Back to California Paid Family Leave

Paolo Ricci

PFL overpayment notice returned to work vacation payout — did my employer's lump sum cause this?

So I'm kind of panicking right now and hoping someone here has dealt with this. I took PFL bonding leave starting in August when my daughter was born, and everything seemed fine — payments came in, I was home with her, all good. Then in October my company asked me to come back early, and when I did they paid out the vacation hours I'd accrued during my leave as a lump sum on my next paycheck. Now I got this overpayment notice from EDD and I honestly don't fully understand why. I did report that I went back to work, but I didn't even think about the vacation payout when it happened — I just assumed EDD only cared about actual hours I worked. Is that vacation payout what triggered the overpayment? Do I have 30 days to appeal this? I'm so stressed about owing money back when I genuinely didn't know I had to report that.

Payment dates on my own bonding claim got confusing in a similar situation, so I want to share what I found out. Around the time I went back to work, I wasn't sure which days EDD had actually issued payment for and which were still pending. I tried the phone line every morning for a week and either got a busy signal or the recording ended the call. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the exact dates payments had been issued and which days were still open, so I could figure out the overlap when my employer paid out vacation. That cleared up why the overpayment notice landed when it did.

0 coins

Ok so I want to try this for my own situation — I haven't been able to figure out whether the check EDD shows as issued actually posted for the right week. What do I need to have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your EDD Customer Account Number, and the claim ID from SDI Online. The agent can look up specific payment dates right there.

0 coins

That is so helpful! I've been checking SDI Online every day and the payment history section only tells me so much, good to know an agent can give you the exact dates.

0 coins

To answer your question about what triggered it: EDD considers wages the period they were earned, not the period they were paid. Vacation pay that your employer pays out when you return to work is wages, and if any of those days overlapped with days EDD paid you PFL, that is what creates the overpayment. Reporting only your return date was the right instinct, but the vacation payout needed to be reported too since it covers the same leave period.

0 coins

Thank you, so the vacation hours I accrued during leave — EDD treats those as if I earned them during those same days?

0 coins

Exactly right. The payout is attached to the period it covers, so EDD looks at which PFL-paid days those vacation hours correspond to and that is the overlap they flag.

0 coins

Wait, so even if your paycheck came in October but the vacation hours were from August and September, EDD goes back to August and September? That seems like it would catch a lot of people off guard.

0 coins

It does catch people off guard. The rule ties wages to when they were earned, not the paycheck date, so the timing of when your employer cuts the check doesn't change how EDD counts it.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is real and it starts from the date on the notice, not the date you received it. So open that envelope, find the date printed on the notice, and count from there. If you think the amount is wrong or you didn't actually receive wages for those days, file the appeal. The Appeal Form number is DE 1000A and you can do it online or mail it.

0 coins

Got it, the date on the notice itself — I'll look at that tonight. Mine is dated November 3rd so I need to move.

0 coins

November 3rd means you're already a couple weeks in. File the appeal this week, don't wait.

0 coins

Seconding this. The 30 days goes fast.

0 coins

You reported going back to work and that was right. The piece you missed was reporting the vacation payout as wages. EDD combines what you earned with what they paid you, and when that total is more than your normal pay for those days, that's the problem.

0 coins

So is it possible the overpayment amount is just the PFL days that lined up with the vacation pay, not my entire bonding claim?

0 coins

Right. It shouldn't be the whole claim, just the days where the two overlapped. Check the notice — it should say which weeks and what amount.

0 coins

The notice should break it down by week. If the figures don't match what your paystub shows for those weeks, that's what you'd point to in an appeal.

0 coins

Worth knowing: PFL wages plus any other wages for the same days can't add up to more than your normal weekly pay. So if the vacation payout was big enough to push you over your usual weekly amount for those days, EDD takes back the difference. It doesn't automatically wipe out the whole claim.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring, I was afraid it meant they'd want everything back.

0 coins

Yeah that's how it works, they're not trying to cancel your whole leave, just recover the overage. The notice amount should reflect that.

0 coins

mines was way less than i expected when i read the actual notice carefully, worth doing that before you stress too much

0 coins

How many weeks I had left came up for me when I went back early too. I'd used about five weeks and wasn't sure if the remaining three were still available. Tried calling EDD multiple times, the line just dropped every time. Used Claimyr and the agent told me I had three weeks remaining in my 12-month window from the baby's birth date. That mattered because I ended up needing more time later.

0 coins

The remaining weeks question is exactly what I had too. I used Claimyr for my own claim and once the agent confirmed how many weeks were left, she also told me which weeks had already been paid and when my next payment cycle was due. I had honestly just been guessing before that.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that line for three weeks straight, nothing but the recording every time

0 coins

Three weeks is a lot of frustration. The agent I spoke with was clear and had everything right there on the claim.

0 coins

The DE 2530 guide EDD publishes specifically says that any return to work, even partial, and any wages — including wages not yet paid — are supposed to be reported. The vacation payout counts as wages for the days it covers. If your employer's HR can give you a written breakdown showing which days the payout corresponds to, that document would be useful if you appeal.

0 coins

HR gave me the payout on a separate line on my paycheck but I don't think they broke it down by day — I'll ask them for that detail.

0 coins

Ask them to specify which pay period or which accrued dates the vacation covered. EDD will want to match it to specific PFL-paid days.

0 coins

A letter from payroll showing the accrual dates is the clearest thing to include with an appeal. Without it EDD has to guess at the mapping.

0 coins

EDD is not going to waive the overpayment just because you didn't know about the vacation payout rule. Appeal if the amount is wrong. If the amount is right, they'll set up repayment.

0 coins

That's what I figured honestly. I'm not expecting a free pass, I just want to make sure they calculated it right.

0 coins

Then pull the paystubs, compare the vacation days to the PFL payment dates, and see if their number matches yours.

0 coins

My coworker went through almost this exact thing last year. She came back from bonding leave two weeks early and her employer paid out her remaining PTO in a lump sum. EDD sent her an overpayment notice for the two weeks. She appealed because she thought the PTO wasn't supposed to count, but EDD explained it covers wages for that period. She ended up setting up a payment plan.

0 coins

Payment plan — is that something you can just ask for or do they offer it automatically?

0 coins

She just asked when she responded to the notice. EDD worked with her on it.

0 coins

Yeah they generally let you set something up rather than demanding everything at once.

0 coins

you should definitely appeal if you think the number is off, they dont always calculate it perfectly especially with the lump sum situation

0 coins

Yeah I'm going to compare my paystubs tonight to what the notice says and see if anything looks off.

0 coins

good call, the notice should have a breakdown, if it doesnt match your stubs thats what you bring up

0 coins

I'm still confused about one part — if vacation pay is wages, does that mean paid sick leave would cause the same problem? Like if someone uses a sick day and the employer pays it out during PFL, is that also an overpayment situation?

0 coins

Sick leave used during the same days you're getting PFL can create the same issue if the combined amount goes over your normal daily wages. The key is whether the two payments together exceed what you'd normally earn.

0 coins

So it's not the type of leave, it's just whether you end up getting more than your regular pay for those days?

0 coins

Exactly. The cap is your normal wage for those days. PFL plus any employer pay for the same days can't go over that without triggering a problem.

0 coins

November 3rd on the notice means your 30-day window runs out early December. If you're going to file the DE 1000A appeal, do it this week and keep a copy of everything you submit.

0 coins

Filing online through SDI Online or mailing the form — does it matter which?

0 coins

Either works, but online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ gives you a submission confirmation. Mailing it, send it somewhere you can track it.

0 coins

The confirmation from online submission is good to have if there's ever a question about when it was received.

0 coins

Start date on my claim was something I had to verify before I could figure out my 41-day window and which weeks fell inside it. My employer paid out accrued vacation the same week I filed, and I needed to know exactly when EDD recorded my claim starting. Got through to an agent using Claimyr after three mornings of the line dropping on me. The agent said my claim start date was recorded as the first day I reported my leave, not the day EDD processed it, and confirmed I was still inside the 41 days.

0 coins

I've called that line probably nine or ten times and every single time it either says the volume is too high or just cuts off. I'm not sure anything gets through on that line anymore, honestly.

0 coins

I'd say the same thing, I really did give up for a few days. What I did with Claimyr was just let it handle the hold part and my phone rang when an agent picked up. My receipt number and claim ID were right in front of me and the conversation went fast.

0 coins

Claim start date matters a lot when vacation payout is in the picture. Good that you got that confirmed directly.

0 coins

EDD's overpayment notices do sometimes have arithmetic errors. Worth doing the math yourself before you decide whether to appeal or just pay.

0 coins

Doing the math myself tonight. If their number matches mine I'll probably just ask about a payment plan.

0 coins

That's the sensible move. Appeal when the number is wrong, arrange repayment when it isn't.

0 coins

Payment method was actually something I had to sort out on my bonding claim, because my direct deposit info changed banks right as I went back to work and I wasn't sure which payments had gone where. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent confirmed which payment method was on file and that the last two payments before I returned had gone to the old account. Knowing that helped me reconcile everything before the overpayment question even came up.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned here.

0 coins

You give it your info and it stays on hold with EDD's PFL line for you, so when a person picks up, you're the one talking to them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

My claim has a payment method question I haven't been able to get cleared up for two weeks. Might be worth trying.

0 coins

The piece a lot of people miss is that the overpayment isn't a penalty, it's just EDD recovering money that went out for days you were also paid by your employer. It doesn't mean you did something wrong intentionally.

0 coins

That framing helps, honestly. I've been treating it like I'm in trouble when really it's just a reconciliation issue.

0 coins

Exactly. File the appeal if the number's off, or set up a payment plan if it's right. Either way you're not in legal trouble.

0 coins

This is a good point. The notice sounds scary but it's really just EDD saying we paid you and your employer paid you for the same days, here's the difference.

0 coins

Also wanted to flag: PFL has no waiting period, so there's no built-in unpaid week at the start of your claim! Sometimes people mix that up with disability claims. Your overpayment math shouldn't have a waiting-period deduction in it.

0 coins

Wait, I thought all EDD claims had a one-week waiting period where you don't get paid?

0 coins

That's disability insurance, not PFL. PFL doesn't have a waiting period — EDD's own site says that clearly. If someone got confused on this for a bonding claim, those first days would be missing from the payment history and it could actually make the overpayment math wrong.

0 coins

Good to know, I'll make sure the notice doesn't subtract a waiting week that shouldn't be there.

0 coins

Side question — if you appeal and lose, can you still set up a payment plan? Or does losing the appeal mean they expect it all at once?

0 coins

Losing an appeal doesn't automatically mean the full amount is due immediately. You can still request a payment arrangement after a determination comes through.

0 coins

EDD generally doesn't demand a lump sum on overpayments unless you ignore them entirely. Responding to the notice, appeal or not, is the main thing.

0 coins

Ok that makes sense, good to know the payment plan option doesn't go away.

0 coins

Report wages when they're paid and what period they cover. That's the piece that trips people up here. If you go back early and get a vacation payout, let EDD know the dates those wages are for.

0 coins

That's the lesson I'll carry forward. I reported the return date but didn't realize the payout itself needed its own report.

0 coins

Yep. The return date and the wage amount are two separate things EDD needs to know.

0 coins

edd also sends a continued claim certification form sometimes when you go back parttime, did you get one of those? just wondering if that played into it at all

0 coins

I went back full time so I don't think that applies to me, but good to know that exists for partial returns.

0 coins

yeah if you went back full time you dont have to worry about the DE 2580GF, that ones for people splitting their leave

0 coins

The DE 2580GF is the continued claim form for partial or intermittent leave. Full return wraps the claim, so you're right it's not in play here.

0 coins

One thing to double-check on the notice: the weekly benefit amount EDD used. Your Notice of Computation from when you filed shows your weekly benefit rate. If the overpayment calculation used a different number, that's another thing to flag in an appeal.

0 coins

I saved the Notice of Computation — I'll compare the weekly rate on that to what the overpayment notice used.

0 coins

If they match, then it's really just about which weeks overlapped. If they don't match, that's your strongest appeal point.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure