Back to California Paid Family Leave

Monique Byrd

How to fix paid family leave overpayment after SDI extension approved

So this is kind of a mess and I'm hoping someone has dealt with this before. I took PFL bonding leave after my wife's disability claim ended, eight weeks starting in July. Got paid, everything seemed fine. Then her doctor submitted some extra paperwork and EDD went back and extended her disability claim by two weeks, which pushed her end date past when my PFL bonding started. Now EDD is saying I was paid PFL for days that overlapped with her extended disability period and I owe them money back. I didn't do anything wrong here, the extension happened after I was already paid, but apparently that created an overpayment on my end. Has anyone had to deal with fixing something like this? Do I just pay it back or is there an appeal option? I'm totally lost on what to do next.

Overpayment notices come with an Appeal Form, DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it. If you think the overlap happened through no fault of yours, that's worth putting in writing.

0 coins

The notice came Saturday so I still have time. Where do I send the appeal form, same address that's on the notice?

0 coins

Yes, send it where the notice says. Each notice prints the right address for that office.

0 coins

Got it, I'll check tonight. Thank you.

0 coins

EDD does this and it drives me insane. The extension on her claim was their own decision and now you're on the hook? Appeal it. You didn't know about any extension when you filed your bonding claim.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a guy at my job. He appealed and explained the timeline and it got sorted. Keep your paperwork.

0 coins

Yeah the timeline is everything here. Date you filed, date her extension was approved, all of it.

0 coins

Payment method on my own bonding claim got tangled after a date change on the underlying disability period, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone at EDD's PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the debit card was still the active payment method and that no redirect had been flagged on the account. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Tried Claimyr myself a while back for a completely different reason. Got a DE 2514 in the mail with no explanation and I needed to know what it meant for my case. The agent read me exactly what the determination said and confirmed the appeal window was still open. Ended up filing within that window.

0 coins

Wait, so when you used Claimyr you just ended up talking to an actual EDD agent? Like someone who works there?

0 coins

Yes, a real EDD agent answered. It keeps the line for you so your phone rings when someone picks up, that's the whole thing.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense. I've been trying to get through for three mornings now and it just rings forever and disconnects.

0 coins

The rule here is that PFL and Disability Insurance can't cover the same days. If her disability period was extended to include days EDD had already paid you PFL for, they treat that as an overlap and issue an overpayment notice for the PFL side. The appeal is the right move if you believe the dates don't actually overlap or if the extension was backdated incorrectly.

0 coins

The extension added two weeks onto the end of her claim. My bonding started the day after what we thought was her last disability day. So yeah it's a backdated extension that created the overlap after the fact.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of situation worth appealing. Put the original end date, the extension notice date, and your PFL start date all on the same page so the appeal reviewer can see the sequence clearly.

0 coins

This is so unfair honestly. You filed based on the dates you were given and now you're the one who has to fix it.

0 coins

Appeal it. Thirty days. Don't miss that window.

0 coins

Deadline is marked on my calendar already.

0 coins

0 coins

EDD's overpayment process assumes you did something wrong until you prove otherwise. The appeal form is your chance to lay out what actually happened.

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't stop them from asking for the money in the meantime, right? Or does it pause things?

0 coins

Don't know the answer to that one for certain. Worth asking EDD directly.

0 coins

I'd put that question in a Request Claim Update in SDI Online while also filing the appeal, just to get the answer in writing.

0 coins

My receipt number on a bonding claim for my daughter kept not matching anything when I checked SDI Online, so I tried Claimyr to get through to PFL and talk to someone. The agent looked up the receipt number and found that the claim had been created under a slightly different name spelling, which is why the status wasn't showing right for me. She confirmed the claim was active and told me which document was still pending on their end.

0 coins

This kind of sounds like it could be one of those services that just tells you what you want to hear. How do you even know the person who answered was actually at EDD?

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I heard about it. Used it anyway when my own care claim for my father was stuck because Part D hadn't been matched. Agent pulled up the claim, said the form came in but hadn't been linked to my receipt number yet, told me to give it a few more days. It matched two days later. That's not a script, that's someone looking at the actual file.

0 coins

Okay, that's more convincing than I expected. I've been trying to get through about my own proof of relationship for my partner's bonding claim. Might just try it and see.

0 coins

Can you even appeal an overpayment that was caused by EDD's own late processing? Like is that something the appeal covers?

0 coins

An appeal covers any overpayment decision. You explain the circumstances and the reviewer looks at whether the original determination was correct given the full timeline.

0 coins

So basically you're not just asking them to waive it, you're saying the overpayment itself might be wrong.

0 coins

Exactly. If the dates were extended after you were already paid, the question is whether that creates a valid overpayment at all.

0 coins

edd does this overlapping thing all the time and nobody explains it when you file. you just get a letter out of nowhere saying you owe money and you're supposed to know what to do

0 coins

Letter came out of nowhere for me too. No warning, just a number and a deadline.

0 coins

exactly and if you miss the 30 days its just done, no more options

0 coins

Appeal rights on that DE 1000A are pretty narrow in terms of time, so if you haven't sent it yet, do it today or tomorrow rather than waiting until the last day. A short letter explaining the backdated extension is all you need to get it in front of a reviewer.

0 coins

Writing the letter tonight. I have the original notice for her disability claim, the extension notice, and my PFL award letter. That should cover the timeline.

0 coins

That's the right set of documents. Put the dates in order at the top so it's immediately clear to whoever reads it.

0 coins

Is there a specific form for the appeal letter or just a regular written explanation attached to the DE 1000A?

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the form itself. You fill it out and attach your explanation and the documents that show the timeline.

0 coins

Went through a similar overlap situation last year, different reason but same kind of overpayment letter. I appealed and got a hearing date mailed to me. The hearing was by phone, took maybe fifteen minutes, and I just walked them through the dates.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything specific to prepare for the phone hearing?

0 coins

I had all my letters in front of me with the dates highlighted, that was really it. The reviewer asked me to walk through the timeline and I just did.

0 coins

That's good to know. I always assumed appeals were this huge complicated process but fifteen minutes on a phone call sounds manageable.

0 coins

The eight weeks for PFL are shared across bonding, care and military assist in the same 12-month period, right? Just want to make sure this overpayment situation doesn't affect any remaining weeks.

0 coins

Yes, it's one pool of eight weeks across all claim types in a 12-month period. An overpayment dispute doesn't consume the weeks, but until it's resolved EDD may hold things. Worth asking them directly where the remaining balance stands.

0 coins

That makes sense. So the actual week count isn't reduced just because there's an overpayment notice outstanding.

0 coins

Right. The notice is a billing question, not a determination that those PFL days were ineligible unless that's specifically what it says.

0 coins

Don't pay the overpayment amount before the appeal decision comes in if you're disputing the dates. Once the money is gone it's harder to argue the point.

0 coins

I had not thought about that at all. I was just going to pay it and then try to deal with it. So I should wait?

0 coins

If you believe the overpayment is wrong, file the appeal first. You can still pay later if the appeal doesn't go your way.

0 coins

This is the right call. File the appeal, then decide.

0 coins

Does the overpayment notice say anything about whether you can set up a payment plan if the appeal doesn't work out? Just asking because the amount might not be something you can pay all at once.

0 coins

My notice mentioned contacting EDD if repayment all at once wasn't possible, but how that's handled is something to ask EDD directly since it varies.

0 coins

Okay good, so it's at least something they discuss, not just a bill with no options.

0 coins

Had a question about my own Notice of Computation after a date adjustment on my claim. Tried calling the PFL line several times across two weeks, mornings, never got past the hold music before it cut off. Used Claimyr for it and got an agent. She confirmed the weekly benefit amount on my DE 429DF and explained that the amount hadn't changed despite the date shift since my base period wages stayed the same.

0 coins

When you got through on that call, did you need to verify your identity before the agent could pull anything up?

0 coins

She asked for my Social Security number and claim ID, then she was looking at the account right away.

0 coins

been trying that line myself for two weeks, mornings mostly. it just plays the message and hangs up every single time.

0 coins

For anyone not sure what goes on the appeal form, the main thing is to state clearly that you disagree with the determination and briefly say why. You don't have to have a legal argument. The reviewer's job is to look at the full record.

0 coins

So basically you're just asking them to look again, not like, hiring a lawyer or anything.

0 coins

For this kind of situation, a written explanation with the dates is usually enough to get in front of a reviewer. A lawyer isn't required at all.

0 coins

That's reassuring. I always thought appeals meant big formal hearings.

0 coins

Checked my own PFL claim in SDI Online last week and the payment history wasn't showing two of the weeks I thought I'd been paid. Used Claimyr and got someone in PFL on the line. She went through the payment log and confirmed both weeks had been issued, just on different dates than I expected, and told me the next certification period would open the following Monday.

0 coins

My bonding claim has a week sitting in pending that I can't figure out. I'll try Claimyr for it. Need to know if EDD is waiting on me for something or if it's just processing.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the specific week dates ready before you get on the line. The agent went straight to those when I asked.

0 coins

That pending week thing has been my life for ten days. Line either drops or I'm on hold for an hour and it drops anyway.

0 coins

Yeah I've called four mornings straight and got nothing. Gonna try it tomorrow.

0 coins

The notice itself should tell you which specific days EDD says overlap. Check whether those days are actually inside both the extended disability period and your bonding period or if EDD might have the dates wrong on their end.

0 coins

Looked at it just now. The overlap they're claiming is exactly the two-week extension period. And my bonding start date on the PFL claim is two days into that extended window. So the numbers match what they're saying, but the extension was filed after I was already getting PFL payments.

0 coins

That sequence matters. Document it in the appeal: extension notice date, your first PFL payment date, your bonding claim filing date. All three in order.

0 coins

If the extension notice is dated after your first PFL payment, that's the core of your appeal right there.

0 coins

How did you even find out about the extension on her claim? Did EDD send you a notice directly or did you find out some other way?

0 coins

Her SDI Online account showed the updated dates and she told me. I had no idea it would affect my separate PFL claim until the overpayment letter showed up.

0 coins

That's such a rough situation. Two separate claims, one person's extension quietly wrecks the other person's payment.

0 coins

EDD really should flag something when a disability extension creates a downstream PFL overlap. Instead you just get the bill after the fact.

0 coins

for what its worth i looked up the appeal form online and the DE 1000A is pretty short. you can file it online or mail it. not as scary as the letter made it sound

0 coins

Filed it online this morning through SDI Online. Attached a one-page timeline and all three notices. Now I wait.

0 coins

good luck. hope the reviewer sees the backdating clearly.

0 coins

Glad you got it in. The 30 days goes fast.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure