Back to California Paid Family Leave

Tyrone Hill

PFL overpayment never received repayment letter but 1099G shows full amount paid

Filing my taxes and I pulled up my 1099-G from EDD and I'm genuinely confused. It shows the full amount of PFL benefits I received last year, but back in October I got a notice saying I had an overpayment because I returned to work earlier than I reported. I sent in a check to repay it in November. The 1099-G still reflects the total original amount, not the reduced amount after repayment. I never got any letter acknowledging that EDD received my repayment, and nothing updated in SDI Online either. Did EDD not credit the repayment? Is the 1099-G supposed to show the gross amount before repayment, or should it reflect what I actually kept? And if I never got a formal repayment letter or receipt from EDD, how do I even know they applied it correctly? I'm worried I'm going to owe taxes on money I already gave back.

Start date on my claim was flagged as a discrepancy, so I needed an answer fast before the 41-day window closed. Tried EDD's line three mornings in a row and the recording ended the call every time. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and an agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file matched my first day of leave, so the 41-day count was running from the right date. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Wait, what is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned but I've never tried it.

0 coins

You dial into EDD but it stays on the line while you do other things, and when an actual EDD employee picks up your phone rings. That's the whole thing. What do you need to ask them about?

0 coins

My claim shows pending and I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet, like two weeks in now. That's exactly what I'd want to clear up. Might give it a shot.

0 coins

The 1099-G showing the full original amount is actually expected in most cases. EDD reports what it paid out in that calendar year. If you repaid in November of the same year, the amount on the 1099-G may still reflect the gross amount before the repayment was processed. How that gets handled for tax purposes is genuinely something to bring to a tax professional or look at EDD's tax information page, because EDD itself doesn't give tax guidance on overpayment repayments.

0 coins

So EDD doesn't issue a corrected 1099-G even if you repaid in the same year? That's what's tripping me up.

0 coins

My understanding is that the 1099-G reflects what was paid to you, not the net. Whether the repayment changes your taxable amount is a question for a tax professional, not EDD's phone line.

0 coins

Agreed on the tax professional part. The IRS has its own rules about repaid benefits and whether a deduction applies, but that is completely outside what EDD decides, so their agents won't know.

0 coins

November 14th I sent my own repayment check for an overpayment from last spring. By December the balance on my overpayment notice still showed in SDI Online. I called EDD in January and an agent confirmed they had received the payment but it had not yet posted to the claim. Took until late January to show as cleared. So your payment may be received but not yet reflected.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. Did you eventually get any kind of letter or receipt confirming it was credited?

0 coins

A notice came in the mail about three weeks after I called, confirming the balance was paid in full. If you haven't gotten that, it's worth contacting them.

0 coins

EDD's mail is slow. I had a 10-day gap between them processing something and me actually getting a letter about it.

0 coins

EDD not sending a repayment confirmation letter is classic. You send them a check, it disappears into the void, and then you're left wondering if it even hit the right account. I never got a letter either after my repayment and had to call to confirm it. Their phone line is an obstacle course but it's the only way to actually verify anything.

0 coins

Obstacle course is generous.

0 coins

How many times did it take you to get through?

0 coins

Four mornings. Two of those the recording just said high call volume and ended. I finally got through on a Friday afternoon.

0 coins

The overpayment notice itself, the one EDD sends, should include repayment instructions and state where to send the check. If you followed those instructions and sent it to the right address, the payment should be tracked on the claim. What you can do now is use the Request Claim Update in SDI Online to ask EDD to confirm the repayment was received and applied. That's under your claim ID in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/

0 coins

I didn't know you could do that through SDI Online. I'll try that before calling.

0 coins

Pick the claim, then Request Claim Update, choose the type that fits and write your question. It goes to EDD's team directly.

0 coins

Does that actually get a response? I've sent two and heard nothing back after two weeks.

0 coins

It can take a while. If nothing comes in another week I'd follow up by phone.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing last year with my care claim. Sent in a repayment, no letter, 1099-G showed the full amount, panicked at tax time. My accountant said the repayment still matters for federal purposes but the specifics depend on the year and the amount. She handled it. Definitely get a tax person involved if you repaid a significant amount.

0 coins

Was the 1099-G ever corrected or did you just handle it on your own return?

0 coins

No corrected 1099-G came. My accountant just noted the repayment on the return separately. EDD doesn't issue revised ones for repayments as far as I know.

0 coins

Same situation for me two years ago. The 1099-G stayed as-is and my tax preparer handled it. EDD's tax info page has some guidance too, worth reading.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim was showing wrong in SDI Online, said check when I'd signed up for direct deposit. Spent a week trying to get EDD on the phone. Used Claimyr and an agent confirmed my bank info was on file and the payment method had already switched to direct deposit, the status just hadn't updated on the screen yet.

0 coins

I actually used Claimyr too for my care claim, glad it worked for you. When I spoke with an agent I asked about intermittent days I'd already worked but hadn't reported yet. She pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2580GF had been sent to me and I had a deadline to return it or payments would stop. That was news to me.

0 coins

When you got the DE 2580GF, did you have to list every single day you'd worked or just the weeks?

0 coins

Every day and the hours. The form had a row for each week and you fill in which days. Agent was clear that wages had to be reported even if I hadn't been paid yet.

0 coins

Glad you caught that before payments actually stopped. Missing the DE 2580GF return is how a lot of people end up with overpayments.

0 coins

If you appealed the overpayment notice and lost track of that, the 30-day window to appeal matters. You get a DE 1000A with the overpayment notice. If that window's closed and you just paid, then you paid it, and the 1099-G is what it is.

0 coins

I didn't appeal, I agreed with the overpayment. I returned to work a week earlier than I'd reported and the difference was clear. I just didn't realize repaying didn't update the 1099-G.

0 coins

Then you're in good shape on the EDD side. The tax piece is between you and your preparer.

0 coins

edd never sends letters when you want them to and sends three when you dont lol. check sdionline for your claim balance, if it shows zero youre good

0 coins

The balance does show zero which is why I was confused about the 1099-G still being the full amount.

0 coins

zero balance means they got it. the 1099g thing is a tax question not an edd question

0 coins

Tax season with an overpayment in the mix is stressful! For what it's worth, EDD's tax information page has some details on this. It's under the PFL section of edd.ca.gov. And a good tax preparer who's dealt with government benefit repayments will know exactly what to do with that 1099-G!

0 coins

I haven't looked at their tax page yet, good reminder. I've been so focused on whether the repayment was processed that I didn't check what EDD actually says about the tax side.

0 coins

The tax page won't answer everything but it's a starting point before you go pay for a tax pro appointment!

0 coins

Receipt number was something I lost track of when I first filed, nearly caused me a mess later. Used Claimyr and got an agent on my PFL bonding claim who found the receipt number attached to my filing and read it off to me, so I could match it to what I'd written down. Turned out I had one digit wrong in my notes.

0 coins

Honestly this reads like marketing to me. A service that gets you through EDD's phone line, that sounds like something you'd see advertised, not something a real person would just find.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned. Then I tried it because I had a DE 2514 sitting in my mailbox and no idea if the appeal window had started. Agent confirmed the date on the notice was the date I should count from for the 30-day appeal. That was real information from an actual EDD person.

0 coins

Okay that's more useful than I expected. I've been sitting on a pending overpayment question for two weeks and can't get anyone on the line. I'll probably just try it.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the last four of your Social ready when you call. That's what the agent asked me for right away, anyway.

0 coins

Zero balance in SDI Online is the clearest sign the repayment posted. The 1099-G question is for your tax preparer, not EDD.

0 coins

That's the most direct answer I've gotten. Thank you. Balance is zero so I'll bring the repayment amount and date to my preparer.

0 coins

Same situation last year. Tax preparer handled it, no issue.

0 coins

Worth knowing that if you had appealed the overpayment and won, EDD would send a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514, and you could appeal again from there. Since you agreed and paid, that path doesn't apply to you, but it's how the appeals chain works if someone reading this is still in dispute.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the DE 1000A appeal form is firm. If you miss it the original determination stands, so anyone who disagrees with an overpayment notice should file that form right away.

0 coins

The DE 1000A comes with the overpayment notice itself, so you don't have to track down a separate form. It's right in the envelope.

0 coins

EDD's 1099-G represents what left their account going to you. It doesn't track what came back. That's just how government reporting works. Your repayment is your own record to bring to a tax professional.

0 coins

Okay, I think I finally understand. I was treating the 1099-G like a net statement and it's not.

0 coins

Exactly. Gross out, your problem in.

0 coins

Repayment by check can also take a few weeks longer to process than people expect, especially if you mailed it close to a state holiday. If your balance shows zero in SDI Online I'd trust that over waiting for a letter.

0 coins

I sent it November 8th, so it was well before the holidays. Balance is zero as of this month so I'll go with that.

0 coins

You're in good shape then. Keep a copy of your cancelled check as your own proof, just in case.

0 coins

What worries me about this thread is that if someone doesn't have zero balance showing, they might not know the overpayment is still open. Is there any other way to tell besides SDI Online?

0 coins

EDD mails a notice when the balance is cleared. If you haven't received that and the balance is still showing in SDI Online, a Request Claim Update is the right next step.

0 coins

So there's no way to know without either the letter or the online balance. Got it.

0 coins

Calling EDD directly is the third option if neither of those is giving you clarity. An agent can tell you what's posted on the claim.

0 coins

Not reporting early return to work is how most bonding overpayments happen. You owe for the days you were paid PFL while actually earning wages. EDD catches it eventually.

0 coins

That's exactly what happened to me. I went back a week early and forgot to update EDD. Learned my lesson.

0 coins

yeah they match wage records so they always find it

0 coins

Does California tax the PFL you received, or just the federal side that's in question?

0 coins

California doesn't tax PFL benefits. EDD sends the 1099-G for federal purposes. For anything beyond that, a tax professional is the right call, since EDD's agents don't give tax advice.

0 coins

That's actually helpful to know. So the 1099-G matters for the federal return, not state.

0 coins

Right, and that's exactly where the repayment question gets complicated, which is why the tax professional advice in this thread is correct. The state side is clean.

0 coins

For anyone coming to this thread later, the main takeaways seem to be: check SDI Online for a zero balance to confirm EDD received the repayment, use Request Claim Update if you're unsure, and bring the repayment details to a tax preparer for the 1099-G question!

0 coins

SDI Online balance zero is the main thing. Everything else is paperwork.

0 coins

Agreed. Straightforward once you know where to look.

0 coins

Updating in case anyone finds this later: I sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online asking EDD to confirm my November repayment was applied. Got a response within about a week confirming the balance was cleared as of November 22nd. No corrected 1099-G will come, so I'm taking the repayment documentation to my tax preparer and letting them handle the federal return. Zero balance confirmed, repayment confirmed in writing now. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

Good outcome. Keep that SDI Online confirmation message saved somewhere.

0 coins

That confirmation message is exactly what you want on file. Well done following up through the system.

0 coins

November 22nd posting date is clean. Your tax preparer will know what to do with that.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure