Back to California Paid Family Leave

Emma Garcia

How to apply for SDI when employer paid leave runs concurrently with PFL in California

My company gives us eight weeks of paid parental leave and my HR person told me they run it at the same time as PFL, so I'd be getting both. I went ahead and filed my bonding claim on SDI Online last week after my daughter was born, but now I'm second-guessing everything. Like, do I even still file for PFL if my job is already paying me? And if I do, does EDD care that my employer is paying me at the same time? I don't want to mess this up or end up with an overpayment or something. The HR person also said something about not going over my normal wages but I didn't totally follow what she meant by that. Has anyone done this where the company leave and PFL overlap?

Filing the bonding claim was the right call. PFL is your benefit, earned through CASDI withheld from your paychecks, and it doesn't disappear just because your employer also pays you during leave. What your HR person was describing is the wage cap: your employer wages plus your PFL payment together can't exceed what you normally earn. If your regular weekly pay is, say, eight hundred dollars, then whatever your employer sends you counts against how much PFL can add on top. Your Notice of Computation will show your weekly benefit amount, and from there you and HR can sort out how the numbers line up.

0 coins

So I still get the PFL money even though my job pays me the whole time? Or does EDD reduce it?

0 coins

EDD pays whatever your Notice of Computation shows. It's your employer who adjusts, usually by topping you off only to your normal pay rather than giving you a full paycheck on top of full PFL. Ask HR exactly how they calculate it.

0 coins

Ok that makes sense. HR said they'd handle it on their end. I just didn't want EDD to come after me later for an overpayment.

0 coins

Report your employer wages to EDD. Even wages not yet received. That's how you avoid an overpayment.

0 coins

This. Don't skip reporting. EDD finds out anyway.

0 coins

How do I report them? Do I do it in SDI Online?

0 coins

EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification after you file. Answer the wage questions on that honestly. If it doesn't come, check SDI Online and send a Request Claim Update.

0 coins

Two days a week I was going back to the salon after the baby turned three months, and the second payment wasn't matching what I expected at all. Took me forever to get anyone at EDD on the phone. I finally tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually ended up talking to a live EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through which intermittent days had been recorded on the DE 2580GF and which ones hadn't posted yet. Turned out two of my reported days hadn't matched up yet. She said to give it a few more business days and my payment would reflect them.

0 coins

Did they ask you anything specific about how you'd reported the days before they could look it up, anyway?

0 coins

They wanted my Social Security number and claim ID, that's it. Had those ready and they went straight to the DE 2580GF history on my claim.

0 coins

Three weeks of hitting redial every morning and I'm still getting the recording that dumps me. How is anyone getting through to a human on that line.

0 coins

The SDI wage cap works out to this: your PFL weekly benefit plus any wages you're receiving that week, excluding overtime, can't be more than your regular weekly wages. EDD's site has a benefits calculator if you want to estimate before the Notice of Computation arrives. That said, the Notice is what actually governs, so check the numbers on it when it shows up.

0 coins

So if my employer pays me my full salary, PFL might just pay nothing at all?

0 coins

If your employer pays your full regular wages, your PFL benefit would be reduced to zero for those weeks, yes, because you'd already be at your normal wage amount. This is why some employers only pay a partial supplement instead of full salary alongside PFL.

0 coins

That's wild. I had no idea the two were connected that way. Good to know before I file.

0 coins

December 3rd is when my employer leave ended and PFL kicked in solo. For those first weeks the combined amount hit the wage cap exactly, so the PFL came through at a reduced amount. Once employer pay stopped the full weekly benefit posted. Worth knowing the two phases can look very different on your payment history.

0 coins

That's really helpful to see how it played out in real life. Did EDD ever question the employer wages or just process it?

0 coins

No questions from EDD. The Continued Claim Certification asked about wages each period and I reported accurately. Payments came through without any notice about an issue.

0 coins

Good to hear it worked smoothly. I've been worried about the same thing.

0 coins

my job does the same thing, runs their parental leave with pfl at the same time. just report everything and you'll be fine dont overthink it

0 coins

Easy to say but EDD overpayments are no joke. Report the wages properly every time.

0 coins

yeah fair point, report it right, wasnt saying skip it

0 coins

Pending weeks after I filed a care claim, I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail that made no sense to me. Tried the EDD line most of a week with zero luck. Ended up using Claimyr and spoke with an EDD agent directly. The determination said I had wages in the base period but EDD needed to verify one employer before releasing the claim. Agent confirmed it was noted on the file and said a decision notice would go out by mail once it cleared.

0 coins

My own determination is sitting here and I can't tell if it's an approval or a partial denial. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, claim ID from SDI Online, and the determination letter in front of you. Tell them the notice date. They can pull up exactly what it says on their end.

0 coins

Wait, so a determination letter isn't necessarily a denial? I got one too and I panicked.

0 coins

A Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination is what EDD sends when they've made a decision on eligibility. It could go either way. If you disagree with what it says, you have 30 days to appeal using the Appeal Form that comes with it.

0 coins

If your company is running their leave concurrent with PFL, get the exact number from HR about what they'll pay each week. Then when your Notice of Computation comes, compare the two. Anything that pushes you over your normal weekly pay is what you have to watch.

0 coins

HR told me they true it up each pay period. I think I understand it now but I'll double-check with them once the Notice arrives.

0 coins

That's the right move. Get it in writing from HR if you can.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came for me about a week after I filed and I was so relieved to finally have a number to work with! It doesn't mean you're approved yet, just tells you what the weekly benefit would be if you are. Keep an eye on SDI Online for the status to update too.

0 coins

So pending just means they're still deciding? Mine has said pending for ten days and I'm sort of losing my mind about it.

0 coins

Ten days is totally normal! EDD says deciding can take up to 14 days, so you're right in that window. Hang in there!

0 coins

Ok, fourteen days. I'll mark that on my calendar. Thank you.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD can explain this concurrent leave thing clearly anyway. I asked two different times and got two different answers. At some point you just file, report the wages, and hope the math works out.

0 coins

The rule itself is consistent. The cap is wages plus PFL can't exceed your normal pay, and overtime is excluded. What two agents may have phrased differently is how employers implement it, which is genuinely up to each employer.

0 coins

Fine, the EDD rule is what it is. Employers doing whatever they want is the real variable. That part I believe.

0 coins

Went through this with my company leave last spring. HR set it up so they only paid the difference between my PFL benefit and my normal salary each week. So EDD paid the PFL piece and my job topped me off. Never had an overpayment issue. Report everything and it usually works itself out lol.

0 coins

That's how my HR described it too. They called it a 'supplement' arrangement. Sounds like that's the cleaner way to structure it.

0 coins

Yeah exactly. The messier version is when a company pays full salary AND you get full PFL, then you're definitely over the cap and it has to get sorted out.

0 coins

My HR said they handle it on their end. I think they do the supplement method but I'm going to confirm before my first payment comes through.

0 coins

Proof of relationship is something that caught me off guard on my bonding claim. Uploaded the birth certificate right away but SDI Online still showed the document as not yet matched three days later. Tried Claimyr and ended up on the line with an EDD agent who checked the claim. She said the certificate had come in and was linked to the right receipt number, it just hadn't updated the status display yet. Told me to expect the status to reflect it within a couple of days.

0 coins

The proof of relationship timing was the same issue I ran into. Ended up using Claimyr too, and once the agent confirmed EDD had the document, I set up direct deposit in SDI Online while I had the claim open. She walked through which payment method was on file so I knew it would go to the right account.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying that line before I gave up and just waited. Glad some people are getting through somehow.

0 coins

Direct deposit tip is good, hadn't thought about checking that at the same time. My payment went to the debit card for the first claim and I'm still figuring out how to change it for the second one anyway.

0 coins

Payment method can be updated in SDI Online under the claim. Direct deposit is only available for SDI Online claims, not paper filings.

0 coins

just file and report wages. don't double-dip is basically the rule. your employer knows this too.

0 coins

Yep. Simple as that.

0 coins

Does PFL have a waiting period like disability does? I read something about seven unpaid days somewhere and now I'm confused about whether that applies here too.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. The seven unpaid days is for Disability Insurance, which is a separate program. Your PFL bonding claim starts paying from the first day you're eligible, no gap.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness. I was dreading a week with no pay from either side. That's a relief.

0 coins

Tripped me up with my first kid too, thought I had to sit out a week. PFL is different, no waiting around anyway.

0 coins

Eight weeks is the PFL maximum across bonding, care and military assist claims combined within any 12-month period. Worth knowing if you're planning to use some weeks for bonding now and might need weeks later for a family care situation. They share one pool.

0 coins

Wait, so it's not eight weeks for bonding separately and eight more for a care claim? They share the same eight weeks?

0 coins

Correct. One pool, eight total weeks per 12-month period, across all three claim types. If you use six bonding, you have two left for a care claim in that same window.

0 coins

That's not how I had it in my head at all. Good correction.

0 coins

EDD's site spells this out in the FAQs. Worth reading before you plan your leave schedule so there are no surprises later.

0 coins

CFRA and PFL are not the same thing. PFL pays you. CFRA might protect your job. You can get one without the other depending on your employer and situation. Ask HR, not EDD, about job protection.

0 coins

My HR person mentioned CFRA when we talked about my leave. So my job should be protected even though EDD says PFL doesn't protect it?

0 coins

Whether CFRA covers your situation is between you, your employer and that law. HR can tell you. EDD only handles the payment side.

0 coins

Got it. I'll loop back with HR specifically about CFRA. I had been assuming PFL handled all of it.

0 coins

Nobody told me when I first filed that you have to keep returning those Continued Claim Certifications or the payments stop. Almost missed one while dealing with the baby and the salon schedule at the same time. Set a phone reminder for yourself.

0 coins

Same thing nearly happened to me. EDD sends the DE 2580GF and if it doesn't come back, they just stop paying. No warning, no grace message, just stops.

0 coins

Is there a deadline on those or just whenever you get it in?

0 coins

Return it promptly when it arrives. EDD uses it to verify ongoing eligibility, and delays in returning it can delay or stop your payments.

0 coins

If your company leave ends before your eight PFL weeks are done, whatever weeks are left keep paying at the full weekly benefit amount with no employer wages offsetting it anymore. So the second phase of your claim may actually be simpler to track.

0 coins

Exactly what happened with mine. Last three weeks were straightforward, full PFL benefit, no wage calculation to worry about.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. My company leave is six weeks so there'd be two more weeks after where it's just PFL by itself.

0 coins

edd doesn't care who else is paying you they just care what you report. report everything and dont stress

0 coins

EDD does actually care about wages, that's what the wage cap is for. But reporting everything is right.

0 coins

yeah ok fair, the cap thing, i meant they dont penalize you for the employer paying you as long as you report it right

0 coins

My bonding claim got approved about twelve days after I filed and uploaded the birth certificate. First payment info came through on the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification. It all moved faster than I expected honestly!

0 coins

Twelve days gives me hope. Mine is on day ten. So maybe just a couple more days.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for you! Check SDI Online, sometimes the status updates before any mail arrives.

0 coins

Bottom line: file, report what your employer pays you every period, return the certifications when they come. That's it. Don't overthink the math, just be accurate.

0 coins

Honestly this thread helped me more than the EDD website did. I think I've got it now. File, report wages, return the certifications, let HR handle the cap calculation on their end.

0 coins

You got it. Good luck with the new baby.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure