Back to California Paid Family Leave

Leo Simmons

Paid family leave denied because of sick pay — how to appeal

I filed a PFL bonding claim after my daughter was born in September and genuinely thought everything was fine. EDD sent me a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination and it said I was denied for some of the weeks because I was receiving sick pay from my employer at the same time. I honestly had no idea that was even a problem. My HR told me to use my sick time while I was out, so I did, and now EDD is saying I was overpaid or something? I'm not totally sure I understand the denial letter. The weeks they're flagging are the first three, which is exactly when I was using my accrued sick leave. Has anyone appealed something like this? The letter mentions an Appeal Form DE 1000A and says I have 30 days. I'm already two weeks into that window and panicking a little. Do I have a real case here, or is this just how it works when you get paid leave from your job at the same time?

Sick pay combined with PFL is genuinely one of the trickier situations. What EDD looks at is whether your wages plus the PFL benefit added up to more than your regular weekly wages. If your employer was paying you full salary through sick leave and EDD was also sending benefit payments, the total could have exceeded your normal pay, and that is what triggers the problem. The appeal is still worth filing if you think their math is off or if the sick pay your employer paid was less than your full wages.

0 coins

I assumed sick pay and PFL just stacked on top of each other. My HR never mentioned any kind of coordination rule.

0 coins

A lot of HR departments don't flag it in advance. The rule is that wages, not counting overtime, plus PFL can't go over what you'd normally earn in a week. If your employer paid 100 percent of your salary through sick leave, the PFL on top of that would have been the excess.

0 coins

So if my employer only paid 60 percent sick pay, there might be room for PFL to cover the rest without going over? That actually gives me some hope for the appeal.

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the form to use. It says on EDD's site that you can file it online or mail it, and you have 30 days from the date on the determination notice, not the date you received it. Worth double-checking that date on your letter because two weeks in still leaves you time, but just barely.

0 coins

The date on the letter is October 3rd so I think I have until November 2nd or so. Filing online through SDI Online is an option?

0 coins

SDI Online does have an appeals option tied to the claim. The Appeal Form is also listed on EDD's site if you want to download and mail it. Either way, make sure you explain the sick pay situation clearly and attach anything showing what your employer actually paid you each week.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but I think you can include a statement from your employer explaining their sick leave policy? I might be wrong about that but it seems like it could help show you weren't getting full salary.

0 coins

Weeks two and three of my bonding claim both showed pending with no payment, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the phone. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me week two had already paid and week three was processing, with the next payment set to issue on a specific date she read off the screen. Good to have that confirmed instead of just staring at SDI Online.

0 coins

Claimyr showing up here reads like a sponsored post to me, I'll be honest. I've tried that number so many mornings that I stopped counting, so I get the frustration, but I don't put much stock in services that promise a live EDD agent.

0 coins

Felt the same way the first time I saw it mentioned. But I'd been dialing the PFL line for two and a half weeks on my care claim and went ahead and tried it. The agent I ended up talking to confirmed how many of my eight weeks I had left in the 12-month window, which was exactly what I needed to know before I filed the second stretch of leave.

0 coins

Okay that's actually useful context. If I can get someone to explain the denial letter I'm dealing with, I'd try it. Still a little skeptical but not writing it off entirely.

0 coins

The EDD phone line is a full-time job on its own. Called every day for a week about a denial and never got through. The determination letter they send is not always clear about exactly which week tripped the wire, so if yours is vague, the appeal statement is your chance to lay it out week by week with the actual amounts.

0 coins

Called at 8 on the dot three days running and got the recording every time. If the line just dumps you, what else are you supposed to do.

0 coins

Exactly. The appeal is probably your better move anyway. Put the numbers in writing, attach your pay stubs showing what sick pay you got each week, and let EDD recalculate. At least then there's a paper trail.

0 coins

Pay stubs as evidence in the appeal, that's a solid idea. I have all of mine. If I show the actual sick pay amount per week it should be clear whether the total exceeded my normal wages or not.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast. File first, explain later if you need to.

0 coins

Filing it today actually. Even a bare-bones appeal to hold the spot, then I can send more documentation?

0 coins

That's the move. Get it in, then follow up with the paperwork.

0 coins

My cousin did exactly that with her PFL denial, filed the appeal right away and then mailed a fuller explanation a few days after. The appeal date is what matters for the deadline.

0 coins

HR telling you to use sick time while you're on PFL is super common and I think a lot of people end up in this exact mess because nobody explains the wage cap rule upfront. Your employer might not even know they're supposed to coordinate.

0 coins

My HR was completely caught off guard when I told them EDD flagged it. They thought sick pay and PFL were totally separate things.

0 coins

Yeah they often don't talk to each other lol. Worth asking HR if your sick leave payout was full salary or a percentage, because that number is what the appeal hinges on.

0 coins

Employers can require employees to use accrued paid leave at the same time as PFL, but the combined total still can't top the person's regular weekly wages. That part is EDD's rule, not the employer's choice.

0 coins

Appeal it. Worst they say is no, and then you're no worse off than you are right now.

0 coins

Is there any risk that appealing makes things worse somehow? Like, could they look at the whole claim again and deny even more of it?

0 coins

The appeal is about the determination they already issued. You're not reopening the whole claim, you're contesting that specific decision.

0 coins

The notice itself explains the appeal process. The DE 1000A is narrow, it addresses the determination on that letter. File it, state your case about the sick pay amounts, and attach your documentation.

0 coins

DE 2500E on my bonding claim never came through even though the claim said eligible, so I tried Claimyr to reach someone. The agent found that the payment notification had been issued three days earlier to the debit card address on file, and that the card was still being mailed out to me.

0 coins

Did you end up switching to direct deposit after that, or did the card actually show up?

0 coins

Card came about four days later. The agent said to give it the full mailing window before doing anything else, so I waited and it arrived.

0 coins

ive been trying that line since monday and cant get anyone, four mornings straight and the same recording every time

0 coins

Pay stubs are the key thing to pull together. For every week EDD flagged, you want the stub showing exactly what your employer paid you. Then it's just math: their sick pay plus whatever EDD sent, compared to your regular week's wages. If the total is under, the denial is wrong. Anyway.

0 coins

Three weeks flagged means three pay stubs. I have them all, and at least for weeks one and two my sick pay was definitely not full salary, so there should be room.

0 coins

Put the numbers side by side in your appeal statement. Week one, sick pay X, PFL payment Y, normal weekly wages Z. If X plus Y is under Z, say so. Clear math is hard to argue with. Anyway.

0 coins

This is exactly how to frame it! The adjudicator reviewing the appeal needs to see the numbers laid out, not just a general explanation.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period, so the denial isn't about that. But if EDD issued payments before catching the sick pay overlap, they may now be treating the flagged weeks as an overpayment rather than just a denial. Check the letter carefully for that word.

0 coins

The letter says denial for those weeks, and there's a separate paragraph about potential overpayment recovery. So yes, both are in there.

0 coins

Appeal the denial. The overpayment piece usually follows the same track, and if the denial is reversed the overpayment question changes with it.

0 coins

I didn't realize the overpayment and the denial were connected like that. I thought an overpayment notice was always its own separate thing.

0 coins

They can be separate, but when the denial is specifically about weeks already paid, the overpayment claim is tied to the same calculation. Win the appeal and the overpayment for those weeks may no longer stand.

0 coins

I've seen this come up with clients who went back to work part time during their leave too, not just sick pay. Any wages at all while PFL is running gets reported, and if nobody told them, they end up with the same kind of denial.

0 coins

I didn't go back to work at all, it was purely the sick pay my employer was sending. No hours worked, just the accrued sick leave payout.

0 coins

That actually helps your appeal, because it's cleaner. You were fully out of work, employer paid partial sick leave, and EDD paid PFL on top. If the two together didn't exceed your regular wages, that case makes sense.

0 coins

edd logic is wild, you do what hr says and then edd comes at you for it. appeal it and attach every stub you have

0 coins

HR and EDD don't talk to each other. Never have. You find out the hard way.

0 coins

my partner went through the same thing with her bonding claim, hr told her to burn through pto first and then edd flagged half the weeks. had to appeal two months into leave

0 coins

Intermittent days I took for my own bonding claim got jumbled in the reporting, so I used Claimyr to get EDD on the phone about the DE 2580GF situation. The agent walked through which days were showing as reported and found that two Tuesdays hadn't posted yet, told me to give it a few more days before the form would clear.

0 coins

I want to ask about my care claim, whether Part D from my mom's doctor ever got matched up after I gave the office the receipt number. I'll try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the receipt number ready and your claim start date. The agent pulled everything up fast once I gave them those two things.

0 coins

Didn't realize intermittent reporting could lag like that. I took the full eight weeks straight so I didn't have to deal with the DE 2580GF at all, but good to know for next time.

0 coins

The appeal statement itself doesn't need to be formal or long. Write out what your employer paid each flagged week, what EDD paid, what your normal weekly wages were, and state that the combined amount didn't exceed your regular pay. That's really the whole argument.

0 coins

Plain language, week by week breakdown, and the pay stubs attached. That's the plan.

0 coins

Exactly. Keep it factual and specific. EDD adjudicators read a lot of these and a clear numerical argument stands out.

0 coins

The more specific the better. Vague appeals that just say the denial was wrong don't go anywhere. Numbers with documentation is the approach that actually gets reviewed seriously.

0 coins

DE 2514 on my bonding claim said I was ineligible for one week and I couldn't figure out why the math was off. Got on the phone through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the week in question had a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination issued because my employer had reported wages for that Tuesday that I hadn't flagged in my claim. Agent read me the exact dollar amount they had on file.

0 coins

Wages showing up that I hadn't reported is exactly my fear with the intermittent weeks I'm still waiting on. I used Claimyr too after that, and once the agent confirmed the claim start date and walked me through the 41-day window, I understood which weeks were actually in play. Then I filed the right form for the ones I'd missed.

0 coins

been trying that line so many times, three weeks of mornings and same result every time, the recording just ends

0 coins

yeah it just cuts off, no queue, nothing. anyway.

0 coins

Something worth knowing about the 30-day window: it's counted from the date printed on the determination notice, so look at the top of your letter, not the postmark or when it arrived in your mailbox.

0 coins

Checked again: the date on mine is October 3rd. So my deadline is around November 2nd. I have a few days left.

0 coins

File today if you can. Even a brief online filing through SDI Online holds the spot, and you can submit the full documentation after.

0 coins

I keep getting confused about whether the 30 days is calendar days or business days.

0 coins

Calendar days, based on the date on the notice. EDD's own guidance on the Appeal Form says 30 days from the date of the notice, no business-days qualifier.

0 coins

The good news is that appeals on PFL denials do get reviewed! EDD has to look at the actual numbers once you submit documentation. It's not just a rubber stamp.

0 coins

Getting to actually talk to someone about an appeal once it's in is a different story. But yes, filing it is the necessary first step.

0 coins

Totally, the filing is what starts the clock on the review. Once it's in, EDD has to process it.

0 coins

If your sick pay was a flat percentage of your salary, your pay stubs will show it clearly. HR can also give you a letter stating their sick leave policy and what rate they paid. That kind of employer documentation has weight in an appeal.

0 coins

HR has already said they'd put something in writing for me explaining the policy. 60 percent of base salary is what they paid out, so the stubs plus that letter should make the case.

0 coins

60 percent sick pay plus PFL would very likely come in under full wages. That's a solid appeal.

0 coins

An employer letter explaining the policy and confirming the payment rate is exactly what an adjudicator needs to see alongside the stubs. That combination is as clear as it gets.

0 coins

sent my appeal in last month for a different reason and still waiting to hear. the process is slow but at least it stops the clock on the overpayment while it's pending, i think

0 coins

Filing the appeal does put the overpayment recovery on hold while the determination is under review. That's one of the main reasons to file even if you're not certain you'll win.

0 coins

good, because getting a recovery notice while you're still waiting on the appeal outcome felt really unfair

0 coins

Filing the appeal today is the right call. You have the documentation, you have the employer letter coming, and the math seems to be on your side. Put it in and let the process run.

0 coins

Filing it now. I'll attach the three pay stubs and add a note that the employer letter is coming. Thanks everyone, this thread helped me understand what I was actually dealing with.

0 coins

Good luck with it. Post back when you hear something if you feel like it.

0 coins

Hope it goes your way.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure