Back to California Paid Family Leave

DeShawn Washington

How to dispute paid family leave overpayment for vacation pay — my employer paid out PTO while I was on PFL

Okay so I'm kind of freaking out here. Got a letter from EDD saying I was overpaid on my PFL bonding claim because my employer paid out vacation time during the same weeks. I had no idea that was going to trigger anything, HR just processed it automatically like they always do at the end of the year. Now I'm looking at an overpayment notice and I don't know if I should just pay it back or if I can fight it. The vacation payout wasn't because I was working, it was just a lump sum they always issue in December. Does anyone know how to dispute paid family leave overpayment for vacation pay specifically? The notice came with an appeal form but I don't know if that's even the right move here. Kids are asleep, trying to figure this out before I crash for the night, anyway.

DE 2514 sitting on my counter right now too, different reason but same sick feeling. Tried the EDD line six mornings before I finally got through using Claimyr (claimyr.com). Agent pulled up my claim and read me exactly what the notice said word for word, then confirmed the appeal window, 30 days from the date on the letter. That was the part I needed to hear out loud. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Five days I've been hitting redial on that line and it cuts off every single time before I get to a person. How does Claimyr actually do anything different?

0 coins

Honestly I had the same question. It stays on hold with EDD's line in your place and your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's it. The agent I talked to was EDD's own staff, not Claimyr's.

0 coins

Tried it myself after weeks of busy signals. Agent found that my receipt number had never been matched to my actual claim, which explained why everything stalled. Got that sorted once I had the right person.

0 coins

Alright, that's more specific than I expected. I'll give it a go this week.

0 coins

The appeal form that came with your DE 2514 is exactly what you use. You have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to file it, either online or by mail. Missing that window is the part that really matters here, so do not wait.

0 coins

Is the date on the notice the day they printed it or the day I got it?

0 coins

The date printed on the notice itself, not the postmark or when it arrived in your mailbox. If you're close to the edge, file the appeal first and add the explanation after.

0 coins

Does the appeal form ask for a reason or do you just submit it and explain later? I'm dealing with something similar and I didn't know there was a form at all.

0 coins

There's a section for your reason, but writing something brief is fine for now. Getting it in before the deadline is the priority, details can follow.

0 coins

The vacation pay issue comes down to what EDD counts as wages. PFL can't be paid for the same days that wages were paid, so if your employer issued vacation payout and EDD counted those days as wages, the two overlapped. What your employer called it matters less than whether EDD treated it as wages for those same days.

0 coins

So the question is whether EDD sees a December lump sum as wages for specific days or just a separate payment?

0 coins

That's exactly the question you'd raise in your appeal. The timing and how your employer reported it are what determine whether there's real overlap. EDD has to show which days they're counting.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. If the payout wasn't attached to any specific workdays, the case for disputing it is a lot stronger. Worth spelling that out clearly in the appeal.

0 coins

My cousin went through something similar, HR ran an automatic PTO payout and EDD sent an overpayment notice three months later. She wrote a letter explaining the payout was automatic and not tied to any specific days worked, attached the pay stub showing it, and filed the appeal. EDD reversed it. I can't promise that happens for everyone but it worked for her.

0 coins

Did she use the DE 1000A or did she write a separate letter on top of that?

0 coins

She did both, the DE 1000A to actually file the appeal and then a written explanation with the pay stub attached. The pay stub showing it was a lump sum and not hourly wages was the key piece.

0 coins

Pay stub documentation really does help. When I filed my appeal on a different issue EDD asked for supporting paperwork anyway, so having it ready upfront saves a round.

0 coins

Don't pay it back yet. If you pay before the appeal is decided you might not get it back easily. File the appeal first, then deal with repayment only if the appeal doesn't go your way.

0 coins

Is that actually allowed, to hold off on paying while the appeal is pending?

0 coins

You can appeal it. That's what the form is there for. Paying it without disputing it means you're accepting the overpayment as valid.

0 coins

This is the right call. Appealing doesn't mean you're refusing to pay, it means you're asking EDD to explain why the overpayment stands before you do.

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but I think the overtime part matters here too? Like, if the vacation payout pushed your total income above what your normal wages would have been, that's the problem? Or am I reading this wrong. I might be way off.

0 coins

Close but the actual rule is that your wages, not counting overtime, plus PFL can't go above your normal wages for those days. Overtime specifically gets excluded from the calculation. The issue in this case is more about whether the vacation payout counted as wages for the same days PFL was paid.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense, I thought I had it backwards. So the question is really about timing and how EDD mapped the payout to specific days.

0 coins

Right, and that's exactly what a well-written appeal would address. If the lump sum wasn't tied to working any particular day, that case is different from getting your regular hourly wages paid out.

0 coins

December 3rd is on the envelope, December 9th is when I got it, and I almost let a week slip by assuming I had more time. For anyone counting their 30 days: use the printed date, not the day it landed in your hands. Lost nearly a week assuming the later date was fine.

0 coins

How did you figure out it was the printed date and not the received date?

0 coins

Phoned EDD and the agent confirmed it. After that I filed the same afternoon.

0 coins

That's a costly assumption to almost make. Good reminder.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my bonding claim had been sitting unmatched for two weeks and SDI Online just said pending with no other detail. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent who told me the birth certificate uploaded fine but was waiting to be matched to the claim ID manually. Knowing that was the actual holdup let me stop guessing and just wait.

0 coins

Wait how does Claimyr work, I've never heard of it?

0 coins

You give it your info, it waits on hold with EDD while you go do other things, and you pick up when a live agent is on the line. Took the place of me sitting there redialing for the fifth morning in a row.

0 coins

Oh that makes sense. I'd use it to ask why my own bonding claim still shows pending after uploading everything three weeks ago.

0 coins

Have your receipt number ready and know the date you filed. The agent pulled everything up fast once I had those two things.

0 coins

edd overpayment appeals take forever just so you know, file it now and dont wait around expecting a quick answer

0 coins

How long did yours take?

0 coins

like two months for them to even schedule anything, file early

0 coins

The timeline varies a lot but filing early is always the right move, there's no upside to waiting.

0 coins

Get the paperwork from your employer in writing. Letter on company letterhead showing the vacation payout was automatic and not wages for days worked. That kind of documentation carries weight in an appeal.

0 coins

Does HR usually do that without a lot of pushback?

0 coins

In my experience if you tell them it's for an EDD appeal they put something together. They don't want the headache any more than you do.

0 coins

A dated letter specifying the nature of the payment and that it was not tied to hours worked is what you're after. The more specific, the better.

0 coins

EDD sent my employer a questionnaire after I filed an appeal. My employer filled it out saying the PTO payout was a standard year-end distribution, not compensation for working specific days. That documentation ended up being what turned the appeal around.

0 coins

Does EDD always contact the employer directly, or only sometimes?

0 coins

Not always, but on wage-overlap disputes it seems common. Either way having your employer ready to put it in writing doesn't hurt.

0 coins

This is really helpful, I didn't realize EDD could loop in the employer during an appeal.

0 coins

My HR told me to just pay the overpayment and not bother appealing because EDD always wins. That felt wrong to me and from reading this thread it clearly is wrong!

0 coins

HR isn't the right place to get advice about an EDD appeal. They handle internal policy, not EDD's appeals process.

0 coins

HR told you wrong. File the appeal. EDD has to prove the overpayment is valid, you don't just have to accept it.

0 coins

Yeah I'm going to file. This thread convinced me.

0 coins

What if you already missed the 30 days? I realized I had an overpayment notice from a few months back that I sort of ignored because I didn't know what to do with it. Is there anything left to do or is it completely over?

0 coins

Filing after the deadline is still possible in some cases, but whether EDD accepts a late appeal depends on your reason for missing it. Contact EDD and explain what happened, that's the first step.

0 coins

Don't assume it's over just because the window passed. Contact them first.

0 coins

Okay. I'll phone them this week and explain I didn't understand the form.

0 coins

Payment that was three weeks late on my care claim finally posted. Used Claimyr to get an agent who told me the payment date had been issued on the 11th but my payment method hadn't been confirmed on the account, so it was held. Got that straightened out the same day I called.

0 coins

Had a similar situation with a payment on my own claim. After getting through to an agent, turns out the Notice of Computation showed a weekly amount that didn't match what I expected because my base period wages weren't what I thought. The agent read me the actual figure on the notice. At least I knew what number to work from after that.

0 coins

Can I ask what made the amount on your notice different from your estimate?

0 coins

My highest quarter wasn't the one I assumed, the base period they used was earlier than I expected. The number on the notice was what it was, I just needed to know what it was.

0 coins

That base period thing catches a lot of people off guard.

0 coins

filed my appeal two weeks ago, nothing yet. just waiting

0 coins

Two weeks is still early for appeals. Keep checking SDI Online for any update on the status.

0 coins

yeah i know, just anxious

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the wages rule, PFL and regular wages can't both cover the same days, vacation payout included if EDD treats it as wages. The appeal is the place to argue that your payout wasn't wages in that sense.

0 coins

Does EDD ever just waive the overpayment instead of going through a full appeal?

0 coins

There's an appeals process and that's what the form is for. Whether EDD reverses it depends on the facts. Nobody can promise a waiver.

0 coins

That's right. The appeal form is the official path. What comes out of it depends on your documentation and how EDD reads the wage question.

0 coins

Weeks remaining on my PFL was what I needed to know. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who confirmed I had three weeks left in my 12-month window for a care claim after my bonding leave, something I couldn't figure out from SDI Online alone.

0 coins

That whole thing sounds like marketing to me honestly, too convenient.

0 coins

I had the same thought when I first came across it. Tried it anyway because I'd already spent three mornings getting nowhere with the line. Agent told me which weeks had been paid on my claim and that my next payment was scheduled after my continued claim certification came back. That was real information from EDD's own staff.

0 coins

Okay if someone else is saying the same thing I'll consider it. Still a little skeptical but I'll try before my deadline.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the dates you're asking about ready when you pick up. The agent went right to it.

0 coins

HR paying out vacation automatically while you're on leave is more common than people realize. The problem is most employees have no idea it can create a PFL overlap issue until the overpayment notice arrives.

0 coins

Honestly I'd never even thought about it. HR just did it and I assumed it was fine.

0 coins

Most employers don't flag it either. The burden ends up on the employee to sort it out with EDD after the fact, which is not ideal.

0 coins

Worth telling HR to pause any automatic payouts for employees on PFL. Easier than dealing with an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

File the appeal before anything else. Document everything: the pay stub showing the lump sum, a letter from HR, the dates. Keep copies of what you submit.

0 coins

Should I send copies or originals?

0 coins

Copies. Keep originals for yourself.

0 coins

EDD has to explain what days they're calling overpaid and why. If they can't map the vacation payout to specific PFL payment days in a way that makes sense, that's your argument.

0 coins

That's the core of it. The notice should identify which weeks and amounts are in dispute. If it doesn't, that itself is worth raising in the appeal.

0 coins

The notice does list specific weeks, which I guess is useful even if it's frustrating to look at.

0 coins

Then you know exactly what to respond to. Match your documentation to those specific weeks.

0 coins

Came through on the other side of a PFL appeal last month. It took about eight weeks from filing to a decision letter. The key thing was having a clear one-page explanation of why I disagreed, with the specific dates EDD listed in the notice addressed one by one.

0 coins

Eight weeks is a long time to sit on this. Did you hear anything in between or just silence until the letter?

0 coins

Mostly quiet. I checked SDI Online a few times but nothing showed there. The decision came by mail.

0 coins

Eight weeks is way longer than I expected. I'm going to file mine right away.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure