PFL overpayment from filing before maxing out SDI pregnancy disability — has anyone dealt with this?
So I'm kind of panicking right now and hoping someone has been through this. I had a pregnancy disability claim running and my OB cleared me to return to work about two weeks before my disability period was supposed to end. I didn't realize I should have waited, so I filed my PFL bonding claim right then thinking I was doing everything right. EDD processed it and I got a couple of payments. Now I got a letter saying I have an overpayment because the disability and bonding overlapped somehow. I'm honestly not sure I even understand what I did wrong. Did filing PFL while disability was still technically active cause this? Can I appeal? I'm a first-time mom and I really didn't know these were two separate things that couldn't run at the same time.
78 comments

Kelsey Chin
The letter you received makes sense once you understand how these two programs interact. PFL and disability insurance can't pay for the same days, so when your bonding claim started while your disability period was still open, EDD flagged those overlapping days as overpaid. You'll want to look at the overpayment notice carefully for the exact dates they're disputing and the amount. There's an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, included with the notice, and you have 30 days from the date on the letter to file it if you disagree with their determination.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorThe letter does list dates. It's the two weeks where I had both going at once, which is exactly when I filed the PFL. So I guess that's the overlap. Do I have a real shot at an appeal if I just didn't know?
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Filing an appeal is always your right within that 30-day window. What you explain to EDD is your version of events, what you understood at the time, and that you weren't trying to double-collect. The decision comes from the administrative law judge, not EDD itself, so your honest account does matter.
0 coins
Norah Quay
Thirty days goes fast. Mail that appeal form before you do anything else.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
You can't get paid from both at the same time, that's just how it works. Disability covers your own condition, PFL bonding starts after. Overlap equals overpayment in EDD's eyes every time.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorNobody explained that to me when I filed. The SDI Online system just let me submit the PFL claim without any warning.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
Yeah the system won't stop you. It's on you to know the timing. Frustrating but that's EDD.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
Filing the appeal doesn't cost anything and you get to tell your side. Worth doing even if you're not sure it'll change anything.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
Two weeks of intermittent days I worked part-time after bonding started showed up differently than I expected on my claim, and I couldn't figure out if I'd reported them right. I tried the EDD line maybe eight or nine mornings over two weeks and kept getting the high-volume recording before it disconnected. Eventually I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the PFL line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my DE 2580GF and confirmed it had been received and matched to my claim, and told me which of the two weeks had already been processed for the intermittent days I'd reported. That at least settled the question of whether the form got there.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Eight or nine mornings and still nothing? I've had the exact same thing happen every time I try that line. Hard to believe any service actually gets you to a person there.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
I had the same doubt, genuinely. What happened was my phone rang and an EDD agent was on the line. She worked for EDD, confirmed the DE 2580GF was matched, and told me which week had been processed. That was enough for me.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
My bonding claim had a question about the payment method EDD had on file, and I used Claimyr the same way! The agent confirmed my direct deposit information was what I'd entered in SDI Online. Such a relief to hear it straight from someone at EDD!
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Ok that's actually useful to hear from two people. I've been trying that line since my own claim went pending and I'm starting to think I need a different approach.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
The overpayment notice should show a specific dollar amount and the exact days in question. Keep a copy of everything, the notice, the appeal form, your proof of when you filed both claims. Dates on file in SDI Online can back up your timeline.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorI do have the SDI Online confirmation from when I submitted the PFL claim, with the date stamp. Would that help in an appeal?
0 coins
KingKongZilla
Yes, that receipt showing the date you filed is exactly the kind of documentation to include. It shows you filed after your doctor cleared you, not trying to game anything.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
I'm not sure if uploading documents to SDI Online counts for an appeal or if you have to mail everything. Does anyone know which way is right?
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
For an appeal you use the DE 1000A form from the notice and follow the instructions on it for where to send it. The notice itself tells you the address.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Oh wow I went through something weirdly similar. My client actually told me about this, she had her disability claim and tried to start bonding before her doctor officially closed the disability period. Same result, overpayment notice. She ended up appealing and just explained the whole situation honestly. Fingers crossed for you!
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorIt's honestly reassuring that someone else has been through it. Did she hear back on the appeal quickly or did it take forever?
0 coins
Nathan Dell
She waited a while, I won't lie. But she said the judge actually listened and let her explain the timeline. She didn't get the full amount waived but some of it was sorted out.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
EDD doesn't promise any timeline on appeals. Could be months.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
edd literally has no way to warn you in the system when you file pfl too early its so annoying. ive seen people mess this up all the time because nobody tells you disability has to close first
0 coins
Amaya Watson
Does the disability close automatically when you go back to work or do you have to tell EDD?
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
you gotta let edd know you went back, the system doesnt just know on its own
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Reporting your return to work is required. When disability and PFL overlap because that step was missed, EDD treats the PFL payments for those days as an overpayment. That's exactly what happened here.
0 coins
Grant Vikers
Sent my DE 2501FP in after the disability ended and thought I was fine, then got a confusing notice about dates. Took me days to untangle what week they were talking about. If your notice has overlapping dates just go line by line.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorMine lists four specific dates in November. At least it's clear about which days they're counting.
0 coins
Grant Vikers
Four days is manageable. Easier to explain on appeal than a whole month. You've got this, anyway.
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
Patients mix these two programs up constantly. The rule is simple: disability ends, then bonding starts. No gap is required but they can't share a single day.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
So there's no waiting period between disability ending and PFL starting? I thought there were seven unpaid days or something at the start of PFL?
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
PFL has no waiting period. The seven days you're thinking of is a disability insurance thing, not PFL. Different program.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
Oh wow I had that completely wrong. So bonding can start the day after disability closes with no unpaid gap at all?
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
Correct. The day after disability ends is fine.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
The DE 2514 sitting in my portal was what started my whole spiral about whether my care claim had been denied outright or just delayed. I eventually got a live person at EDD using Claimyr after trying the phone line myself across probably a dozen mornings with no luck. The agent looked up the DE 2514 and told me it was a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination reflecting one specific week that wasn't covered, not a full denial, and that I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal if I disagreed with that week being excluded.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
What exactly is Claimyr? I keep seeing people mention it and I'm not clear on how it works.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
The way it worked for me: Claimyr holds the line with EDD so you don't have to sit there redialing, and when an EDD agent picks up, your phone rings and you're talking to them directly. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
Got it. I'd want to ask EDD about why my claim still shows pending after 11 days. Might try it for that.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
Eleven days is still inside the 14-day window EDD says they can take to decide. If it goes past that, asking them directly is the right move.
0 coins
Levi Parker
The overlap issue comes up more than people realize. Disability and PFL both pull from your SDI contributions but they're separate claims and EDD absolutely will claw back anything paid on overlapping days. I've heard of people successfully reducing the overpayment amount on appeal when they can show they didn't understand the timing rules, though EDD never promises a waiver.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorReducing it, not eliminating it entirely, is probably more realistic for me anyway. Even that would help.
0 coins
Levi Parker
Yeah that's usually where appeals land when the overlap was unintentional and the person can show it. Document everything.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
The appeal form being included with the overpayment notice is actually the one thing EDD does right lol. At least you don't have to hunt for it.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorTrue, I'll give them that. It was right there attached to the letter.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
Fill it out fast and send it certified mail so you have proof it arrived before the 30 days is up.
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
Tracking the 30-day deadline from the date on the notice, not the date you received it, matters. If it arrived late in the mail you need to account for that.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorThe letter is dated the 3rd and I got it on the 7th. So I'm already four days behind the clock without having done anything.
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
Get the appeal form in the mail this week then. Mailing it certified gives you a postmark date as your record.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
Agreed. Postmark and a copy of everything for your own records before anything goes out.
0 coins
Sofia Peña
reading this at 2am because i got a similar notice last month. appeal is filed, waiting now. it's a rough process.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorI hope yours works out. How long have you been waiting since you filed the appeal?
0 coins
Sofia Peña
six weeks and counting. no word yet.
0 coins
Levi Parker
Part D not" received sat on my care'claim s status for over a week after the'doctor s office had already submitted it online with the receipt number. Tried the PFL line for days, never once got past the automated message. I ended up using Claimyr to get through, and when the agent looked at my claim she told me the Part D was there but'hadn t been matched to the claim yet. She confirmed the receipt number on file and said the form wascomplete.
0 coins
Grant Vikers
I'd used Claimyr for my own claim too, and I'm glad I did. The receipt number question was what I needed answered, specifically whether the one I'd written down from the confirmation screen was what EDD actually had on file. The agent read it back to me and it matched exactly, which meant the mix-up was somewhere else.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
What did you do after the agent confirmed the receipt number matched?
0 coins
Grant Vikers
Went back into SDI Online and looked at the claim status again. At that point I could see the Part C had already been received, so the last piece was just waiting on EDD's side to finish processing.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Two Part D situations sorted out through that line in one thread. Makes me think my pending claim issue might be worth a call too.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
Circling back to the original question: for the appeal, the written explanation you attach to the DE 1000A is your chance to lay out the full story. When you got the medical clearance, when you filed, that you weren't trying to draw from both at once. Keep it factual and in order by date.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorFactual and in date order, I can do that. I have the doctor's return-to-work note too, which shows the exact date I was cleared.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
That note is exactly the kind of thing to attach. It corroborates your timeline independently of anything you're saying yourself.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
The clearer the documented timeline, the easier it is for the judge to follow. That return-to-work note helps.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
If the appeal doesn't go your way, is there another level you can take it to or is EDD's decision final at that point?
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
The administrative law judge's decision can be further appealed to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. The appeal form and the notice will have information on that process.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
So there's more than one level. Good to know before assuming the first decision ends it.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
How long did you have the PFL payments coming in before EDD caught the overlap and sent the notice? Just wondering how long it usually takes them to flag it.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorI got two payments before the notice arrived. So maybe three to four weeks total from when I filed PFL to when they flagged it.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
Three or four weeks is actually faster than I expected EDD to notice anything.
0 coins
Norah Quay
They're not always that fast. Sometimes it takes longer and the amount is bigger when they finally do catch it.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Can I ask something that might be dumb: does appealing the overpayment pause any collections while you wait? Like would EDD try to take back money before the appeal is decided?
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Filing the appeal is the step to take, and your situation with collections during the appeal period is something to raise directly with EDD or note on the appeal form itself. The notice should also have instructions about that.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Makes sense to ask EDD directly on that one. I'll pass that along.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
The myEDD portal at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ shows your payment history by date, which could help you pull exactly which days were paid under each claim. Having that side by side with the overpayment notice makes the overlap pretty visible.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
AuthorI didn't even think to look at the payment history that way. Pulling it up now to compare against the dates on the notice.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
The dates column is super useful for exactly this! Each payment shows which period it covers, so you can line it up with what disability was paying at the same time.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
Bottom line for anyone reading this later: finish your disability claim fully before you start PFL bonding. EDD doesn't care if you misunderstood, the overlap is an overpayment regardless.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
wish someone had posted this like a year ago lol. i see people make this mistake constantly
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
It's one of those things that seems obvious after but nobody tells you upfront. The systems are connected but the claims are completely separate.
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
Disability covers your own medical condition. PFL bonding is for time with the baby. Two different purposes, two different claims, they don't run at the same time.
0 coins