Does amending W2 for missing CASDI contributions affect paid family leave claim
So I've been going through kind of a stressful situation and want to make sure I'm not about to blow up my PFL claim before it even gets reviewed. Background: I work for a small landscaping company and when I checked my W2 from last year I noticed the CASDI withholding box was blank, like zero. My wife just had our second kid and I filed a PFL bonding claim on SDI Online last week. Now I'm realizing my employer may have just never withheld the SDI contributions properly. My tax person says I need to amend the W2 to show the actual CASDI that should have been taken out. My question is whether that amendment process is going to mess with my pending bonding claim or delay it somehow. I'm already stressed about the gap in income with the new baby and can't afford to wait months for this to shake out. Anyone dealt with something like this?
83 comments

Logan Scott
DE 2500E on my claim took longer than I expected because I had a wage question too. Tried the PFL line for three days straight before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got an agent on the phone. She pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued and that my first payment was processing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Chloe Green
four days of that line ending with a recording and you're telling me you got through? I've tried before 8, right at 8, midday. nothing ever connects. what actually happened when you used it
0 coins
Logan Scott
it sat on hold with EDD in my place and my phone rang when an actual EDD agent picked up. thats it. the agent was real, she worked there, confirmed my DE 2500E was issued and gave me the payment date
0 coins
Lucas Adams
Had a similar wage question on my bonding claim. After reading that the agent confirmed the DE 2500E was out, I tried the same approach and got through too. Agent checked my claim's start date and confirmed it was within the 41-day window, so my filing date held.
0 coins
Harper Hill
The CASDI question is worth sorting out carefully. EDD requires at least $300 in base period wages with SDI withheld to qualify for PFL. If your W2 showed zero CASDI and your employer actually failed to withhold it, EDD has a process for that. You'd want to contact them directly to explain the employer error rather than waiting for an amended W2 to work its way through.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorSo EDD has seen this kind of thing before? I wasn't sure if this would just automatically disqualify me or if there's a way to explain it.
0 coins
Harper Hill
Employer withholding errors do come up. EDD looks at whether the wages were actually SDI-covered and whether the contributions should have been made. The amended W2 showing the CASDI helps, but reaching EDD to flag the situation on your active claim is the more direct path.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
wait does this mean if my employer never took out CASDI I might not qualify for PFL at all? I've been assuming I was fine because I've worked there two years
0 coins
Avery Flores
To answer the question directly: an amended W2 that adds the CASDI line doesn't automatically delay your PFL claim, but it also won't fix it on its own. EDD bases eligibility on the wages in your base period and whether SDI was withheld. If your employer should have been withholding and didn't, the amendment shows the correction, but EDD still needs to verify it on their end before they can confirm you meet the $300 threshold.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorMakes sense. So the amendment is step one but I still have to actually loop EDD in on what happened.
0 coins
Avery Flores
Exactly. The amendment documents the employer error. EDD decides eligibility from there. Getting something in writing from your employer acknowledging the withholding mistake can also help when you explain it to EDD.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
my employer messed up my CASDI once too. EDD had me provide documentation. took a bit but it worked out
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Okay so I went through something kind of adjacent to this. My employer switched payroll companies mid-year and there was a whole mess with my SDI withholding showing up wrong on my W2. What helped me was calling EDD early before my claim was decided rather than waiting to see if it got denied first. If you catch it early they can note it on the file.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorThat's what I keep going back and forth on, do I call now or wait to see if they just figure it out. Sounds like calling first is smarter.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
100% call first. Waiting and then appealing a denial is so much more stressful than just flagging it upfront. At least that was my experience.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
I'm not sure though, like what if calling draws attention to the problem and they deny it faster? I know that probably sounds paranoid but I've heard stories
0 coins
Ashley Adams
I get the worry but EDD is going to review the base period wages regardless. Calling just lets you explain the employer error in context instead of letting EDD reach a conclusion without that info.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
August 14th was the date my W2 issue surfaced, two weeks after I filed my care claim. The base period they look at is the highest quarter of wages going back 5 to 18 months before the claim start. If the CASDI line was blank for that whole period that's the problem. If it only missed one quarter the math might still work out depending on where your wages fall.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorGood point. It's actually only the most recent quarter where the withholding looks wrong. The prior quarters seem to have CASDI on them. So I might still clear the $300 threshold from those.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
If the prior quarters show CASDI withheld and those fall in your base period, you're likely fine on the $300 minimum. The pending claim should process off those wages. The amended W2 is still worth filing to fix the record but it may not hold up your bonding claim at all.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
that's actually a big relief to hear framed that way. the base period piece is what trips most people up
0 coins
Michael Adams
edd doesnt always catch W2 discrepancies right away anyway, my bonding claim processed before any of my wage stuff was fully sorted. probably depends on how obvious the issue is in their system
0 coins
Logan Scott
thats risky to count on tho. if they catch it after and decide you didnt qualify that could mean an overpayment situation
0 coins
Michael Adams
fair point yeah. better to just deal with it upfront
0 coins
Natalie Wang
Went back part time after my bonding leave and those intermittent weeks got complicated fast. Tried the PFL line a bunch of mornings with nothing to show for it, then used Claimyr and got an actual EDD agent on the phone. He found my DE 2580GF on file and confirmed which weeks I'd reported correctly and which ones were still pending, saved me from guessing.
0 coins
Noah Torres
what is Claimyr
0 coins
Natalie Wang
you give it your info and it waits on hold with EDD while you go do something else. your phone rings when a person at EDD picks up. that's the whole thing.
0 coins
Noah Torres
hm. I've got a question about which of my intermittent days actually got reported right. might try it for that
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
Sorry to jump in but I'm confused about something related. I thought PFL had a waiting period like the first week is unpaid. My coworker told me that. Is that true or did she mean something else?
0 coins
Harper Hill
PFL doesn't have a waiting period. EDD is clear on that. Your coworker is probably thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have an unpaid period at the start. PFL benefits can begin from the first day you're eligible.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
oh wow okay so I've been budgeting wrong this whole time. that actually helps a lot thank you
0 coins
Avery Flores
Really common mix-up. DI and PFL are both under SDI but they have different rules. The waiting period is DI only.
0 coins
Chloe Green
EDD's phone line is a whole other kind of pain. I've called at every hour those people suggest and it doesn't matter. The W2 thing the original poster is describing would stress me out too because you'd really need to talk to a human at EDD to explain employer error situations like that.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorYeah exactly. I feel like this is not a situation I can just leave in a message or a form. I need someone to actually look at my claim and understand what happened with my employer.
0 coins
Chloe Green
and that's exactly the problem right. the online form doesn't let you explain nuance. it's a checkbox and a text box and hope for the best
0 coins
Samantha Hall
Have you tried the Request Claim Update in SDI Online? It's not as good as a phone call but you can at least describe the situation in writing and have it attached to your claim ID!
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorI did submit a Request Claim Update already but I'm not confident it captured the full picture. Thinking I need the actual call.
0 coins
Ryan Young
Employer forgot to withhold CASDI, employee files PFL, EDD finds the gap. It happens more than people think at small companies. The employer is technically the one who owes the contributions, not you.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorWait, so the liability for the missing withholding falls on the employer, not on me personally? That changes how I've been thinking about this.
0 coins
Ryan Young
That's right. If your employer failed to withhold and remit SDI contributions when they were supposed to, that's the employer's problem to fix with EDD, not yours. You still need to show the wages and that they should have been SDI-covered.
0 coins
Harper Hill
That's an important distinction. The employee isn't penalized for an employer withholding error when the wages themselves were SDI-covered.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
my manager made the same mistake for like half a year and i had to get HR involved to send EDD a letter explaining it. that letter was what finally moved my claim along lol
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorHR letter explaining the employer error, got it. Did EDD ask you for it or did you just send it proactively?
0 coins
Sophia Clark
I sent it proactively with the amended W2. EDD didn't specifically ask but I figured the more documentation the better and it seemed to help
0 coins
Ashley Adams
that proactive approach makes so much sense for employer error situations. don't wait for EDD to ask, just explain it up front with whatever documentation you have
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
I've been reading all of this and now I'm kind of scared. My W2 shows CASDI withheld but what if the amount is wrong, like not enough taken out. Does the amount have to be a specific number or just any amount above zero?
0 coins
Aaron Lee
The minimum to qualify for PFL is $300 in base period wages with SDI withheld. The specific dollar amount of withholding on the W2 itself isn't what EDD checks against a formula, it's whether the wages were covered and the threshold is met.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
okay so as long as my wages hit that and there was some CASDI taken out I should be okay? that's a bit of a relief, I was spiraling a little
0 coins
Harper Hill
If your W2 shows CASDI withheld and your base period wages meet the threshold, you're in the normal review process. The situation the original poster has is specifically about zero CASDI showing, which is a different issue.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination came in for a client I was helping and it was a denial tied to a wage discrepancy. I tried the PFL line myself that afternoon but the line cut out after twenty minutes of hold. Used Claimyr to get through on a second try and an EDD agent confirmed the DE 2514 had been issued because the base period wages showed no SDI withheld. The agent said to appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A and to submit the corrected wage documentation with the appeal.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
Got a DE 2514 on my own care claim last month and also ended up talking to an agent. They told me my payments had been set up on debit card but I could switch to direct deposit through SDI Online. Took care of it right there.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
Wait, you can change from debit card to direct deposit after the claim is already set up? I didn't know that was an option!
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
Agent confirmed it, yeah. You just log into SDI Online and update the payment method. Easy enough once I knew it was possible.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
The 41-day filing rule is worth flagging here too. PFL bonding claims need to be filed no later than 41 days after the leave starts. If the wage question causes EDD to reach out for more information and that back-and-forth stretches things out, it's good to know your filing date is already locked in. The 41 days is about filing, not about when EDD finishes reviewing it.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorI filed on day 7 so the 41-day piece I'm good on. Good to know the review timeline after that is separate.
0 coins
Avery Flores
Right, the receipt number from SDI Online is proof you filed on time. Keep that. Everything after that is EDD's review process and the employer documentation you're pulling together.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Employer contribution errors come up in clinical settings too with agency staff. The key piece is documentation: amended W2, employer letter, any payroll records that show the wages were SDI-covered work. Get those organized before you call EDD.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorPractical checklist, appreciate that. I've got the original W2, I'm waiting on the amended one, and I'll ask my employer to put the error in writing.
0 coins
Madison Allen
That's the right order. The employer letter explaining the withholding mistake is often what moves it.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
been dealing with this exact thing for three weeks. my w2 had casdi blank for two quarters. still pending
0 coins
Aaron Lee
Two quarters with no CASDI is trickier than one. If your other quarters in the base period show withholding and enough wages, those might carry it. Worth getting EDD on the phone to find out exactly which quarters they're looking at.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
yeah haven't been able to get through. might try submitting through ask edd in the meantime
0 coins
Noah Torres
Sounds like the amendment is the right move but I wouldn't expect it to speed anything up. EDD runs on its own schedule with these things.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorYeah I'm trying to be realistic about the timeline. Just don't want the amendment to actively make things worse.
0 coins
Ryan Young
It won't. Correcting the record is always better than leaving an error on file, even if the timing feels uncertain.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
Eight weeks of PFL to bond with a new baby is such a good benefit when it works right! Hope the employer fix gets sorted quickly so you can actually enjoy some of that time without the financial stress hanging over you.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorThat's the goal. Baby is here, just need the income piece to follow.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
rooting for a smooth resolution
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
One thing I've seen trip people up: if EDD sends a Notice asking for more information about the wages and you miss it or respond late, that can stall the claim more than the original issue. Watch your mail and check SDI Online regularly while this is pending.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorChecking SDI Online every couple days already. I'll make sure my mailing address is current too, good call.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
does edd mail notices to the address on your SDI Online account or somewhere else? I want to make sure mine are going to the right place
0 coins
Lucas Adams
The address in your myEDD profile is what EDD uses for mailed notices. Worth logging in to confirm it matches where you actually live.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Honestly the new baby plus a wage documentation issue at the same time sounds exhausting. At least you found out before EDD sent a denial rather than after.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorFor real. Catching it now means I can try to get ahead of it. If I'd waited for a denial letter and then had to figure out the appeal process with a newborn at home that would have been so much worse.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
appeals with a newborn, that sounds like a nightmare. glad you're on it now
0 coins
Michael Adams
did your employer know they werent taking out casdi or did they just not know what they were doing
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorHonestly I think it was just ignorance. Small operation, owner does their own bookkeeping, probably set up payroll wrong from the start. No bad intent but still a problem for me.
0 coins
Michael Adams
yeah small companies are bad for this. ive seen coworkers get burned by the same thing
0 coins
Natalie Wang
New payroll software or a one-man-band owner who doesn't know the SDI rules. Happens all the time on small crews. Not an excuse but it's rarely intentional.
0 coins
Avery Flores
To close the loop on the original question: amending the W2 to show the correct CASDI contributions is the right move and shouldn't hurt your pending bonding claim. It could only help by giving EDD accurate information. The claim doesn't reset or restart because of a corrected W2. What matters is that you also communicate with EDD directly so they know the context behind the correction.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorThis is exactly the summary I needed. Amend the W2, get the employer letter, loop in EDD proactively, watch for notices. I think I have a plan now.
0 coins
Harper Hill
That's a solid approach. Keep records of everything you submit and when. If EDD issues a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination and you disagree with it, you have 30 days to appeal using the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Mila Walker
AuthorNoted on the DE 1000A and the 30-day window. Really appreciate everyone here, this thread answered questions I didn't even know I had going in.
0 coins