Back to California Paid Family Leave

Nathan Dell

Can I apply for paid family leave if SDI maternity claim was disqualified

So I'm in a really stressful situation and hoping someone here has gone through this. I had my daughter in August and filed a disability claim for my maternity leave. EDD sent me a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination saying I didn't qualify for the disability part, something about not meeting the wage requirement from what I can tell. I've been going back and forth trying to understand if the disqualification on the SDI side means I'm also blocked from filing a PFL bonding claim for my daughter. They feel like the same thing to me but I've also seen people say they're separate? My daughter is almost two months old now so I'm worried about timing too. Has anyone dealt with this? Can I still file for PFL bonding even though the SDI maternity claim didn't go through?

Left in the 12 months, that was my question when I phoned EDD about my own bonding claim. I'd used some weeks on a care claim earlier in the year and had no idea how many bonding weeks I still had. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through since the line just ended my call every time I tried on my own. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I had three weeks remaining in my 12-month window. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Every morning for two weeks I've tried that line before my shift and it either rings out or cuts off. I'm skeptical anything actually gets you to a person there, not some workaround, not anything. What exactly happened when you used this, did you just end up on hold forever?

0 coins

Nope, my phone rang and an EDD agent was on the line. That was it. I'd given up on the regular way of calling.

0 coins

Tried it too on my PFL claim. Agent confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued on October 3rd and the first payment would follow. That date matched what I saw in SDI Online two days later.

0 coins

PFL bonding and SDI disability are two separate claims. Getting turned down for the disability side doesn't automatically kill a bonding claim. File the PFL bonding claim on its own and let EDD decide eligibility separately.

0 coins

Filing it now then. Do I do it in SDI Online the same way I filed the disability one?

0 coins

Yes, through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/, then Apply for Benefits and choose Apply for PFL Bonding. Save the receipt number at the end.

0 coins

Wait so they look at the wage requirement separately for PFL? I thought if disability was denied the whole thing was done, I'm relieved but also not sure I understand why they'd be separate.

0 coins

Different programs, different determinations. File and see what EDD decides on the bonding side.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost exactly this last spring, the disability claim got denied and she just went ahead and filed PFL bonding on its own. She got approved for bonding even though the other one didn't go through. So it's worth filing for sure!

0 coins

That's really good to hear, thank you. Did she have any issues with timing since she filed the bonding one after the disability denial?

0 coins

She filed pretty quickly after getting the denial letter, within a week I think. She said the 41-day thing was what she was worried about most.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline is counted from when bonding leave actually started, not from the denial date on the disability claim. For a birth, bonding leave could start the day the baby arrived. So the clock is running from then, not from whenever the denial came.

0 coins

Yes that's what she said, she counted from the birth date and made it just in time.

0 coins

The wage requirement for PFL bonding looks at whether you had at least $300 in SDI-withheld wages in your base period, same calculation as disability but it's its own determination. The disqualification reason on the SDI claim matters here. If it was a wage issue, the bonding claim faces the same question. If it was something else, the bonding claim might still clear. File and see.

0 coins

The denial mentioned the SDI wage calculation. So I might have the same problem on the bonding side? I'm trying not to panic but this is really stressful.

0 coins

It's worth filing anyway. EDD makes the call, not us. And bonding has its own eligibility decision even if the base period overlaps.

0 coins

Filing costs nothing and the worst they can do is send another determination letter, which you can appeal within 30 days if you disagree.

0 coins

spent three mornings hitting redial on that PFL line and getting a recording every single time. the system is a joke honestly

0 coins

Same. I gave up after day four. Eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online instead.

0 coins

yeah i ended up doing that too. slower but at least something happens

0 coins

The claim's start date and the 41-day window was the specific thing I needed clarified on my own bonding claim, so I found Claimyr and spoke with an EDD agent through it. The agent confirmed my bonding start date in EDD's system and told me exactly how many days I had left before the 41-day filing deadline. I had filed a week after my son arrived and wanted to be sure the date was recorded right.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I've got my own situation where I need to know if EDD received Part D for my mom's care claim.

0 coins

You give EDD's Paid Family Leave line to it and it stays on until an agent picks up, then your phone rings with that agent ready. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

ok if it actually does that I'd use it to confirm the Part D came in. the doctor's office submitted it online with my receipt number and I have no way to tell if EDD matched it to my claim.

0 coins

my wife had the same question when her disability claim for the pregnancy got weird. she filed PFL bonding separately, it took about 12 days to get the Notice of Computation, anyway

0 coins

12 days for the Notice of Computation, that's helpful to know. Did EDD ask for any extra documents for the bonding one?

0 coins

just the birth certificate uploaded in SDI Online as proof of relationship, nothing else after that anyway

0 coins

Birth certificate is the standard one for bonding as a mom too. Some people ask if the hospital record works but EDD lists the birth certificate, a Declaration of Paternity form, the foster letter, or the Adoptive Placement Agreement as what they accept.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar boat and I want to make sure I understand. If I file the PFL bonding claim and it also gets denied because of wages, is the denial letter the one with the Appeal Form attached? I want to know what I'm looking at if that happens.

0 coins

The notice EDD sends when PFL is denied is called a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514. The Appeal Form, which is the DE 1000A, comes with it. You'd have 30 days to file the appeal.

0 coins

ok so I'd need to appeal within 30 days of that letter. got it, that's less scary than I thought.

0 coins

Appealing the denial is a real option and people do succeed with it. Keep the denial letter and the appeal form somewhere you can find them.

0 coins

edd and sdi are literally two names for the same office it drives me crazy. pfl bonding is under the same roof but its a different claim just file it

0 coins

Worth clarifying: SDI is the program that runs both disability insurance and PFL. EDD administers both. So when people say their SDI claim was denied, they might mean disability or PFL, depending on what they filed.

0 coins

yeah ok fair but the point is file the bonding one separately thats what i meant

0 coins

The two-month mark your daughter is at right now is what I'd focus on. Bonding benefits have to be used within 12 months of the birth, and the 41-day filing window from when bonding leave started is a hard cutoff. If you haven't filed PFL bonding yet, do it today.

0 coins

Filing it this afternoon. I didn't realize the 41-day thing was from when bonding leave started, I thought it was from when I first tried to claim. Going to count back from when I stopped working.

0 coins

Yes, count from your first day of leave, not from the disability denial date. That's the date EDD uses.

0 coins

Don't wait on this one. 41 days goes fast when you're dealing with a newborn.

0 coins

got denied on a care claim once because I missed the 41 days by four days. no exceptions, no extensions, they were clear about that

0 coins

That's terrifying honestly. I'm going right now.

0 coins

0 coins

Payment method was something I had to sort out on my own bonding claim because my direct deposit info from an old claim was still on file and I wasn't sure it would go to the right account. Called EDD using Claimyr and the agent confirmed which bank account was set for the payments and told me I could update it in SDI Online if needed.

0 coins

Used Claimyr on my own claim too. After I went back part time, I wanted to know how EDD handles the days I actually worked. The agent walked me through what the DE 2580GF is and confirmed EDD had sent it to me already.

0 coins

What did EDD say to do with the DE 2580GF once you got it?

0 coins

Return it with your work days and wages reported. If you don't send it back, benefits stop. Agent was very clear on that.

0 coins

pfl also doesn't have that 7-day waiting period that disability does, just throwing that out there since people mix those up all the time lol

0 coins

This is accurate and worth knowing. Disability has seven unpaid days at the start, PFL bonding has none. Benefits can start from the first day of leave.

0 coins

I genuinely had those mixed up. I thought I'd have to eat a week of nothing either way, good to know that's not the case for bonding.

0 coins

yeah i made that mistake too on my first claim, the agent had to explain it to me

0 coins

receipt number on a bonding claim matters more than people think. mine got separated from my proof of relationship upload and EDD couldn't match the document. used Claimyr to get an agent and she confirmed the birth certificate was sitting there unmatched. she tied it to the right claim on her end.

0 coins

This reads like something a service would write to get people to sign up for it. What's the actual process here, how does someone give EDD's hold line to a third party?

0 coins

thought the same thing when i first saw it mentioned. tried it anyway when my own determination notice made no sense to me. agent told me the DE 2514 on my claim had been mailed three days earlier and explained what the appeal window on it was. not a pitch, just what happened.

0 coins

alright, I'll look into it. I've been meaning to call EDD anyway about a document question.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind on the wage side: the base period EDD uses for PFL is the 12 months ending about five to eighteen months before your claim date. If your disability denial was because of wages in a different quarter, it might be worth checking which quarters EDD would use for the bonding claim. The Notice of Computation will show you the actual breakdown.

0 coins

The denial letter for the disability one mentioned a specific quarter. I'll compare it to what the bonding determination says when it comes in.

0 coins

Keep both letters together. If the base periods overlap and the wage issue is the same, you'll have everything in one place if you appeal.

0 coins

EDD's benefits calculator on edd.ca.gov can give you an estimate before the notice arrives, if you want a rough idea of what the weekly benefit amount might look like.

0 coins

Job protection is a different thing from PFL. PFL pays you, it doesn't protect your job. If you need job protection you're looking at CFRA, that's a separate conversation with HR.

0 coins

HR told me my CFRA leave started when my daughter was born. So the job protection is running but I still need the PFL filed separately to actually get paid?

0 coins

Exactly. CFRA holds the job, PFL pays the benefits. Two separate things, same situation.

0 coins

This comes up constantly and it's worth being clear: PFL and CFRA can run at the same time. You're protected by CFRA while also receiving PFL pay, if you qualify for both. Whether you qualify for CFRA is between you and your employer.

0 coins

I went back part time after six weeks and didn't know I could still use my remaining PFL weeks later! EDD sent me the Continued Claim Certification and I almost didn't send it back in time.

0 coins

Always return the Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, right away. If it doesn't get back to EDD, the payments stop even if you still have weeks left.

0 coins

Yes! I learned that the hard way, payment stopped for two weeks until I sorted it out.

0 coins

The 12-month window for using bonding benefits runs from the birth date, not from when you file. So even if the PFL claim gets approved in November, you can use the weeks up until August of next year, the month your daughter turns one.

0 coins

August deadline, got it. That gives me a little breathing room on when I actually take the leave weeks, as long as I file the claim now.

0 coins

File first, use the weeks second. The filing is what has the 41-day deadline, not the actual leave days.

0 coins

just want to say the PFL phone line is brutal. tried for four days before i gave up and sent a message through Ask EDD instead. response took a week but at least it arrived

0 coins

four days is nothing, i had a stretch where i tried every single morning for two and a half weeks. nothing.

0 coins

eventually someone is going to fix that line. probably not soon though

0 coins

filing a new claim after a denial is not the same as appealing it. appeal goes on the denied claim. new PFL bonding claim is its own thing filed fresh. make sure you're doing the right one

0 coins

Filing fresh PFL bonding claim, not an appeal of the disability one. I think I understand the difference now.

0 coins

right. if the bonding one also gets denied then you appeal that one separately within 30 days.

0 coins

I had those totally confused too. I thought I had to appeal the disability denial before I could even file for bonding. Glad someone cleared that up.

0 coins

update us after you file! the forums here have been super helpful to me when I was going through my own bonding claim, rooting for a smooth approval for you

0 coins

Will definitely report back. Filed the PFL bonding claim about an hour ago in SDI Online. Receipt number saved. Fingers crossed the determination comes back differently than the disability one did.

0 coins

Receipt number saved is the right move. Hold onto it in case the doctor's office or anyone needs it later, even on a bonding claim.

0 coins

good luck, the wait for that first notice is the worst part anyway

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure