reason for denial carefully. The notice will say exactly what EDD found missing or wrong. If it's the proof of relationship, an appeal is probably your best path because you're asking EDD to reconsider with the correct document, the birth certificate, rather than starting over and risking your original start date.

0 coins

The notice says something about the relationship not being established. So it really does sound like the wrong document is the whole problem.

0 coins

That tracks. The hospital discharge paper doesn't prove the parent-child relationship the way a birth certificate does. Appeal with the right document and explain what happened.

0 coins

Exactly, and when you file the appeal online or by mail with the DE 1000A, write a plain explanation: wrong document submitted in error, correct birth certificate attached. Keep it factual and straightforward.

0 coins

Part D not" received sat on my care claim status for ten days after my'mom s doctor submitted it, so I used (Claimyr) claimyr.com to get someone at EDD on the phone. The agent pulled up the claim and confirmed Part D had come in but was sitting unmatched because the receipt number was off by one digit. She fixed the reference right then, and the claim moved to eligible the next day.'Claimyr s video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave:https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Did you have anything specific ready when the agent pulled up your file?

0 coins

Receipt number, my mom's name and date of birth, and the date leave started. Having those meant the agent didn't have to search around.

0 coins

Three weeks of trying that line at every hour I can think of and I've never gotten through. How is this even possible?

0 coins

Refiling from scratch means your start date resets to the new filing date. You'd lose whatever weeks passed since October. The appeal is the right move here. Attach the birth certificate and state plainly on the form that the wrong document was uploaded by mistake.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of with refiling. So the 30-day appeal window on the DE 2514, that's the thing I need to pay attention to right now.

0 coins

Correct. Miss that window and you're in a much harder spot. File the appeal first, sort the rest after.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost the exact same thing last spring, wrong document on a bonding claim, and she won the appeal by just sending in the actual birth certificate with a short note. EDD isn't trying to trap anyone, they just need the right proof.

0 coins

Does she know if EDD looked at her original filing date when they approved it on appeal? That part matters.

0 coins

They kept the original date, yeah. That was the whole point of appealing instead of redoing everything.

0 coins

Appeals take time though. Could be weeks before a decision comes back.

0 coins

October start date, denial notice in hand, 30-day window running: the math says file that appeal now and attach the birth certificate. Every day you wait on this is a day closer to losing the right to appeal at all.

0 coins

You're right, I've been sitting on it too long already. I'll file this week.

0 coins

Yes, do it now! The 30 days goes fast, and an appeal with the right document is a genuinely straightforward fix for this kind of mistake!

0 coins

dont refile, you lose your dates. appeal is the move, just send the real birth cert and explain what happened. edd sees this kind of thing all the time

0 coins

Is the appeal done online or does it have to be mailed? Trying to figure out the fastest route, anyway.

0 coins

you can do it online or mail, online is prob faster

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be submitted online through SDI Online or mailed to the address on the form. Online will log a receipt immediately, which is useful for tracking.

0 coins

The second payment on my bonding claim never showed in SDI Online, so I tried Claimyr to reach a live EDD agent. She checked the payment history and told me the payment had issued on November 3rd to the debit card on file, but the card had been reported lost in my account settings, so it was flagged. She told me to update the payment method in SDI Online and the reissue would process. I updated it that afternoon.

0 coins

The date question is what I need answered for my own claim — payment issued but nothing on my end. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the date range the payment should cover. That's what the agent asked me for right away.

0 coins

The payment method thing is actually something I hadn't thought about. I need to double-check what's on file for my claim too.

0 coins

Thirty days to appeal is tight when you're also dealing with a newborn. File the DE 1000A, write two sentences about the document mistake, attach the birth certificate. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Two sentences really is enough? I'd be tempted to write a whole explanation.

0 coins

EDD needs the fact, not the essay. What went wrong, what you're attaching. Done.

0 coins

This is accurate. Appeals that go on forever don't do better than clear, short ones with the right document attached.

0 coins

Wait, if the appeal gets denied too, is there another appeal after that? Or is a second denial the end of the road? I'm asking because I'm about to file a care claim for my dad and I'm terrified of making a similar mistake.

0 coins

For a care claim, your biggest protection is making sure Part D reaches EDD within 41 days of your leave start date. Get the receipt number to your dad's doctor's office right away so they can submit Part D in SDI Online or mail it.

0 coins

Part D is the doctor's certification, right? Not the form I fill out?

0 coins

Correct. Part C is what your dad fills out himself and mails in. Part D is the physician's certification, and the doctor's office handles that one, either by mail or through SDI Online with your receipt number.

0 coins

Honestly the appeal route makes so much more sense here. Redoing the whole claim just resets the clock and you lose those weeks you already took off. Send in the birth certificate with the appeal and you're basically asking EDD to look at it again with the right info.

0 coins

Yeah I think I was overthinking whether to refile because it felt like starting fresh would somehow be cleaner. But losing October is not an option.

0 coins

Exactly, the whole point of the appeal is to fix the original claim, not abandon it. lol don't abandon it.

0 coins

For the appeal, write the date leave started, name the document that was submitted by mistake, and attach the birth certificate. Short. Clear. Submit before the 30-day window closes.

0 coins

does the birth cert need to be an original or is a copy fine

0 coins

A clear copy is fine. No need for a certified original for SDI Online.

0 coins

Good to know, I have a certified copy but I didn't want to send the only one I have through the mail.

0 coins

Eight weeks on a bonding claim and I wanted to know how many I still had left after going back to part-time, so I tried Claimyr to actually reach someone at EDD. The agent checked my claim and said five of the eight weeks had been certified and three remained available within my 12-month window, which runs through next September. That answered the question I'd been trying to get from that phone line for three weeks straight.

0 coins

Three weeks left on my bonding claim and I've been trying to figure out the same thing, how many weeks I still have. Used Claimyr for something else before and the agent had my payment history pulled up in under a minute. Once they confirmed how my weeks were split, I knew exactly when I needed to use them before the 12-month window closed.

0 coins

been dialing that line since tuesday, never get past the recording

0 coins

Tuesday through Friday for me last time. Mornings, afternoons, didn't matter.

0 coins

The denial reason on the DE 2514 tells you exactly what EDD didn't have. Proof of relationship not established means the birth certificate is what's needed. Appeal with DE 1000A, attach it, reference the original filing date.

0 coins

I keep going back to whether I should mention the wrong dates I might have entered too, or if I should focus only on the document.

0 coins

List every error in one place on the appeal form. Fixing only part of it and finding out later there's a second issue is worse than addressing both now.

0 coins

Agreed. The appeal is the place to correct everything at once, dates and document both, so EDD has the full picture when they review.

0 coins

The DE 1000A is available right in SDI Online, which makes filing the appeal pretty painless! You attach the birth certificate directly in the same session and get a confirmation number right away!

0 coins

I did not realize I could do the whole appeal in SDI Online. I was planning to mail it, which would have taken extra days.

0 coins

Yes, online is so much faster! Just log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and the appeal option is under your claim.

0 coins

What happens to the weeks you already bonded during the time between filing and the denial? Do those just disappear or does EDD still count them if the appeal goes through?

0 coins

If the appeal is approved with your original start date intact, EDD will typically pay the eligible weeks from that start date forward. That's why keeping the original filing date is the whole point of appealing rather than refiling.

0 coins

So those October weeks aren't gone yet. Got it.

0 coins

Appeal timelines vary. Don't expect a fast turnaround. File it this week and then settle in to wait.

0 coins

How long is a realistic wait usually?

0 coins

Honestly no way to say for certain. EDD doesn't publish an average. File and check SDI Online periodically.

0 coins

Filing it now is the only part you can control. Get it in and then it's out of your hands.

0 coins

The 12-month window for bonding is from the birth date, right? So if she was born in October and you haven't used all eight weeks, you have until October next year. But you have to actually win the appeal first, anyway.

0 coins

The 12 months runs from the birth date, yes. Any bonding weeks not used by then can't be claimed after.

0 coins

October is coming faster than I'd like to think. I need to get this appeal in and move.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period, just so everyone here knows. Some people think there are seven unpaid days like with disability insurance but that's not how bonding works, it starts paying from day one you're eligible.

0 coins

yeah i thought it was the same as sdi and was totally wrong

0 coins

Super common mix-up! Disability has the waiting period, PFL doesn't. Totally different.

0 coins

For the record, PFL and DI are separate programs even though they're both under SDI. DI is for the worker's own condition, PFL is for bonding or care or military assist. The seven-day wait applies to DI only.

0 coins

Just to close the loop on something: even if the appeal takes a few weeks, the original start date in October is preserved as long as the appeal is filed within the 30-day window. That date is what determines your benefit period, not the date EDD decides the appeal.

0 coins

That framing actually helps. The appeal protects October even while I'm waiting for the decision.

0 coins

Correct. And if the decision goes against you, the DE 2514 that comes back will include another appeal form and another 30-day window to respond to that decision.

0 coins

Wait, so there can be more than one round of appeals? That's actually reassuring to know.

0 coins

filed mine monday, waiting now. the pending status hasn't moved in four days. starting to wonder if the appeal even registered.

0 coins

Four days after filing is still early. Check SDI Online for a status update and look for the receipt confirmation from when you submitted. If you have a receipt number from the appeal submission, EDD has it.

0 coins

i do have the confirmation number. guess ill give it another week before worrying.

0 coins

Confirmation number means it's in. Status takes time to reflect. Wait.

0 coins

Update from me: filed the appeal in SDI Online this morning with the birth certificate attached and a short note explaining the hospital discharge paper was uploaded by mistake. Got a confirmation number immediately. Now I wait, but at least October is still in play.

0 coins

Filing it right was the whole battle. The birth certificate and a plain explanation is exactly what that appeal needed.

0 coins

Good. Now keep an eye on the 30-day clock if they come back with another denial. You'll have another shot.

0 coins

Great news! The confirmation number means EDD has everything. Fingers crossed the decision comes back quickly!

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure