Back to California Paid Family Leave

Lydia Santiago

Do RSU vesting count as income while receiving PFL benefits?

So I started my California EDD PFL bonding claim about three weeks ago and payments have been coming in, which is great. But my company's RSU vesting schedule doesn't pause just because I'm on leave. A batch of shares vested last week and I'm genuinely not sure how EDD handles that. Do RSU vesting count as income while receiving PFL benefits? I reported my regular salary days before I went on leave but I haven't reported anything since because I haven't actually worked. The shares just vested automatically. I don't want to end up with an overpayment notice six months from now because I didn't report something I should have. Has anyone dealt with this?

DE 2500E on my bonding claim showed up about nine days after I filed, which is when I realized I had no idea how the payment cycle actually worked. Spent three mornings on EDD's line before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and reached a live agent. She confirmed the DE 2500E had already posted to my claim and walked me through what the first payment would cover, week by week. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I genuinely don't know what it does.

0 coins

You dial EDD, it stays on that hold for you, and when a live person picks up your phone rings. That's it. What's your claim situation?

0 coins

My bonding claim has been pending eleven days and I want to ask EDD whether the proof of relationship they got actually matched to my file.

0 coins

Whether RSU vesting is wages under EDD's rules is exactly the kind of thing these facts don't settle clearly. EDD says wages earned, not wages paid, matter, but equity comp sits in a gray zone. The safest move is to ask EDD directly how your own claim should treat the vesting event, because a wrong answer either way can create an overpayment.

0 coins

That's what worries me. I'd rather over-report than end up owing money back. Did you have to deal with something similar?

0 coins

Not RSUs specifically, but I did have a bonus pay situation and EDD's guidance was that any compensation tied to work already done before leave started was handled differently than wages earned during leave. RSUs get complicated because the vesting is tied to continued employment, not hours worked on a given day. Really worth a direct call to EDD on this one.

0 coins

Ok I'll try to get someone on the phone. The SDI Online message system takes forever to get a response.

0 coins

When I filed my care claim for my husband a couple of years ago, I had a small amount of consulting income come in partway through the leave. EDD's rule as I understood it is that you report any wages, even wages you haven't yet received if you've already earned them. The tricky part with RSUs is figuring out whether the vesting event counts as wages at all under EDD's definition. I'd write to EDD through Ask EDD and keep a copy of whatever they tell you.

0 coins

I didn't even think of Ask EDD as an option. Is the response time faster than the SDI Online message?

0 coins

In my experience, Ask EDD was a bit quicker, but results vary. For something this specific I'd follow up by phone too if the written answer wasn't clear.

0 coins

Wait, is Ask EDD the same as the Request Claim Update in SDI Online? I keep getting those two things mixed up.

0 coins

They're separate. Ask EDD is EDD's general contact form on their website. Request Claim Update is inside SDI Online and goes directly to your claim file. For a question about what to report, Ask EDD might actually get you to someone who handles that more generally.

0 coins

edd's phone line is a full-time job unto itself. i tried before 8, right at 8, midday, nothing. either a busy signal or they just hang up after you've been holding twenty minutes. the RSU question is a good one though, i'm curious what they actually say.

0 coins

Same problem here. I gave up after a week of trying.

0 coins

it's not a system issue it's a staffing issue and they know it. anyway if you do get through post what they say about RSUs because i feel like a lot of people on stock vesting schedules run into this.

0 coins

i thought pfl just cares about whether youre working during the claim days, like if you work you report it, if you dont you dont. do RSUs even count as working

0 coins

That's roughly how it works for hourly wages, but EDD's rules say to report wages earned, and the question is whether equity comp vesting counts as wages earned during the leave period. It's not the same as clocking in.

0 coins

ok fair i didnt know there was a difference

0 coins

Yeah this is exactly what I'm hung up on. It's not like I did any work for the RSUs to vest, they just vested because I stayed employed long enough. But EDD might still see it as compensation.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of like this with a commission that posted while she was on leave. She ended up calling EDD and the agent told her commissions for work done before the leave started were still wages she had to think about. RSUs are different but I'd treat them seriously and not assume they're invisible to EDD.

0 coins

Commission for pre-leave work is an interesting parallel. RSUs also vest based on a schedule that started before my leave, so there might be a similar logic.

0 coins

Exactly what I was thinking. Either way you don't want to find out the hard way.

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish a clear rule on equity comp that I've ever found. You'll get a different answer depending on who you reach on the phone. Document everything.

0 coins

That's not super encouraging but probably realistic. I'll keep notes on whatever anyone tells me.

0 coins

Keep the date, the name if they give it, and exactly what they said. If you get an overpayment notice later you have something to point to.

0 coins

Tried taking my PFL days intermittently and missed one week's report. DE 2580GF didn't go back in time and I wanted to know which weeks EDD had marked as paid versus pending. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who told me exactly which weeks had processed and which one was sitting open waiting on the certification form.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for my own claim too, glad it worked for you. Asked the agent about the 41-day deadline because I wasn't sure my care claim got filed in time, and she pulled up the start date they had on file and confirmed I was within the window.

0 coins

Wait, how did they know the exact date EDD had on file? Did you have to give them all your info or did they just pull it up anyway?

0 coins

She asked for my Social Security number and the receipt number from when I filed and found it right away.

0 coins

Can I ask a maybe dumb question? If RSUs count as income, does that mean PFL gets reduced dollar for dollar, or does it just get cut off entirely? I'm trying to understand what the actual risk is.

0 coins

EDD's rule is that your wages plus PFL can't go over your normal wages, excluding overtime. So if the vesting payout pushes you past that ceiling the PFL for those days would be reduced or eliminated. But whether RSUs even count as wages in EDD's eyes is the open question here.

0 coins

Ok so it could reduce the benefit for specific days rather than the whole claim. That's slightly less terrifying than I thought.

0 coins

Right, it's not an all-or-nothing thing. The bigger risk is not reporting and then EDD finding it later and issuing an overpayment for those days.

0 coins

I'd report it. Doesn't matter if you're not sure exactly how it's classified. You tell EDD what you got, let them sort out how it counts. That way you're not hiding anything.

0 coins

That's basically where I've landed too. Report it and let EDD figure out the math rather than guess.

0 coins

Exactly. You can always dispute an overpayment if they miscalculate, but you can't undo not reporting.

0 coins

The not-knowing is the worst part of this honestly. EDD's written guidance covers wages in a pretty traditional sense and RSUs are just newer than the forms.

0 coins

Pretty much. The DE 2501F doesn't exactly have a checkbox for 'restricted stock units.

0 coins

Ha, right. The form hasn't caught up with how people get paid now.

0 coins

been on leave three weeks and just getting used to checking SDI Online every couple days. never thought about RSUs and PFL crossing paths. good thread.

0 coins

Same, three weeks in and still learning how all of it fits together.

0 coins

wait does pfl even have a waiting period before the first payment? i told a coworker she'd have to wait a week before benefits started and now i'm not sure i got that right

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. That waiting week is for Disability Insurance, not PFL. If your coworker is filing a bonding or care claim under PFL, benefits start from the first day of leave with no unpaid waiting period.

0 coins

oh no i hope she didn't delay her filing because of that. i'll let her know, thanks for the correction

0 coins

Worth double-checking the filing date too. The deadline is 41 days from when the leave starts, and if she held off thinking there was a waiting week she might be cutting it close.

0 coins

For the RSU question specifically: EDD's SDI Online doesn't have a clear field for equity comp. If you do report it, use the wages field and add a note in whatever comment section is available. Keep your brokerage statement showing the vesting date and the value assigned at vesting.

0 coins

That's practical, thank you. I do have the brokerage statement with all of that detail.

0 coins

Good. The vesting date and fair market value at vesting is what EDD would want if they ever follow up.

0 coins

DE 2514 landed in my mailbox after EDD initially said I wasn't eligible for my care claim. Filed the appeal using the DE 1000A form attached to it. While I was waiting I used Claimyr to reach an agent who confirmed the payment method EDD had on file for me was debit card, not direct deposit, which explained why my payments were slower than expected. Got that updated.

0 coins

That payment method thing sounds like it could be an ad for the service more than a real call, honestly.

0 coins

I thought the same thing at first, but I tried it after weeks of not getting through and the agent told me EDD still had my old address on file for the debit card. That was why mine was delayed. Not an ad, just an actual problem you'd only find out from a person.

0 coins

Fair enough. If my claim doesn't move soon I might just try it.

0 coins

RSUs and PFL crossing wires is not something HR warned me about at all. Worth bringing up with payroll too, they might know how the company typically handles it on their reporting side, anyway.

0 coins

Good call. If the company reports it as income on a W-2 during my leave period that could be the clearest signal for how EDD would treat it.

0 coins

Yeah exactly, and payroll has probably dealt with this before for other people on leave anyway.

0 coins

I'm in a similar spot but with a bonus that was approved before my leave and paid out two weeks in. I've been going back and forth on whether to report it. Reading this thread I think I have to.

0 coins

A bonus for work done before leave started is still worth reporting to EDD and asking how they classify it. EDD's guidance is to report wages earned, so if the bonus was compensation for work during the base period, that matters.

0 coins

I'll send a message through Ask EDD today. I don't want an overpayment hanging over me.

0 coins

Part D on my mom's care claim kept showing as not received in SDI Online for two weeks after her doctor submitted it. Called EDD after trying for days and finally got through, but I'd used Claimyr to reach the agent. She looked it up and said Part D had been received but wasn't yet matched to my claim ID, and told me to give it three to five business days.

0 coins

How long were you on hold before the agent picked up when you used it?

0 coins

Honestly not long, maybe twenty minutes total from starting to actually talking to the agent. For comparison I'd been trying on my own every morning for four days straight and gotten nothing.

0 coins

four days straight is about where I am right now on a totally different question. might just do it.

0 coins

Report the RSUs. Let EDD determine how they're classified. The worst outcome from reporting is a minor benefit adjustment. The worst outcome from not reporting is an overpayment notice plus interest.

0 coins

That framing actually helps a lot. It's not really a close call when I put it that way.

0 coins

Exactly. Document the vesting date and the amount. If EDD ever asks, you have it.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten a definitive answer from EDD on RSUs specifically? Like not just 'report wages' but actually 'here is how we treat equity vesting.' I'd love to know if that guidance exists somewhere in writing.

0 coins

Nothing I've found on edd.ca.gov addresses RSUs by name. The benefits calculator and the wage reporting guidance use traditional wage examples. For equity comp the advice everyone gives is the same: ask EDD directly about your own situation and document the answer.

0 coins

That's what I figured. EDD's written materials are very much a 2005 payroll world.

0 coins

Ha, accurate. I'm going to call and document whatever they tell me and report back here.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure