PFL overpayment went back to work how to claim remaining weeks after returning early
So I went back to work three weeks earlier than planned and now I have an overpayment notice from EDD and I'm completely lost. I had filed for the full eight weeks of PFL bonding after my daughter was born, took about five weeks, then my job needed me back sooner and I went full-time before the leave was done. I didn't report the return to work right away because honestly I didn't know I was supposed to, and now there's an overpayment for those overlapping days. The part that's killing me is I still have weeks left in the 12 months since her birth. Can I even use them? Do I have to pay back the overpayment first before I can file again? I really can't figure out if the remaining weeks are just gone now or if there's a path to claim them, and I need them because childcare costs are brutal.
80 comments

Tyler Lefleur
Intermittent PFL caught me sideways too. Had weeks left after going back part-time and EDD sent me a DE 2580GF to fill out. I kept trying the phone line about whether my days were being counted right, every morning for a week, nothing. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got someone on the phone inside that session. Agent pulled up my claim and said two of my reported intermittent days hadn't been matched yet to the DE 2580GF EDD received, so they were still showing pending. She told me to give it a few more days for processing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
Every time someone mentions a service like this I figure it's just marketing dropped in a forum. What actually happened when you tried the number on your own?
0 coins
Max Knight
Tried 8 a.m. sharp four days in a row myself. Got the busy signal recording each time, line just died. Doubted it too until I tried it on my bonding claim. Agent told me my payment method was still set to check and I could switch to direct deposit in SDI Online if I wanted faster.
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
Okay that's more useful than I expected. Might give it a go just to find out where my own certification stands.
0 coins
Emma Swift
The overpayment and the remaining weeks are two separate things, worth keeping them apart in your head. EDD's guide says you can break up the eight weeks across the 12 months from the birth, so the weeks you didn't use aren't automatically gone. But not reporting wages when you returned is what triggered the overpayment, and you can appeal it within 30 days using the Appeal Form DE 1000A if you disagree with the amount.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorSo the appeal and filing for the rest of the leave can happen at the same time? I didn't realize I could do both.
0 coins
Emma Swift
Nothing in EDD's rules says you have to resolve one before doing the other. File the new claim for the remaining weeks, and appeal the overpayment separately if the notice gives you grounds.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
Does the overpayment notice say anything about whether you can file a new claim while it's open? Mine just showed an amount and an appeal form, no explanation of next steps.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
My cousin did exactly this, went back early and panicked about the same thing. The weeks left inside the 12-month window don't disappear because you returned to work early, they're still yours to use. What she had to do was file a fresh DE 2501F for the remaining stretch.
0 coins
LordCommander
Wait, is the DE 2501F a whole new claim form or some kind of update to the existing one?
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Full new claim form. The original bonding claim is closed once you've gone back full-time, so the remaining weeks need their own filing.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
That part scares me a little, not sure if filing again after an overpayment looks bad to EDD or flags something on my account.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
The 12-month window from the child's birth is the governing rule here. As long as you file the new claim before that window closes, the remaining weeks are still available to you. The DE 2501F is what you'd submit, and you mark question A13 yes if you plan to work any days during the new leave period.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorHer birthday window doesn't close for another four months so I should be okay on timing at least.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
Four months is enough time to file and have EDD process it, yes. Keep a copy of your submission and the receipt number.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
EDD's whole overpayment process is designed to confuse people, I swear. You didn't know to report your return and they just let the payments keep going, then hit you with the notice weeks later. Appeal it. The DE 1000A is in the notice packet and you have 30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you received it, so check that date carefully.
0 coins
Connor Richards
30 days from the date ON it not when you got it, that actually matters a lot didnt know that
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Yeah it tripped me up once. If your notice is dated the 1st and you got it on the 8th you've already burned a week of your appeal window.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Is there anything specific to write in the appeal or just that you disagree?
0 coins
Steven Adams
The not-reporting part is really common, nobody tells new parents they have to contact EDD the day they go back. The overpayment comes from payments issued for days after your return when you were already earning wages. Those two things together, wages plus PFL, can't add up to more than your regular pay, so EDD calculates the overlap and that becomes the overpayment amount.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
Does EDD know automatically when you go back to work, or did they just notice when you eventually reported it?
0 coins
Steven Adams
They find out when you report it, or if your employer reports wages that show up in EDD's records later. Either way it catches up.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorIn my case I think the employer wage report is what triggered it. I had no idea that was a thing.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Appeal the overpayment and file for the remaining weeks. Do both. Waiting on one to resolve before doing the other helps nobody, least of all you.
0 coins
Max Knight
Short and right. File the new DE 2501F now while the window is still open.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
yeah dont wait, four months sounds like a lot until it isnt
0 coins
Victoria Stark
For the new claim covering the remaining weeks, you'll want the receipt number from that filing. EDD should issue a Notice of Computation again for the new claim, showing what your weekly amount will be. If your base period wages are the same as before it'll probably be the same figure, but check your own notice rather than assuming.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
Do you get a new Notice of Computation even if it's the same person filing a second bonding claim within the same 12 months?
0 coins
Victoria Stark
From what I can tell, yes. Each new claim filing generates its own notice. The benefit amount can shift if your base period earnings changed.
0 coins
LordCommander
That makes sense since the base period looks back at wages from a specific window, not a fixed number forever.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Got a DE 2514 Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination on my own claim after a mix-up with the dates I reported. Spent three mornings trying the EDD line and each time it dropped. Ended up using Claimyr and spoke with an agent who looked at my claim and confirmed the determination was because I'd listed my leave start date wrong on the form. She told me I could appeal with the DE 1000A and correct the date in my statement.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
What did you need to have ready when you called? Like did they ask for anything specific to pull up your claim?
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Social security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the date on the determination notice. Had all three ready and the agent found everything right away.
0 coins
Connor Richards
ive been redialing since tuesday, three attempts every morning and it just cuts off every single time
0 coins
Lucy Lam
Okay so I'm worried about something slightly different. If I appeal the overpayment and lose the appeal, does that mean I definitely have to pay the whole amount back? Or is there a way to dispute the amount itself?
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
The appeal is your chance to dispute both the finding and the amount. Present any documentation you have showing when you actually returned to work, pay stubs, emails from your employer, whatever you've got.
0 coins
Emma Swift
An overpayment notice can be appealed the same way as any determination. EDD will send you their decision by mail and you go from there.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
So I'd need to actually show proof of my return date. I have a text from my manager, would that work?
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Don't sit on the appeal deadline. 30 days goes fast when you're back at work full time and dealing with a baby. Write the date on your calendar today.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorAlready did that this morning after reading all this. The notice is dated the 3rd so I've got until the end of the month roughly.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Good. Get the DE 1000A in well before that, not on day 29.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Status on my own bonding claim said the proof of relationship was still pending weeks after I uploaded, so I tried Claimyr and got an agent. She could see the birth certificate had come in but wasn't matched to the claim ID yet, still sitting in a document queue. She said to allow a few more business days and check SDI Online again.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
My situation with the second bonding claim is exactly the kind of thing I'd want an agent to look at. What did you have with you when you reached her, just the claim ID?
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Claim ID and the date I uploaded the document. Have those handy, the agent used both to find the file on their end.
0 coins
LordCommander
The fact that documents can be received but unmatched to a claim for days is wild. No wonder people's statuses stay pending so long.
0 coins
Connor Richards
wait so you file a totally new de 2501f for the weeks you didnt use? i thought you just updated the same claim somehow
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
Yes, a fresh DE 2501F. The original claim is closed once you returned full-time, so the remaining weeks need their own submission with a new receipt number.
0 coins
Connor Richards
ok that makes way more sense now, thought i was missing some update button in sdi online
0 coins
Steven Adams
One thing that tripped up my neighbor in a similar spot was thinking there's a waiting period for PFL before the first payment. There isn't one. PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way some other programs do, so once EDD processes the new claim the payments start from the first eligible day.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
Wait, I thought there were seven unpaid days at the start? My HR told me that.
0 coins
Steven Adams
That's the waiting period for Disability Insurance, not PFL. They're different programs. PFL doesn't have one.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
HR gave me wrong info then, I would have thought I was losing a week for no reason. Glad I asked.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
the 12 month clock is really what you need to watch. everything else can be sorted, but once that window closes you lose whatever weeks are left
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorFour months left on mine, filing the DE 2501F this week before anything else slips.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
good. the overpayment stuff will drag on way longer than four months if you let it, but the bonding window wont wait
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Payment timing on my second PFL stretch confused me. The agent date on my claim showed a gap I couldn't explain. Used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line. She looked at the payment history and told me one week had been held because the DE 2580GF came in after the processing window for that period. She confirmed the payment was scheduled and I'd see it in SDI Online.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
Payment date gaps are exactly what I'm dreading on my own claim. I tried Claimyr on a different question and ended up getting the receipt number confirmed on the spot by the agent, which at least let me know the claim wasn't floating out there somewhere unattached.
0 coins
Grace Durand
How long had you been trying the EDD line before that?
0 coins
Lucy Lam
About nine days of trying mornings before I stopped counting.
0 coins
LordCommander
Just to make sure I understand the math: if someone took five weeks of bonding, went back to work, and the overpayment covers two of those five weeks due to unreported wages, do they still have three remaining weeks to use, or eight minus five regardless of the overpayment?
0 coins
Emma Swift
The overpayment doesn't add weeks back. The eight weeks total is the ceiling regardless of what you used and whether some of it was later flagged as an overpayment. So five weeks used means three left, full stop.
0 coins
LordCommander
That's what I figured but wanted someone to confirm it. So the appeal might reduce the overpayment amount but doesn't change the weeks available.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
Exactly right. The benefit weeks and the repayment amount are separate calculations.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
EDD not explaining any of this in plain language when you first file is half the problem. The DE 2501F instructions don't say anywhere that going back to work full-time before your leave ends requires you to notify EDD immediately. You find out the hard way.
0 coins
Max Knight
Found out exactly that way. Got an overpayment notice two months after I went back and had no idea what I'd done wrong.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
And by then the appeal window on the payments is tighter. The whole system assumes you already know what it never tells you.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
It's actually reassuring to see that the remaining weeks can still be used! I was reading this thinking the person who posted would just lose everything after the overpayment notice and that seemed really unfair.
0 coins
Steven Adams
The leave is still there inside the 12-month window. The overpayment is a separate debt situation, it doesn't cancel the leave entitlement.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
That distinction really matters and I had no idea EDD treated them separately.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
For the new DE 2501F filing, have your daughter's birth certificate ready again. EDD will want proof of relationship on a fresh bonding claim even if you submitted it before.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorEven for the same child, same parent, second filing?
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Yes. Each claim is its own filing. Submit the document again and keep a copy.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorAnnoying but okay. At least I still have the PDF.
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
The Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, is what EDD sends when you're taking leave intermittently and working some days. If the new claim involves going back part-time rather than a full continuous stretch, that form becomes important. Missing it or not returning it stops payments.
0 coins
Connor Richards
so for the new claim if im doing like two days a week at work and three days on leave i have to report every week?
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
Every eligible work period, yes. EDD sends the DE 2580GF and you return it. If it doesn't come in, benefits stop until it does.
0 coins
Connor Richards
ok noted, the reporting is the part i always forget
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Appeal filed, new DE 2501F in, receipt number saved. That's the whole list. Do it in that order and stop worrying.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
AuthorHonestly this thread gave me more clarity than three days of reading EDD's website. Filing both today.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Good. Come back if the status stays pending past 14 days on the new one.
0 coins