Can teachers get paid family leave if employer uses alternative disability plan
I'm a middle school teacher in the Elk Grove district and I just found out my school district uses an alternative disability plan instead of the state SDI program. My daughter is due in March and I've been trying to figure out if I can even get PFL for bonding afterward. Everything I read about California EDD PFL seems to assume you're paying into the standard SDI, but my paystubs say something different — no CASDI line anywhere. Does the alternative plan change whether I qualify for PFL through EDD? Or does my district handle the whole thing including bonding? I've asked HR twice and gotten two different answers, which is not helping my anxiety at all. Has anyone else been in this situation?
88 comments

Levi Parker
Before I understood how alternative plans work, I assumed everything was wrapped together and filed the wrong way entirely. If your district uses a Voluntary Plan (sometimes called a VP) for disability, that plan replaces the state Disability Insurance side only. PFL is a separate piece. As long as the district's plan includes PFL benefits at least equal to what EDD would pay, the VP covers it and you go through the district's plan administrator, not EDD directly. But if the VP covers only disability and not PFL, then you may need to file PFL through EDD — provided you have at least $300 in wages with SDI withheld somewhere in your base period. The first step is confirming with HR exactly what your plan covers.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorHR told me the VP covers disability for my own medical leave but was vague about bonding. So I might actually need to file with EDD for PFL separately?
0 coins
Levi Parker
Possibly, yes. Ask HR specifically whether the Voluntary Plan includes Paid Family Leave for bonding, or only state disability. Those are two different things and not every VP bundles both.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
Does the $300 SDI withheld have to be from the district job or can it be from a second job? I do some tutoring on the side and I think CASDI does come out of those checks.
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
The SDI Online filing page and EDD's own DE 2530 guide both note that PFL is part of SDI, but Voluntary Plans are employer-run alternatives. What that means in practice: if your district's VP includes PFL, you apply through the plan administrator. If it doesn't include PFL, and you have qualifying wages with SDI withheld from another employer in your base period, you can file for PFL through EDD. The tutoring income question above is a good one — that CASDI on those checks could be your ticket.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorSo the tutoring wages that have CASDI deducted might actually make me eligible to file PFL with EDD even though my main district job has no CASDI?
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
That's the direction the rules point, but whether those wages meet the $300 threshold and fall in the right base period quarters is something the EDD calculator on their site can help you estimate. The actual determination comes from EDD once you file.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
I keep wondering if filing through EDD when your main job has a VP causes any complications. Like does EDD flag it somehow?
0 coins
Levi Parker
EDD looks at wages with SDI withheld. If the tutoring wages are there in the base period with CASDI deducted, the VP situation at the district job doesn't block a PFL claim through EDD for those wages.
0 coins
Sofia Peña
That DE 2514 sitting in my mailbox was the reason I ended up on the phone with EDD in the first place. My bonding claim got denied and the determination notice gave a reason I didn't understand, so I needed to talk to someone. Spent four mornings trying that line — same recording every time, never got past it. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up the DE 2514 and walked me through what the denial code meant on my specific claim, and told me I had 30 days from the mailing date to appeal using the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
Four mornings hitting a dead line is nothing — I've been at it for two weeks on a care claim question. How does that service actually manage to get through when everyone else can't?
0 coins
Sofia Peña
Honestly I can't tell you what it does on the backend. What I know is I stopped getting the recording and started talking to an EDD person. That's all I can say about it.
0 coins
Sophia Carter
Used it myself when the receipt number on my bonding claim wasn't matching up in SDI Online. The agent confirmed the number was correct in EDD's system and that the claim was linked properly — it just hadn't updated on my end yet. Might be worth trying if you're stuck, though for the appeal question the 30-day window is what matters most.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
Alright, I'll give it a shot. Already tried calling at 8 a.m. twice this week and got the same result.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Your HR giving two different answers is a red flag. Push them to give you the actual plan documents. The VP plan has to be in writing and it'll say what it covers. If bonding leave isn't in there, you have your answer.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorYou're right, I've just been taking their word for it. Can I ask for the full plan documents as an employee?
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Yes. It's your benefit. They have to give you the plan summary at minimum.
0 coins
Brandon Parker
I went through something adjacent to this with a client of mine who works at a charter school — she had the same confusion about whether her district plan covered bonding or just her pregnancy medical leave. Turned out her plan covered disability for the actual birth and recovery but bonding after was filed separately through EDD. She didn't realize they were two different claims.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorThat's exactly what I'm afraid is happening with mine. My HR kept talking about disability for the birth but got quiet when I asked specifically about the weeks after.
0 coins
Brandon Parker
That silence usually means bonding isn't in their plan. I'd pin them down on that exact question in writing.
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
Filing the bonding claim as a new mother through EDD is a separate form too — the DE 2501FP — and you have 41 days from when bonding starts to submit it, so knowing early gives you time to prepare.
0 coins
Jace Caspullo
Alternative disability plan teachers who want PFL usually end up filing with EDD anyway. It happens more than people think.
0 coins
Melody Miles
wait so the district plan and edd pfl are just completely separate things and you can be in both at the same time?
0 coins
Jace Caspullo
Different coverage, different claims. District plan handles its thing, EDD handles PFL if you have qualifying wages there.
0 coins
Melody Miles
ok that actually makes it clearer than anything ive read today
0 coins
Nathaniel Mikhaylov
No CASDI on your paystubs means no SDI deductions going to EDD, which means EDD has nothing to pay you from unless you have other qualifying wages elsewhere. The tutoring income angle is probably your best shot if bonding isn't in the district plan.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorIs there any way to know before I actually file what EDD will count toward the base period from those tutoring wages?
0 coins
Nathaniel Mikhaylov
The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate. Put in your tutoring wages and see what it shows.
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
The base period covers wages from roughly five to seventeen months before your claim starts. If tutoring wages with CASDI withheld fall in those quarters, they count. The calculator at edd.ca.gov can run those numbers for you.
0 coins
Eva St. Cyr
Two rejections at the Part D stage taught me to never assume the doctor's office submitted anything. For my mom's care claim I called the office three times and each time they said it was done. It wasn't. I ended up using Claimyr to get through to EDD and ask an agent what document they were actually waiting for — the agent said Part D hadn't come in at all, even though the office had my receipt number. I went back to the office in person with the receipt number written on a sticky note on the form and watched the front desk submit it right then.
0 coins
Kristian Bishop
What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't seen that mentioned before.
0 coins
Eva St. Cyr
It stays on hold with EDD in your place, so when a live person picks up, your phone rings. That's pretty much it.
0 coins
Kristian Bishop
Useful to know. I've got a question about whether my own proof of relationship came through on a bonding claim. That's what I'd want to ask about.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
Part D and the 41-day window, those two things together kept me up at night on my wife's care claim. We had to physically drive the form to the doctor's office the last week to make sure it went, anyway.
0 coins
Axel Far
your district's HR benefits person probably doesn't even know the answer to the pfl question. the person who does is the VP plan administrator, which might be a third party company not even at the school
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorHR gave me a name and a 1-800 number for the plan administrator last time. Maybe that's who I should be calling instead of HR directly.
0 coins
Axel Far
yes. that person knows what the plan covers. hr just knows what HR knows
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
The plan administrator is the right call. They can tell you in one conversation whether PFL bonding is included or not, which saves all the back and forth.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
I'm in a similar situation, different district. My paystub shows something called 'STRS' and 'PERS' deductions but no CASDI. I've been assuming I'm just not covered for PFL at all but reading this thread I'm wondering if I'm wrong about that.
0 coins
Levi Parker
STRS and PERS are your pension contributions, not disability. The question is whether your district has a Voluntary Plan that includes PFL, or whether you have wages from any other job with CASDI withheld. Worth checking both.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
I did some substitute work before my current contract and I think CASDI came out of those checks. Would those wages count?
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
If those substitute wages fall within your base period and had SDI withheld, yes, EDD could count them. The base period goes back roughly five to seventeen months from when your leave starts, so check whether those paystubs fall in that window.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
I still have all those old stubs. I should actually go look at the dates before I assume anything.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
Talked to a guy at a neighboring site who's also a teacher and he said his district's VP covered disability but bonding was just unpaid CFRA time for him. No PFL payment at all because there was no CASDI history anywhere. He found out two weeks before his wife gave birth.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorTwo weeks before — that's terrifying. I really need to get this sorted before March.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
Yeah he said the job protection was there through CFRA but no actual payment. That distinction matters a lot when you're counting on the money.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
PFL pays but doesn't protect the job. CFRA protects the job but doesn't pay. They're different things and not everyone gets both.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Exactly right. Having CFRA leave at your school doesn't mean you're getting PFL checks. You'd need the EDD piece for that.
0 coins
Luis Johnson
Payment date on my bonding claim was showing in SDI Online but it had been four days past that date with nothing hitting my account. Tried the EDD line six times in one day and got nowhere. Used Claimyr and got someone at EDD on the line — the agent said the payment had actually issued two days earlier to the debit card address on file, which I hadn't updated. All that stress for a wrong address.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Ha, I used Claimyr too after my husband's bonding claim got confusing! The agent pulled up his Notice of Computation and confirmed the weekly benefit amount that was showing, which matched what we'd calculated from EDD's site. Such a relief!
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
Did they tell you if there was anything you needed to do after they found the address issue, or did it fix itself?
0 coins
Ellie Kim
For us it was more of a confirmation thing so we didn't have to do anything extra. But for an address issue I'd assume you'd need to update it in SDI Online first.
0 coins
Luis Johnson
Yeah I updated the address in myEDD that same day and the payment showed up the next morning.
0 coins
Sophia Carter
The 41-day deadline trips everyone up. Whether you end up filing through EDD or through the VP plan administrator, start the clock from day one of your bonding leave, not from the birth. Missing that window can mean losing benefits for those early days.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorIs the bonding leave clock separate from the disability clock if I'm a birth mom? Like does bonding officially start the day I give birth or when the disability period ends?
0 coins
Sophia Carter
The disability claim is for your own recovery from childbirth. Bonding starts when that disability period ends and you're doing the PFL claim. The 41 days for PFL bonding runs from your bonding start date, not the birth date.
0 coins
Levi Parker
For a new mother, once the disability claim closes, EDD sends the DE 2501FP specifically for that transition. The 41-day window for bonding runs from when that bonding period begins, so there's usually a little time built in.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorOk that makes the sequence clearer. Disability claim for recovery, then PFL bonding after, and the 41 days starts when bonding starts. Got it.
0 coins
Levi Parker
Weeks remaining on my PFL was something I completely lost track of after going back to work part time. Took intermittent days here and there for about four months and by the time I wanted to take the last stretch I had no idea how many weeks I had left. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent told me exactly how many of my eight weeks had been paid out and what was left in the 12-month window from my child's birth date. Saved me from filing a new claim I didn't need.
0 coins
Brandon Parker
Eight weeks sounding like a lot but gone fast when you take it in little pieces — wait, actually can I ask, did the agent say whether the weeks reset or carry over past the 12-month mark?
0 coins
Levi Parker
The agent was clear that anything unused after 12 months from the birth date is simply gone. No rollover. That's why knowing how many were left mattered so much.
0 coins
Brandon Parker
That's exactly what I suspected but I've been going back and forth on it. I might just be marking this one down and trying that line myself.
0 coins
Eva St. Cyr
The 12-month limit is firm. Any weeks not used by then can't be claimed. The earlier you know your remaining count, the better you can plan the last stretch of leave.
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
Even going back to work part time each day still uses benefit days — EDD pays one-seventh of the weekly amount per eligible day, so the weeks do add up faster than people expect when they think intermittent means slow.
0 coins
Melody Miles
my coworker is also a teacher and she said her district just pays her full salary during leave so she never had to think about edd pfl at all. is that a thing some districts do
0 coins
Levi Parker
Some districts do top up salary during leave using sick time banks or supplemental pay, but that's the district's own policy separate from PFL. The PFL piece through EDD or the VP still runs underneath; the district is just adding to it. Worth asking HR how the two interact.
0 coins
Melody Miles
ok so she might be getting both and not realizing it
0 coins
Jace Caspullo
Probably. The PFL goes to the employee, and if the district has an agreement about how it combines with salary, that's between the employee and HR.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Are teachers covered by CFRA for the job protection part? I keep reading that CFRA has an employer size minimum and I don't know if school districts count differently.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
Whether CFRA covers a particular teacher at a particular district is a question for HR and potentially a legal question. This thread is really about the PFL payment side.
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
The job protection side — CFRA, FMLA and what your district's policies say — is separate from the PFL payment question. For the CFRA piece, HR or the Civil Rights Department's site is the right place to check.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Fair enough, I didn't mean to derail. The payment side is the more urgent question for the original poster anyway.
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
Filing in SDI Online through myEDD is the smoothest route if you end up going directly to EDD. The whole bonding claim for a new mother goes through the DE 2501FP after the disability period, and no extra documents are needed for that form specifically.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorIs there a way to file the DE 2501FP in SDI Online or does it have to be mailed?
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
The DE 2501FP is the paper form EDD sends to new mothers whose disability claim is ending. You fill it out and mail it. The SDI Online path is for other claimants filing bonding directly, like the other parent.
0 coins
Libby Hassan
So if I'm the dad I'd just log into myEDD and file for PFL bonding through SDI Online with the proof of relationship like a birth certificate?
0 coins
Adriana Cohn
Exactly. Upload the proof of relationship, save your receipt number from the confirmation page, and that's the start of it.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Bottom line for the original question: get your VP plan documents, ask the administrator specifically whether bonding PFL is included, and check whether your tutoring wages with CASDI get you to $300 in a qualifying quarter. Those two things tell you everything you need to know.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorThank you, that's the clearest action list I've seen. I'm calling the plan administrator tomorrow and pulling my tutoring stubs tonight.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Good. And get it in writing from the administrator. Email is fine.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
Nobody told us that PFL doesn't have a waiting period until after I'd already budgeted for seven unpaid days at the start. Thought it was like disability where there's a waiting week. No waiting period on PFL at all.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
PFL has no waiting period. I made the same mistake at first.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
Wish someone had flagged that earlier for us. The waiting week is a disability insurance thing, not PFL. Completely different program, anyway.
0 coins
Sophia Carter
For anyone reading and unsure — PFL benefits start from the first day of the leave with no unpaid days up front. Disability Insurance has the waiting week; PFL does not.
0 coins
Axel Far
if the tutoring gig is through a platform that treats you as a contractor and not an employee, there would be no casdi withheld and those wages probably wouldnt count for pfl
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
AuthorThe tutoring I do is through a small private family, not a platform, and I have W2s from them because they set it up that way. So CASDI should actually be on those.
0 coins
Axel Far
w2 with casdi withheld is exactly what you need. check the box and the stub and youre in a much better spot than you think
0 coins
Hunter Hampton
W2 wages with SDI withheld from a household employer absolutely count toward the base period. That changes the picture significantly from someone whose only income is through the district VP.
0 coins