Back to California Paid Family Leave

Logan Chiang

Does PFL apply if employer has private disability plan

So my company offers a Voluntary Plan for disability through a private insurer instead of the state SDI. I just found out I'm pregnant and started looking into what leave benefits I'd actually have. Someone in HR mentioned it might affect my PFL eligibility and now I'm spiraling a little. Does PFL apply if employer has private disability plan or am I just out of luck for the bonding part after the baby comes? I have CASDI on my paystubs so I assumed I was covered for everything but now I'm not sure what that even means under a private plan. Has anyone dealt with this?

The CASDI deduction on your paystub is the key thing to look at. My daughter-in-law had almost this exact situation at her company last year. What matters for PFL eligibility is that you have at least $300 in wages with that SDI withholding in your base period. PFL is administered by California EDD regardless of whether your employer uses a state plan or a voluntary private plan for disability, but the interaction between the two does depend on the specifics. I'd recommend calling EDD's PFL line at 1-877-238-4373 to ask how your plan type affects your bonding claim specifically.

0 coins

So the CASDI on my check means I'm contributing to state SDI even under the private plan? That's what I couldn't figure out from the HR paperwork.

0 coins

Exactly. If CASDI appears on your paystub, withholding is going to state SDI, and that's what funds PFL. Your employer's voluntary disability plan is a separate thing. EDD can confirm how yours is set up.

0 coins

HR told me to email them but honestly I think calling EDD directly is smarter for the PFL question. Thank you.

0 coins

Voluntary plans cover the disability part, same as state SDI does for a pregnancy. PFL bonding is still a California EDD program. Had a guy on my crew ask me the same thing two summers ago. His wife had the private plan through her work, still filed for PFL bonding with EDD and got approved.

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear from someone who actually saw it happen. Did he say anything about whether her paystub had CASDI on it?

0 coins

He didn't go into the paystub details with me. I just know EDD paid the bonding claim. Tell your HR you need to know if CASDI is withheld, that's the real answer you need.

0 coins

DE 2500E came through on my bonding claim about ten days after I filed, which was the first real confirmation I had that payment was actually coming. Filed through SDI Online, had CASDI on every check. My company also uses a private insurer for the disability side. For the bonding PFL piece, EDD handled it completely on their own. When the DE 2500E was slow I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach an EDD agent and they pulled up the claim and confirmed the first payment date right on the call. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's PFL line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Knowing that date helped me plan the first two weeks home.

0 coins

Honestly that Claimyr thing reads like a sponsored post to me. How would some third party even get through when I've been redialing that 877 number since 7 in the morning and it just tells me to try later?

0 coins

I thought the exact same thing when I first saw it mentioned somewhere, like there's no way. But I was two weeks in on my own bonding claim and desperate, so I tried it. Ended up talking to an actual EDD agent who looked at my claim and told me the 41-day window for my leave start date and confirmed I was still within it. The agent absolutely worked for EDD. I was skeptical until that moment.

0 coins

Okay that's more convincing than I expected. If I can't get through by Friday I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

The claim start date and the 41-day deadline tripped me up too. Good to know the agent can actually confirm that on the call.

0 coins

Worth clarifying one thing that often gets mixed up here: PFL pays you during leave but it doesn't protect your job. That comes from CFRA or FMLA depending on your employer's size and your situation. PFL is purely the wage replacement benefit, and it's a California EDD program separate from whatever disability arrangement your employer has set up.

0 coins

Wait so I could get PFL payments but my job isn't guaranteed? I hadn't even thought about that part. I need to ask HR about CFRA separately then.

0 coins

Yes, they're different. PFL is EDD's benefit. CFRA job protection is your employer's obligation under a separate law. HR or your employer's legal team can tell you if it applies to your situation.

0 coins

CFRA caught me off guard too when I first went on leave. Ended up having a whole separate conversation with HR about it.

0 coins

edd's phone line is a full-time job on its own. spent three mornings last month hitting redial and got the 'call volume is high' message every single time. if you do get through somehow, ask specifically whether your employer's voluntary plan changes anything about how EDD processes your PFL bonding claim, because the answer actually matters for your paperwork.

0 coins

Three mornings just trying to get through is exhausting. I'm already stressed about the pregnancy stuff and adding phone roulette on top doesn't help.

0 coins

it really does pile on. the information is worth getting though because the voluntary plan interaction is not something the EDD website explains clearly.

0 coins

EDD's hold times are genuinely brutal. No argument there.

0 coins

When I filed my PFL bonding claim through SDI Online, the system didn't ask anything about whether my employer used a voluntary plan or state SDI. It just needed my wage information and the proof of relationship. The CASDI on the paystub is what ties everything together on the EDD side.

0 coins

So SDI Online just processes it normally and doesn't have a separate question about the type of plan? That's actually helpful to know before I sit down to file.

0 coins

Right, nothing in the SDI Online flow asked about my employer's disability arrangement. It was really just about my wages and the birth certificate for the proof of relationship.

0 coins

Same with ours, filed for my youngest last year, SDI Online never brought up our company's plan at all, anyway.

0 coins

Intermittent days after going back part time created more confusion on my claim than anything else. Tried to report them through SDI Online and wasn't sure the DE 2580GF had been processed right. Claimyr got me to an agent who confirmed which weeks EDD had marked as reported and which ones were still showing open.

0 coins

What did you have ready when the agent answered? Like did you need your claim ID or anything specific?

0 coins

Claim ID, the dates I'd worked the partial days, and my weekly hours. Agent matched it up to the DE 2580GF and went through each week.

0 coins

been dialing that line myself since last tuesday. every time the same recording. starting to wonder if a live person even exists on that number.

0 coins

PFL is funded by SDI payroll withholding. If CASDI appears on your pay stub, you're contributing. The voluntary plan your employer has for disability is a separate arrangement between them and a private insurer. EDD runs PFL on its own track.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation I've seen. So the two tracks basically don't overlap for the bonding claim portion.

0 coins

For bonding, yes. The disability piece during pregnancy may go through the private plan rather than state EDD. That's the part worth confirming with your HR and EDD before the baby comes.

0 coins

my old job had one of those private plans and i still got pfl when my kid was born. filed on sdi online, got the receipt number, uploaded the birth certificate. edd paid it. wasnt complicated at all

0 coins

Did anything feel different about the filing process because of the private plan? Or was it just the same as anyone else filing?

0 coins

literally the same. edd didnt care what my company did for disability. just needed the birth certificate and my wage stuff

0 coins

Pretty much same experience here. The private plan stuff is on the employer's side, EDD just does its own thing with the bonding claim, lol.

0 coins

A proof of relationship is required for every bonding claimant except a birth mother coming off a pregnancy disability claim. For everyone else, a birth certificate, a Declaration of Paternity form, a foster care letter, or an Adoptive Placement Agreement will work. Get that document ready before you file so the receipt number isn't sitting there waiting on paperwork.

0 coins

I'll be the birth mother so I should get the DE 2501FP after the pregnancy disability claim, right? My HR made it sound like I'd have to file everything from scratch for bonding.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP is the form EDD sends to new mothers at the end of a pregnancy disability claim, and filing it starts the bonding PFL. It doesn't require a separate proof of relationship document. HR may not know that detail.

0 coins

Correct. You submit the DE 2501FP within 41 days of when bonding leave starts, and it handles the transition from pregnancy disability to PFL bonding. No birth certificate needed on that form.

0 coins

That is a huge relief. I was picturing having to gather everything all over again right after delivery.

0 coins

The eight weeks of PFL is shared across bonding, any care claims, and military assist all in the same 12 months! So if you end up needing to care for someone else later in that year, the weeks you used for bonding count against the total. Just something to keep in mind when you're planning.

0 coins

This is accurate and a lot of people don't realize it going in. It's one pool of eight weeks, not eight weeks per reason.

0 coins

Okay I genuinely didn't know that. I thought bonding and caring for a family member were separate eight-week allowances. Good to know before I assume I'd have more weeks available later.

0 coins

Many people assume they're separate. They're not: California EDD gives you up to eight weeks total within any 12-month period, spread however you need across the different claim types.

0 coins

DE 2514 came on my claim after EDD sent an initial determination I didn't agree with. Used Claimyr to reach the PFL line and asked the agent what the notice said specifically and whether the appeal window was still open. Agent confirmed the 30-day appeal period from the notice date and what document EDD still needed from me.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came back lower than I expected and I want to know if EDD has everything right before I decide anything. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have out when they answer?

0 coins

Have the claim ID, the notice date, and your base period wage quarters if you can find them on the notice. The agent pulled up my claim and read the specific determination off it, so the more detail you can give them upfront the better.

0 coins

This is making me realize I should understand the Notice of Computation before anything else. I didn't know you could appeal it.

0 coins

if the notice of computation comes and the weekly benefit amount looks wrong, do you just call EDD or is there an actual form to dispute it

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the appeal form. It comes with any denial or determination notice. You have 30 days from the notice date to submit it, either online or by mail.

0 coins

30 days sounds like enough time but honestly knowing EDD it probably goes by fast while you're trying to reach someone. Good to know the form has a name at least.

0 coins

The form is included with the notice itself. Read everything EDD mails you carefully because the deadlines start from that date.

0 coins

My cousin told me PFL had a waiting week like disability does, so I was mentally subtracting seven days when I was calculating my payments. Turns out PFL doesn't have a waiting period at all. Wish someone had told me that before I did all that math.

0 coins

The waiting period thing mixes people up constantly. PFL starts paying from day one of eligible leave, no unpaid week sitting at the front.

0 coins

Right, and I'd already adjusted my budget for that phantom week. Got a nice surprise when the first payment covered the full first week.

0 coins

my coworker said the same thing about a waiting week and i believed her for like two weeks before i looked it up

0 coins

eight weeks total sounds like a lot until you actually use it and realize how fast it goes. took six weeks bonding with my son and had two left when my mom got sick the same year. barely enough for her care claim.

0 coins

That's exactly why the shared pool rule matters so much in practice. People plan the bonding weeks without thinking about what might come up later in that 12-month window.

0 coins

nobody tells you to think ahead on that. just figured bonding was bonding and care was care.

0 coins

Knowing how many weeks remain in a 12-month period is worth keeping track of. EDD can tell you the number if you're not sure.

0 coins

the private plan vs state sdi question is actually more nuanced than most people think. some voluntary plans are approved by the california labor commissioner to substitute for state sdi, and in that case your employer may handle the disability claim while EDD handles PFL. others are supplemental on top of state sdi. the difference matters for who processes what.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of thing my HR couldn't clearly explain. So I really need to know which category my company's plan falls into before I assume anything.

0 coins

Ask HR specifically whether the plan is a California EDD-approved Voluntary Plan that substitutes for state SDI, or whether it's something supplemental. Those are very different arrangements.

0 coins

Calling EDD directly with your employer's EIN and asking how your employer's plan is filed with EDD is the most reliable way to get a definitive answer for your specific situation.

0 coins

we had the private plan situation too and i kept going back and forth with hr for two weeks trying to get a straight answer. in the end edd was the one who clarified everything. hr just wanted to send me pdfs anyway

0 coins

PDFs that explain nothing, that tracks. I might just go straight to EDD and skip the HR roundabout.

0 coins

honestly would have saved me time. edd knew exactly how our plan was set up once i got someone on the phone, anyway.

0 coins

filed last week and still pending. no notice of computation yet. nine days in. is that normal or should i be doing something

0 coins

EDD can take up to 14 days to decide a claim. Nine days is still within that window. If it goes past 14, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

ok. nine days felt forever but 14 days makes me feel less panicked.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update is in SDI Online under your claim. Pick the right request type and write out your question. That creates a record too.

0 coins

does anyone know if two parents can both file PFL bonding for the same baby or is it only one per household

0 coins

Each parent can file their own separate PFL bonding claim with EDD. The eight-week limit applies individually per person, not per baby. So both parents have up to eight weeks each, used within 12 months of the birth or placement.

0 coins

that's really good to know, we were assuming only one of us could do it

0 coins

Pretty common assumption. Both parents file separately and EDD processes each claim on its own.

0 coins

pro tip from someone who learned the hard way: save your receipt number from SDI Online the second you get it. doctor's offices need it to submit Part D on a care claim through the system, and if you lose it you'll be digging through emails or calling EDD to get it again, lol.

0 coins

Filing for bonding so no Part D for me, but I'll definitely screenshot the receipt number. Seems like it matters for everything.

0 coins

Yeah for bonding you don't deal with Part D at all. But that receipt number ties your whole claim together so worth keeping it somewhere obvious.

0 coins

Wrote mine on a sticky note on my fridge, which sounds silly but I referenced it three times in the first week.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure