California EDD paid family leave denied unable to determine when you began providing care — what does that even mean?
I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail last week and I'm honestly confused and panicking a little. The denial reason said paid family leave denied unable to determine when you began providing care, and I don't understand what I did wrong. I filed my care claim in SDI Online for my mom back in October. She's been having a really hard time health-wise and I've been taking her to appointments and staying with her during the day while my dad works. I completed all five sections online, and I'm pretty sure Part C and Part D both went in. My receipt number is on the confirmation page I saved. The letter came with an Appeal Form DE 1000A and says I have 30 days to appeal, but I want to understand what they're actually asking for before I do anything. Did anyone else get a denial like this? Is the leave start date what they couldn't figure out, or is something missing from the Part D? I don't want to miss the appeal window while I'm trying to sort this out.
81 comments

Ana Rusula
Part D not received in time was the exact status on my care claim two months ago, same kind of situation, caring for a family member. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD's Paid Family Leave line and an agent pulled up my claim right there. She confirmed Part D had been received but that the leave start date on Part D and the date I'd entered in SDI Online didn't match, so the system flagged it as incomplete. That mismatch is probably what's behind your denial too. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
Three mornings I tried that line before 8:05, got the recording every time. How does anyone actually reach a person there?
0 coins
Fidel Carson
The start date mismatch is exactly what worried me on my own claim. Used Claimyr too, and once the agent confirmed my Notice of Computation had been issued and showed the weekly amount, I went back and checked my SDI Online confirmation to make sure everything lined up with what I'd entered.
0 coins
Xan Dae
The denial language about being unable to determine when care began almost always points to the leave start date being unclear or missing from Part D. The physician fills in the certification, but if they left the start date blank or wrote something vague, EDD can't pin down when your leave actually began. That's what triggers this particular denial reason.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorSo it's likely the doctor's section, not anything I filled in myself? I really thought I'd done everything right on the SDI Online side.
0 coins
Xan Dae
Exactly right. Part D is the physician's certification, so the doctor's office controls what goes in those fields. It's worth calling them to ask what date they listed as the start of your care leave before you file the appeal.
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
This happened to a neighbor of mine too. The doctor's office had filled in the date they last saw the patient instead of when the family member actually started providing care. Easy mix-up, but EDD needs that specific date to figure out the claim period.
0 coins
Thais Soares
Appeal it. 30 days goes fast. Don't sit on the DE 1000A waiting to fully understand everything first.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorFiling the appeal while I'm still getting information, is that okay? I don't want to appeal and then not have my ducks in a row.
0 coins
Thais Soares
You appeal to protect the window. You can still gather info after. Missing the 30 days is worse than appealing without everything perfect.
0 coins
Nalani Liu
I didn't know you could appeal while still figuring things out. I sort of assumed you had to have all the answers before you filed the DE 1000A. Good to know, not sure I would have done that on my own.
0 coins
Axel Bourke
41 days surprised me when I first read the rules. The leave start date has to be established within that window from when care actually began, not from when you filed. If the Part D your doctor submitted left the start date unclear or inconsistent, EDD can't confirm your claim falls inside the 41-day filing period either, which compounds the denial reason.
0 coins
Ana Rusula
That's a really important point about the 41 days counting from when care started, not the filing date. It means the date on Part D matters for two different things at once.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorWait, so even if I appeal, if the start date on Part D is off and it now puts me outside 41 days from when care actually started, could I lose benefits for those early days even after a successful appeal?
0 coins
Xan Dae
That's a question for EDD directly on your specific situation. What these facts say is that the 41 days runs from the day your leave began, so getting the correct start date on Part D and into EDD's hands is exactly what the appeal process is for.
0 coins
Aidan Percy
edd denies claims for 'unable to determine' reasons all the time and it almost always means a date is missing or illegible on Part D. had the same thing happen on a care claim for my father-in-law. the doctor's office forgot to date one of the fields and edd kicked the whole thing back.
0 coins
Fernanda Marquez
Ugh, so the doctor's office makes an error and the person taking unpaid time off pays the price. That is so frustrating.
0 coins
Aidan Percy
yeah pretty much. called the office, they re-submitted Part D in SDI Online with the corrected date and the receipt number. appeal still went through just to be safe.
0 coins
Norman Fraser
re-submitting Part D actually works? i thought once edd denied it you just had to appeal and start over
0 coins
Fernanda Marquez
My care claim for my grandmother got denied for something similar last year and I will say, once I got on the phone with an actual EDD agent it got sorted pretty quickly. The hard part was getting through to a person.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorHow long did it take once you got someone on the line? I've been calling in the morning and just getting a recording.
0 coins
Fernanda Marquez
Once I had an agent it was maybe 15 minutes? They pulled up everything and told me exactly which date was the problem. The getting through part was the battle.
0 coins
Kendrick Webb
Mornings, afternoons, tried both. The recording doesn't care what time it is.
0 coins
Axel Bourke
Payment issued October 31st was what I needed to confirm, because my bank hadn't posted it yet and I wasn't sure if the problem was EDD or the deposit method. Claimyr is what I ended up using to reach a live agent, and she confirmed that date and that all my eligible weeks had been issued. Helped me stop worrying about a problem that didn't exist.
0 coins
Thais Soares
That sounds like something that just tells you what you want to hear. I tried that line eight times in two weeks. Can't imagine anything actually gets you through.
0 coins
Axel Bourke
The agent told me the exact dates each week had been paid and confirmed the amount matched my Notice of Computation. She worked for EDD, not for a service. I had the same doubt before I tried it.
0 coins
Hattie Carson
Agent gave me which weeks were paid and when the next disbursement was due on my care claim. Useful to have that confirmed in writing after the call.
0 coins
Thais Soares
Alright, might give it a shot. My claim has been sitting for three weeks and I can't tell if anything's actually moved.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
You got 30 days on that appeal window, not 30 business days. Calendar days. Count from the date on the determination letter, not the day it showed up in your mailbox.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorThe letter is dated a week ago and I just got it Saturday. So I've already burned a week of that window.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
Then file the appeal online today if you can. Don't wait for the perfect answer.
0 coins
Nalani Liu
I didn't realize the 30 days started from the letter date, not when I received it. That detail would have really caught me off guard.
0 coins
Dyllan Nantx
your doctor's office can resubmit Part D in SDI Online using your receipt number, they don't have to mail a whole new form. give them that number off your confirmation page and ask them to include the specific start date you gave EDD when you filed.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorI saved that confirmation page, so I do have the receipt number. I'll contact the office tomorrow and see if they can submit it online.
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
Yep, the receipt number is the key there. It links the new Part D submission directly to your existing claim so it doesn't float around unmatched.
0 coins
Norman Fraser
my aunt had this exact denial reason on a care claim for my grandpa. edd said they couldnt determine the start date. turned out her doctor dated Part D from when my grandpas condition got officially diagnosed, not when she actually started taking time off work to care for him. those are two different dates and edd needs the second one.
0 coins
Xan Dae
That distinction is exactly right. Part D should reflect when the claimant began losing wages to provide care, not when the medical condition began or when the patient received a diagnosis.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorThis is really helpful. I started taking her to appointments in early October but she'd been unwell since summer. I need to make sure the Part D date matches October, not some earlier date related to her diagnosis.
0 coins
Norman Fraser
yeah tell the doctors office exactly what date you first missed work to care for her. that's the number that needs to be on Part D
0 coins
Aidan Percy
Had four weeks left in my 12-month window and no idea because I'd used some PFL earlier in the year for my baby. I went through Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and the agent confirmed exactly how many of the eight weeks I'd used and how many were still available in that period. Didn't realize the bonding and care weeks all count from the same eight.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Wait what is Claimyr, I keep seeing it mentioned. Does it actually get you a live person or is it one of those things that just puts you on hold anyway?
0 coins
Aidan Percy
It waits out the EDD line so your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's really all it does. You're on the phone with an actual EDD employee when it connects.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Oh interesting. I'd want to ask about my own claim, whether the Part D my wife's doctor sent for her mom ever got matched to our file. been trying that line for a week with nothing, anyway.
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
The eight weeks total for everything is something most people don't realize until they've already used some. Glad you caught it before you assumed you had a full eight left.
0 coins
Anna Xian
Before you appeal, write down a clear timeline: the date your mom's care need began, the date you first missed work to provide care, and what date you put in SDI Online when you filed. Then get the doctor's office to confirm what date they entered on Part D. Any gap between those numbers is the 'unable to determine' problem.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorThis is a good checklist. I'm going to do exactly this before I call the doctor's office and before I write anything in the appeal.
0 coins
Xan Dae
The appeal is also the place to explain the timeline in your own words, so doing that work ahead of time helps you write a clear, specific statement to include with the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Nalani Liu
Forty-one days running from the actual start of care, not from when I filed, that number surprised me too on my own claim. I ended up calling EDD and I went through Claimyr to get a live agent. She looked at my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file matched what I'd entered, and that I was still inside the 41-day window when I filed. That date confirmation took a lot of weight off.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Used Claimyr on mine and I'll say it did what it said. Agent found the DE 2500E had been issued for my care claim, confirmed the payment info on it. I hadn't been sure if it had even gone out yet.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
The DE 2500E going out is such a relief when you're waiting! Did they say if that meant payment was actually on its way?
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Agent said it had been issued. Didn't go further than that on the timing, but seeing it confirmed on the claim was enough for me.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorKnowing the start date EDD has on file matches what I entered would really help me here too. That's one of the things I want to verify before I write my appeal statement.
0 coins
Hattie Carson
Part D has a field for the start date of the patient's need for care and a separate field for when the claimant's leave began. Doctors sometimes fill in the first and skip the second. EDD needs both.
0 coins
Xan Dae
That's a really important detail. Even if the physician fills in the medical condition dates perfectly, leaving the leave start date blank gives EDD nothing to anchor the claim period to.
0 coins
Norman Fraser
so the form has two different date fields and both have to be filled in? the doctors office probably didnt realize that
0 coins
Hattie Carson
Correct. Ask them specifically about the leave start date field, not just the diagnosis or treatment start date.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
The DE 1000A for appealing is pretty short actually! It's a one-page form and you can submit it online through SDI Online. You just describe what you believe is incorrect about the determination and ask for a hearing. You don't need a lawyer or anything formal at this stage.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorI didn't realize I could file the appeal in SDI Online. I was about to mail the paper form but doing it online would be faster.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
Either way works. Online is faster to confirm receipt. Keep a copy of whatever you submit.
0 coins
Kendrick Webb
Care claims with a date mismatch almost always come back as 'unable to determine.' EDD isn't saying you didn't provide care. They're saying the paperwork doesn't prove when. That's fixable.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorThat framing actually helps. It's a documentation gap, not a judgment that I wasn't actually caring for her.
0 coins
Fernanda Marquez
Exactly. And the appeal process is specifically designed for situations where the supporting documents just need to be corrected or added to. It's not like you're starting from scratch.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Part C, did your mom complete and mail that? I know Part D gets all the attention but Part C is the care recipient's statement and it has to go in by mail too. if that one's missing EDD might also be unclear on dates.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorI helped her fill out Part C and she mailed it in. I assumed it got there but I never confirmed it was received. I should check on that too.
0 coins
Xan Dae
You can ask EDD to confirm whether Part C is showing as received on your claim. That's one of the things an agent can verify when you reach them.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
yeah don't assume mailed means received, anyway. worth a quick check before the appeal window closes
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
just to close the loop on the waiting period confusion I've seen elsewhere, PFL doesn't have one. there are no seven unpaid days before benefits start the way disability insurance does. if someone told you to expect that gap, that's for a different program.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorSomeone at work told me there were seven days I'd have to wait and I've been bracing for that. So that's actually not right for PFL?
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
Right, no waiting period for PFL. The seven-day unpaid period is for Disability Insurance, which is a separate claim. For a PFL care claim, benefits start from the first day of your approved leave.
0 coins
Nalani Liu
I had the exact same mix-up. I thought the waiting period applied to everything under SDI and it doesn't. PFL is different on that one.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
October 3rd through October 10th, that was my first week of care leave, and my Part D showed October 7th because that was the doctor's appointment date. EDD sent the same denial. The fix was getting the physician to correct the start date and resubmit with my receipt number.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorThis matches what I think happened on my claim. The first real care day was different from the first appointment I took her to. I'll bring this up when I call the doctor's office.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
Exactly. The start of care isn't necessarily the first appointment date. It's the first day you couldn't do your regular work because of the caregiving.
0 coins
Dyllan Nantx
lol EDD really expects everyone to know that distinction. Like of course your doctor writes the appointment date, that's the only date they know.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
filed care claim in september. doctor submitted Part D but put the wrong start date. EDD denied it, same wording as yours. appeal is still pending but I resubmitted Part D with the corrected date.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorHow long has your appeal been pending? I want to get a sense of the timeline.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
six weeks now. no hearing date yet. just waiting.
0 coins
Ana Rusula
Filing the corrected Part D alongside the appeal is the right move. It gives EDD the documentation they need and also shows you're addressing exactly what the denial cited.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
the denial doesn't mean you're out of benefits, it means the paperwork is incomplete. appeal it, correct Part D, make sure the dates match what you entered in SDI Online. that's the full fix.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
AuthorOkay. Appeal filed, Part D corrected, dates aligned. That's my action plan. Thank you all, this thread has been genuinely useful.
0 coins
Thais Soares
Good. Keep copies of everything you send.
0 coins