Back to California Paid Family Leave

Mei Chen

Driver license number already assigned to an account duplicate account PFL nightmare

So I'm losing my mind here. Tried to file my PFL bonding claim in SDI Online after my daughter was born three weeks ago and the system throws an error saying my driver license number is already assigned to an account. I have no idea what that means. I've never filed for PFL before, never had a disability claim, nothing. Created my myEDD login fresh last month when I figured I'd need it for leave. Now it won't let me move forward and I can't tell if there's some ghost account out there with my info or what. Has anyone hit this exact wall? Do I just mail in the paper DE 2501F to avoid the online mess, or is there a way to fix the duplicate account thing in SDI Online? The 41-day clock is ticking and I'm starting to sweat it anyway.

Around day four of trying to sort out my own SDI Online account issue, I got a DE 2514 denial notice in the mail and had no idea how to read it or what to do next. Phone line was dead air for me every morning I tried. I ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually got a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave on the line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my account and walked me through what the determination letter actually said, which weeks were denied and why, and told me I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal using the DE 1000A. I had no idea the clock was already running. Really glad I didn't just sit on that letter another week.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try that number before the Claimyr thing? I've hit it probably fifteen times across two weeks and the line just drops me after a couple minutes of hold music.

0 coins

Tried seven or eight mornings straight, same thing every time, gone before I ever got to anyone. The Claimyr situation just had my phone ring and an EDD agent was there, that was the whole thing. I know it sounds hard to believe but the person I talked to was clearly EDD, knew my claim details the second I gave my ID number.

0 coins

used it too tbh, agent told me my receipt number on the new account i made after the duplicate error, confirmed it was actually in the system. that was the thing i needed to know

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Wait so you also had the duplicate account problem and still ended up with a valid receipt number on a new one? That actually helps me feel like there might be a path forward here.

0 coins

The duplicate license number error usually means EDD's system already has a record tied to that ID, sometimes from an employer wage report or an old account someone barely started. The fix is not to file twice. Phone EDD's PFL line at 1-877-238-4373 and ask them to look at what account the number is attached to. They can sort it out on their end.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

So there's no way to resolve it myself inside myEDD? I have to call?

0 coins

Correct. The account merge or ID reassignment has to go through EDD. Nothing in myEDD lets you untangle that yourself.

0 coins

Does EDD need anything specific when you call, like documents or just your SSN and the driver license number?

0 coins

Your Social Security number, your driver license number, and the myEDD username you created. That's enough for them to pull both records up.

0 coins

My husband ran into something similar last year, not identical but EDD kept saying his SSN was in use already. Turned out he'd started an account ages ago and forgotten about it. EDD merged it over the phone and his bonding claim went through fine after. The 41-day deadline thing is real so don't wait too long to call.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Did they make him refile everything after the merge or did his progress carry over?

0 coins

His progress didn't carry over, he had to refile in the corrected account, but the rep confirmed the original filing date still counted for the deadline. So he wasn't penalized.

0 coins

Good to know the date counts. That's the part I'd worry about most.

0 coins

The 41-day window runs from the first day of your bonding leave, not from when the baby was born, so if you stayed home from day one those dates are the same. What matters is getting EDD on record that you filed within that window. If you have to refile after the account gets fixed, make sure to tell the agent the leave start date so they can note it.

0 coins

Wait, leave start date and birth date can be different? Like if someone went back to work for a few days first and then started leave?

0 coins

Yes, they can differ. The 41 days run from the day the leave actually started, so if you took a week before going back and then started leave formally, those dates diverge. EDD's own materials say the leave start date is what triggers the window.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

For me they're the same, I was home from day one. But still good to know.

0 coins

THREE WEEKS of trying to get through on that PFL phone line and I am not exaggerating. Try before 8, try at 8:01, try at lunch. Same result every single time. The duplicate account error sounds exactly like what happens when EDD's system has a wage record from your employer that created a shell profile before you ever logged in. You need a human at EDD to fix it and that is the fun part.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Yeah the calling part is what's killing me. How are people actually getting through?

0 coins

Honestly I never did crack the code on the regular line. Eventually used a third-party thing someone posted about elsewhere. Got a person in under an hour after weeks of nothing.

0 coins

Three weeks is brutal. Mine was two weeks of that before I just mailed the paper form and hoped for the best.

0 coins

Paper DE 2501F is a real option if the online system won't cooperate. Mail it certified so you have proof of the date it was sent. That date matters for your 41 days. Downside is you can't see the claim status in SDI Online the same way.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Is there a way to switch to online later after mailing? Or is it stuck on paper once you go that route?

0 coins

You'd have to ask EDD. I wouldn't assume you can switch mid-claim. Better to fix the account issue and file online if you can manage it in time.

0 coins

Went paper for my care claim and honestly it was fine, just slower. No real disasters, just more waiting.

0 coins

Proof of relationship was what hung up my bonding claim, EDD kept showing no document received even though I'd uploaded what I thought was the right thing. I ended up calling EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the file I uploaded wasn't reading as the birth certificate, it was something from the hospital but not the official vital records document. Got that sorted and resubmitted the right one.

0 coins

What exactly does Claimyr do? I've seen the name a few times but don't know what it actually is.

0 coins

It handles the hold time with EDD for you so when a live agent picks up, your phone rings instead of you having to stay on the line waiting. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh. I've got a question about whether the proof of relationship I already uploaded is actually showing as received. That would be worth a call for me.

0 coins

The birth certificate one is what EDD wants, the official one from vital records not the hospital keepsake copy.

0 coins

December 3rd was when I first got the duplicate license error on my account. By December 10th I had called EDD twice with no answer, and on December 14th I just mailed the DE 2501F certified. Got a Notice of Computation dated December 29th. So the paper route did work, just took a while.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Did the Notice of Computation show up before any payment, or did payment come first?

0 coins

Notice came first, about ten days before the first payment info showed up. The DE 429DF just tells you the weekly amount they calculated, not that you're approved.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't the approval? I thought getting that meant you were good to go.

0 coins

No, it's not approval. It's just the math on what you'd get if approved. The actual payment confirmation is a separate notice.

0 coins

Worth checking whether your employer filed wage reports under your SSN before you ever created a myEDD account. EDD's system can apparently generate a shell record from those reports, and when you try to register with your driver license number it conflicts with whatever record already exists. That would explain a 'duplicate' error even on a brand new account.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

That actually makes a lot of sense as an explanation. My employer is big, files everything electronically. Probably exactly what happened.

0 coins

Yeah if that's the case the fix is straightforward once you get EDD to look at both records. It's annoying but not a permanent block.

0 coins

My sister-in-law had this exact thing happen and she was so stressed about the 41 days! EDD fixed the account and the original date she tried to file actually counted. So don't panic about losing those days!

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Did she have to prove the original attempt somehow or did EDD just take her word for it?

0 coins

She had the error message she screenshotted and her myEDD account showed the date she created it, and the EDD rep used that to note the original attempt. So screenshot everything if you haven't!

0 coins

A payment came through on my care claim but the date it was supposed to cover didn't match what I expected at all, and I couldn't figure out from SDI Online which weeks had actually been paid. I tried Claimyr after three mornings of getting nowhere on the phone, and reached an EDD Paid Family Leave agent who went through my payment history and told me exactly which dates the payment covered and when the next one was due.

0 coins

I had a question about my Notice of Computation amount after my own call, the weekly figure looked lower than I expected. Called through Claimyr on that one and the agent told me the base period they used and what quarter had the highest wages, which is how they set the weekly number. Clear as day once a person explained it.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether you could dispute the base period they used?

0 coins

Agent said if I thought wages were missing I could send in my pay stubs and EDD would review. Didn't promise anything, just said that's the process.

0 coins

The payment date question was the main thing I needed answered and the agent had it right there. Helped me figure out I hadn't missed a payment, the schedule just runs differently than I assumed.

0 coins

Don't file twice trying to get around the error. I did that on a disability claim years ago and it caused a bigger mess than the original problem. One filing, then call EDD to fix the account. That's it.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Noted, I haven't refiled. I'm holding off until I can actually talk to someone at EDD. Good to hear from someone who learned that the hard way.

0 coins

Yeah don't repeat my mistake. The original error is an easy fix. Two filings is a whole new problem.

0 coins

the paper form is honestly less scary than it looks. filled it out for my bonding claim at like midnight, dropped it in a mailbox next morning. payment came through fine.

0 coins

Did you have to include the birth certificate with the paper form?

0 coins

yeah you attach the proof of relationship doc to the paper DE 2501F when you mail it, don't send it separately

0 coins

I'm about to file my own PFL bonding claim next week and now I'm terrified this will happen to me too. Is there any way to check before you file whether your driver license is already in the system somehow?

0 coins

No pre-check that I know of. Most people don't hit this error. If you do, the fix is a phone call to EDD. Try not to borrow trouble ahead of time.

0 coins

Okay that's fair. I'll just go for it and deal with it if the error shows up.

0 coins

Start the SDI Online process and see what happens. If it errors out, you still have the paper option and time to call.

0 coins

Fourteen days is what EDD gives itself to decide a claim once it's properly filed. If your account issue gets fixed and you file cleanly, the clock on that decision starts then. No waiting period for PFL, unlike disability.

0 coins

Wait PFL has no waiting period? I've been reading stuff that said there were seven unpaid days at the start.

0 coins

That's disability, not PFL. PFL has no waiting period at all. Different programs.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Good catch because I definitely had that confused in my head too.

0 coins

lol the SDI Online system is something else. filed a care claim for my dad last spring and got three different errors before it finally went through. the duplicate id one is frustrating but it usually sorts out once EDD looks at the backend

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Three different errors before it took? How long did that take you to get through?

0 coins

about two weeks of on and off trying plus one call to EDD. annoying but eventually fine. your situation sounds fixable.

0 coins

EDD's online system just isn't built for edge cases. The duplicate ID thing is basically a database conflict and there's no self-service fix. You call, they fix it, you refile if needed. That's the whole process.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

At this point I'm resigned to just having to call. Any tips on when the line is less impossible?

0 coins

Can't tell you there's a magic hour. I tried mornings, tried midday. All the same.

0 coins

The paper form is a real fallback. Don't forget it's there if you can't get through before the 41 days start to close in.

0 coins

If you do end up refiling in a corrected account, the proof of relationship you'll need as a dad is a birth certificate or a Declaration of Paternity, the CS-909 form, if the birth certificate isn't ready yet. Either one works.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Birth certificate should be ready, the county processes them pretty fast here. Good to know the CS-909 is a backup though.

0 coins

The CS-909 is the Declaration of Paternity and it's specifically for cases where paternity needs to be established or the birth certificate is delayed. Either one satisfies EDD's proof of relationship requirement for a bonding claim.

0 coins

Bonding leave is supposed to be a good time and instead you're debugging EDD's database. I feel that. Hope this gets resolved fast for you and you get some real time with the new baby before the 12-month window starts eating into it.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Ha, right? Three weeks in and I've spent more time on this than actually sleeping. Update coming once I get through to EDD.

0 coins

The 12-month window for bonding runs from the birth date and you have all eight weeks to use in that period whenever you need them, so at least that part is flexible!

0 coins

For anyone following along, the Notice of Computation (DE 429DF) is different from the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification (DE 2500E). The DE 429DF is just your estimated weekly amount. The DE 2500E is what tells you an actual payment is coming. I mixed these up and thought I'd been denied when I hadn't been.

0 coins

Oh that's exactly the kind of thing I would mix up. So getting the DE 429DF means nothing about approval one way or the other?

0 coins

Exactly right. It just means EDD ran the wage calculation. The actual eligibility decision comes separately.

0 coins

The DE 2514 is the denial notice, if that ever shows up. That one you act on fast because the appeal window is 30 days from the date on the notice.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Final update from me. Called EDD this morning after trying a few days in a row. Got through eventually, agent found two records tied to my driver license, one was an old shell account from my employer's wage filing. They flagged the old one and confirmed my new myEDD account is clean. Refile starting tonight and they noted the original attempt date. Stressful but it worked.

0 coins

So glad it worked out! Refile tonight and get that receipt number saved somewhere safe.

0 coins

Good outcome. Quick action before the 41 days mattered. Nice work.

0 coins

The shell account from employer wage reporting is exactly what I figured it was. Glad EDD could sort it on one call.

0 coins

Receipt number and filing date noted by EDD. You're in good shape from here.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure