Back to California Paid Family Leave

Camila Castillo

PFL eligibility when former employer had private disability plan collecting unemployment

So I'm in a weird spot and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I lost my job back in August and I've been collecting unemployment since then. My former employer had a private disability plan through work, not the state SDI, so my paychecks never showed CASDI withheld. Now my mom has gotten really sick and I want to take time off from job searching to care for her. I looked into filing a PFL care claim but I'm not sure if I even qualify since my old employer opted out of state SDI. And then there's the question of whether I can even collect PFL while I'm on unemployment. I genuinely don't know if I'm eligible for either program at this point or if the private plan through my old job completely blocks me from California EDD's PFL. Has anyone been in a situation like this where the SDI withholding piece is the problem?

Weeks left on my bonding claim were the thing I had to figure out fast when I went back to part-time driving. SDI Online wasn't showing me a clear count so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an actual person on the line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I had three of my eight weeks remaining in my 12-month window, which meant I could still use them for intermittent days before the window closed. That was the number I needed to plan my schedule around.

0 coins

What did you have ready when the agent picked up, just your claim ID or more than that?

0 coins

Had my Social Security number, my claim receipt number, and the date my bonding leave started. Agent found everything fast once I gave those.

0 coins

Been dialing that number myself for three mornings straight. Gets loud, then cuts off. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

The SDI withholding question is the key one here. PFL eligibility requires at least $300 in wages with CASDI withheld during the base period. If the former employer had a Voluntary Plan, an employer-approved private disability plan, those contributions went to the private insurer, not the state. That means those wages wouldn't count toward the state SDI base period for PFL.

0 coins

So if my paystubs never showed CASDI, those wages are just gone for PFL purposes? That's what I was afraid of.

0 coins

Basically yes. The qualifying wages have to have CASDI deducted. Wages paid under a Voluntary Plan employer don't count for state PFL eligibility. If you had any other jobs in the base period that did withhold CASDI, those wages would count.

0 coins

Wait, does that mean her old employer basically just blocked her from getting state PFL without her knowing? That seems like something they should have to tell you.

0 coins

The employer is supposed to notify employees when they're covered under a Voluntary Plan instead of state SDI. Whether that actually happens clearly is another matter. But yes, the effect is that those wages don't build state SDI or PFL eligibility.

0 coins

The unemployment piece is also worth knowing. PFL and unemployment don't pay for the same days. You can't collect both at the same time.

0 coins

So I'd have to stop unemployment to file PFL? Or does PFL just not pay on days unemployment already paid?

0 coins

You'd need to stop certifying for unemployment for the days you're claiming PFL. They don't overlap. Talk to EDD about how to handle the transition.

0 coins

My cousin tried to do both at the same time and got an overpayment notice. She had to pay back the PFL portion. Don't do that.

0 coins

Private plan wages, no CASDI, no state PFL. That's the short version.

0 coins

Is there any way around it, like if I have wages from a second job that did withhold CASDI?

0 coins

Then those wages count. Need at least $300 of CASDI-withheld wages in the base period. If you have them from anywhere, check the calculator on EDD's site.

0 coins

The base period covers wages earned 5 to 18 months before the claim start date, the highest quarter in a 12-month window. If you had any gig work or a part-time job in that range that showed CASDI on the stub, that could get you there.

0 coins

Filing the claim is still worth doing even if you're not 100% sure you qualify. EDD will look at your actual wage records. If you have any CASDI wages in the base period from any employer, it's worth finding out what your Notice of Computation shows.

0 coins

Filing even when unsure sounds like the right move. I do have about two months of work at a different place before this job that definitely had CASDI taken out. I need to look at what period that falls in.

0 coins

Plug those dates into the calculator on EDD's site and see what comes up. That'll give you a rough weekly benefit amount estimate. The official number is on the Notice of Computation after EDD processes it.

0 coins

What if EDD finds she doesn't qualify, does she get a denial letter or does it just sit there?

0 coins

She'd get a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination and there's an appeal window, 30 days, using the form that comes with it.

0 coins

Filing date ended up being the stressor on my care claim. My mom's doctor submitted Part D online with my receipt number but I wasn't sure if EDD had matched it to my claim before the 41-day window. Couldn't get through on the phone for days, so I ended up using Claimyr to reach EDD's PFL line. The agent checked my claim and confirmed the Part D had been received and matched five days before my 41-day deadline. That was such a relief to have confirmed instead of just guessing from the status screen.

0 coins

My own care claim has the same deadline pressure and I still don't know if Part D made it in. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready?

0 coins

Have your receipt number from when you filed, the date your leave started, and your Social Security number. The agent can look up exactly what EDD has received and when.

0 coins

This is making me realize I need to actually file first and get a receipt number before anything else even makes sense to worry about.

0 coins

For the PFL care claim itself, once you do file, your mom needs to fill out Part C, her own statement on a paper form, and her doctor does Part D. Part D can go by mail or the doctor can submit it in SDI Online with your receipt number. You have 41 days from when your leave starts to get it in, anyway.

0 coins

Part C is mailed, not uploaded, right? I saw somewhere that uploading it causes delays.

0 coins

Don't upload either one. EDD says not to upload Part C or Part D, it can slow things down. Mail Part C, have the doctor mail or submit Part D online with your receipt number.

0 coins

Exactly right. The instructions on the forms themselves say the same thing. Part D going in through SDI Online with the receipt number is usually faster than mailing it, as long as the doctor's office has that number.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, no seven unpaid days like DI does! So once EDD clears your claim you're not sitting there waiting for the first week to pass unpaid.

0 coins

wait is that actually true no waiting period at all

0 coins

Yes! EDD's own guidance says PFL does not have a benefit waiting period. That's different from Disability Insurance which has an unpaid first week. PFL goes from day one of approved leave.

0 coins

I thought there was a waiting week. Good to know I was wrong.

0 coins

CFRA might be worth looking at too for the job protection piece. PFL pays you but it doesn't protect your job, those are two different things.

0 coins

But I'm not currently employed so job protection isn't the issue for me right now. It's just about whether PFL pays anything at all given my situation.

0 coins

Fair point. If the CASDI wages check out you should be fine on eligibility. EDD's calculator will tell you fast.

0 coins

PFL not protecting the job is something a lot of people don't know going in.

0 coins

Payment method had me second-guessing myself when I filed my bonding claim online. I chose direct deposit in SDI Online but then got nervous nothing was actually set up right. Used Claimyr to get through to PFL and the agent confirmed my direct deposit information was on file and showed me as the payment method selected on the claim. Went back to SDI Online after that and the first payment processed a few days later.

0 coins

Direct deposit being confirmed like that is exactly what I needed on my own claim. Used Claimyr after my first week still showed nothing, and once the agent told me the DE 2500E had been issued I knew it was processing. Filed my second week right after that call.

0 coins

been trying that phone line since monday. mornings, afternoons, same result. good to hear it worked for someone.

0 coins

Every morning last week for me too before I tried a different route. The line just ends the call before you get anywhere.

0 coins

To put the base period question more concretely: wages from August 2024 through roughly July 2025 would be in the range EDD looks at for a claim started in late 2026. If your two months at the CASDI employer fall anywhere in that window, those wages count.

0 coins

My two months at the other job were October and November 2024, so that could actually be right in the window. I need to look at those paystubs and see what CASDI amount was taken out.

0 coins

Pull those stubs and check for CASDI on the deductions line. Even a small amount withheld is good news, as long as your total qualifying wages hit $300 EDD will determine whether you have a weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Run the numbers through EDD's benefits calculator once you have the quarterly totals. It'll give you an estimate before you file.

0 coins

Receipt number was the piece I kept second-guessing after I filed my care claim through SDI Online. The confirmation screen showed it but I forgot to write it down before I closed the window. Used Claimyr to reach the PFL line and asked the agent to confirm it. She pulled it up from my Social Security number and claim date and read it to me so I could save it properly. Gave that number straight to my husband's doctor's office the same afternoon so they could file Part D online.

0 coins

Every time I call that line I get through the menu and then it just hangs up on me. Three weeks of that. How is it possible you got through to an actual person?

0 coins

Honestly I'd given up on the regular line too. What Claimyr does is handle the hold on EDD's line for you, so when a person picks up your phone is the one that rings. I don't know how they manage it but I ended up talking to an EDD agent in my own kitchen.

0 coins

Went through the same hang-up cycle on the regular number before my bonding claim sorted itself out. That line is brutal.

0 coins

Huh. I might give that a try. I've got a question about whether my doctor's Part D actually reached EDD and right now I have no way to know.

0 coins

if you end up qualifying can you take the pfl weeks one at a time or does it have to be all at once

0 coins

Breaks up fine. Eight weeks total but you can spread them out. Report any work and wages to EDD and they send you a Continued Claim Certification to fill out. Keep returning that or payments stop.

0 coins

ok so its not like you have to use all 8 in a row got it

0 coins

What if she files and gets approved but then EDD finds out the base period wages don't add up and asks for the money back? Can that happen after they already paid?

0 coins

An overpayment can happen, yes. That's why running the calculator first and understanding your CASDI wages is worth doing before filing. But if you receive a determination you disagree with, you appeal within 30 days using the form EDD sends with it.

0 coins

The appeal form comes with the denial letter automatically? I didn't know that.

0 coins

It does. The Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination includes the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from that notice to file it, either online or by mail.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot but if you've used any bonding or military assist time in the same 12 months those weeks all come out of the same pool. PFL isn't eight weeks per reason.

0 coins

I haven't used any PFL at all before, so if I qualify I'd have the full eight weeks available for my mom's care.

0 coins

Then you'd have the full eight if EDD confirms eligibility. Care claims just need Part C from your mom and Part D from her doctor within 41 days.

0 coins

The one pool for all reasons is something a lot of people get surprised by.

0 coins

Care claim for a parent versus a sibling, does it matter? My sister is in the hospital and I'm not sure if she counts.

0 coins

Siblings are on EDD's list of qualifying family members for a care claim. File and let EDD determine your eligibility based on your specific wage record.

0 coins

Filing for a sibling is something I hadn't tried before. Good to know that's even possible.

0 coins

Parent, child, spouse, registered domestic partner, grandparent, grandchild, sibling, parent-in-law. Those are the family members EDD lists for PFL care.

0 coins

does anyone know if filing online through myedd is faster than the paper form

0 coins

SDI Online through myEDD is what EDD recommends. Paper by mail takes longer by default just for delivery and processing time.

0 coins

ok going online then, been putting this off too long

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online also lets you pick direct deposit for payments, which the paper form doesn't allow. Worth it for that alone.

0 coins

Thank you all. Plan is to pull my October and November 2024 paystubs tonight and check the CASDI line. If those wages are in range I'm going to run the calculator on EDD's site and then file the care claim online as soon as I can. I'll stop certifying for unemployment once I start the PFL claim. Didn't realize those two can't overlap.

0 coins

Get that receipt number saved the second the confirmation screen shows it. Screenshot it or write it down right then, you'll need it for the doctor's office.

0 coins

Screenshotting the confirmation is now on my list. And then handing the receipt number to her doctor's office the same day if I can.

0 coins

Once Part D is in and EDD processes it, check SDI Online for status updates. If it goes past 14 days with no movement, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

Good luck. Hope your mom gets some relief soon.

0 coins

Thank you. She's had a rough few months and I just want to be there for her without losing everything financially.

0 coins

That's what this program is for. Hope it works out.

0 coins

One more thing on the unemployment overlap. Stop certifying for UI on the same days you claim PFL. EDD sees both systems.

0 coins

Stopping UI certifications the day PFL starts, understood. I don't want an overpayment on top of everything else.

0 coins

Exactly. Keep it clean from day one.

0 coins

The overpayment headache from overlapping those two is not something you want. Way easier to just stop one before you start the other.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure