Back to California Paid Family Leave

Effie Alexander

California EDD paid family leave eligibility $300 wages subject to SDI versus amount withheld — does it matter which?

So I've been going back and forth on this and I can't figure out if I'm reading the EDD website wrong. I'm planning to file for PFL bonding leave when my baby arrives in February and I keep seeing two different things mentioned: wages subject to SDI and the amount actually withheld. My paystubs show CASDI withheld each pay period, but my job also has some kind of supplemental stipend that I'm not sure SDI is taken out of. I want to make sure I actually qualify before I count on this money because we're really banking on it. Does EDD look at whether you earned at least $300 that had SDI taken out, or do they look at how much SDI was withheld? Because those could be different numbers on my situation and I'm panicking a little.

About six weeks into my care claim for my dad I realized I had no idea how many of my eight weeks I had left, since I'd taken a few days here and there over the summer. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to reach someone at EDD, because I'd tried the 1-877-238-4373 line maybe a dozen mornings and gotten the busy signal or the "call volume too high" recording every single time. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly how many of the eight weeks were still available within my 12-month period, and also confirmed the date that period closes. That was the specific thing I needed and there was no guessing after that. Anyway, to actually answer the question here: EDD's minimum is $300 in wages that SDI was withheld from, meaning the wages themselves have to be subject to SDI, so the $300 threshold is about those wages, not about the dollar amount of the deduction. If that stipend doesn't have CASDI taken out, it probably doesn't count toward the $300. Worth verifying with EDD or your HR if you're unsure about that stipend.

0 coins

The weeks-remaining question is exactly what I needed answered on my claim too. Used Claimyr as well, and once the agent told me I had three weeks left in my period I went straight into SDI Online and checked what the DE 2500E showed for the first payment.

0 coins

been trying that line since monday, four mornings, same recording each time. good to know thats an option

0 coins

Appreciate the detail on the $300. So the question is really whether my stipend has CASDI withheld, not whether SDI was taken out of some other portion of my pay. I'll check with HR this week.

0 coins

The $300 figure is about wages that were subject to SDI deductions, not the total amount that was withheld. So if you earned $300 or more in a quarter where CASDI appeared on your paystubs, that box is checked. The actual dollar amount taken out of your check doesn't have to reach any particular number, it just has to come from at least $300 in eligible wages. The base period EDD uses goes back quite a ways, 5 to 18 months before your claim starts, so your highest quarter in that window is what they look at.

0 coins

Wait, so the base period could include wages from before this current job? I've had two jobs in the last year and a half.

0 coins

Potentially yes, if wages from both fall in that 5-to-18-month window and both had CASDI withheld, EDD can consider them. Your Notice of Computation will show what they used.

0 coins

I think I was confusing this, I kept reading the eligibility page and thinking the $300 meant how much EDD took from me, not how much I earned. Good to know I was misreading it.

0 coins

CASDI on your paystub is the whole thing. If it's there, that paycheck's wages count. If it isn't, they don't. Pretty simple.

0 coins

yeah exactly, my first check from a new gig didnt have casdi and i almost panicked thinking i wasnt covered

0 coins

Always check every paystub when you start somewhere new. Some gig setups don't withhold it and then you find out the hard way.

0 coins

The stipend question is worth a quick call to HR before you assume either way. Some supplemental pay at certain companies is excluded from SDI withholding for reasons that aren't obvious from the paystub label alone. If HR confirms it's not subject to SDI, those dollars just don't go toward your $300 minimum.

0 coins

HR kind of gave me a vague answer, they said "it depends on how payroll codes it." I might just have to look at every paystub myself and see if CASDI appears on the lines for the stipend.

0 coins

If the stipend shows up on its own line and CASDI isn't deducted from it, that's your answer right there. The paystub won't lie.

0 coins

My salon gives me a service charge split that one quarter didn't have CASDI on it and I didn't even notice until I filed. EDD only counted the base wage for that period, not the whole amount.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the base period EDD calculates your benefit from is four calendar quarters, taken from about 5 to 18 months before your leave starts. So for a February claim, the quarters they'd pull from go back to roughly early-to-mid 2025 at the furthest end. Any quarter in that range where you had at least $300 subject to CASDI clears the threshold. Your actual weekly benefit amount comes from whichever of those quarters had your highest wages.

0 coins

February start means I should actually map out which quarters that covers. I had a gap between jobs last spring, wondering if that knocks anything out.

0 coins

A gap doesn't erase the other quarters. EDD looks at the highest single quarter, so as long as you hit $300 in wages with CASDI in at least one quarter of that period, you meet the minimum.

0 coins

I didn't know it was just the highest quarter, I thought they averaged everything. That's actually better for me if I had one strong quarter.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline to file after leave starts is the one that caught me off guard on my own claim. I assumed I had more time and I nearly missed it. Claimyr was the only way I actually reached a live person at EDD after the hold times defeated me for two weeks straight. The agent confirmed my claim's start date and walked me through exactly where I stood relative to the 41 days. For the question here, what I'd add is that the EDD eligibility page at edd.ca.gov is careful to say 'wages subject to SDI tax,' not 'SDI withheld,' and that's the distinction the original question is picking up on. The wages have to be in the subject-to category; the deduction amount is just a byproduct of that.

0 coins

Honestly I don't believe you got through on that line. I've called probably eight times over two weeks and every single time I get the recording telling me to try again. What morning did you even call.

0 coins

It was a Tuesday around 8:15. I didn't call in the usual way, I used Claimyr so it handled the hold while I was at my desk, and then I was talking to an EDD agent. That's the only reason I actually got through rather than hitting the same wall again.

0 coins

I had the same frustration as the person doubting it, tried Tuesday mornings three weeks running, nothing. But I tried Claimyr on mine and the agent told me my DE 2580GF for the intermittent days I'd been reporting was received and matched to the right weeks. That was a relief because I was not sure the form had made it.

0 coins

The 'subject to SDI tax' wording is exactly what was confusing me. I kept reading 'SDI withheld' in some places and 'subject to SDI' in others and thought they meant different things.

0 coins

EDD's whole eligibility setup assumes everyone has a normal W-2 job. Gig workers, people with mixed income streams, anyone with a stipend on the side, the $300 thing sounds easy until you realize your situation doesn't fit the standard picture neatly.

0 coins

facts, i had three different 1099s one year and had to piece together which gigs even withheld casdi

0 coins

And they don't make it easy to figure out in advance. You file and then find out after the Notice of Computation what they actually counted.

0 coins

Two jobs plus a stipend is a lot to track, anyway. If you can pull all your paystubs from roughly early 2025 through whenever your leave starts and just look at every line that says CASDI, those are your eligible wages. Add them up by quarter and see where you land.

0 coins

Going to do exactly that this weekend. I've got digital copies of everything so it shouldn't take too long.

0 coins

Mark which lines the CASDI appears on, ignore the ones it doesn't, then add those wage amounts. That'll give you a clear picture before you file, anyway.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows you what EDD actually used. File, get the notice, see if the number looks right. If it doesn't, you'll know something wasn't counted.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate. You can speculate all you want beforehand; the notice tells you what actually happened.

0 coins

True. I guess I'm just anxious because I want to know before filing whether I'm even going to qualify, not after.

0 coins

Reasonable to want to know. But the $300 bar is low enough that most people clear it without realizing they were worried for nothing.

0 coins

So to be clear for the original poster, PFL doesn't protect your job on its own, right? Like I went on PFL bonding last year and my stylist friend told me I was covered and then I found out EDD literally says PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. Had to look into CFRA separately for that piece.

0 coins

You're correct that PFL itself is the payment side only. Job protection is a separate question under CFRA or FMLA and depends on your employer and situation. EDD handles the PFL payment; the job question is for HR and those laws.

0 coins

Oh that's actually something I need to look into separately then. I assumed PFL covered both.

0 coins

Ask your HR specifically about CFRA. That's the California one and it's the one more workers here can use, but whether it applies to you is between you and your employer.

0 coins

I'm also filing for bonding soon and I keep second-guessing the proof of relationship part. Like, my wife is the one who gave birth, so do I still have to submit a birth certificate or does her pregnancy disability claim somehow connect to my bonding claim?

0 coins

Your claim and hers are separate. As the other parent filing for bonding, you need to provide your own proof of relationship, so yes, the birth certificate or a Declaration of Paternity works for that.

0 coins

That's exactly what tripped me up with my first kid. Thought my wife's claim would somehow cover me too. Filed separately and uploaded the birth certificate, was fine after that, anyway.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. So I file my own bonding claim in SDI Online and attach the birth certificate myself.

0 coins

If your paystubs show CASDI on the wage line, those wages count. If they don't, they don't. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

yeah man its really that straightforward, people overthink it

0 coins

Exactly. Pull the stubs, look for CASDI, done.

0 coins

The payment method question caught me completely sideways on my claim. Claimyr is what finally got me to a live agent after six straight mornings of the same 'we're experiencing high call volume' message. The agent confirmed which payment option was on file for my claim and told me direct deposit was set, which I'd chosen in SDI Online but couldn't tell if it had actually saved. That alone was worth getting through.

0 coins

Wait, what is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

You give it your info and it handles waiting on EDD's line for you, so you're just on the phone with the actual EDD agent when one picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Got it. The question I'd want answered is whether my two bonding weeks from July are going to push into the same 12-month window as the care leave I might need this fall, so I'd probably use it for that.

0 coins

For what it's worth, EDD's benefits calculator on their site gives you a pretty solid estimate of what your weekly amount might look like! You just put in your quarterly wages and it spits out a range. Really helpful for planning before the Notice of Computation actually arrives.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a calculator, finding that now. That'll at least give me a ballpark.

0 coins

Yes! Just go to edd.ca.gov and look for the PFL benefits calculator. Plug in your highest quarter wages and you'll get a rough idea of your weekly amount.

0 coins

The calculator uses the same logic EDD does, highest-quarter wages in the base period. If you know that one number you can get a pretty accurate estimate.

0 coins

Before I filed, the receipt number question stressed me out more than anything. I wasn't sure I'd saved it right from the confirmation screen. Claimyr is how I finally reached someone who could check for me, because I'd tried the phone line twice with no luck at all. The agent looked up my claim by my SSN and confirmed the receipt number on file matched what I had written down, and that EDD had the claim.

0 coins

Went through something similar. Used Claimyr on mine and the agent told me EDD had issued a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination on my claim, which explained why my payment hadn't come. I hadn't even known a DE 2514 had gone out.

0 coins

Did the agent say what the determination was for, like why EDD sent it?

0 coins

She said the notice explained the reason and that I had 30 days to appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed with it. She didn't get into the why beyond that, just said to read the notice carefully.

0 coins

The base period question comes up a lot and the short version is: EDD looks back 5 to 18 months before your claim's start date, takes the four calendar quarters in that window, and your weekly benefit is calculated from whichever quarter had your highest SDI-subject wages. The $300 minimum just has to be met somewhere in that period.

0 coins

So if my highest quarter was last spring when I was at my old job, that could actually be the one they use even though I've since moved on?

0 coins

Correct, as long as that quarter falls within the base period window and your wages there were subject to SDI. Your old employer's wages don't disappear just because you changed jobs.

0 coins

This helped me too, I didn't realize a past job could be the one that determines your benefit amount. My highest-paying quarter was at a job I left eighteen months ago and EDD still counted it.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. I want to flag this because a few patients have come to me thinking they lose the first week unpaid like with disability. That's disability insurance, not PFL. Bonding benefits can start from day one of leave.

0 coins

I definitely thought there was a waiting week. Good to know bonding doesn't have that.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I filed last year! My coworker told me I'd lose the first week and I almost planned around that.

0 coins

Disability Insurance has the seven-day unpaid waiting period. PFL does not. EDD is clear on that distinction. The two programs are related but that rule is different between them.

0 coins

Realizing I never looked closely at which paystub lines had CASDI and which didn't. Going to do that tonight because I have a care claim coming up for my mom and I want to know where I stand before I file lol.

0 coins

Good idea to do it now. If you're unsure about any line item, HR payroll can usually tell you in one email whether a particular pay type is SDI-subject.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll email them before the end of the week.

0 coins

One more thing on the two-jobs situation: if both employers were withholding CASDI, you can potentially use wages from both in the base period. EDD combines them. The person earlier asking about their old job, that's the same idea. It all goes into the highest-quarter calculation.

0 coins

So I'm not penalized for changing jobs during the base period. Both sets of wages, as long as CASDI was withheld on each, go into the pool.

0 coins

Right, it's your wages in the period that matter, not which single employer they came from.

0 coins

didnt know that either, assumed it was just your current job. good to know

0 coins

File on time. That 41-day window from when your leave starts is the one deadline that bites people. If you miss it, you can lose some of those days. File the day leave starts if you can.

0 coins

Filing the same day feels fast but I'll put a reminder on my phone the moment I know my start date.

0 coins

Filing right at the start is the safest move. You can file in SDI Online and it doesn't take long once you have your info ready.

0 coins

Don't sit on it. That's the only advice that matters on timing.

0 coins

Sounds like you've got a pretty clear picture now. The CASDI lines on your paystubs are the ones that count, your highest-quarter wages in the base period determine the benefit, and the $300 is about those subject wages, not the deduction total. Hope February goes smoothly for you.

0 coins

Thank you, this thread answered questions I didn't even know I had. HR conversation and paystub audit are both on my list for this week.

0 coins

Filed my own bonding claim last month and had the same mix of questions. It gets clearer once you've looked at every paystub once.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure