How to appeal PFL overpayment after filing wrong claim type
I made a really bad mistake and I'm panicking a little. I filed a bonding claim when I think I should have filed a care claim for my mom, who's been pretty sick this year. I realized the error about two weeks in and by then EDD had already paid out several weeks on the bonding claim. Now I have an overpayment notice sitting on my kitchen table and I genuinely don't know what to do next. Can I appeal this? Do I have to pay it all back right now? I haven't been able to find anything on EDD's site that explains what happens when the wrong claim type was the reason for the overpayment. Any help would be really appreciated.
78 comments

LordCommander
Two days after filing a care claim for my dad, I got confused about which receipt number went with which claim because I had filed a PFL claim once before and the confirmation pages looked similar. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the EDD Paid Family Leave line, and the agent pulled up my file and read me the receipt number for the new care claim right off the screen. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Having the right number meant I could give it to my dad's doctor for Part D, so the whole thing moved a lot faster after that.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
What did you have ready when the agent answered? Like did you need your Social Security number or the claim ID or both?
0 coins
LordCommander
Social Security number, date of birth, and my EDD customer account number. Had them on a sticky note. The agent verified those three and then went straight to the claim.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
I've been dialing that line since 7 in the morning three days running and not once have I gotten past the recording. Nice to know someone's actually getting through somehow.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
The overpayment notice should have an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, attached to it or inside the same envelope. You can appeal it online or by mail, but you have to do it within 30 days of the date on that notice. Missing that window is the part that really matters here, so I would look at the date on the letter today.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorThe notice is dated about ten days ago, so I still have time. I'm going to look for that DE 1000A tonight. Do I need to explain on the form why I filed the wrong claim type?
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Yes, write out what happened as clearly as you can. The fact that it was a filing error rather than intentional matters, so put that in your own words on the appeal.
0 coins
Connor Richards
I didn't even know you could appeal an overpayment. I thought once EDD said you owed money that was just it. Good to know the DE 1000A covers this too.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Don't ignore that notice. Thirty days goes fast. Fill out the appeal and mail it certified so you have proof it went out.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorCertified mail, got it. I wouldn't have thought of that.
0 coins
Steven Adams
Certified is the right call. Date on the postmark is what counts if they ever question when you sent it.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
If your mom needed care and you genuinely should have filed a care claim instead of a bonding claim, the appeal is where you explain that. EDD will look at whether you actually had a qualifying reason to take leave. It won't guarantee anything, but laying out the facts of your mom's situation is exactly what that form is for.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorShe was pretty seriously ill, so the reason for leave was real, just filed under the wrong type. That's what I'll explain.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
The DE 2530 guide on EDD's site lists the qualifying family members for a care claim. Worth double-checking that your mom fits the list before you write the appeal, just so you know where you stand.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
Makes sense to get that straight first.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Wait, bonding and care are both PFL, right? So is it even a different claim type or is it more like a coding error on the same program? Asking because that might matter for how you frame the appeal, anyway.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
They're both under PFL but the qualifying reason is different. Bonding is for a new child, care is for a seriously ill family member. EDD tracks them separately, so filing one when you meant the other does create a mismatch they'll want explained.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Okay that makes sense, I wasn't sure if it was the same bucket. Good to know before I end up in the same mess anyway.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
yeah same program different reasons, edd still treats them like separate claims tho
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Thirty days. That's the whole rule. Don't overthink the form, just get it in.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Short and right. The clock is what matters.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorTen days left on mine. Filing this week.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Weeks before my Notice of Computation showed up, I kept second-guessing whether my benefit amount was going to be what I expected. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent and she told me my weekly benefit amount right from the DE 429DF on my claim. That number on the notice ended up matching exactly what she said.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
The amount on my own DE 429DF looked lower than the calculator estimate and I want to understand why. I'm going to try Claimyr for that. Do I need anything specific beyond my Social Security number and claim ID?
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Have your base period start and end dates handy too if you know them. The agent can explain which quarter EDD used and that might clear up why the number is different from the estimate.
0 coins
Avery Saint
EDD's online calculator has always been off for me too. I stopped trusting it and just wait for the actual notice now.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Does PFL have a waiting week before it starts paying? I feel like I remember there being like a seven day thing but I'm not sure if that's just for disability.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
That seven-day wait is for Disability Insurance, not PFL. EDD is pretty clear that PFL has no benefit waiting period, so your first eligible day is paid.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Oh wow okay I totally mixed those up lol. Good to know.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
yeah i made the same mistake when i filed, was sweating about losing a week for nothing
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
For anyone wondering about the appeal process in writing: the DE 1000A is the form, it goes by mail or online, and 30 days from the notice date is the deadline. EDD will schedule a hearing where you can present your case. The overpayment doesn't have to be paid immediately while the appeal is pending, but the notice itself will tell you what EDD expects in the meantime, so read it carefully.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorThe notice doesn't say anything about paying while the appeal is in process. I'll read it again more carefully tonight to make sure I'm not missing something.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Reading the whole notice is exactly right. It should spell out whether any immediate action is required or whether the amount is held until the hearing.
0 coins
Connor Richards
I didn't realize appeals meant an actual hearing. That sounds more involved than I expected.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
It can feel that way but it's your chance to explain what happened. You present the facts, EDD presents theirs, and a judge decides. Having your documents organized helps.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I've tried for weeks and the recording just dumps me after telling me call volume is too high. Meanwhile people are sitting with overpayment notices and the clock is ticking.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Use the Request Claim Update in SDI Online while you're trying to reach someone by phone. At least there's a record of you contacting them.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
I've sent three Request Claim Updates and heard nothing back. The phone is the same story. At some point you just have to hope the appeal form alone does the job.
0 coins
LordCommander
Request Claim Update did nothing for me for two weeks either. The phone is better when you can actually get through.
0 coins
Connor Richards
Weeks of waiting to hear about which weeks were paid on my claim, I finally tried Claimyr to reach a PFL agent. The agent told me exactly which two-week periods had been paid out, what the remaining balance of weeks was, and when the next payment was scheduled to process.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Part D on my care claim had been sitting unmatched for a while, and I used Claimyr too. Once the agent confirmed Part D was in and matched, I went back into SDI Online and the status had already updated. You're right that talking to a person cuts through a lot of the guessing.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
been trying that line every morning this week, still nothing. glad some people are getting through.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
I kept trying the same hours each day and getting nowhere. Mixing up the days I called seemed to help but honestly it was inconsistent.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
If you can't get through on the phone and the 30-day window is getting close, is it okay to just mail the DE 1000A without talking to anyone at EDD first?
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Absolutely fine to mail it without speaking to anyone. The appeal stands on its own. Talking to EDD beforehand doesn't affect whether the appeal is valid.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
That's a relief. I was worried I had to call first to tell them I was appealing.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Mail it. Don't wait for a phone conversation that may not happen in time.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
Is the overpayment amount on the notice the total they paid out on the wrong claim type, or is it calculated some other way?
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
The notice should state exactly how they arrived at the amount. It's usually the payments issued that EDD has determined were not properly owed. Read the breakdown section on the notice, it should itemize the weeks and amounts.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
Mine lists each week separately. I want to verify those weeks against my payment history in SDI Online before the appeal.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Cross-referencing your SDI Online payment history is smart before you file anything. If even one week is off you want to catch it.
0 coins
Steven Adams
If you filed the wrong claim type because the forms are confusing, say that plainly in the appeal. EDD sees a lot of these. Plain language, stick to the facts.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorPlain language I can do. I've been overthinking how formal it needs to sound.
0 coins
Steven Adams
No need for legal language. Just what happened, when, and why the leave was real even if the form was wrong.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
did edd give you any heads up before the overpayment notice or did it just show up out of nowhere
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorCompletely out of nowhere. No warning in SDI Online, nothing by email, just a letter in the mail one morning.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
That's exactly how EDD operates. No advance notice, then a letter with a 30-day clock already running.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
ugh thats rough, at least you caught it with time still on the window
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Get a copy of everything before you appeal: the overpayment notice, any payment confirmations from SDI Online, and whatever confirmation you got when you filed the original claim. Having the paper trail organized before the hearing is worth the hour it takes.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorI saved the confirmation email when I filed, so I have that. Payment history I'll pull from SDI Online.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Good. Also note the date you received the overpayment notice, separate from the date printed on it. Both can matter.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
Does filing the appeal stop any collection action on the overpayment?
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
The notice should tell you what happens during the appeal period. Generally submitting an appeal means EDD processes it through the hearing before collection moves forward, but your specific notice is the place to confirm that.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
Okay I'll check the notice itself.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
the 30-day part is what gets people. seen it on here before where someone missed it by a few days and had no recourse.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Yep. Date on the notice, not the date you got it in the mail. Count from there.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorMine says the 15th. I'm sending the appeal out Thursday.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
good, cutting it close but you got it
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Can a person file a correct care claim now, separately, even while the appeal on the overpayment is going? Or does the appeal have to resolve first?
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Filing a new claim and appealing the overpayment are separate actions. EDD handles them independently. If you're still within the 12-month period and you have weeks remaining, it's worth asking EDD directly how the two interact given your specific situation.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
That's what I figured, but good to hear they don't block each other. The 12-month window is the trickier part.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorThis is actually something I was wondering too. I may still have leave left to take for my mom.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
OP, once your appeal is filed just keep copies of literally everything. The hearing can be weeks out and you want to remember exactly what you submitted.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorKeeping a folder with every document, every date. I've learned my lesson on paperwork.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Good call. Even screenshot your SDI Online payment history before anything changes in the system anyway.
0 coins
Avery Saint
EDD overpayments are brutal but the appeal process exists for exactly this kind of situation. File it, state the facts, and wait. That's all you can do.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
AuthorYou're right. I've been spiraling all week but it comes down to filing the form and making the case clearly.
0 coins
LordCommander
Appeals take time but they do get decided. Put your facts on the form and let the process work.
0 coins