Back to California Paid Family Leave

Alicia Stern

How to appeal paid family leave overpayment notice within 10 days documents needed

Got an overpayment notice from EDD last week on my PFL bonding claim and I'm kind of losing it a little. I took leave after my daughter was born back in the spring and apparently EDD is saying I was paid for days I shouldn't have been. The notice came totally out of nowhere. I didn't report any wages wrong intentionally, I went back part time for a few weeks and I thought I did everything right. The notice says I can appeal but I genuinely don't know what that means in practice. Like what documents do I even send with an appeal? Do I attach pay stubs, my work schedule, the original claim stuff? And is there actually a point to appealing or does EDD just rubber stamp these things? I have 30 days to file but I want to get this in fast anyway.

The appeal form that comes with an overpayment notice is the DE 1000A. You fill it out, state why you disagree, and mail or submit it online within 30 days of the date on the notice. Supporting documents you'd want to include are anything that shows your actual work schedule and wages during the leave period: pay stubs, employer letters, timesheets, whatever backs up what you reported. Keep copies of everything you send.

0 coins

So the DE 1000A is what I need. Does the notice itself say where to send it, or is there a specific address?

0 coins

The mailing instructions are on the notice itself, so follow wherever it directs. And filing it online through SDI Online is also an option if you filed your claim there.

0 coins

ok thank you. im going to pull up the notice again and look for the address tonight.

0 coins

DE 429DF on my bonding claim showed a weekly amount that looked wrong to me, nothing like what I expected from my wages. Tried that EDD phone line maybe eight or nine times before I actually got through using Claimyr (claimyr.com). Agent pulled up my claim and read me the exact quarter they used for the calculation and the weekly benefit amount on the notice. Turned out the base period they used was correct, the wages just weren't what I remembered. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My pending bonding claim has been sitting there eleven days and I still haven't gotten a Notice of Computation. That's what I'd want to ask EDD about. Would Claimyr work for something like that?

0 coins

Have your receipt number and Social Security number ready when it rings through. Those are what the agent will ask for first.

0 coins

Good to know. I've been trying that line since Tuesday and it just dumps me into a recording and cuts off.

0 coins

same thing happened to me for days. good luck getting through.

0 coins

The 30-day window for appealing is worth flagging here, because the notice date is what starts the clock, not the day you received it. So if the notice is dated last Monday and you got it Thursday, you're already a few days in. EDD's own materials say to file the DE 1000A within 30 days of the determination date on the document.

0 coins

Wait, the date on the notice, not when it arrived in my mailbox? Let me check the date on mine because I might have fewer days than I thought.

0 coins

Exactly, look at the date printed on the notice itself. That's your starting point. If you're close to the edge, file the appeal first and gather documents right after.

0 coins

Is it ok if the reason I write on the DE 1000A is kind of long? Like I want to explain the whole part-time situation in detail. Is there a word limit or something?

0 coins

No word limit that I know of. When I appealed something on my claim I basically wrote out the full story, attached my pay stubs for every week in question, and that was it. The more you can show that your wages matched what you reported, the better your case looks.

0 coins

That makes sense. So the pay stubs are kind of the main evidence then.

0 coins

For a wages situation, yes. If the dispute is about something else, like whether you were even working those days at all, then timesheets or a letter from your employer spelling out your schedule could help too.

0 coins

EDD sends these overpayment notices and half the time it's because someone didn't return the Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF. If you went back part time and EDD sent you that form and you missed it, that's usually where it goes sideways. Did you get one of those?

0 coins

I honestly don't remember seeing a DE 2580GF. Is that the form they send when you go back part time?

0 coins

Yeah if you were working while drawing PFL they're supposed to send you that certification form. If it doesn't get returned, benefits keep paying even though they shouldn't, and then you end up with one of these notices.

0 coins

This might actually be what happened. I was so scattered after going back to work I might have missed a form in the mail. Would that still be appealable though?

0 coins

You can still appeal and explain the circumstances. EDD can review whether the overpayment amount is accurate and whether you had a good reason for missing the form. Put it all in writing.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and reading this thread nervously. I went back part time after my son was born and I reported my wages each time, I think. But I'm not sure if I reported them correctly through SDI Online. What if I reported them but on the wrong screen or something? Would that show up as an overpayment later?

0 coins

Wages and any return to work, even part time, need to be reported to EDD when you go back. If you did report them and have the SDI Online history to show it, that's your documentation if anything ever comes up.

0 coins

So I should probably log into SDI Online now and see if my reporting is showing up in there?

0 coins

Yes, checking your payment history and claim status in SDI Online is a good first step to see what's been recorded on your end.

0 coins

Had a question about which weeks EDD had paid on my bonding claim and when the next payment was coming, so I used Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line. The agent went through my claim and listed every payment date, told me exactly which two-week periods had been issued and which one was still processing. Super useful for anyone unsure if the weeks on their notice match what EDD actually paid out!

0 coins

That detail about which weeks were actually paid matches something I ran into on my own claim. I used Claimyr as well and the agent confirmed the exact date my first payment was issued, which helped me match it to when the funds hit my account. After that I knew my remaining weeks and planned my schedule around them.

0 coins

How hard was it to actually reach someone? I've been dialing that line every morning for a week.

0 coins

Mornings I tried were the worst for me too, the line just ended the call after a couple minutes. Claimyr handled the wait and I got the agent without sitting there myself.

0 coins

Might be worth trying then. I need to know why my payment for last week hasn't shown up yet.

0 coins

Thirty days feels like a lot but it goes fast. File the appeal the minute you have it filled out. Don't sit on it waiting to gather perfect documents. Send the DE 1000A first and you can submit additional evidence after if needed.

0 coins

Can you actually submit more documents after you file the initial appeal? I didn't know that was an option.

0 coins

You can send additional documents to the address on your notice. At the appeal hearing stage you can also bring evidence. File first, documents right behind it.

0 coins

wait does the 10 days thing in the title mean something different or is it just 30 days to appeal

0 coins

The standard window to appeal an EDD Paid Family Leave determination or overpayment notice is 30 days from the date on the notice. Some people want to move faster than that, which is smart, but the official deadline EDD gives you is 30 days.

0 coins

ok so 30 days. the 10 days thing scared me for a sec

0 coins

Same, I put 10 days in my post because I wanted to move quick. The 30-day deadline is the actual rule but I'd rather not use all of it.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up when I got a notice was figuring out whether to submit the appeal online or by mail. I ended up doing it through SDI Online because I had already filed the original claim there and it felt faster. Either way works, just make sure you get some kind of confirmation.

0 coins

If you file it in SDI Online do you get a confirmation number or something you can save?

0 coins

Yeah there's a confirmation when you submit it, lol, screenshot it or write it down just in case.

0 coins

Thank you. I always forget to save those things and then panic later.

0 coins

For anyone who reported wages while on intermittent PFL leave, it's worth double-checking that the wages you reported match your pay stubs exactly. Even a small difference between what you entered and what your employer reported can trigger an overpayment notice. If the numbers line up, that's your defense.

0 coins

What if I rounded the hours or something when I reported? Like I wasn't tracking it perfectly.

0 coins

If there's a discrepancy between your reported wages and what your employer submitted to EDD, the overpayment notice might reflect that gap. In your appeal you'd explain the circumstances and provide the actual pay stubs as the accurate record.

0 coins

ok that is making me nervous but at least I know what to look for now.

0 coins

Keep the notice itself, the original claim confirmation, pay stubs for every week you were also working, and anything you got from your employer about your schedule. Those are the basics. Bring them all if it goes to a hearing.

0 coins

I have most of those. My employer can probably give me a letter about the part-time schedule too, which might help.

0 coins

An employer letter is useful. Get it on company letterhead if you can, with the specific dates and hours.

0 coins

The appeal form asks you to briefly state the reason you disagree. Keep it factual: dates you worked, wages you earned, what you reported and when. Avoid vague statements and stick to the specific weeks the notice is disputing.

0 coins

This is basically what my HR manager told me to do when I went through something similar. Stay specific to the dates and amounts, don't write a whole emotional essay.

0 coins

Exactly. The reviewer needs facts, not frustration, even when the frustration is completely warranted.

0 coins

EDD reading an emotional essay and caring about it is not something I believe happens.

0 coins

DE 2500E on my bonding claim listed a payment that matched my bank but I wasn't sure the amount was right for the days I'd actually worked that week. Ended up talking to a PFL agent through Claimyr about it, the agent pulled up the DE 2500E and confirmed the exact dollar figure for the payment period and which days it covered.

0 coins

Honestly not sure I believe anything gets through on that line. I tried at least a dozen times on my care claim, every time it cut me off inside two minutes.

0 coins

That was my experience too before I tried it. The agent I spoke with was an actual EDD employee and confirmed the payment details right on the call. I wasn't expecting it to work either.

0 coins

i verified with an agent how many weeks i had left in my 12-month window after using it too. had used some weeks earlier for bonding and needed to know what was still available for a care claim. agent told me the number right there.

0 coins

Alright, may actually try it then. Need to sort out my own notice before the 30 days runs out.

0 coins

Going back to the documents question, if your overpayment relates to wages you earned while on leave: pay stubs are the clearest thing to send. If it's about days you claim you didn't work, a schedule or calendar from your employer showing those days is good backup.

0 coins

My situation is about wages during the part-time weeks so the pay stubs angle is what I need. I'll pull everything for those weeks.

0 coins

Line them up against the weeks mentioned in the overpayment notice specifically. Makes it easy for whoever reviews it to see the comparison.

0 coins

Went intermittent on my bonding claim for about six weeks and EDD sent me a DE 2580GF every two weeks to certify. Tried calling to ask about the reporting for one specific week that looked off and used Claimyr to reach the PFL line. Agent confirmed which days on that form were marked as working days and that my reporting matched what was in the system.

0 coins

Not sure exactly what Claimyr is, haven't heard of it. How does it work?

0 coins

You let it handle the hold time on EDD's line and your phone rings when an actual PFL agent picks up. That's essentially it.

0 coins

Got it. I'd want to ask EDD whether the DE 2580GF I returned last month was received and recorded, because I still got a notice I didn't expect.

0 coins

i waited a full week to try that line and it dropped every single time. wish id known about this sooner.

0 coins

Does PFL have a waiting week before benefits start? My buddy told me EDD takes out the first week so I might owe that back somehow.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That's Disability Insurance that has the seven unpaid days at the start. PFL benefits begin with the first day of qualifying leave, so there's no week to owe back for that reason.

0 coins

ok good, my buddy must have been thinking of disability then.

0 coins

Half the bad information out there about PFL comes from people mixing it up with disability. Different program, different rules.

0 coins

if the notice says you owe money but you think the amount is just wrong, not that you owe nothing, is the appeal still the right path?

0 coins

Yes. You can dispute both whether you owe anything at all and whether the amount on the notice is accurate. Put both arguments in the DE 1000A if both apply to your situation.

0 coins

ok that helps. i thought it was one or the other.

0 coins

Something I'm still unclear on: if I appeal and lose, do I still have to pay the full amount back, or can I ask EDD for some kind of payment arrangement?

0 coins

Appealing an overpayment and asking about repayment arrangements are separate things. If the appeal doesn't succeed, you would owe the amount. For anything about repayment options, that would be a question for EDD directly, since arrangements vary by situation.

0 coins

ok so I should probably ask EDD about that separately even while the appeal is going on.

0 coins

Keeping those two questions separate is the right approach. The appeal challenges whether the overpayment is valid; repayment is a different conversation.

0 coins

Just want to say to the original poster, you are not alone in this. I've seen a few people in my circle go through overpayment notices and all of them got through it. File that DE 1000A, attach your pay stubs, and state clearly which weeks and amounts you're disputing.

0 coins

Appreciate that. I was really panicked when I first got the notice but reading through all of this has helped. I'm going to file the appeal this week with my pay stubs for the part-time weeks.

0 coins

You've got this. And keep copies of absolutely everything you send.

0 coins

does appealing stop them from collecting the money while its pending or does edd still try to take it

0 coins

Whether collection activity is paused during an appeal is something to ask EDD directly, since it can depend on your specific situation. It's worth noting that in your appeal and asking EDD when you file.

0 coins

ok ill ask when i send the form in

0 coins

Filing the appeal fast, before 30 days, is always smarter than waiting for perfect documentation. Send the DE 1000A now, state the week numbers and wage amounts you're disputing, and follow up with documents as you gather them.

0 coins

Final plan after reading all this: file the DE 1000A this week, attach the pay stubs I have, get the employer letter for the part-time schedule, and note in the appeal that more documents may follow. Does that sound right?

0 coins

That's a solid plan. Note in the form that additional documentation will follow and then send it promptly.

0 coins

Agreed. Getting the DE 1000A in before the 30 days is the most important step. Everything else can follow.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure