Back to California Paid Family Leave

Ellie Kim

PFL claim active online but received denial letter, what to do?

Okay so I'm kind of freaking out right now and hoping someone here has dealt with this. I filed my PFL bonding claim about three weeks ago when my daughter was born and everything seemed fine. SDI Online showed my claim as active, I uploaded the birth certificate right away, and I even got the Notice of Computation in the mail showing my weekly amount. Then yesterday a letter showed up saying my claim was denied. How does that even make sense? The website says active but I'm holding a denial letter? I haven't started getting payments yet either which is a whole other stress. Has anyone else had their PFL claim show active online but then gotten a denial letter? Like what do I even do from here, do I just give up or is there something I can do to fight it?

Payment date confusion on my own bonding claim is what pushed me to finally phone EDD instead of just refreshing SDI Online. The status had said active for nine days with zero payment history showing, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the first payment had been issued three days earlier and the deposit was processing through the payment method I'd selected. That was the only thing I needed to hear to stop panicking about it.

0 coins

Claimyr is something I've used too, and after the agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and told me my next payment was due the following Tuesday, I went back into SDI Online and watched for it. It arrived exactly when she said it would.

0 coins

five days of hitting redial every morning before I found out about that. wish i'd known sooner.

0 coins

Wait, the denial letter, does it say which one it is? I think there's a specific form they send, like a DE 2514 or something? Mine said the same notice name on it. Is the reason listed anywhere on the letter because that might be the key to figuring out what happened.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

Yes it says Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination right at the top, DE 2514. The reason it gives is kind of vague, something about eligibility not met. I'm not sure what that means when the online status still says active.

0 coins

that vague language is so frustrating but the reason code or the paragraph below it usually gives a little more. worth reading the whole letter top to bottom before deciding your next step.

0 coins

I got one of those too and I wasn't sure if "active" on the website meant they'd already decided or if the letter came before the system updated. does anyone know which one is more current, the letter or what SDI Online shows?

0 coins

The letter is the official decision. Active in SDI Online just means the claim exists in their system, not that it's been approved for payment.

0 coins

Appeal form is in the envelope with the denial. 30 days from the date on the letter. don't let that pass.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

There is an appeal form in there, yes, the DE 1000A. So I actually have a shot at reversing this?

0 coins

you do. file the appeal and state your case. the system makes mistakes.

0 coins

yes appeal it, seriously. a denial is not the end, anyway.

0 coins

30 days from the letter's date is the window to submit that DE 1000A. You can file it online or mail it, whichever you can manage faster. Include any documents that support your case, like the birth certificate if there's any chance it wasn't matched to your claim properly.

0 coins

Can she file the appeal online through SDI Online or is it only by mail? I'm asking for my own situation too because I'm worried I'll end up here.

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be submitted online or mailed to the address on the determination notice. Online is faster if you want to be sure it arrives in time.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

Filing online sounds easier and faster. I'll do that. Thank you.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute black hole. I called at 8:01 on a Monday, waited, got a recording about high call volume and then it disconnected. Did that four times in one week. If you need to actually talk to someone before that 30-day appeal window closes, good luck getting through the normal way.

0 coins

same exact thing happened to me. called like 6 mornings in a row and got nowhere. its like theyre not even there

0 coins

I've called that line a dozen times across two different claims. Nine of them ended in a hang-up before I spoke to anyone. That's just how it goes.

0 coins

it really is exhausting. been trying for two weeks on mine.

0 coins

Active status and denial letter at the same time could be a timing thing where the determination was made but the online system didn't update instantly. It could also be that the proof of relationship document got uploaded but wasn't matched to the claim before they processed the eligibility decision. EDD does say that uploading documents in SDI Online can sometimes delay things if the system doesn't match them right away.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

That actually makes a lot of sense. I uploaded the birth certificate pretty much right after I filed. Is there a way to know if EDD actually received it and matched it, or do I just have to wait and see?

0 coins

best way to know for sure is to reach an agent who can see what's actually on file. SDI Online doesn't always show document receipt status clearly.

0 coins

the Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online is worth trying too if you can't reach anyone by phone. choose the right request type and write out your question. I've gotten responses to those within a few days.

0 coins

Six weeks into my bonding leave and I wasn't sure how many of my eight weeks I still had available, especially because I'd taken a few days intermittently before. I used Claimyr to get an agent on the line. She looked at the claim and said I had two and a half weeks of PFL remaining in my 12-month period, which helped me plan the rest of my leave.

0 coins

I'll be honest, that sounds too convenient. I've been trying that number Monday through Friday for going on three weeks and I've never gotten past the hold music. How does something like that actually work?

0 coins

I had the same doubt, tried the EDD line every morning for a week first. Claimyr holds the line so you're not the one stuck waiting, and your phone rings when an agent is on. The agent was an EDD employee, answered questions about my claim directly.

0 coins

The agent on my call found the DE 2500E had been issued but I hadn't gotten the notification. She confirmed the payment method on file so I knew where to look for the deposit!

0 coins

Alright. I might look into it. Got a week left on my appeal window and I still haven't reached anyone.

0 coins

if the denial is because they didn't get the birth certificate matched to your claim, appealing with the certificate attached should fix it. had a coworker deal with something similar, the document was there but not linked right, lol.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

That's what I'm hoping it is, honestly. Something fixable like a document matching issue rather than an actual eligibility problem.

0 coins

yeah fingers crossed. attach everything you have when you file the appeal, makes it easier for whoever reviews it.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared reading this because I just filed my bonding claim last week. My claim shows pending, not active. Is there a difference? And how do I know if my birth certificate uploaded correctly? I'm worried I'll end up getting a denial letter too.

0 coins

Pending is normal at first. EDD has up to 14 days to decide. Hang tight and watch for the Notice of Computation in the mail.

0 coins

Okay that helps. And if 14 days pass with no movement, what should I do then?

0 coins

At the 14-day mark, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online. Pick the request type that fits, write what you're asking, and you should hear something within a few days.

0 coins

Don't overthink the online status. The letter is what counts. Get that appeal in and attach the birth certificate again to be safe.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

You're right, I keep going back and forth checking SDI Online when really the letter is the actual answer. Filing the appeal today.

0 coins

good. don't wait on it.

0 coins

41 days was the deadline detail that caught me off guard on my own care claim. I wasn't sure if I'd filed in time because I'd taken a couple of days of leave before I even knew about the deadline. I used Claimyr to get through to an agent, and she confirmed my claim's official start date in EDD's system and said my filing date fell within the 41 days. That was a relief because I had no idea if I'd cut it too close.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It's a service that keeps the line open with EDD until a live person picks up, then your phone rings. That's basically it. One call, one agent.

0 coins

Good to know. I'd want to ask about why my claim's start date in the system doesn't match what I wrote on the form. That's been nagging at me.

0 coins

the denial letter being dated the same week the notice of computation arrived is strange timing. the NOC shows up when they're deciding your weekly amount, so you'd think eligibility would be confirmed before that. worth mentioning in your appeal.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

I noticed that too, the NOC came like four days before the denial letter. It seemed weird that they'd calculate a benefit amount and then say I wasn't eligible. I'll definitely bring that up.

0 coins

the Notice of Computation isn't a confirmation of eligibility, it's just showing the potential weekly amount based on your wages. so it can come before the actual decision either way. still worth flagging in the appeal as part of the timeline.

0 coins

okay that clarifies something i was confused about. i thought the NOC meant you were approved. so you can get one and still get denied?

0 coins

Yes. The NOC is a wage calculation, not an approval. The actual decision comes in a separate notice.

0 coins

been dealing with a similar situation for two weeks. appeal form is sitting on my table. just hard to get to it when you're taking care of a newborn.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

I feel that so much. It's the worst timing to have to deal with paperwork.

0 coins

file it online if you can, way faster than mailing it and you don't need to leave the house.

0 coins

the system showing active while a denial letter is in the mail happens more than people realize. the statuses don't always update in real time.

0 coins

and there's no way to know unless you actually get the letter, because EDD isn't going to call you to explain anything.

0 coins

exactly. the letter is always the real answer.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period like disability does, so if the denial is about some waiting period they might have applied the wrong rules to your claim. Worth checking what the stated reason is carefully!

0 coins

That's a good point about the waiting period. PFL has no unpaid waiting days at all. If anything on the denial hints at that, definitely raise it in the appeal.

0 coins

wait really? I thought there were seven days you had to wait without pay at the start. that's for disability not PFL?

0 coins

Correct. The seven-day unpaid period is for Disability Insurance. PFL has no waiting period, benefits start from day one of leave.

0 coins

okay wow I did not know that. I was mentally budgeting for seven days with nothing, that changes things.

0 coins

my wife got a denial on her first bonding claim attempt and she re-filed with the corrected documents and it went through fine. sometimes it's just a document issue, anyway.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

That's reassuring to hear. Did she appeal or re-file, there's a difference right?

0 coins

There is a difference. Appealing the existing determination is usually the right move because you're contesting the decision on the same claim. Re-filing opens a new claim and could affect your 12-month window for benefits. Appeal first if you're within the 30 days.

0 coins

she appealed, not re-filed. I misspoke, sorry. the appeal is what fixed it.

0 coins

edd is so bad about updating their portal. the status thing is confusing on purpose i swear

0 coins

it's not on purpose but the effect is the same. you have no idea what's actually happening until a letter arrives.

0 coins

right exactly. the letter is the only real info

0 coins

Before you file the appeal, make a copy of everything. The denial letter, the DE 1000A you fill out, the birth certificate, the Notice of Computation. Keep the copies somewhere you can find them.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

Good call, I would not have thought to copy the denial letter itself.

0 coins

It has the claim number, the date, and the reason code on it. All of that is useful if you end up needing to follow up or if the appeal takes a while.

0 coins

the appeal window being 30 days is not a lot of time when you're home with a newborn and EDD's phone line is impossible to reach. file the appeal online first, then worry about reaching someone to ask questions.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

Filing it today. Appeal is submitted. Status still shows active online which is weird but at least I know the letter is what matters now.

0 coins

good. once the appeal is in you have a little more breathing room to get answers about what actually caused the denial.

0 coins

hope it goes your way.

0 coins

did the denial letter have a reason code on it? sometimes it's a number and you can look it up to understand what triggered it. saves a lot of guessing.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

Author

There's a paragraph that mentions wages and base period but I honestly don't fully understand it. I'm going to include a note in the appeal explaining my work history.

0 coins

If the base period is the issue, it's worth looking at the benefits calculator on EDD's site before you submit so you understand what wages they might be looking at. It's under the PFL section.

0 coins

after all this I'm realizing I should save every confirmation screen and receipt number from SDI Online just in case. I didn't screenshot anything when I filed.

0 coins

the receipt number is the most important one. it's on the confirmation page right after you submit. if you log back into SDI Online you can usually find the claim ID which serves the same purpose for follow-up.

0 coins

I do have the email that said my claim was submitted, does that have enough info?

0 coins

check if it has a receipt number or claim ID on it. if it does, you're in good shape. that number is what any agent or EDD form will ask for first.

0 coins

just want to say this thread answered stuff I was too tired to even figure out how to search for. appeal form, 30 days, NOC isn't approval. noted.

0 coins

the NOC one tripped me up too when I first filed. easy to assume it means yes when it's really just the number they calculated.

0 coins

yeah the wording on it makes it sound final. glad i know now before I'm in that situation.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure