Back to California Paid Family Leave

QuantumQuasar

Can employer make use PTO while on paid family leave in California?

I started my California PFL bonding claim two weeks ago when my daughter was born and I'm honestly still figuring all of this out. My HR sent me an email saying I need to use my accrued PTO at the same time as PFL. I didn't know that was a thing they could do? I thought PFL was its own separate thing and I could keep my vacation days for later. Is this actually legal or is HR wrong? I don't want to lose my PTO but I also don't want to get in trouble with my job. Anyone dealt with this before?

Your accrued sick leave, vacation or other paid time off can run alongside PFL, but there's a limit your HR may not have explained fully. The combined amount from your employer's PTO and your EDD weekly benefit can't exceed what you'd normally take home in a regular week, excluding overtime. How an employer handles that combination is its own policy, so your HR is the right place to ask exactly how they're applying it to your pay.

0 coins

So EDD and my employer can both pay me at the same time, they just can't add up to more than my normal wages? I hadn't understood it that way at all.

0 coins

That's the idea, yes. EDD pays its portion and your employer's PTO fills in around it, up to your normal weekly wages. The exact math is your employer's call, so keep that conversation with HR going.

0 coins

Does HR have to tell you in writing that they're requiring PTO to run at the same time? My company sent something vague too and I'm not sure if it's official policy or just someone guessing.

0 coins

Around the time I filed my bonding claim I wasn't sure my leave start date was right, since I'd had a few days between delivery and when I actually stopped working. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the line because I'd been trying the 1-877-238-4373 number for days and kept hitting a recording. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date they had on file and told me I had until 41 days from that date to have everything in. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting got confusing for me too so I tried Claimyr for my own situation. EDD's agent said the DE 2580GF is what handles that, they send it once you've got active weeks, and you send it back or the payments pause. Glad that cleared it up anyway.

0 coins

What did the agent say about whether you report each day separately on that form?

0 coins

They said each day worked gets listed on the DE 2580GF before you return it. Pretty simple once someone actually explains it.

0 coins

The 41-day thing is so stressful! Good to know calling actually worked for you.

0 coins

Your HR can require it. It's their policy. EDD doesn't stop them. The only rule is your combined pay can't go over your normal wages for the week.

0 coins

Ugh, so I'm basically stuck. I was saving those vacation days for a real trip someday.

0 coins

Yeah, that's the downside. Some companies let you hold them, some don't. Ask HR if there's any flexibility written into your policy.

0 coins

My job did the same thing to me lol. I thought I was sitting on two weeks of vacation and then HR was like nope, it runs with your PFL. It stinks but it's not EDD's rule, it's your company's.

0 coins

Worth separating two things here since they sometimes get mixed up. PFL from EDD pays your wage replacement benefit. Job protection, if you have it, comes from CFRA or FMLA at the employer level. Those are different buckets entirely. EDD's PFL doesn't say anything about what your employer does with PTO, so HR has real authority here on the PTO question.

0 coins

So PFL from EDD has nothing to do with whether my job is protected? I thought they were connected.

0 coins

They run at the same time for a lot of people but they're separate. CFRA or FMLA is what protects the job. PFL is the paycheck piece. For specifics on whether CFRA covers your situation, HR or an employment attorney is a better source than EDD.

0 coins

I did not realize those were two totally different things. I've been thinking EDD was handling all of it.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I tried every morning for a week before I got anyone. Even then I got disconnected twice. The PTO question is real but honestly just getting a human at EDD to ask it took me longer than finding the answer.

0 coins

same exact thing happened to me, called like six days in a row and nothing, its wild how hard it is

0 coins

And then when you finally do get through they act like it's your fault you couldn't reach them. Frustrating doesn't cover it.

0 coins

been there. the line just ends the call sometimes without saying anything.

0 coins

Direct deposit setup on my bonding claim got dropped somewhere and payments were going to the default debit card instead of my bank. Tried the EDD line three mornings in a row, nothing past the hold music. Ended up using Claimyr and spoke to an agent who confirmed the payment method on file and walked me through what had to happen to update it in SDI Online.

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment to me. Automated line that holds your place sounds like something someone's selling.

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Tried it anyway after a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) showed up denying a week I definitely took off. Agent confirmed which week the determination covered and told me the appeal window was 30 days from the date on the notice. That part was real, it was an EDD agent who answered.

0 coins

Alright. Might give it a look if the line stays like this.

0 coins

DE 2514 denial sounds terrifying. At least you got an actual answer fast.

0 coins

The EDD benefits calculator at edd.ca.gov gives you an estimate of your weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives. Your actual number will be on the DE 429DF once EDD issues it. That's the document that shows what your base period wages came to and what weekly benefit you're approved for, not a guarantee of eligibility, just the computed amount.

0 coins

DE 429DF, is that what shows up in SDI Online or does it only come by mail?

0 coins

EDD mails it. You can track your claim status in SDI Online but the DE 429DF itself arrives as a paper notice. Keep an eye on the mail in the first couple weeks after filing.

0 coins

Exactly right. The notice comes in the mail and the payment history lives in SDI Online. Two different places for two different things.

0 coins

PTO question depends on your company handbook. Some employers have it written in that PTO runs concurrent with any state leave. If HR is telling you to use it, dig out the handbook and read the section on leave policies before you push back.

0 coins

I never actually read the handbook. That's embarrassing to admit but I didn't know any of this was going to come up.

0 coins

Nobody reads it until they need it. Go find it now, it'll answer whether this is policy or just someone at HR winging it.

0 coins

Seriously, the handbook is where it'll say if the PTO concurrent thing is a formal policy or just HR's preference. Big difference if you end up needing to push back.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period before the first benefit. If someone told you to expect seven unpaid days at the start, that's disability insurance, not PFL. Bonding claims pay from the first eligible day.

0 coins

Wait, there's no waiting period at all for PFL? My coworker told me to expect seven days with nothing. I've been budgeting for that gap.

0 coins

Your coworker is thinking of the DI pregnancy claim, which does have a seven-day wait. PFL bonding starts paying from day one of your leave. No gap.

0 coins

This is such a relief to read. I had mentally written off that first week already.

0 coins

If you're taking the eight weeks all at once, EDD pays out every two weeks for the duration. If you're doing it intermittently, like a few days a week, you'll get the DE 2580GF from EDD and need to return it reporting the days you worked and the days you were on leave. Missing that return stops payments.

0 coins

what happens if you send it back late, do you just lose those days or can you fix it

0 coins

Contact EDD if a form is late. I wouldn't assume the days are gone without asking first.

0 coins

Intermittent was confusing to set up but once the DE 2580GF cycle starts it's pretty routine. Report the days, return the form, payment follows.

0 coins

On the PTO question specifically, the EDD rule as I understand it is that PTO plus your PFL payment can't add up to more than your regular weekly pay. The employer decides whether to require the PTO or let you keep it. EDD doesn't make that call for them.

0 coins

That tracks with what HR told me too. EDD's piece is capped, employer piece fills up to the normal wage and no more.

0 coins

Yep, the wage cap is EDD's rule. Everything about whether the employer forces you to use PTO is in the company policy, not in EDD's rules.

0 coins

Eight weeks total for bonding is so much better than what it used to be! But just to flag, those eight weeks are shared across bonding, care claims and military assist within the same 12 months. If you use six weeks now and your spouse gets sick in the same year, you'd only have two PFL weeks left for a care claim in that period.

0 coins

That's a really important point. A lot of people assume bonding and care are each their own eight weeks but it's one pool of eight for all of it in any 12-month stretch.

0 coins

I did not know that. I thought care claims had their own separate eight weeks on top.

0 coins

Super common mix-up! One pot, shared across claim types in the 12 months.

0 coins

Receipt number on my bonding claim never showed up in my confirmation email and I wasn't sure the filing went through. Tried the EDD line a few times with no luck. Used Claimyr and the agent confirmed EDD had received the claim and read me the receipt number right off the file so I could save it.

0 coins

When the agent confirmed the receipt number, did they say anything about the proof of relationship document being matched to the claim already?

0 coins

They said the birth certificate upload was showing as received but hadn't been reviewed yet. Told me to give it a few more days before worrying about the proof of relationship side.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that line for about two weeks now. two weeks of mornings wasted.

0 coins

Tracking dates matters here. PFL bonding has to be used within 12 months of the birth, and the claim itself has to be filed no later than 41 days after your leave starts. If HR's PTO requirement pushes your leave start date around, make sure the date you tell EDD matches when you actually stopped working.

0 coins

My HR put my leave start date as the day my daughter was born but I technically worked a half day that morning. Does that mess up my claim start date?

0 coins

That's worth clarifying with EDD directly. The start date affects the 41-day window and the 12-month bonding period, so you want what EDD has on file to match reality.

0 coins

Agreed, a half-day discrepancy is the kind of thing that can matter at the margins. Send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online or phone EDD to confirm what date they're using.

0 coins

my company has the same thing in our handbook, pto runs with pfl, found out the hard way when i got my first payment and realized the pto was already being docked. nobody warned me

0 coins

HR really should walk people through this upfront instead of letting them find out from their paystub. My company didn't either.

0 coins

exactly, the email they sent was like two lines and i had to google everything

0 coins

Proof of relationship docs confused me when I filed as the dad. EDD wants a birth certificate or a Declaration of Paternity for a bonding claim if you're not the birth mother. Got the birth certificate uploaded same day we got it from the hospital.

0 coins

I'm the dad and I uploaded the birth certificate too. How long did it take for EDD to show it as received in SDI Online?

0 coins

Showed up as received within a day or two for me. Getting it reviewed and matched to the claim took longer, maybe a week after that.

0 coins

Is a Declaration of Paternity the same as the paternity acknowledgment form from the hospital? Or is that a different document?

0 coins

EDD doesn't care whether your PTO is being used at the same time. That's a contract issue between you and your employer. What EDD enforces is the wage cap on combined payments. Everything else is HR's turf.

0 coins

Short and correct. Some people think EDD has rules about forcing PTO and they don't, not on the employer's end.

0 coins

Helpful to hear this stated plainly.

0 coins

Bonding claims for dads and non-birth parents really do need that proof of relationship doc or the claim just sits. Upload the birth certificate the day you get it. Don't wait until you have everything else figured out.

0 coins

I uploaded it at 11pm the night we got home from the hospital. Hoping that was fast enough.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move. The claim can't move without it and there's no reason to hold it.

0 coins

Same advice I'd give. The birth certificate is the one thing EDD needs from you on a bonding claim as a dad, so get it in as soon as it's in your hands.

0 coins

PFL doesn't pay for the same days unemployment does, or the same days a DI claim covers. If your situation overlaps somehow, you get one or the other for any given day, not both.

0 coins

Worth adding that a birth mother's pregnancy disability claim is DI, not PFL. After that ends she can move to PFL bonding. The two run back-to-back, not at the same time.

0 coins

So if I had a DI claim for my own medical recovery first, PFL bonding would start after that one closes? Not at the same time?

0 coins

Correct. DI for the pregnancy recovery, then PFL bonding after. EDD sends a DE 2501FP to birth mothers to file for the bonding piece.

0 coins

Appeals on a denial go through the Appeal Form DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on the determination notice to file. Online or mail both work. Missing that window is a real problem so don't sit on it.

0 coins

Haven't gotten a denial, just asking in case. Good to know the 30-day window exists.

0 coins

30 days goes fast with a newborn in the house. Worth knowing that number before you need it.

0 coins

Payments come by debit card, direct deposit if you set it up in SDI Online, or check. Direct deposit only works if you filed online through SDI Online, not on the paper form.

0 coins

didnt know the paper form cant do direct deposit, i was about to mail mine in and expect a deposit

0 coins

File in SDI Online through myEDD if direct deposit matters to you! Paper claims get a debit card or check only.

0 coins

The debit card EDD uses is through Money Network, not Bank of America, in case anyone has older information floating around from when that changed.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure