Back to California Paid Family Leave

Freya Andersen

How to appeal paid family leave denial full wage continuation — denied after returning part-time

So I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail last week and it says my PFL claim was denied. I'm caring for my mom who's been really sick and I had reduced my hours at work to take her to her appointments and stay with her during treatment. My employer has this full wage continuation program where they top up my pay so I was still getting my full salary even with the reduced hours, and I think that's why EDD denied it? The notice mentioned something about wages but I honestly don't understand the reasoning. I have the Appeal Form DE 1000A that came with it and I know I have 30 days to appeal but I don't know what to write or what to include. Has anyone appealed a PFL denial before? Did you win? What do I actually put on the appeal form?

The 30-day clock on the DE 1000A starts from the mailing date on that determination notice, not from when you received it, so check that date right away. For the appeal itself, you don't need a legal brief; you write a plain explanation of why you disagree with EDD's decision. State what your leave situation was, that you reduced your hours to care for your mother, and explain how your employer's wage continuation program works. Attach anything that supports your version: pay stubs showing the reduced hours, a letter from your employer about the program, whatever you have.

0 coins

The mailing date on mine is from nine days ago so I still have time, but not a lot. I didn't realize it ran from the mailing date rather than when I actually got it.

0 coins

Good point about the date. People sit on those notices thinking they have more time and then they're out of luck.

0 coins

Does the appeal go by mail or can it be done online?

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be submitted online or mailed. The notice itself should tell you where to send the paper form. Online is faster.

0 coins

My PFL care claim got denied last year for a different reason but I appealed and it was eventually resolved. The key thing I learned was to be specific in the appeal box. Don't just say 'I disagree,' actually walk through the facts: the dates you reduced your hours, what your mom's condition required, and what your employer's wage continuation plan says in writing. If your employer can give you something official explaining that the top-up is their own policy separate from your PFL claim, that could help explain the wage picture to whoever reviews the appeal.

0 coins

Getting something in writing from HR is a good idea. My employer does have a written policy on the wage continuation program, I just never thought to include it.

0 coins

Does EDD actually read the attachments? I always worry they just look at the form itself and nothing else gets seen.

0 coins

In my experience the attachments went into the file. I can't promise anything but I'd still send everything relevant rather than leave it out.

0 coins

Around the time my care claim was processing I kept checking SDI Online and the DE 2500E showing the first payment info just never appeared, so I ended up getting on the phone with EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because I couldn't get anyone live any other way. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent I spoke with pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2500E hadn't been generated yet because Part D from my dad's doctor had just been matched to the account the day before, and the payment would follow within a couple of days. That was such a relief to know rather than just staring at a pending screen.

0 coins

Honestly that sounds like a sponsored comment to me. I've never seen anything that actually breaks through to a live EDD person, every tool that promises that has just been garbage in my experience anyway.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw mentions of it! But then I tried it myself because I was at week three of silence on my own claim. The agent told me my leave start date was recorded two days later than I had filed for, which would have put me right at the edge of the 41-day window. Got that corrected and my payment came through. Definitely a real EDD person on the other end.

0 coins

Huh. Okay that's actually a specific detail not just 'it worked.' I might give it a shot because I've been getting cut off at the same menu point for two weeks straight.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for PFL is a joke. I tried for four mornings in a row before giving up. Doesn't matter what time you start, the volume message comes on and then it just ends the call. Your best bet is using the Request Claim Update in SDI Online while you sort out the appeal, at least that creates a record.

0 coins

Four mornings is nothing. I hit that recording eleven days straight on a care claim. The Request Claim Update thing did eventually get a response though, took about a week.

0 coins

Eleven days. That's brutal. And yeah the online message at least gets logged, which is more than a dropped call does.

0 coins

request claim update worked for me too. slow but it got answered

0 coins

The wage thing on your denial is worth looking at closely. PFL doesn't pay you for the same days you're already getting full wages, so if your employer was paying your complete normal salary during the same period you were claiming PFL, that could be why it got kicked back.

0 coins

That actually makes sense now that I think about it. I was getting my full salary the whole time because of the continuation policy. So EDD saw full wages for days I was claiming PFL and said no.

0 coins

Exactly right. If wages plus PFL would exceed your normal pay, EDD won't pay PFL on top. The employer's policy determines how the two interact; it's worth asking HR whether the continuation is meant to run alongside PFL or instead of it.

0 coins

HR told me the policy was designed to cover the gap, meaning they top up whatever PFL doesn't pay. But if EDD sees the full wages first and denies PFL, the whole thing falls apart. I'll bring that HR explanation into the appeal.

0 coins

October 3rd was my care claim start date and Part D arrived at EDD on October 19th, well inside 41 days. When EDD still showed pending on day 15 I sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining the timeline. Got a written response that the claim was under review. Appeal situation is different from pending though, so the process you're dealing with is more formal.

0 coins

Mine went straight to denial, no pending limbo. I did receive Part D in time though so that wasn't the issue, it was definitely the wage thing.

0 coins

Pending and denied really do feel like two completely different planets to deal with.

0 coins

They are. Denied means you're in appeal territory and need that DE 1000A submitted with documentation. Pending just means wait or nudge them online.

0 coins

my coworker had her care claim denied and she just wrote like two paragraphs on the appeal form explaining her whole situation and they reversed it. so dont overthink the form itself, just be clear and attach the proof

0 coins

Two paragraphs reversed it? That's actually encouraging. I've been dreading writing a whole argument.

0 coins

yeah she said she just explained what happened factually, included her pay stubs and the employer letter, and that was enough. ymmv obviously but it wasnt some big legal thing lol

0 coins

Not sure if this is relevant but I thought PFL had a waiting period before payments start, like seven days unpaid? I'm wondering if that played into your denial somehow, like maybe they counted waiting period days differently with the wage continuation on top.

0 coins

PFL actually has no waiting period at all. That seven-day unpaid period is for Disability Insurance, which is a separate program. PFL benefits start from the first eligible day of leave.

0 coins

Oh wow I didn't know that. I've been confusing those two this whole time. Good to know before I file my own claim.

0 coins

A lot of people mix those up. DI for your own illness or pregnancy, PFL for bonding or caring for a family member, and no waiting period on the PFL side.

0 coins

Went back part-time after taking the first few weeks of PFL for a bonding claim and I completely froze on how to report the days I actually worked. I got on the phone with EDD using Claimyr and the agent walked me through what the DE 2580GF was asking. Turns out EDD had already sent one to my address and I hadn't opened it yet, thought it was junk mail.

0 coins

What did they say about the wage reporting part specifically, the part where you log what you earned each day?

0 coins

Agent said to report wages for each day I worked even if I hadn't been paid for them yet, and not to combine days. Daily breakdown, not a weekly total.

0 coins

ive been trying the edd line since tuesday and it just cuts me off every time, glad that worked for you

0 coins

On the appeal form there's a spot to explain your reason. Keep it short and factual. Date you started leave, what your mom needed, what your employer paid you and why, and why you think the denial is wrong. Don't editorialize. EDD reviewers read a lot of these.

0 coins

Short and factual. Got it. I tend to over-explain when I'm stressed so that's a useful reminder.

0 coins

Same advice I'd give. The facts do the work. The more emotion in it the less it reads like a case.

0 coins

Wage continuation from an employer often overlaps awkwardly with PFL because the system sees income and flags it. Worth clarifying in the appeal whether the employer was replacing PFL entirely or supplementing it. HR should know and should be able to put it in writing.

0 coins

HR confirmed in an email this morning that the intent was to supplement, not replace. I'm going to attach that email to the appeal form.

0 coins

That email is probably the strongest single piece of documentation you have. Make a copy before you send anything.

0 coins

My sister had a PFL denial reversed on appeal last year and she said the appeals office was actually pretty responsive once her file was complete. She attached her employer's written policy and her pay stubs from each week of leave and the reviewer understood the situation pretty quickly.

0 coins

Pay stubs from each week of leave, that's a good call. Mine should show the reduced hours clearly alongside the top-up amount.

0 coins

Exactly, the more the reviewer can see the actual numbers week by week, the clearer your argument gets!

0 coins

edd denied my partners care claim too. they appealed it and nothing has happened for like 6 weeks. is that normal or did something get lost

0 coins

Appeals can take some time to process. If six weeks have passed with no acknowledgment at all, sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining that an appeal was submitted on a specific date is a reasonable next step.

0 coins

ok yeah i dont think theyve gotten any response at all, not even a confirmation. ill tell them to do the online update

0 coins

No acknowledgment in six weeks on an appeal would have me nervous too. The online update leaves a paper trail at least.

0 coins

Dealing with a denial notice on a DE 2514 is rough, especially when you're already managing caring for someone. I called EDD through Claimyr about a DE 2514 I'd received on my own care claim because I wanted to know exactly what grounds EDD had listed on file before I wrote my appeal. The agent read me the specific reason code and confirmed which weeks were listed as ineligible. Knowing that going in made my appeal letter actually address the right thing instead of guessing.

0 coins

My DE 2514 arrived last week and I haven't touched it yet because I didn't know what the reason code actually means in practice. I'm going to try Claimyr for my own situation so I can find out what EDD has on file. What would you suggest I have ready when I get through to the agent?

0 coins

Have your claim ID number from SDI Online handy, plus the mailing date off the DE 2514 itself because they'll ask about the timeline. The agent can then pull up exactly what's in your file.

0 coins

The idea of knowing the specific reason code before writing the appeal is something I hadn't thought of. I might try to get more detail on what exactly EDD has recorded before I submit my DE 1000A.

0 coins

The deadline to appeal is firm. If the 30 days pass, your option becomes filing a new claim if you're still eligible, not reopening the old denial. Submit the DE 1000A well before that date even if your documentation isn't complete, then follow up with additional documents.

0 coins

File first, add documents after. That makes sense. I'd rather have an appeal on record than miss the window trying to gather everything at once.

0 coins

Exactly. The appeal locks in your position on the timeline. You can supplement after.

0 coins

My employer's HR told me PFL and CFRA are the same thing and that EDD handles both. That can't be right, can it?

0 coins

They are definitely not the same. PFL is EDD's benefit payment program, up to eight weeks of partial wage replacement. CFRA is a job protection law, it keeps your position while you're on leave. EDD handles PFL, not CFRA. For CFRA questions, your HR department or the Civil Rights Department's site is the right place.

0 coins

So EDD can deny my PFL payment and my job protection is a separate question entirely. That's actually a bit scary to realize.

0 coins

Two separate systems, yes. PFL says whether you get paid. CFRA, if it applies to your situation, says whether your job is protected. Worth asking HR about CFRA directly.

0 coins

submitted my appeal two months ago and got a letter saying it was received but nothing since. does that mean its still being reviewed or did it get stuck somewhere

0 coins

A receipt letter means it's in the queue. Send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online referencing the appeal and your original claim ID to ask for a status update.

0 coins

ok will do that today

0 coins

Eight weeks is the total for bonding, care and military assist all together, not eight weeks for each. I've seen people assume they can stack them and that's not how it works.

0 coins

Wait, so if I took five weeks bonding with my son earlier this year, I only have three weeks left for a care claim if something came up with a family member?

0 coins

If it's all in the same 12-month period, yes. Three weeks left. EDD tracks the total used within any 12 months.

0 coins

That's a lot smaller buffer than I thought. Good to know before I'd need to file a care claim.

0 coins

The appeal form asks for your claim number and the date on the determination notice. After that it's essentially a written statement section. I'd keep it organized: one paragraph on what your leave situation was, one on how your employer's wage continuation works, and one explaining why you believe the denial doesn't reflect the actual facts. Clear and numbered if you can.

0 coins

Organized into three paragraphs, that's exactly how I'll structure it. I'm going to draft it tonight while the HR email is still fresh.

0 coins

If you can get your employer to sign or officially stamp the documentation that explains the continuation policy, even better. It signals to the reviewer that it's a formal policy, not an informal arrangement.

0 coins

wait does pfl pay taxes or do i owe something at the end of the year on it. asking because my denial situation might get reversed and i dont wanna be surprised

0 coins

California doesn't tax PFL benefits. EDD sends a 1099-G in January showing what was paid in that year. For the federal side, that's really a question for a tax professional or EDD's own tax information page, not something I'd want to get wrong for you.

0 coins

ok fair enough, ill check edds site and ask my tax person. thanks

0 coins

PFL benefits don't pay for the same days as unemployment either. If anyone reading this is out of work entirely and thinking of combining them, you can only get one at a time.

0 coins

didnt know that. my situation is care claim not unemployment but good to know

0 coins

Care claim is a whole different thing from unemployment, you're fine on that front. Just wanted to flag it because I see people ask about combining them sometimes.

0 coins

Update: I submitted the DE 1000A today, two weeks before the deadline. Included the HR email, my pay stubs from each week of reduced hours, and a paragraph explaining that the wage continuation was designed to supplement PFL, not replace it. The appeals office acknowledged it online in SDI Online. Now I wait. Thank you all, this thread genuinely helped me figure out what to actually put on that form.

0 coins

Good documentation choices. The HR email in particular should give the reviewer a clear picture of how the policy was structured.

0 coins

Two weeks early was smart. Hope it resolves in your favor.

0 coins

You did it right. Now just let the process run.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure