Back to California Paid Family Leave

Andre Moreau

Are SDI and PFL paid from the same claim balance? Confused about my benefits

I've been going back and forth on this and I'm honestly not sure I understand how it works. I'm on a pregnancy disability claim right now and my due date is in a few weeks. Someone at work told me that once I switch to bonding, the PFL weeks get taken out of the same pool as my disability weeks, like there's one big bucket of time you draw from. That doesn't sound right to me but I genuinely don't know. Are SDI and PFL paid from the same claim balance, or are they totally separate? I'm trying to figure out how many weeks I'd actually have for bonding after the disability part ends. I don't want to plan eight weeks with the baby and then find out I only have like three left because disability already used some of them.

They're separate programs. Your pregnancy disability claim is DI, the other one is PFL. Different claim, different balance. DI covers your own body; PFL bonding is for time with the baby after. The eight weeks of PFL don't get eaten into by however long your disability ran.

0 coins

So whatever my disability weeks were, those don't count against the eight weeks of PFL at all? That's the part I kept second-guessing.

0 coins

Correct. Two separate buckets, as you put it. File the PFL bonding claim after disability ends and you have the full eight weeks available.

0 coins

Came here with the same question. Good to have it spelled out plainly.

0 coins

The 41-day window on my bonding claim had me in a full panic earlier this year. Baby arrived February 3rd and I didn't realize the clock on filing PFL starts from whenever your bonding leave begins, not from some later date. I tried EDD's line for three mornings straight and either hit a busy signal or got cut off after holding for a while. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to a live agent the same day. She looked up my claim's exact start date and confirmed I still had a few days left in the 41-day window. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent also walked me through where to file in SDI Online so I didn't lose those weeks.

0 coins

Pardon me for asking, but what exactly is Claimyr? I've never come across it and I'm trying to figure out whether Part D from my mother's doctor has been received. I'd be calling about that specifically.

0 coins

It handles the hold time for you so when a live EDD person picks up, your phone rings. You're on with a real agent without sitting through the whole wait yourself. For a Part D question that sounds exactly like what it's for.

0 coins

That does clarify it, thank you. I'd want to ask whether the Part D her specialist mailed three weeks ago has been matched to my receipt number. I may give it a try.

0 coins

Wait, so the 41 days runs from when bonding leave starts, not from the birth date? Those could be different days if you kept working a bit after delivery?

0 coins

Yes, they can be different. The clock is from the first day you're actually off work for bonding. Worth checking that date carefully when you file.

0 coins

My sister kept insisting the disability weeks and the PFL weeks were all one pile and that freaked me out before I had my second. Turns out she was mixing up two different things completely. DI is its own claim, PFL is its own claim, and you file them back to back, not instead of each other.

0 coins

That's exactly what happened at my job too, the person telling me this stuff meant well but clearly had it mixed up.

0 coins

Honestly it's such a confusing system that I don't blame anyone for getting it wrong. Just glad forums like this exist so you can double-check.

0 coins

Just to be clear because I see this question a ton: SDI during your pregnancy is DI. PFL bonding after is PFL. Neither one drains the other. The only place eight weeks gets shared is WITHIN PFL itself, meaning if you use some PFL weeks for a care claim and then want bonding with a later baby in the same 12 months, those weeks add up to eight total, not eight each. That part trips people up.

0 coins

Oh that's actually really useful. So the eight weeks is a combined limit across all PFL reasons in one 12-month stretch?

0 coins

Exactly. Bond for five weeks this year, you've got three left for a care claim if something comes up, not a fresh eight.

0 coins

Didn't know that part about the shared pool across claim types. Good to know before I plan anything.

0 coins

The eight-weeks-each rumor is everywhere and it's wrong. Glad someone said it here.

0 coins

Okay so I think I have this straight now but can I ask a dumb question. When you say file the PFL claim after disability ends, do you file it like right when you get the last disability payment or is there a form EDD sends you as the birth mother? I've heard something about a special form for moms?

0 coins

EDD mails new mothers a DE 2501FP, the Paid Family Leave form specifically for new mothers. You fill it out and send it back within 41 days of when your bonding leave starts. No extra documents are needed with that one, which is nice.

0 coins

And I shouldn't just file a regular PFL claim online in SDI Online instead, right? I should wait for that paper form?

0 coins

The DE 2501FP is the right path for a birth mother coming off disability. Submit it within your 41 days and you're set.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP being no extra docs is such a relief! Dads and partners have to get the birth certificate or the paternity declaration together, so the birth mom form is definitely the easier one.

0 coins

Eight weeks is eight weeks and it doesn't matter which claim it came from, PFL or disability. Those are two different programs. Nobody at EDD is subtracting your pregnancy leave from your bonding leave. File your bonding claim when disability ends and you'll see the full eight weeks sitting there.

0 coins

That's the clearest version of this answer I've seen. Period.

0 coins

EDD gets a lot wrong. This particular thing they actually got right: fully separate.

0 coins

my coworker told me the same thing about one big pool and i almost didnt file for pfl at all because i thought id used it up on disability. filed anyway and got the full bonding weeks no problem

0 coins

That's really reassuring honestly. I keep almost not filing because I'm afraid of getting denied or finding out the weeks are gone.

0 coins

just file it, worst they say is no and then you can appeal if you think theyre wrong

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the debit card had me confused when my care claim processed earlier this year. The status in SDI Online didn't tell me which one was coming, and I'd filed on paper so I wasn't sure I could switch. I called the EDD Paid Family Leave line through Claimyr and got an agent who pulled up the claim and told me it was set for the debit card because paper claims default that way, but that I could update to direct deposit if I logged into myEDD. She told me the debit card is issued through Money Network, which I hadn't heard before. That detail about the payment method being changeable was worth the whole call.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for intermittent days a few months back when my DE 2580GF didn't seem to match up with what EDD had on file. Agent looked at the claim and confirmed they'd received the form and that the days I'd reported were showing correctly. Felt a lot better after that call.

0 coins

Did they say anything about timing for when the payment would actually post after those intermittent days were confirmed?

0 coins

She said payments for those days would process once EDD finished reviewing the certification, didn't give me a date but at least I knew the form was there.

0 coins

Direct deposit only works on SDI Online claims, not paper ones, good detail. Didn't know about Money Network being the card issuer either, I always thought it was Bank of America still.

0 coins

Agent specifically said Money Network. I'd been telling people Bank of America for two years based on an old claim, so I had to correct myself.

0 coins

Every time I see this SDI vs PFL confusion I feel like EDD should just put a giant banner somewhere that says THESE ARE TWO DIFFERENT CLAIMS. The overlap in names makes it so easy to assume they come from the same pot.

0 coins

The State Disability Insurance umbrella covers both programs and that's what confuses everyone. PFL is under SDI but it's its own separate claim balance. EDD's own site explains it but honestly who reads all that before they're already panicking.

0 coins

Nobody reads it lol. You only go digging when you're already worried you messed something up.

0 coins

I went through three weeks of thinking I had to choose between using disability time OR PFL time and that they'd cancel each other out. My wife set me straight eventually. We both filed separate PFL bonding claims and they were fully independent of her disability claim. Anyway the main thing is you don't have to pick one, you get both in sequence.

0 coins

Wait you said you both filed PFL bonding claims. So each parent files their own claim separately?

0 coins

Yes, each parent files their own. My wife filed hers for her weeks and I filed mine for my weeks. We just couldn't take them at the exact same time and have them overlap in a weird way, anyway.

0 coins

each parent files separately is the part nobody tells you until you stumble on a thread like this

0 coins

My receipt number situation was a mess when I first filed. The confirmation screen in SDI Online showed a number and then I lost it and panicked thinking I had no way to track anything. I spent two mornings trying EDD's line before I tried Claimyr and got someone on the phone. The agent found my claim right away, confirmed the receipt number and told me which documents were still showing as not received so I could follow up with the doctor's office. Saved me from sending things in twice or to the wrong place.

0 coins

The idea of a third-party service getting you to an EDD agent reads like marketing to me. EDD's own contact form exists for a reason.

0 coins

Ask EDD worked for me once and took eleven days. Had a question about a DE 2514 I got in the mail and by the time they answered I'd already figured it out and filed an appeal on my own. So honestly the form has its limits.

0 coins

Eleven days is rough. I may reconsider if my current question about the DE 2514 denial I got doesn't get answered faster than that.

0 coins

What is on a DE 2514 exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I don't know if I'll get one.

0 coins

It's the notice EDD sends when they decide you're not eligible. Has an appeal form attached, DE 1000A, and you have 30 days from the date on it to appeal.

0 coins

For anyone still uncertain after reading through this: the Notice of Computation, the DE 429DF, that arrives separately for each claim. Your disability claim and your PFL bonding claim will each have their own notice showing the weekly benefit amount for that claim. Finding two separate notices in the mail is normal, not a sign something went wrong.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I was going to panic the first time I saw a second notice thinking they'd opened something wrong.

0 coins

Same. I did not know there would be two. Good heads up.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation doesn't confirm eligibility either, just so you know. It shows what you could receive if approved, not that you're approved.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. You get disability for the pregnancy, file PFL after, full eight weeks waiting. EDD isn't combining balances across the two programs.

0 coins

Short and correct. This is the answer.

0 coins

I was so stressed reading about the 41-day deadline before I had my son. I kept wondering does it start from the birth, from when disability ends, from the first day I'm technically on bonding leave. It's the first day of bonding leave, which could be the day after disability ends or whenever you stop working if there was no disability claim first.

0 coins

So if disability ends March 1st and bonding starts March 2nd, the 41 days is running from March 2nd?

0 coins

That's how I understand it, yes. The first day of your bonding leave is day one of the 41-day window.

0 coins

Filing as early as you can rather than on day 40 is worth it. Gives EDD time to work on it and you room to fix anything they flag before the deadline passes.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount was lower than the EDD calculator estimated. I wanted to call and ask whether the base period they used was right, because I'd had a gap in wages one quarter that might have shifted things. The EDD line hung up on me twice at the same point in the hold queue, so I used Claimyr and got to an agent. She went through the base period quarters on my claim and read me the wages they had on file for each one. Turned out one quarter had the right wages and I'd just miscalculated on my end. So the notice was correct.

0 coins

Did the agent tell you if there's any way to flag a base period dispute if the wages had been wrong?

0 coins

She said to appeal if I disagreed with the determination and that EDD would review the wage records. Since mine were actually correct I didn't need to, but good to know the appeal path is there.

0 coins

Been hitting that line since Tuesday and it's just not connecting. How many tries did it take you before you went to Claimyr?

0 coins

Three days, same result each time. That's when I decided the hold time wasn't something I could manage on my own between shifts.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, just so that's out there. Some people think there are seven unpaid days at the start like there used to be for disability. There aren't for PFL.

0 coins

I was literally going to ask about that next. Someone at work told me to expect the first week to be unpaid.

0 coins

Different program. That seven-day thing is DI, not PFL. File, and your first eligible day counts.

0 coins

My coworker gave me the same wrong info. The internet rumor about seven unpaid PFL days refuses to die.

0 coins

Payment timing question from me: once PFL is approved, is there any pattern to when payments come in, like every two weeks on a set day, or is it whenever EDD gets around to it?

0 coins

Claims taken all at once pay out every two weeks for the duration. Intermittent claims work differently because you're reporting days as you go and EDD issues payment based on what you've certified.

0 coins

EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of a properly completed claim being received. After that, every two weeks on a continuous claim. No guaranteed calendar date though.

0 coins

Every two weeks makes sense, I'll stop looking for a specific day. Thank you both.

0 coins

Does the PFL weekly amount change between bonding and a later care claim, or is it based on the same wages either way?

0 coins

Each claim calculates from the highest quarter in your base period at the time you file. If you file a care claim a year or two after bonding, your base period shifts and your wages might be different. The benefit amount can change.

0 coins

Makes sense. So the Notice of Computation for the care claim would show whatever the new calculation works out to.

0 coins

Exactly. Each claim's DE 429DF is its own calculation. Don't assume a later claim will match the first one.

0 coins

the pregnancy claim ending is what confused me most honestly. i thought i had to call EDD to officially switch to pfl bonding but you just file the new claim or send back the DE 2501FP they mail you. no one has to close the disability claim for you first.

0 coins

So I don't have to do anything special to close out my disability side, it just wraps up and I file PFL on my own?

0 coins

right. edd wraps the disability end date and your bonding claim starts when you say it starts. they dont need you to call and hand it off.

0 coins

That is a genuine relief. I was imagining a whole process of calling in to announce the switch.

0 coins

Random thing I got wrong early on: I thought PFL and CFRA were the same thing. PFL is the money, CFRA is the job protection. EDD handles PFL and pays you; CFRA is a separate law and your employer handles that side. You can have both running at the same time but they're not the same and EDD has nothing to do with the CFRA part.

0 coins

This distinction matters so much. If you're worried about whether your job is protected, that's a CFRA question for HR or the Civil Rights Department, not an EDD question.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way. EDD straight up told me they don't handle job protection, go talk to your employer.

0 coins

Posting an update: I went ahead and filed in SDI Online this afternoon. Got my receipt number saved this time, didn't make the mistake the person above described. The claim shows pending but I'm within the 41 days so I think I'm okay. Thank you everyone for straightening me out on the DI versus PFL balance question. I was completely wrong about how it worked and would have talked myself out of filing.

0 coins

Pending is normal for the first stretch. EDD has up to 14 days to decide eligibility, so give it a full two weeks before worrying.

0 coins

Great that you filed! Keep that receipt number somewhere obvious, you'll want it if you need to follow up with EDD about anything.

0 coins

If it goes past 14 days with no movement, the Request Claim Update in SDI Online is the right first step, then the phone line if that doesn't get a response.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure