Back to California Paid Family Leave

Luca Bianchi

Can self-employed wife get SDI PFL without elective coverage? Trying to figure this out before she files

My wife has been self-employed for about four years, running a small alterations and tailoring shop out of our garage. She's pregnant and due in March, and we just realized we never looked into whether she can even get PFL for bonding after the baby comes. I went on EDD's site and saw something about "elective coverage" for self-employed people but it was confusing. Does she just not qualify at all without it? Or is there some other way she could be covered that we're not thinking of? She doesn't have any W-2 income on the side. I feel like we dropped the ball on this and now it might be too late.

The elective coverage piece is the key thing here. To qualify for PFL, you need at least $300 in wages with SDI withheld, which shows up as CASDI on a W-2. Self-employed people don't have that automatically, so unless your wife opted into elective coverage through EDD at some point, she most likely isn't covered. Worth double-checking her past tax records to be sure, but if there's no CASDI withholding in her base period, PFL won't apply.

0 coins

We looked through everything last night. No CASDI on anything. So that's that, I guess. Really frustrating that we didn't know about this earlier.

0 coins

It stings to find out this way, but now you know for future pregnancies or if her business situation changes. Elective coverage is something she could set up going forward.

0 coins

Yeah we're already looking into it for next time. Wish someone had mentioned this when she registered her business.

0 coins

No CASDI, no PFL. That's just how the program works. She'd have had to enroll in elective coverage and pay into SDI herself. Can't collect what you didn't put in.

0 coins

Not sure if this is a dumb question but, does elective coverage have like a waiting period before you can use it? Because if she signed up now, could she still get anything for this baby?

0 coins

41 days after the bonding leave starts is the filing deadline, but the underlying question is whether she has enough wages with SDI withheld in the base period. Elective coverage enrolled right now wouldn't cover a claim starting in March, the base period goes back further than that.

0 coins

Oh wow, so it really is too late for this one. That makes sense but still hurts to hear.

0 coins

Payments were showing in SDI Online but I honestly couldn't tell which weeks had been paid or when the next one was coming, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone from EDD on the phone. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed exactly which weeks had been issued and what the next payment date was. Cleared up two days of me refreshing the portal constantly.

0 coins

Eight weeks total is what I had too and I lost track of how many I'd actually used. Had to do the same thing to find out how many were left in my 12 months. Agent counted them off for me and said I had three weeks remaining. Went back to work part time after that knowing exactly where I stood.

0 coins

Man I tried that line six mornings in a row and kept getting the busy tone. Never got through once.

0 coins

The portal really should just show a running count of weeks used but it doesn't, so calling was the only way to get a straight answer.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to get a real answer instead of just refreshing the page.

0 coins

To add some context to what's already been said: elective coverage is voluntary SDI enrollment for self-employed people and sole proprietors. You apply for it through EDD, pay the SDI rate yourself, and then you're in the same pool as employees for both Disability Insurance and PFL purposes. The catch is exactly what was said above, it's not retroactive, so coverage you start this month won't help with a claim that starts in a few months.

0 coins

So there's literally no workaround for this pregnancy? Even if she pays now she can't file for this baby?

0 coins

For this pregnancy, almost certainly not. The base period looks at wages from about five to eighteen months before the claim starts. Contributions from December wouldn't be in that window.

0 coins

Okay. That's hard to hear but I appreciate the straight answer.

0 coins

EDD's whole system assumes you're a W-2 employee. Freelancers, sole proprietors, anyone self-employed basically gets ignored unless they did the homework and signed up for elective coverage on their own. Most people don't even know it exists until it's too late, which is exactly the situation you're in.

0 coins

The elective coverage option has existed for a long time but EDD really doesn't advertise it at all! You'd think there'd be some kind of prompt when you file your business taxes or register as self-employed.

0 coins

You'd think.

0 coins

edd doesnt make anything easy thats for sure

0 coins

The DE 2530 guide, which is EDD's own Paid Family Leave brochure, says eligibility requires wages subject to SDI during the base period. For employees that's automatic. For self-employed it comes from elective coverage. No other path is listed. So unless there's W-2 work somewhere in her base period, the program isn't available to her for this claim.

0 coins

Exactly. Base period is the highest quarter of the four quarters ending roughly five to seventeen months before the claim start date, and if SDI was never withheld in any of those quarters, the weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation would be zero.

0 coins

Well put. And just to add, the Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly benefit amount but it isn't an approval itself. Someone without sufficient wages wouldn't even get a valid one.

0 coins

We're definitely in the zero-wages-with-SDI bucket. No question there.

0 coins

Had a bonding claim going and the DE 2500E never showed up, which I needed to track the first payment info. Spent three mornings dialing before anyone picked up. Eventually used Claimyr and an EDD agent told me the DE 2500E had been issued the week before but to a mailing address I'd updated late, so she confirmed the payment amount and date right on the call.

0 coins

I don't know, I tried calling EDD fourteen times over two weeks and not once did it even ring past the first message. How did you actually get a person on the line through Claimyr? That just sounds made up to me.

0 coins

I had the same doubt, trust me. What happened is I ended up with a live EDD agent on my phone while I was making lunch. I didn't do anything except answer when my phone rang with an agent already there. The person I spoke with was definitely EDD, she had my claim ID and everything.

0 coins

Tried it on a care claim for my mom. Agent confirmed the claim start date and that the 41-day window for Part D was still open by four days. Barely made it.

0 coins

Okay if an actual EDD agent had your claim ID I'll give it a shot. I've got nothing to lose at this point anyway.

0 coins

fourteen times and nothing, thats rough

0 coins

Okay so here's a question for the thread. If her situation was different and she did have some W-2 work mixed in, like even just a part-time job for a few months, would that count? Or does it have to be all one kind of income?

0 coins

Any W-2 wages with CASDI withheld count, even if the rest of her income is self-employment. The base period just looks at those wages. So yes, even a part-time job with SDI withheld could qualify her.

0 coins

Oh interesting! So it's really just about whether the paycheck had that CASDI line on it.

0 coins

She had a part-time teaching gig two years ago but that was before the base period window would cover this claim.

0 coins

Two years back almost certainly falls outside the base period for a March claim. But worth saving that detail in case her situation changes and she files in a future year.

0 coins

She can still look into CFRA with her employer for job protection but wait, she's self-employed. Never mind. Yeah there's not a lot of options here without that SDI coverage.

0 coins

CFRA covers employees, not self-employed individuals running their own business. So that's not a path here. PFL and CFRA are also separate things, by the way, PFL is the wage benefit from EDD and CFRA is job-protected leave through the employer, they're not the same program even though they often overlap for employees.

0 coins

Right, I knew that, just blanked for a second. Good clarification for anyone who didn't.

0 coins

I definitely did not know PFL and CFRA were different things. I thought PFL meant your job was protected. So PFL has no job protection built in?

0 coins

EDD says it plainly: PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. The job protection piece comes from CFRA or FMLA for those it covers, and that's between the employee and their employer, not EDD.

0 coins

Okay that's a huge thing I had totally wrong. Good to know before I ever need to file.

0 coins

self employed and pregnant is rough all around. no PFL, no employer paid leave, no disability coverage unless you planned ahead. hope you guys can figure something out for the time off.

0 coins

Thank you. We're just going to have to plan around it differently. Trying to look at it as useful information for next time.

0 coins

That's a healthy way to look at it. And you've already started the right steps by looking into elective coverage for going forward.

0 coins

For anyone else reading: elective coverage enrollment forms are on EDD's site. If you're self-employed and not enrolled, it's worth doing now rather than waiting until the next pregnancy or family situation comes up.

0 coins

Yes! The form is right there on edd.ca.gov and you can also find info through myEDD. Really wish more business owners knew this existed from day one.

0 coins

Bookmarked the right page finally. Better late than never.

0 coins

Intermittent days were tricky to report and I kept second-guessing whether I'd done it right. Ended up using Claimyr to reach EDD and ask. The agent said the DE 2580GF had been received and matched to my claim and that the days I reported were logged correctly. That was the one confirmation I actually needed.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? Never heard of it.

0 coins

It handles the hold time with EDD's line so you end up talking to an actual agent. That's about all there is to it.

0 coins

Hm. I've got a question about my own Notice of Computation, the weekly amount on it looked lower than I expected. Might give that a try.

0 coins

edd line is a black hole so worth trying anything at this point

0 coins

Wait, going back to the main question. If she signs up for elective coverage now, is there a minimum time she has to be enrolled before she can file? Like if she enrolls in January and has another baby in two years, would that work?

0 coins

The base period for a claim starting two or more years from now would almost certainly include wages from elective coverage she starts paying into early next year. So yes, enrolling soon and maintaining it would put her in a good position for a future claim.

0 coins

Okay that's actually useful to know. Sounds like the move is to get enrolled now and not wait.

0 coins

Just make sure she checks the form requirements on EDD's site. The enrollment process has its own steps.

0 coins

March due date, so the earliest a bonding claim starts is the birth date. Forty-one days from then is the filing deadline. That's roughly mid-April at the latest to file without losing benefits. For next time, those dates are worth marking early.

0 coins

We wouldn't be filing because she's not covered. But I'm writing those numbers down anyway for if she's enrolled in the future.

0 coins

Smart. The 41-day rule catches people off guard even when they are covered.

0 coins

Yes, 41 days goes fast with a newborn!

0 coins

does she do any work for anyone else like even gig stuff? doordash, task rabbit, any of that? sometimes those have different setups

0 coins

Gig platform income is generally treated as self-employment for SDI purposes unless the platform withholds CASDI, which most don't. So it usually lands the same way: no withholding, no coverage.

0 coins

fair enough, was just thinking out loud

0 coins

Good thought though. If any platform does withhold it, that could matter.

0 coins

My sister went through something similar last year, self-employed photographer, found out about elective coverage too late for her second kid. She enrolled right after and has been paying into it since. At least going forward you have a plan.

0 coins

That's actually helpful to hear. Makes me feel less alone in missing this.

0 coins

So many people are in this exact situation. EDD really needs to do better outreach to self-employed folks.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way DI does. No seven days unpaid at the start. That comes up sometimes as a worry and I want to make sure it's not adding to the stress here.

0 coins

I had assumed PFL had a waiting period too. So for employees who are covered, they'd start getting paid from day one of the leave?

0 coins

Payments usually come within two weeks after EDD gets the completed claim. No benefit waiting period built in.

0 coins

That's actually better than I thought. Good to know.

0 coins

She can apply for elective coverage. It won't help in March. That's the whole answer.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate.

0 coins

Sometimes that's what you need to hear.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the PFL weekly benefit amount for covered workers is estimated on EDD's calculator on their site! So when she is enrolled and covered in the future, you can run those numbers ahead of time and actually plan around it. So much easier than guessing.

0 coins

The calculator gives an estimate, the real number is on the Notice of Computation once a claim is filed. But yes, running it early is a good way to plan finances.

0 coins

I already found the calculator and ran numbers just to see what it would have been. Honestly useful for future planning.

0 coins

Has anyone thought about whether she might qualify for anything through a union or professional association? I know some have their own programs.

0 coins

That would be outside EDD entirely. PFL is a California state program funded through SDI. Any private program through an association is a completely separate thing with its own rules. Worth asking whoever runs her association, but EDD can't speak to it.

0 coins

Makes sense, just throwing out ideas. Worth a quick inquiry to her tailoring guild or whatever if one exists!

0 coins

She's not part of any formal association but that's not a bad thought for the future.

0 coins

Bottom line for anyone landing on this thread: self-employed means no CASDI withheld automatically, which means no PFL eligibility unless you signed up for elective coverage yourself. It's not complicated but it's easy to miss.

0 coins

Well put. And the enrollment info is on edd.ca.gov, no need to call anyone just to get started on it.

0 coins

should be somewhere in the new business registration flow honestly. would save a lot of people from finding this out at the worst time.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure