Back to California Paid Family Leave

Liam O'Sullivan

PFL form 2504re filed by mistake claim still active — what do I do?

So I really messed up and I'm hoping someone here has been through this. I was bonding with my daughter after she was born in August and my PFL claim was going smoothly, payments coming in like clockwork. Then I got confused looking at a form online and submitted what I now realize was a DE 2504RE — that's the return to work form, basically telling EDD I was going back to my job. The thing is I'm NOT going back yet. I still have weeks left and I haven't set foot in my workplace. I panicked the moment I realized what I'd done. SDI Online still shows the claim as active but I genuinely don't know if that form is going to cut off my benefits or trigger some kind of overpayment situation. Has anyone accidentally filed that return to work form while their bonding claim was still supposed to be running? Did it mess everything up or did EDD just ignore it?

Accidentally submitted something like that during my own care claim for my father two years back, so I know that sinking feeling. The key thing is to get to EDD quickly and explain what happened before any payment is recalculated on the basis of that form. Send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online right away and explain in plain language that the form was submitted in error and that you have not returned to work. Keep it factual and short.

0 coins

Thank you, I did exactly that this morning. Sent the update and wrote out clearly that I haven't gone back and the form was a mistake. Fingers crossed they catch it before anything changes.

0 coins

Smart move doing it fast. I'd also jot down the date and time you sent that update, just so you have a record if anything does get flagged later.

0 coins

October 3rd is when I filed something incorrectly on my own bonding claim and by October 7th EDD had sorted it out after I sent an update request. The important point is that any wages you haven't actually earned should not be reported, because reporting wages you didn't make is what creates an overpayment, not the form itself sitting there.

0 coins

Good to know the timeline on yours. I genuinely haven't worked a single day since the baby came, so at least the wages side is clean.

0 coins

Wait, so does filing that form automatically trigger an overpayment or does it only happen if you actually report wages along with it? I'm not sure how EDD reads that form versus what you actually earned.

0 coins

The overpayment comes from being paid for days you weren't eligible, usually because wages weren't reported or benefits overlapped with work. A form filed in error that gets corrected before payment recalculation is a different situation, though EDD still needs to see it corrected.

0 coins

Payment date on my bonding claim went weird after a documentation mix-up, and the SDI Online status page wasn't giving me anything useful. Tried the EDD Paid Family Leave line for days, mornings mostly, and kept hitting the same recorded message. Eventually I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent looked up my account and confirmed that my next payment was scheduled for a specific date about five days out, which was all I needed to stop worrying.

0 coins

Tried that line myself, six mornings in a row, same result every time. Hard to believe anything actually gets you through to a person there.

0 coins

Totally get the doubt. What happened for me was I ended up talking to an actual EDD agent who could see my claim and read off dates. It wasn't some automated thing, it was a person who works there.

0 coins

I used Claimyr for my own claim too! The agent told me exactly which weeks had been paid out and when the following payment cycle would hit, so I could finally plan my budget around it. Really steadied my nerves.

0 coins

The SDI Online status page has been pretty vague for me too. Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone who can read the account out loud.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. You filed wrong, you corrected it, you haven't worked. EDD's not going to burn you if the wages aren't there. Just don't go back to work and forget to report it, that's the actual trap.

0 coins

That's reassuring, but what if EDD already processed the form before the correction request went through? Like is there any notice they'd send that I should watch for?

0 coins

They'd send something in the mail. Read it, and if the numbers look off, you've got 30 days to appeal with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Watching the mail closely now. Appreciate the heads up on the appeal form number.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke, been saying it for years. But the return to work form situation is serious because if EDD processes it as of a specific date, your payment for that week gets cut. You need a human to look at the account, not a message you send into the void.

0 coins

Sending a Request Claim Update isn't the void though. It's in SDI Online and they do respond to it.

0 coins

Sure, eventually. Meanwhile the payment calculation might already be moving.

0 coins

Yeah that's what has me anxious, the timing. I sent the update but I'd feel a lot better if someone at EDD actually confirmed the correction landed.

0 coins

Bonding claim, eight weeks total, one limit for the whole 12 months across any kind of leave. If that form knocked out some days, those days still count against your eight weeks. Worth knowing going in.

0 coins

Wait, so the eight weeks isn't reset if something goes wrong with the form? It just keeps running from the birth date window?

0 coins

The 12 months run from the child's birth or placement date, and your weeks used count within that window regardless of form errors. A corrected form doesn't add weeks back, it just corrects how the existing weeks are recorded.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. So the total doesn't change, the record of it just needs to be accurate.

0 coins

About three months into my own bonding leave I lost track of exactly how many of my eight weeks I'd actually used versus what the system showed, partly because I'd taken it intermittently. EDD's phone line was impossible for weeks. I went through Claimyr to reach an agent, and she confirmed I had two full weeks still available inside my 12-month window, which I hadn't been sure about at all. That cleared up a real planning problem for me.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It handles the hold time with EDD so your phone rings once an agent is on the line. That's really all there is to it.

0 coins

Huh. I'd want to ask about whether my claim start date is actually recorded right, because the date EDD has might be off by a few days and I don't know what that does to my 41-day window.

0 coins

Honestly the return to work form thing happens more than people admit. My cousin filed hers too early by accident and the main thing that helped was calling EDD and being really clear: I did not return to work, this was submitted in error, please do not process it. The more specific you are the better.

0 coins

Did your cousin end up with any gap in payments or did it get sorted before anything was affected?

0 coins

Hers got sorted out before a payment was missed, but it took about a week and a half of back and forth. She said being super direct in the message made the difference.

0 coins

Filed the wrong form, didn't work, corrected it. Probably fine. EDD's seen worse.

0 coins

Ha, that actually makes me feel a little better.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate.

0 coins

Sorry I keep asking things, but does the DE 2504RE actually cancel the whole PFL claim or does it just affect the week it was filed for? I genuinely can't tell from the EDD site what that form triggers.

0 coins

From what I understand, that form signals a return to work as of the date filed, so EDD would stop benefits from that date forward rather than canceling everything prior. That's exactly why correcting it fast matters, so the return date on record reflects what actually happened.

0 coins

Okay so payments before the form date should be untouched, it's just the forward-looking part that's at risk. That helps a lot, thank you.

0 coins

Yep. Past payments already issued for days you were off work and eligible, those don't get clawed back just because a form got filed wrong. The issue is the days going forward until the correction lands.

0 coins

Start date on my bonding claim was recorded two days off from when my leave actually began, and I had no idea until weeks in. Tried calling EDD at 8 a.m. multiple days straight, never got past the recording. Ended up using Claimyr to reach a Paid Family Leave agent directly and finally got somewhere. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the recorded start date, then explained that my 41-day filing window ran from that date, so I was still inside it. Knowing the exact number was a relief I didn't expect.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for my bonding claim too, glad it worked for you. When I got an agent on the line she read off the info on my DE 2500E, confirmed the first payment info was all there, anyway I'd been staring at SDI Online for days waiting for that notification to show up.

0 coins

what did they actually say about the 2500e, was it already in the system or still processing

0 coins

Agent said it was issued and gave me the date. That was it, pretty short call but that's all I needed.

0 coins

Two days off on the start date sounds like a small thing but it matters a lot for that 41-day window. Glad you caught it.

0 coins

The PFL no-waiting-period thing is worth flagging here because I thought I had to wait seven days before benefits started, like you do with disability. PFL doesn't work that way, benefits start from day one of leave. Just in case anyone else is confused on that lol.

0 coins

Wait, really? I had it backwards, I thought PFL and SDI disability had the same waiting period.

0 coins

Nope, completely different. PFL has no waiting period at all. Disability has the seven-day unpaid part, PFL doesn't.

0 coins

Correct. EDD is clear on that point: PFL has no benefit waiting period. The seven-day wait belongs to Disability Insurance only.

0 coins

been there with the wrong form panic. sent a message through sdi online, waited, it was fine. just don't file the same thing twice trying to fix it.

0 coins

That second part is a good warning, I had the urge to refile something to 'undo' it but that seemed like it would only make it worse.

0 coins

yeah exactly. one correction message, then wait.

0 coins

For documentation purposes: screenshot your SDI Online claim status before and after you send the correction. If EDD sends a notice that shows an incorrect return date, you'll want that before-record when you respond or appeal.

0 coins

Dated screenshots are genuinely useful. I do this for every step of a claim and it's saved a lot of confusion.

0 coins

Already did this, thank goodness. Have timestamps on everything since I realized the mistake.

0 coins

Keep an eye on your mail for a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination. If it shows an end date that doesn't match your actual last day of leave, appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A. Don't wait on that window.

0 coins

Noted on the DE 1000A. How do I know if what arrives is that specific notice versus a regular payment notice?

0 coins

The determination notice will say DE 2514 on it. A payment notice reads differently. Check the form number in the corner.

0 coins

I didn't know there were different notice types. Good to know what to look for in the mailbox.

0 coins

edd is not gonna come after you for a form mistake as long as you didnt actually go back to work. the overpayment stuff happens when people get paid and also work and dont tell edd. youre fine

0 coins

But what if EDD processes the form before they see the correction? Does a payment stop automatically?

0 coins

thats why you send the update fast, which sounds like they already did

0 coins

To be precise: if EDD records a return date from the form before the correction arrives, benefits could pause from that date. That's the scenario to prevent by correcting quickly, as the original poster did.

0 coins

PFL bonding benefits are for 12 months from the birth date, so even if there's a little hiccup with the form, you've got time within that window to use your remaining weeks! Just wanted to make sure that part is clear.

0 coins

Right, the weeks don't expire the moment something goes sideways. The 12-month window stays.

0 coins

That's actually a relief. I was worried a form mistake might close the window early somehow.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your payment method on the claim too. After my mix-up got sorted, I confirmed I was still set up for direct deposit through SDI Online because I wanted to make sure nothing had been reset.

0 coins

Payments go by debit card, direct deposit for SDI Online claims, or check. If your direct deposit is in there it should stay, but confirming after any correction is a reasonable step.

0 coins

Checked this morning, still showing direct deposit. At least that part is undisturbed.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you're in it and suddenly half of them are gone. Keep tracking which weeks you've used so you know exactly what's left for the rest of the 12-month window anyway.

0 coins

I've been keeping a spreadsheet actually, week by week. That's part of how I noticed something was off in the first place.

0 coins

A spreadsheet is so smart. I wish I'd done that with my leave, I lost track halfway through.

0 coins

I keep reading about CFRA and job protection and I'm confused whether PFL itself protects the job or if that's something separate. Can someone clarify?

0 coins

PFL pays benefits but does not protect the job. That's EDD's own language on it. Job protection is a separate thing that may come from CFRA or FMLA depending on your employer and situation. For specifics on whether CFRA covers your job, that's a conversation for your employer's HR.

0 coins

Ah okay so PFL is the money and job protection is a completely different question. I had those two things mixed together.

0 coins

Very common mix-up. PFL equals payments. Job protection equals different law, ask HR.

0 coins

Quick update from me: SDI Online still shows the claim as active and no determination notice in the mail yet. The Request Claim Update I sent is showing as received. Feeling a little more settled after everything in this thread. If anything shifts I'll post back here.

0 coins

Active status with the update received is a good sign. Watch the mail over the next week or two.

0 coins

Glad it's looking stable so far.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure