Back to California Paid Family Leave

Dylan Mitchell

Does overpayment apply to SDI claim with private disability insurance alongside PFL?

So I've been going back and forth trying to figure this out and I can't find a straight answer anywhere. I work at a small marketing firm and my employer offers a private short-term disability policy on top of what we pay into California SDI. I filed a PFL bonding claim in SDI Online after my daughter was born in October, and then my HR told me the company's private plan would also kick in some money during my leave. Now I'm panicking because someone in my mom's group said that if you get paid from two sources at the same time EDD will come after you for an overpayment later. Is that actually true? Does overpayment apply to SDI claim with private disability insurance running at the same time as PFL? I don't want to end up owing EDD money I already spent on diapers and groceries.

About ten days into waiting for my Notice of Computation after I filed my own bonding claim, I had absolutely no idea what weekly amount EDD was calculating for me. The estimate on EDD's site pointed one direction, but the actual DE 429DF hadn't landed yet. I ended up reaching a live EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after the phone line cut me off three mornings in a row. The agent pulled up my claim and read me the weekly benefit amount right off the Notice of Computation, plus confirmed the date it had been mailed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Three mornings cut off is rough. I've had the same thing happen and I'm honestly not sure anything actually gets you to a person on that line. What made you think this would be different?

0 coins

Fair skepticism. The line had ended my call mid-menu four times before that. With Claimyr the phone rang on my end and an actual EDD staffer picked up, introduced herself by name, the whole thing. That's what was different.

0 coins

My own claim had a similar wait on the Notice of Computation. When I finally reached an agent she told me the exact date my payment was issued, which matched what arrived two days later. Knowing that specific date helped me stop guessing.

0 coins

Still waiting on my DE 429DF too, so this is reassuring to hear there's a way to get that information without just staring at SDI Online.

0 coins

PFL and a private disability policy aren't the same pot of money. EDD's concern is wages plus PFL going over your normal wages. A private plan is your employer's separate deal. Report what your employer pays you as wages if you're actually earning it, but the private policy itself isn't what EDD flags.

0 coins

So the private plan money doesn't automatically count as wages I have to report to EDD?

0 coins

Ask your HR how they're categorizing it. If they're calling it salary continuation that's wages. If it's a pure insurance benefit payout the rules can differ. EDD's the one who decides your claim, not the private insurer.

0 coins

HR is the right call here. The employer's private plan terms determine how that money is classified, and that classification matters to how you report to EDD.

0 coins

My cousin had almost this exact worry when she was on leave after her second baby, like she was convinced EDD was going to audit her whole life. What EDD actually cares about is whether you're working and getting wages at the same time as PFL, not what a separate insurance policy does.

0 coins

The wages piece is the key thing. EDD's rule is that wages you earn (not overtime) plus PFL can't exceed your normal weekly wages. Private insurance isn't wages in that sense.

0 coins

That framing helps a lot. So it's really about earned wages, not insurance payouts.

0 coins

Exactly, that's what I understood from reading into it too. Your HR and EDD are the two places to get the definitive word on your specific situation.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when my wife was on leave. The overpayment risk everybody talks about is usually from not reporting days you went back to work, not from having a separate insurance policy your employer already set up.

0 coins

Not reporting work days is what causes most overpayments I've read about on here. Did your wife end up reporting intermittent days at any point?

0 coins

She took the eight weeks straight so it wasn't an issue. But yeah, if you go back part time you have to report every day and EDD sends you a form to certify.

0 coins

The form they send is the DE 2580GF, the Continued Claim Certification. If you don't return it benefits stop, so it's the kind of mail you don't want to miss.

0 coins

EDD's overpayment notices do go out when people get paid for the same days they were collecting PFL and also collecting unemployment. Those two can't overlap. Private disability insurance is a totally different thing and I've never heard of EDD coming after someone just for that.

0 coins

yeah the pfl and unemployment overlap thing trips people up. you cant get both for the same days.

0 coins

Same with Disability Insurance. PFL doesn't pay for the same days DI pays. That's the overlap EDD watches.

0 coins

Good to know the overlap rule is specifically about EDD's own programs, not outside insurance.

0 coins

After my second PFL payment came in and I lost track of which weeks EDD had paid versus what was still pending, I tried the EDD phone line Tuesday and Wednesday morning with zero luck, so I tried Claimyr. The agent told me exactly which two weeks had been paid and confirmed when the next payment was due based on my claim. Really cleared up my mental spreadsheet.

0 coins

What's Claimyr? I've never heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on the EDD phone line in your place, and your phone rings once a live EDD agent is on the other end. That's the whole thing. No mystery.

0 coins

Might actually be useful then. I'd want to ask an agent about the proof of relationship on my bonding claim, the birth certificate went up two weeks ago and SDI Online still just says pending.

0 coins

Pending for two weeks on a bonding claim is normal, within the 14-day decision window EDD gives itself. If you hit day 15 without movement, a Request Claim Update in SDI Online is the next step.

0 coins

The PFL overpayment situations I've seen people describe on this forum almost always come down to one of three things: going back to work without telling EDD, collecting PFL and unemployment for the same days, or receiving PFL while also on Disability Insurance for the same period. A private employer disability policy isn't any of those.

0 coins

That breakdown is exactly what I needed. None of those three things apply to my situation.

0 coins

the DI and PFL overlap one is the sneaky one, new moms switching from pregnancy disability to bonding sometimes get a gap payment date wrong and EDD sends an overpayment notice, anyway the dates matter a lot.

0 coins

That transition from pregnancy disability to PFL bonding is genuinely tricky on dates. The new mother's DE 2501FP gets submitted within 41 days of the bonding start date, and the DI claim needs to end before PFL begins, they can't pay for the same day.

0 coins

Private insurance plan your employer bought has nothing to do with what you owe EDD. EDD issued you PFL. The insurance company issued you a benefit. Two separate entities.

0 coins

yeah exactly its not like edds tracking what your job does on the side

0 coins

still worth asking HR in writing so you have a record of how they're classifying it, just in case.

0 coins

I keep reading this thread trying to figure out if my situation is the same. I went back to work two days a week about five weeks into my bonding leave, I think I reported it right on the DE 2501F but I'm not sure if EDD processed it or if I'll get an overpayment notice later. Not sure how to check.

0 coins

If you answered yes to question A13 on the DE 2501F and listed your work days, EDD should have your schedule. The check is whether EDD sent you a Continued Claim Certification form, the DE 2580GF, to return. If they did and you returned it you're likely in good shape.

0 coins

I did answer yes to A13 but I don't remember getting the DE 2580GF in the mail. Should I be worried?

0 coins

Log into SDI Online and check your claim status and document history. If the certification form hasn't come, a Request Claim Update asking about intermittent reporting is a reasonable next step.

0 coins

Checking SDI Online first is the move. The form might be on its way, or the update request will get EDD's attention if something is stalled.

0 coins

my manager told me my company's STD policy would basically replace part of my paycheck and PFL would top up the rest, lol, and I was like okay but am I going to owe EDD money for the combo? took me a while to figure out that wasn't how it works.

0 coins

same energy honestly, i thought any money coming in during leave counted as wages and i was like panicking for a whole week

0 coins

right, the wages thing is specifically what you earn by working, not insurance benefits. once i got that distinction it made way more sense.

0 coins

The classic leave math confusion. So many people go through exactly this calculation in their heads and then realize EDD's rules are narrower than they feared.

0 coins

The good news is PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, so you're not losing a week unpaid on top of worrying about overpayments! When I found that out it was such a relief.

0 coins

wait really no waiting period? i thought there were seven unpaid days like with disability.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all, that's a DI thing. PFL starts paying from day one of your leave once EDD approves the claim.

0 coins

Correct. The seven-day waiting period is for Disability Insurance, not for PFL. EDD is clear on that distinction on their site.

0 coins

My DE 2500E showed up in SDI Online but the payment method still wasn't right because I'd set up direct deposit and it was still showing mailed check. Called EDD four times in one week, nothing. Tried Claimyr on day five and talked to an agent who confirmed my direct deposit info had actually been updated on their end and the first payment was processing to that account.

0 coins

ugh i got the same payment method situation sorted last month, i used Claimyr for it too and found out my eight weeks were still fully intact since i hadnt used any of them yet, agent confirmed that right on the call.

0 coins

How did you know when you asked the agent about the eight weeks whether that also covered care claims or just bonding?

0 coins

the agent said all eight weeks are shared across bonding care and military assist in one 12-month window, so if i used six weeks bonding id only have two left for a care claim that year, anyway that was really useful to hear directly.

0 coins

Worth knowing that the eight-week total is a combined limit, not eight weeks per type of claim. A lot of people assume they get separate buckets and that's not how it works.

0 coins

Someone above mentioned the pregnancy disability to PFL transition and I want to make sure I'm not accidentally in that situation. I'm not the birth mother, my partner is, and I filed a separate bonding claim as the other parent. We filed separately right? Or is that wrong?

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim. Your partner's pregnancy disability claim is entirely hers, and your bonding claim through SDI Online is yours alone. The two don't interfere with each other.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. So I uploaded a proof of relationship, which for me was the birth certificate, and she files her DE 2501FP when her disability period ends?

0 coins

Exactly right. The DE 2501FP is the new mother's form for bonding after a pregnancy disability claim, no extra documents needed with it. Your birth certificate upload for the standard bonding claim is the correct path for a non-birth parent.

0 coins

yeah we did it this way when our second was born, two totally separate claims, different payment timelines and everything, anyway it works fine.

0 coins

Around three weeks into my intermittent leave I tried Claimyr to ask about the DE 2580GF because I hadn't received it and was scared my benefits would just stop. The agent looked at my claim and said EDD had my DE 2501F with A13 answered correctly and the DE 2580GF had been mailed on a specific date, so I knew to watch for it.

0 coins

Claimyr just sounds like a paid-to-move-up-the-line thing to me. How is that any different from the hold-and-hope approach most of us use?

0 coins

I had the same read on it, figured it was just marketing for something that didn't work. Used it anyway after three weeks of mornings where the line disconnected me before I hit the queue. The agent picked up and confirmed my claim's start date and that my 41-day filing window had been received within deadline. That answer, in real time, was what I needed.

0 coins

Okay that's more useful than I expected. I might try it for the pending status question I've had going on ten days.

0 coins

Knowing the specific mailing date for my DE 2580GF meant I could stop obsessing over the mailbox for the first few days. Having a date to aim at made a real difference.

0 coins

If you end up with an overpayment notice for any reason, you can appeal it. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and you have 30 days from the notice. Not saying you will, just good to know the process exists.

0 coins

That's a relief to know there's a formal process rather than just owing money with no recourse.

0 coins

The 30-day window on appeals is tight, so if a notice arrives, don't sit on it. You can appeal online or mail the DE 1000A.

0 coins

my job has a supplemental plan too and i just asked hr directly, they told me straight up it wasnt wages so i didnt report it to edd. no overpayment notice ever came.

0 coins

That's the right move. Get it in writing from HR and keep it. If EDD ever asked you'd have the answer.

0 coins

yeah i should probably have asked for it in writing honestly, just did it over slack lol.

0 coins

Sick leave and vacation can be combined with PFL but wages plus PFL can't exceed your regular weekly wages. That's the ceiling EDD uses. A private insurer's benefit isn't wages, so it doesn't stack against that ceiling the same way.

0 coins

the sick leave combo thing is what got my coworker, her employer paid out sick leave at the same time and her PFL got reduced.

0 coins

Right, the employer's policy on combining paid time off with PFL varies. The EDD piece is about wages, the employer piece is their own policy. Both matter but they're separate questions.

0 coins

Asking HR to put in writing how they handle the PTO and PFL combination is the same kind of documentation that protects you later.

0 coins

PFL also doesn't protect your job on its own, worth flagging since you're a few weeks in. The benefit payments come from EDD but job protection is a CFRA question you'd raise with your employer. Just want to make sure you know they're different.

0 coins

I actually didn't know those were separated out. So PFL pays me but doesn't guarantee my job is there when I come back?

0 coins

PFL is the payment side only. Whether your job is protected depends on CFRA or other laws, which is an HR conversation. EDD handles the PFL claim, your employer's HR handles the leave side.

0 coins

EDD itself states that PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. For the job protection question, your employer's HR or the Civil Rights Department's CFRA page is the right resource.

0 coins

You reported everything correctly, you're not going back to work, the private plan is your employer's arrangement. I'd stop worrying about an overpayment that hasn't happened and isn't likely to.

0 coins

Honestly this thread has completely settled my nerves. Thank you all.

0 coins

EDD sends overpayment notices when people earn wages they didn't report. You haven't done that.

0 coins

For anyone else reading and panicking about the same thing, the EDD benefits calculator at edd.ca.gov can help you check your estimated weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives, so at least you have a ballpark while you wait!

0 coins

The calculator is useful but the actual number is whatever lands on the DE 429DF. Mine was slightly different from the estimate, so the notice is the one to file away.

0 coins

Totally, the notice is the real number. The calculator is just so you're not completely in the dark for two weeks while EDD decides.

0 coins

Also just to close the loop for future searchers: if you're worried about overpayment and you filed correctly and you're not working while claiming, the main thing to watch is reporting any days you do go back. That's where most overpayment situations start.

0 coins

yeah report every day back at work, even one day, dont assume edd wont notice.

0 coins

Exactly. Each day worked is one seventh of your weekly benefit amount that EDD adjusts. Miss reporting a day and that becomes a potential overpayment for that exact amount.

0 coins

the form comes automatically after you report you went back part time, its the DE 2580GF, return it on time or benefits stop

0 coins

Bottom line on this whole thread: private disability insurance your employer bought is not EDD's money. EDD tracks its own payments. Unless you're working and not telling EDD, an overpayment from PFL overlapping with your employer's private plan isn't a real risk.

0 coins

That's the clearest version of the answer I've read in this whole thread. Saving that.

0 coins

Agreed. That's the short version of everything said above.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure