Back to California Paid Family Leave

Zara Malik

PFL overpayment form 1446 repayment plan penalty fraud worry — what actually happens?

So I got a letter from EDD last week saying I was overpaid on my PFL bonding claim and they want the money back. I'm honestly kind of panicking because the letter mentioned something about a "false statement" penalty and I don't even know what I did wrong. I reported my return to work, I thought I did it right, but maybe I made a mistake on the dates or something? The letter referenced a DE 1446 and I've been trying to figure out if that means they think I committed fraud or if it's just a regular overpayment situation. Can you get a repayment plan or do they just demand it all at once? And the penalty part is really scaring me — does that automatically mean they think you were trying to cheat them, or can it happen even when it was just an honest mistake? I haven't been able to get anyone at EDD on the phone to explain any of this to me. I've been trying every morning this week and the line just cuts off after the hold music plays for a while.

Getting that letter with 'false statement' language in it is alarming, and I understand why you're scared. The penalty and the overpayment are actually two separate things, and not every overpayment comes with a fraud finding. Sometimes the penalty language appears even when EDD believes it was an error in reporting, not intentional deception. The DE 1446 is the overpayment notice, and it does give you the right to appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A form. If you disagree with any part of it, including the penalty, you can appeal that too. Don't let the 30 days slip by while you're trying to reach someone by phone.

0 coins

The 30-day part is what I keep fixating on — does that clock start from when they mailed it or when I actually received it?

0 coins

The notice itself will have the date on it, and that's what EDD goes by. If you're close to the edge, file the appeal first and add your explanation after. Better to appeal and not need it than miss the window.

0 coins

Okay filing the appeal is going to the top of my list today. Thank you.

0 coins

Repayment plans exist. You can request one. EDD doesn't always make it easy to find that option but it's there. The appeal and the repayment question are separate tracks — you can do both at the same time.

0 coins

Wait, so I can appeal AND ask for a payment plan at the same time? I wasn't sure if appealing meant I was saying I don't owe anything, like would that make them angrier or something?

0 coins

Appealing just means you're contesting part of the determination. It doesn't block you from working out payment on the amount you do agree you owe. They're handled separately.

0 coins

That's honestly a relief, I didn't realize you could do both. I've been going back and forth on whether to appeal or just pay it.

0 coins

DE 2514 came on my care claim about six weeks into the leave saying I wasn't eligible, and I had no idea what step I'd missed. Spent three mornings dialing and either got a busy signal or the system ended the call on me. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and that got me talking to an actual EDD agent. She pulled up the determination and told me Part D from the doctor had come in after the 41-day cutoff, which is why the DE 2514 went out. Video on reaching a live EDD Paid Family Leave agent: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Once I had that in writing from EDD I knew exactly what to put in my appeal.

0 coins

Receipt number situation on my claim was a mess — I'd filed but the confirmation screen timed out before I could write it down, so I had no idea if EDD had the claim at all. Used Claimyr the same way, ended up with an EDD agent who located the claim by my Social and gave me the receipt number right over the phone. Went back and uploaded the birth certificate with that number the same afternoon, so the bonding claim actually moved forward.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try before you found that? I've been at it since Tuesday and it just rings forever and drops, anyway.

0 coins

Four mornings in a row on that receipt number thing. The agent I finally reached had everything right there, took maybe ten minutes once I was actually on with someone.

0 coins

Tuesday through Friday here too. Same result every time.

0 coins

41 days out from when your leave started is when the window closes to avoid losing benefits — that detail trips a lot of people up. But the overpayment question is different from the filing deadline. If you were already paid and then EDD decides retroactively that some days weren't eligible, that's where the DE 1446 comes from. The false statement penalty specifically is added when EDD believes there was an intentional misrepresentation, so if yours was a reporting error on dates, that's worth explaining clearly in your appeal.

0 coins

So the false statement penalty isn't automatic just because there's an overpayment — EDD has to actually find that you meant to misrepresent something?

0 coins

Right, that's how it works. An honest error in dates or wages reported is different from EDD finding you deliberately hid income. If your appeal explains the mistake clearly, that distinction matters.

0 coins

My cousin got an overpayment notice a couple years back and she was terrified about the same thing. Turned out she'd reported her return date one week off and once she explained it in writing the penalty part got dropped. Not saying that's guaranteed for everyone, but mistakes happen.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it can be submitted online or by mail — the address is on your notice. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my wife's bonding claim was something the portal showed as still pending for almost two weeks after she uploaded the birth certificate. I'd been getting nowhere on the phone, so I went through Claimyr and got an EDD agent who checked the claim. He said the document had been received but hadn't been matched to the claim yet, and told me it should clear within the normal review window. Ended up not needing to do anything extra once I had that confirmation.

0 coins

Fourteen days and a document that's sitting there unmatched — that sounds like the kind of thing where you call and nothing gets done anyway. How do you know the agent actually did anything, not just told you what you wanted to hear?

0 coins

Claim moved to approved status two days later. I can't say whether the agent flagged it or whether it was just the normal timeline, but knowing the document was in there let me stop worrying about re-uploading and making it worse.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my care claim showed a weekly amount that didn't match what I'd estimated using EDD's calculator. After getting through to an EDD agent through Claimyr, she walked me through which quarter of wages they'd used as the high quarter for the base period and confirmed the number on the DE 429DF was correct. I'd been using the wrong quarter in my own calculation.

0 coins

Okay that's fair, the document being matched and the claim moving does tell you something.

0 coins

Can I ask — what does "wages plus PFL can't exceed normal wages" actually mean in practice for someone who went back part time? Like if your employer keeps paying your usual hourly rate but only for fewer days, how does EDD calculate whether you're over the limit?

0 coins

It means your combined wages for those days, not counting overtime, plus whatever PFL pays for the same days can't be more than what you'd normally earn. The math is based on your regular weekly amount. Your employer's HR can tell you how they're calculating their side, and EDD handles theirs through the wage reporting you submit.

0 coins

So I'd need to actually report my part-time wages to EDD as I go, not wait until the leave period ends?

0 coins

Every week you work, those wages go to EDD. They send you a Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, and you have to return it or the payments stop. Don't let that form sit.

0 coins

yeah if you dont return that certification thing they just stop paying you no warning basically

0 coins

Can I just say the hold music on that EDD line does something to your brain after a while lol. I've been dealing with a PFL bonding claim for my daughter and the portal is fine for some things but when you actually have a question about your specific overpayment situation there's no substitute for talking to a person.

0 coins

the portal tells you nothing specific. 'pending' and that's it.

0 coins

Exactly, 'pending' for two weeks and you're just supposed to assume everything is fine.

0 coins

That's exactly where I was with the DE 2514. Seeing that determination in SDI Online with no explanation is a terrible feeling.

0 coins

On the fraud versus mistake question: EDD distinguishes between them. A mistake in dates or in which days you reported as worked is an error. Intentional concealment of wages or working while certifying you weren't is what triggers a fraud finding. Appeal the penalty piece separately if you think it was an honest error. Put the specific mistake in plain language.

0 coins

This helps a lot. The dates I reported — I think I listed the day I went back to the office instead of the last day I was on leave, and those are two different days. That's the kind of thing you mean right?

0 coins

Yes. That's a reporting error, not fraud. Say exactly that in the appeal. Date you returned to work, date you intended to report, what you think actually happened.

0 coins

I did something similar on my claim, mixed up which week a particular shift fell in. EDD sent a form asking me to confirm and I just corrected it in writing. Never got a penalty notice so I think catching it early helped.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way disability does — no seven unpaid days at the front of a bonding claim. Someone at my job told me I'd have to wait a week before getting paid and I almost didn't file on time because I thought the clock hadn't started.

0 coins

Wait, disability has a seven-day waiting period but PFL doesn't? I never knew that distinction. I assumed they worked the same way because they're both through EDD.

0 coins

They're separate programs even though both run through SDI. PFL has no waiting period, benefits can start from day one of the leave. Disability has the seven unpaid days. Easy to mix them up.

0 coins

Yeah it's the same EDD, same SDI Online login, but different rules. Confused me too at first.

0 coins

Intermittent days through December were what I needed clarity on — my care claim was set up for the full eight weeks but I'd been taking it two days a week and the payment for the third week hadn't come through. Tried the EDD Paid Family Leave line four days running and never got past the recording. Ended up getting to an agent through Claimyr, who pulled the payment history and told me the check for those two days had issued on the 18th and I should have it by the end of that week.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I'm not clear on what it actually does.

0 coins

It waits on the EDD phone line in your place, and when a live agent picks up your phone rings so you're the one who actually talks to them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Hm, okay. I'd want to ask EDD whether my employer's paid sick days count toward the wage limit, that's been my sticking point.

0 coins

Agent on a call like that is probably the fastest way to get a specific answer on something like that anyway, good luck.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you realize bonding and care claims pull from the same pool. Used four weeks bonding with my son last spring and I didn't know that until I started reading the EDD site more carefully.

0 coins

wait so its not 8 weeks for bonding and then 8 more if youre caring for someone? its all the same 8 weeks total?

0 coins

One pool for all PFL in a 12-month period. Bonding, care, military assist, they all draw from it. Four weeks bonding means four weeks left for anything else in the same 12 months.

0 coins

ok wow i had no idea. glad i saw this before i made plans

0 coins

The 12 months resets based on your claim start date, not a calendar year, so the window does move around. Worth checking your specific notice for the dates.

0 coins

Remaining weeks question on my care claim for my dad had me genuinely unsure. The notice said eight weeks available but I'd already taken a few days intermittently, and I didn't know if EDD was counting those as full weeks or partial ones. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr and she told me five full weeks and three additional days remained in my 12-month window. That let me plan the rest of his appointments without guessing.

0 coins

Payments on my bonding claim got confusing the same way — I went back part time at week five and the every-two-weeks schedule threw me off. Through Claimyr I got an EDD agent who confirmed weeks one through four had paid in two batches, then the partial weeks starting week five were each issuing separately for the days I didn't work. Knowing which weeks EDD considered paid and which were still pending made the whole schedule make sense.

0 coins

Wait, each partial day pays out separately? I thought it was always a two-week cycle regardless.

0 coins

The agent said each eligible day pays one-seventh of the weekly benefit amount, so when you're only taking two days here and three there the amounts do vary by what you actually claimed. The two-week cycle is for a solid block, not intermittent days.

0 coins

That explains so much, my payments have been slightly different amounts and I kept thinking EDD made a calculation error.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten the penalty piece of a DE 1446 reversed on appeal? Or does appealing the penalty just delay the inevitable?

0 coins

Appeals do get granted, though no one can tell you rates or timelines. The key is making the case in writing that the error was not intentional and laying out exactly what happened. Vague appeals are harder to win than specific ones.

0 coins

Filing the appeal stops the 30-day clock. That alone is worth doing.

0 coins

Okay. Stopping the clock is a concrete reason. That I understand.

0 coins

My PFL bonding claim is for my daughter who was born in October, and I never got anything in the mail about an overpayment but I'm now paranoid I'm going to. I reported my wages every week I went back part time, I turned in the DE 2580GF every time — but reading this thread I'm wondering if I calculated the wage limit right. Is there any way to check if EDD thinks you owe something before they send the notice?

0 coins

SDI Online will show your payment history and claim status. If EDD has issued an overpayment determination, it would show there before the paper notice arrives in some cases. If your wage reporting was accurate and you returned the certifications each time, that's your protection.

0 coins

I do have every DE 2580GF I turned in, I kept copies. That's good right?

0 coins

Keep all of it. If EDD ever questions your reporting, those copies are your evidence. Accurate and complete is what matters.

0 coins

My bonding claim went pretty smoothly but then a whole separate question came up about whether my vacation payout from my employer counted as wages I had to report. I reported it because I didn't want an overpayment issue, but I genuinely didn't know if I was supposed to.

0 coins

Reporting it was the right instinct. Any wages, even ones that aren't your regular paycheck, are supposed to be reported to EDD. Whether they affect the payment depends on the math EDD does, but not reporting and then having EDD find it later is exactly how overpayments happen.

0 coins

Good, then I did the right thing. I'd rather have a smaller payment and be clean than get a DE 1446 six months later.

0 coins

That's exactly the right way to think about it. The overpayment notice is so much more stressful after the fact than just reporting accurately in real time.

0 coins

does anyone know if edd can take the overpayment out of future pfl payments or do they always want a check

0 coins

They can offset future benefits. If you have more PFL payments coming, EDD can apply them toward the overpayment. The notice should say how they intend to collect.

0 coins

ok so i might not need to send a check if i still have weeks left. good to know

0 coins

Read the notice carefully though because sometimes they want the amount before they'll release any further payments. The letter spells out their position on collection.

0 coins

been trying to understand if the 30-day appeal window applies to the penalty separately from the main overpayment amount or if its all one appeal

0 coins

It's one DE 1000A form but you can address each piece separately in what you write. Contest the overpayment amount if you think it's wrong, contest the penalty if you believe it shouldn't apply — both in the same filing within the same 30 days.

0 coins

ok one form covers everything. that makes it simpler at least.

0 coins

This was my same question. Good to know you don't need separate paperwork for each part.

0 coins

October 14 was when I filed my care claim for my father, and I remember specifically because the receipt number confirmation went to my email at 11:47 pm. The 41-day window from that filing date was something I had to track manually because nothing in SDI Online reminded me when Part D was due. Ended up emailing the doctor's office the receipt number so they could submit online, and then confirmed with EDD later that it had been received in time.

0 coins

Part D submitted online with the receipt number — did the doctor's office have any trouble with that process? Our family is in a similar situation with my mom's claim and I'm not sure the office staff knows how to do it.

0 coins

They figured it out without any issues, but I gave them a printed copy of EDD's instructions just to make sure. The key is the receipt number, without that they can't attach it to the right claim.

0 coins

What if the doctor mails it instead of doing it online? Does it still count as long as it arrives within 41 days?

0 coins

Yes, mailed works too. The 41-day clock is the same either way. What matters is that Part D reaches EDD within that window, not how it gets there.

0 coins

Fraud versus honest mistake distinction is one that gets people really scared when they don't need to be. Getting something wrong in your dates because you misread the calendar is not the same thing EDD is looking at when they add a penalty. I've heard people on this forum talk themselves into thinking they're criminals when they just made a math error.

0 coins

This thread has genuinely made me feel like less of a criminal, honestly. I was lying awake thinking about this.

0 coins

Appeal the penalty. Explain the error clearly. That's the right path when it was a mistake.

0 coins

And get it in writing. Even a letter explaining exactly what happened and when. EDD's appeals process exists for exactly this situation.

0 coins

Direct deposit versus debit card is something nobody warned me about when I filed — I picked direct deposit in SDI Online and the payment history showed issued on a Thursday but it didn't hit my account until Monday. Just a heads up for anyone watching their bank account daily.

0 coins

four days felt like forever when i was checking every few hours. glad to know thats normal timing.

0 coins

Completely normal apparently, just bank processing time. EDD considers it issued on the Thursday.

0 coins

I had the same gap on my claim. Worried for nothing.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure