Back to California Paid Family Leave

Connor O'Brien

Can you appeal PFL denial online? Got the DE 2514 and have no idea where to start

Got a denial letter in the mail last week for my PFL bonding claim. It's the DE 2514, the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, and there's an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) attached to it. I'm not sure if I can submit the appeal online or if I have to mail it back. The letter says I have 30 days to appeal and I'm already a week in. I think I may have submitted something wrong when I first filed but I don't know exactly what EDD's issue is with the claim. Has anyone gone through this? Can you appeal PFL denial online or does the form have to be physically mailed? I really can't afford to miss the window on this.

The DE 1000A that came with your denial can be mailed or submitted online through SDI Online. Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/, open your claim, and there should be an option to submit the appeal from there. Either way the 30 days runs from the date on that DE 2514, not the day you received it, so check the letter's date carefully.

0 coins

The date on the letter is different from the day it arrived in my mailbox. Does the 30 days start from the date printed on the DE 2514 itself?

0 coins

Yes, it's the date printed on the determination letter. I'd still move quickly since you're already a week in by your count.

0 coins

Okay, the printed date gives me a little more time than I thought. Going to file through SDI Online today.

0 coins

The Appeal Form (DE 1000A) can go in by mail or through SDI Online, the instructions on EDD's site confirm both. What I'd flag is that the appeal window is 30 days from the date of the determination, so whatever you write on the form, make sure the date you submit or postmark is within that window, not just the day you drop it in a mailbox.

0 coins

Does submitting through SDI Online count as the submission date, or does EDD go by when they process it?

0 coins

SDI Online records a timestamp when you submit, so that date should stand as your filing date. I wouldn't wait to find out the hard way though.

0 coins

Filing online sounds way safer than trusting a postmark then. I didn't realize you could even do it that way.

0 coins

Denial came on my care claim back in October, same form. Tried the EDD phone line four mornings straight and kept hitting a busy signal or getting cut off before anyone answered. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the line. The agent pulled up my DE 2514 and told me exactly which part of the claim triggered the denial, so I knew what to put on the appeal. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've never heard of it before you mentioned it.

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD so you don't have to sit there all morning. When a live agent picks up, your phone rings and you're on with them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

That actually makes sense. I'd want to ask EDD why my own proof of relationship document hasn't shown up on my claim yet, so I might try it for that.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke, I've called at 8 a.m. on the dot and still got a busy tone or a recording that just ends the call. Appeals are nerve-wracking enough without spending half your day redialing. File online through SDI Online if you can, at least you get a timestamp.

0 coins

Eight in the morning doesn't even help half the time. I tried three days in a row for my claim and got nothing.

0 coins

Exactly, three days is nothing, I've had stretches way longer than that. Online filing for the appeal is the move.

0 coins

I went through a denial last spring on my bonding claim and panicked in the same way you are. Filed the appeal through SDI Online and it was actually pretty straightforward once I was in the system. You just find your claim and there's an option to submit the appeal form from there.

0 coins

Did EDD ever tell you what to include with the appeal, or do you just submit the form by itself?

0 coins

The form had a section for explanation, and I attached a note describing what I thought went wrong. No one told me to, I just figured it couldn't hurt.

0 coins

That's smart. Giving them context upfront seems better than waiting for them to ask.

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the letter. That's the whole rule. Online or mail, pick one, just don't sit on it.

0 coins

How much detail do I need in the explanation I write on the form? Like a sentence or a whole paragraph?

0 coins

Enough to say what you think EDD got wrong. More than a sentence is better than less.

0 coins

my cousin got denied and just mailed the form back and it worked out fine but that was a while ago. online seems faster honestly dont risk the mail

0 coins

Mailing it isn't risky if you send it with tracking. But online does give you that timestamp proof.

0 coins

fair enough yea tracking makes it less sketchy i still like having the timestamp from online tho

0 coins

Two weeks after I uploaded my baby's birth certificate, the portal still said EDD hadn't received the proof of relationship. I kept trying the phone line and couldn't get through. Ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent and she confirmed they'd received it and that it was matched to my claim. I would have kept worrying for nothing otherwise.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for my claim too, really glad I tried it. Called about my receipt number because I lost the paper I wrote it down on after filing, and the agent found it and read it back to me so I could give it to my mom's doctor to file Part D online.

0 coins

Wait, the doctor can actually use the receipt number to file Part D online? I didn't know that, anyway my mom's claim is coming up and I need to tell her doctor's office.

0 coins

Yep the doctor's office can submit Part D in SDI Online using that receipt number, makes it easier than mailing the paper form.

0 coins

I'm confused about something. If EDD denied the claim, does the appeal go through the same SDI Online account where I filed, or is it a totally different portal?

0 coins

Same account, same SDI Online. You open the claim that was denied and work from there. No separate login or new account needed.

0 coins

Oh that's a relief, I was afraid I'd have to start from scratch somewhere else.

0 coins

30-day window stressed me out when my wife's claim had issues. We logged into SDI Online together and found the option, submitted the appeal same day, anyway just wanted to say it's doable, don't wait.

0 coins

Did you hear anything from EDD after you submitted? Like a confirmation that the appeal was received?

0 coins

Got a confirmation in SDI Online right away. EDD mailed a letter too a few days later, anyway that was reassuring.

0 coins

You can appeal online. 30 days from the date on the DE 2514. File through SDI Online and keep the confirmation. That's it.

0 coins

Does EDD send anything by mail after the online appeal is filed, or is everything in SDI Online from that point?

0 coins

EDD mails notices. Check SDI Online too, but watch for letters.

0 coins

SDI Online is so much better for things like this than mailing anything! You get a record right away and you can see when EDD has it. Definitely go that route for the appeal if you can!

0 coins

Agreed, paper can get lost or delayed. Online gives you something to point to if EDD ever says they didn't get it.

0 coins

The benefit estimate on my Notice of Computation came in lower than I expected, so I tried calling EDD about it. After three weeks of busy signals and dropped calls I went through Claimyr and spoke with an agent. She confirmed the weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation and walked me through which quarter of my base period they used for the calculation. I'd been reading my pay stubs wrong.

0 coins

Did the agent tell you if there was any way to dispute the amount, or do you just accept whatever the Notice of Computation says?

0 coins

She said if I disagreed with the determination I could appeal it the same way you'd appeal a denial, using the DE 1000A within 30 days. I didn't end up appealing because once she explained the base period calculation it made sense.

0 coins

been trying that phone line for going on two weeks, never once got through to a person. good to know the agent at least gives you a real answer when you do reach one.

0 coins

I assumed PFL came with job protection automatically, like you'd get fired for filing or EDD would somehow shield you. Had to look it up and was surprised. PFL pays you but doesn't protect the job, that protection comes from other laws, and whether those apply depends on your employer and situation.

0 coins

A lot of people mix that up. Worth asking HR directly about what leave protection your employer offers, since EDD doesn't handle that side.

0 coins

I definitely thought PFL meant my job was protected. Glad I found this out before my leave started.

0 coins

Appeal form, 30-day deadline, SDI Online submission with timestamp. That's the checklist. If you're unsure why EDD denied you, call them before you submit the appeal so you know what to address in your explanation.

0 coins

Calling has been impossible for me so far. I keep getting a busy signal before 8:30 and then nothing.

0 coins

Try the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online if calls aren't working. You can write your question there and EDD responds in the portal.

0 coins

Last payment on my bonding claim never showed up when I expected it. After five mornings of busy signals and dropped calls I got through using Claimyr and spoke with an EDD agent. She looked at the claim and told me the payment had been issued three days earlier and gave me the exact date, so I knew to watch my debit card for it.

0 coins

Honestly sounds like marketing to me, paying some service to get through to EDD, I feel like it can't be that simple.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned. Tried it anyway after a week of dropped calls on my own care claim, and the agent confirmed my Notice of Computation amount and what quarter the weekly benefit came from. The person I spoke with was definitely an EDD agent.

0 coins

Okay, if someone who was skeptical tried it and actually got EDD on the line, that changes things a little. Might look into it.

0 coins

mailed my appeal on a bonding denial and it took forever to get any kind of update. next time im doing it online for sure

0 coins

How long did it take before you heard anything back after mailing the appeal?

0 coins

close to three weeks before i got a letter acknowledging they had it. online would have been way less stressful

0 coins

The 30-day deadline is firm. Miss it and you likely lose the right to appeal that denial. EDD isn't flexible about it in my experience.

0 coins

Is there any exception if the mail was delayed and the letter arrived late?

0 coins

EDD goes by the date on the determination letter, not when it landed in your mailbox. So if the letter is dated earlier than you got it, you have fewer days than you think. That's exactly why checking the printed date matters.

0 coins

That's a little alarming honestly. I'll make sure to check the date on any EDD mail the day it arrives.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD ever confirmed why my first PFL claim got denied until I actually reached a live person. Even then the letter they sent was vague. If you can get through to someone before the 30 days are up, do it, it makes writing the appeal explanation a lot easier.

0 coins

The letter I got was vague too. I really want to know the specific reason before I write the explanation on the appeal form.

0 coins

Request Claim Update in SDI Online is worth trying. I've had better luck with that than the phone line on most days.

0 coins

I had it backwards when I first looked into this. I thought EDD's eight weeks of PFL was separate for bonding and separate for a care claim, like you could do eight weeks bonding and then another eight caring for a parent in the same year. That's not how it works. The eight weeks is one shared total across bonding, care and military assist within any 12-month stretch.

0 coins

Phoned about how many weeks I had left in my 12 months using Claimyr after going in circles on that question. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I'd used five weeks on bonding and had three remaining, so I knew exactly what was left before filing a care claim for my dad.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether the 12 months resets on the anniversary of when you first filed, or is it tied to the child's birth date?

0 coins

She said it's 12 months from the child's birth or placement for bonding. I didn't ask about how it works for care claims specifically, just what I had left.

0 coins

been trying to get this same question answered by phone for over three weeks. glad to know the answer exists somewhere.

0 coins

Update: filed the appeal through SDI Online this afternoon. It went through and I got a confirmation right away. The form had space to explain what I think went wrong so I wrote a few sentences about the proof of relationship document I uploaded. Hopefully EDD reviews it quickly. Really glad I found this thread, the 30-day clock was stressing me out.

0 coins

The confirmation is the important part. You have a timestamp now and EDD knows the appeal is in. Watch the mail for their next letter.

0 coins

So relieved you made it in time. The online option is so much better for peace of mind than mailing anything with a tight deadline.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure