Back to California Paid Family Leave

Madeline Blaze

Does a new disability claim after PFL affect benefit amount?

So I took PFL to bond with our second kid earlier this year, used about five of the eight weeks. Now my wife is dealing with something serious health-wise and I'm going to need to file a care claim to take her to appointments and be home with her. Someone at work mentioned that because I already used PFL this year, a new care claim might pay me less or recalculate my benefit amount based on different wages. Is that actually true? Does a new disability claim after PFL affect benefit amount, or does the second claim just use the same weekly benefit I already got? I'm trying to figure out what to expect before I file anyway.

Payment method on my own care claim tripped me up last spring, so I actually ended up phoning EDD directly. The hold times beat me every morning for over a week, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to a live person on the PFL line without sitting on hold myself. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent confirmed my payment was set for direct deposit and that the banking information I'd entered in SDI Online had been received correctly, which was the one thing I couldn't tell from the status screen. I did want to mention for the original question: the agent also said each claim's weekly benefit comes from whatever wages are in that claim's own base period, so a care claim filed later in the year may well pull from a different set of quarters than the bonding claim did.

0 coins

Four mornings I tried that line before 8:05 and got the recorded message every time. Hard to picture getting through to anyone. What actually happened when you used it, did you just hand over your information and wait?

0 coins

Entered the claim details on their site and my phone rang when an agent picked up. The agent was EDD's own staff, not Claimyr. That's really the whole of it.

0 coins

DE 2514 came in my mail after my care claim was denied last year. I had wondered whether to appeal and tried to get someone on the phone to explain my options. After reading that it was hopeless to reach anyone, I gave Claimyr a shot anyway. The agent confirmed the DE 2514 was a denial with an appeal option, that I had 30 days from the date on the letter, and pointed me to the DE 1000A form. Ended up filing the appeal in time.

0 coins

30 days from the letter date, that's the window. Good to know the form is the DE 1000A. I'll keep that in mind if I ever get a denial.

0 coins

Base period is really the key thing here. Each new PFL claim draws from the base period for that claim's start date, which is roughly five to eighteen months back. If your care claim starts several months after your bonding claim did, the quarters EDD looks at will shift, and your weekly benefit could be higher or lower depending on what you earned in those quarters. The EDD site has a calculator that'll give you an estimate once you pick your care claim start date.

0 coins

That actually makes sense. My hours were different earlier this year so I'm a little nervous the care claim might pull from leaner quarters. Guess I'll run the calculator.

0 coins

Calculator on EDD's site really does help with that. Put in a few different start dates and see how the number moves.

0 coins

Wait, does that mean if I start the care claim sooner rather than later my benefit could actually be higher? Or is it just completely unpredictable until you check?

0 coins

It depends entirely on when your higher-earning quarters fall relative to each start date. Try the calculator with two or three different start dates and compare the estimates. The real number will be on your Notice of Computation once EDD processes the claim.

0 coins

They're separate claims, not one big bucket. Bonding is bonding. Care is care. The dollar amount on each one is its own calculation.

0 coins

Okay that's clearer than anything I'd read. Thank you.

0 coins

Separate calculations, yes. But the eight weeks isn't separate. Used five bonding, only three left for care in those same twelve months.

0 coins

Right, the weeks pool together. The money amount is separate. Good catch.

0 coins

Spent three days hitting redial before my care claim got sorted. EDD's phone situation is genuinely one of the more maddening things I've dealt with. For what it's worth on the actual question: my weekly benefit on the care claim was different from my PFL bonding amount because my second quarter had stronger wages. Annoying that I had to call at all to find out the claim was just sitting there waiting on a form.

0 coins

Three days sounds about right. I gave up after that too.

0 coins

The thing that got me was that SDI Online didn't tell me what was missing. Just said pending.

0 coins

Pending forever until it isn't. Classic EDD experience.

0 coins

Receipt number on my bonding claim never showed up in my email like I expected, and I honestly wasn't sure if EDD had gotten the claim at all. I'd been trying to phone the PFL line for days, couldn't get through, so I went with Claimyr to reach someone. The agent pulled up my claim and read me the receipt number right there, confirmed it was in the system and that the birth certificate had been received.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? I've seen it mentioned but don't know what it does.

0 coins

You put in your info on their site and they handle staying on the line with EDD. When a live agent picks up, your phone rings and you're the one who talks to them. That's really it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. I'd want to ask about my own bonding claim, specifically whether the proof of relationship document I uploaded has been matched to my file. That's been the thing keeping me up at night.

0 coins

Birth certificate question is a common one. Hopefully it's already matched and you just can't see it in SDI Online yet.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth understanding before the second claim starts. It shows the potential weekly benefit amount for that specific claim. It is not an approval, just the number EDD calculated from your base period wages. You'll get a new one for the care claim, and comparing the two tells you exactly how the base periods differed.

0 coins

Didn't realize I'd get a whole new Notice of Computation for the care claim. Good to know what to watch for in the mail.

0 coins

Mine came within the first week after I filed the care claim. Yours may land at a different time, but that's when I saw it.

0 coins

Is the Notice of Computation the approval letter? I keep seeing it mentioned and I'm not totally sure what it means for whether I'll actually get paid.

0 coins

It is not an approval. The Notice of Computation just shows the potential weekly benefit amount based on wages. Approval or denial comes separately, either through payments starting or through a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination if there's an issue.

0 coins

My sister went through almost this exact thing last year, bonding first and then a care claim a few months later for their dad. Her weekly benefit on the care claim was actually a little higher because she'd gotten a raise and those wages landed in the base period for the second claim. So it really does depend on your own wage history.

0 coins

That's encouraging. I actually got a small raise mid-year so maybe the care claim base period catches some of that.

0 coins

Run the calculator on EDD's site with your care claim start date and you'll get a rough idea before you even file.

0 coins

Eight weeks is eight weeks total. Bonding and care both pull from it. Used five bonding, you've got three left in those twelve months. That's the one limit that actually matters day to day.

0 coins

So it's definitely not eight weeks each. I had half-wondered if they reset.

0 coins

They don't reset. One pool, twelve months from the first claim's start.

0 coins

yeah had no idea it was combined, thought i had a fresh eight weeks when i filed my care claim and then found out nope

0 coins

Lot of people assume that. One pool for all three claim types in a year.

0 coins

Something my coworker got wrong was thinking PFL has a waiting period like disability does. She was budgeting for seven unpaid days and panicking about rent. PFL has no waiting period at all, so the first day of leave can be a paid day if EDD approves it.

0 coins

Wait, PFL doesn't have the seven-day wait? I had completely read that wrong. That's a relief.

0 coins

No waiting period for PFL. The seven days is disability insurance for a worker's own condition. Different program, different rules.

0 coins

I'm glad that came up. I had the same mix-up in my head when I filed for bonding and then was surprised when payment started without the gap I expected.

0 coins

The confusion makes sense because disability and PFL are under the same SDI umbrella. Easy to blur the rules.

0 coins

Filing the care claim: in SDI Online you complete sections one through five, then Part C goes to the care recipient by mail and Part D goes to the physician. The doctor can submit Part D in SDI Online using your receipt number. Both need to reach EDD within 41 days of the day your leave starts. Missing that window is how claims get delayed.

0 coins

Part D can go in through SDI Online? I was thinking the doctor's office had to mail it. That's easier to push them on.

0 coins

They can mail it or submit it in SDI Online with your receipt number. Give the office both options and whichever they prefer.

0 coins

My wife's oncologist mailed Part D and it still got there within the 41 days. Just make sure you give the office your receipt number either way so EDD can match the form to your file.

0 coins

Is the receipt number the same one from when I first filed, or does a care claim have its own separate one?

0 coins

Each claim filed in SDI Online gets its own receipt number on the confirmation page. Save it and give it to the doctor's office.

0 coins

DE 429DF for my PFL care claim came in the mail showing a weekly benefit amount a bit different from what my bonding claim had shown. Different base period, different wages in those quarters. That matched what people here are saying.

0 coins

Just to be clear I'm talking about the Notice of Computation. Not an approval, just the calculated amount. EDD still had to decide eligibility after.

0 coins

Different quarters, different amount. That's the whole answer to the original question right there in one real example.

0 coins

DE 429DF was the one thing I couldn't find any info on in my SDI Online status screen when my care claim was processing. Tried phoning a few times, couldn't get through. Ended up using Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line. Agent told me the Notice of Computation had been generated and mailed on a specific date, so I knew to watch for it rather than wonder if something had gone wrong with the claim.

0 coins

Got through to EDD with Claimyr on my bonding claim too. The agent told me Part D from my mom's doctor had come in and been matched to my file, which was the one thing SDI Online wasn't showing me clearly. Had been going back and forth with the doctor's office for days thinking the form was lost.

0 coins

Part D matched but not visible in SDI Online, that's exactly the kind of thing you'd have no way to know otherwise.

0 coins

Right, the agent just read me what was in the system. Form received, date it came in, matched to my claim ID. That was enough to stop worrying about it.

0 coins

Line never connected for me once. How many tries before you switched to Claimyr?

0 coins

PFL doesn't pay if you're also receiving unemployment for the same days. Worth knowing if any work situation changes while you're on care leave.

0 coins

Not in that situation, but good to have the reminder. One benefit at a time.

0 coins

EDD catches it. Best not to try to collect both.

0 coins

My benefit estimate from the EDD calculator was pretty close to what actually showed on my Notice of Computation! It's not exact because EDD uses your actual wage records, but it gave me a good ballpark before I filed.

0 coins

Running it now for the care claim start date I'm thinking about. Already seeing a small difference from what my bonding claim showed, which at least means the calculator is doing something.

0 coins

Try a couple of different start dates if you have flexibility. Even a week or two can shift which quarter lands in the base period.

0 coins

my care claim took about twelve days from filing to get the notice in the mail. sat pending in sdi online the whole time with nothing changing so i just waited it out

0 coins

Twelve days pending is honestly reassuring to hear. I'll give it at least that before I start worrying.

0 coins

yeah 14 days is the window they give themselves to decide so as long as youre under that its probably just moving through the process

0 coins

Intermittent days are worth reading up on if you're not taking the care leave all at once. You report work and wages, EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form, and you send it back or the payments stop. Easy to miss if you're just assuming it keeps going automatically.

0 coins

I'll probably be taking some days here and there while also working part time, so this is exactly what I need to know. The form is the DE 2580GF, right?

0 coins

That's the one. Keep an eye out for it in the mail, fill it out, send it back. Missing it is the main way people accidentally interrupt their payments.

0 coins

Does EDD email you when the Continued Claim Certification is coming, or just mail it?

0 coins

It comes in the mail. No email notification from EDD on that one, so just check your mailbox.

0 coins

Not reporting wages while on intermittent PFL is how overpayments happen. EDD finds out eventually and sends a notice. Not worth it, just report everything even if it feels like a small amount.

0 coins

Good warning. Even overtime is excluded from the reporting interaction I think?

0 coins

Overtime is actually excluded from the wage comparison. What they compare is your regular wages plus PFL to your normal wages, not counting overtime. So report everything, but overtime doesn't get stacked against you in the same way.

0 coins

Either way, report it. Let EDD do the math rather than leaving anything out.

0 coins

Appeals are 30 days from the date on the determination letter. Miss that and you've got a harder road. Keep the envelope so you know when it was mailed, not just when you got it.

0 coins

Haven't gotten any denial notices, hoping it stays that way, but keeping that in the back of my mind.

0 coins

The form is the DE 1000A, mentioned on the denial letter itself. Easy to find if you need it.

0 coins

Direct deposit in SDI Online is the fastest payment method. Debit card or check takes longer. If you haven't set it up yet for the care claim, do it when you file.

0 coins

Set it up for the bonding claim already. Assuming it carries over but I'll double check in SDI Online when I file the care claim.

0 coins

New claim sometimes needs you to confirm it again. Worth checking rather than assuming.

0 coins

Confirmed this with my own care claim. Had direct deposit from a prior bonding claim but had to verify it again in SDI Online for the care claim. Took two minutes.

0 coins

Can both parents file PFL care claims for the same person at the same time? Or does only one person get to file?

0 coins

Two different people can each file their own PFL care claim for the same family member. Each claim is calculated on the filer's own wages and their own eight-week pool for the year. They just can't collect for the same days if they're not both actually providing care.

0 coins

Okay so my spouse and I could potentially each have a care claim for one of my parents. That's good to know in case we're both needed at different times.

0 coins

Each of you files your own claim, each uses your own base period. EDD handles them independently.

0 coins

Sick leave stacking is something I had to ask HR about, not EDD. EDD handles the PFL side and your employer handles how their own paid time off layers on top. The cap is that your combined wages and PFL can't exceed your normal weekly pay, but how your job gets you to that point is their policy.

0 coins

HR conversation is on my list. Good to know the ceiling is normal weekly pay so I can at least set an expectation going in.

0 coins

Every employer's policy is different too. Mine let me use vacation to top up PFL to 100 percent of my wages, but my coworker's job didn't offer that at all.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure