Back to California Disability

Luca Bianchi

Why was my SDI claim denied after working another job?

I work two part-time jobs and my main one ended about three months ago. I stayed at the second job and kept going until I hurt my back badly enough that my doctor pulled me out of both. I filed my SDI claim and my doctor submitted the certification, and I honestly thought it would be straightforward. Then I got a Notice of Determination in the mail saying I was denied. I don't even understand what I did wrong. Is it because I was still working one job when the other ended? Does EDD look at both jobs when they decide if you qualify? My doctor already confirmed I can't work either one right now, so I don't know what the denial is based on. The notice mentions an appeal but I'm scared I'll mess that up too. Has anyone had a claim denied in a situation like this and figured out what went wrong?

Payment method on my claim kept showing something unexpected, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD's disability line. I'd been trying that number for three mornings straight and the line just ended the call every time, so I figured I'd try it. Ended up talking to an EDD agent, and she told me my direct deposit hadn't been confirmed because I'd set it up after the first payment had already issued to a Money Network card. She said the card was mailed and I should watch for it. Video on reaching a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

That disability line has ended my calls so many times I stopped counting. Hard to picture it going any differently regardless of what you use.

0 coins

Honestly I had the same feeling after two weeks of that. The agent picked up, confirmed the Money Network card was already in the mail, told me direct deposit only kicks in starting with the next payment once it's confirmed. So it did go differently.

0 coins

I tried Claimyr on mine too! The agent pulled up my Notice of Determination and read me exactly what reason code they'd put on it. That told me what I actually needed to include in the appeal letter. Really glad I had a name and a note from that call.

0 coins

The base period question is worth looking at closely here. EDD calculates your weekly benefit from wages in a specific 12-month window, and if most of your earnings in that window came from the job that ended, that affects what shows on the Notice of Computation. The denial might be about something else entirely though. What reason does the notice give?

0 coins

The notice says something about not meeting the wage requirement. I didn't even know there was a wage requirement separate from just having worked.

0 coins

There's a minimum amount of wages subject to SDI deductions that have to show up in your base period. If the main job wasn't withholding the CASDI deduction from your pay, those wages might not count toward the threshold.

0 coins

Oh that's a whole thing I never checked. I'm going to pull my old pay stubs and look for the CASDI line.

0 coins

Pulling the stubs from both jobs is exactly the right move. The deduction amount on each one tells you which wages EDD can count. If one employer wasn't taking it out, those paychecks may not help your claim.

0 coins

What does your Notice of Determination actually say word for word on the denial reason. That's the place to start before guessing.

0 coins

It says insufficient wages in the base period. That's all I can really make out from how it's worded.

0 coins

Then it's the wage calculation, not the medical side. Your doctor's certification isn't the issue. The money question is.

0 coins

Two part-time jobs is where things get complicated because not every employer sets up SDI withholding the same way. I had one gig where the owner just never took CASDI out, and I had no idea until I had a problem with a claim.

0 coins

Same deal happened to a guy on my crew. Employer skipped the deduction for months and the worker had no idea until he needed SDI.

0 coins

If wages weren't subject to SDI withholding, they don't count toward the base period total EDD uses. The Notice of Computation would reflect only the wages that had CASDI taken out. That's worth comparing against pay stubs from both jobs carefully.

0 coins

You can absolutely appeal this. The Notice of Determination has an appeal form right on it, the DE 1000A, and you have 30 days from the date printed on the notice to send it in. Don't let that date slip past.

0 coins

The date on mine is from two weeks ago, so I still have time. Should I attach anything to the appeal?

0 coins

Send the appeal form or a detailed letter if you can't find the form, and attach anything that supports your side, pay stubs showing the CASDI deductions, your doctor's certification, whatever feels relevant. Mail it to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

The 30 days goes fast. Send it as soon as you can.

0 coins

Medical certification timing caused my claim to stall for a while, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to find out what was actually happening. She confirmed EDD had received the certification from my doctor but it hadn't been matched to my claim yet because my doctor used a slightly different version of my name. Once that was resolved the claim moved forward.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't come across it before.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line in your place and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really it.

0 coins

That's useful to know. I've been trying to reach EDD about a DE 2593 that I sent in and I'm not sure they received it. I'd use it for that.

0 coins

The base period is the 12 months before the quarter your claim starts, and EDD uses the quarter with the highest wages in that window. If your best-earning quarter was at the main job and you had no CASDI taken out there, it's possible your qualifying wages are lower than EDD's minimum. That minimum isn't a huge number but you do have to clear it.

0 coins

So even if I earned a decent amount overall, it might not count if the deduction wasn't taken?

0 coins

Exactly right. The raw dollar amount you earned doesn't matter as much as whether SDI taxes were withheld. Only those wages are counted by EDD.

0 coins

Which is why checking every single pay stub matters. Not just one or two.

0 coins

if one job wasnt doing casdi on your checks those wages just dont exist to edd basically its like you didnt work that job at all for sdi purposes

0 coins

That's pretty much it. EDD can only count what was paid into the system.

0 coins

yeah and nobody tells you that until something goes wrong which is real fun

0 coins

The appeal window and the documentation needed are both on the Notice of Determination. If the denial is wage-related, the appeal should address which wages had CASDI withheld, with pay stubs attached for both jobs covering your entire base period.

0 coins

I'm going to gather everything from both jobs now. This is making a lot more sense. I had no idea the deduction question was so central.

0 coins

It really is the core of a wage-eligibility denial. If you can show stubs with CASDI on them that bring your total above EDD's threshold, the appeal has something solid to work with.

0 coins

I mixed up SDI and unemployment when I first got hurt and filed the wrong one, lol. If you've been trying to work unemployment into this at all while still out of work, that won't fly. You can't collect both for the same days.

0 coins

No I haven't touched unemployment. My doctor says I genuinely can't work either job right now so I know I need SDI specifically.

0 coins

Good, just wanted to flag it because I saw someone in another thread trying to do both at once and it made everything messier.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window on that notice isn't flexible unless you can show a good reason for the delay, so getting that form in the mail is the priority.

0 coins

Understood. I'm treating this week as the deadline even though I technically have more time.

0 coins

That's the right mindset. File first, refine the argument after if needed.

0 coins

late appeals can be reviewed if you explain why you were late but the bar for that is high. just get it in on time.

0 coins

Agree. Don't risk it.

0 coins

Waiting period confusion cost me days of stress on my own claim. EDD doesn't pay the first seven calendar days of a new disability claim, and I kept thinking that week was processing time and something was wrong. When I finally got through to an agent using Claimyr, she confirmed the claim was fine and those first seven days simply aren't payable under the program's rules. The benefit payments start on day eight.

0 coins

I used Claimyr on mine too and I'm glad I did. The agent told me my claim start date had been entered a day off from what I'd put on the form, which explained why the payment weeks weren't lining up with my calendar. Good to have that corrected early.

0 coins

Can I ask, did they fix the start date on the spot or did they say to expect a notice?

0 coins

She said a corrected notice would go out by mail and to watch for it. Came about a week later and the weeks lined up after that.

0 coins

The seven-day thing is really good to know. I hadn't realized there's a waiting period built into every new claim.

0 coins

base period quarter thing tripped me up too, anyway I ended up calling EDD through Claimyr after trying the number myself every morning for two weeks, it just kept cutting off. The agent looked up which quarter of my base period they'd used and it turned out to be a quarter where I'd worked fewer hours because of a family situation, so the weekly amount was lower than I expected. I went back and checked my Notice of Computation and sure enough that quarter was the one listed.

0 coins

Sounds like marketing to me. Hard to believe you just ended up talking to someone at EDD after two weeks of nothing.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first heard about it, to be honest. But I tried it after getting nowhere for days on my own. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which receipt number was on file. Mine matched what my doctor's office had used, so at least that wasn't the holdup. That part was reassuring to get confirmed.

0 coins

Alright, might give it a shot. Got questions about my own extension that I haven't been able to get answered.

0 coins

The base period quarter piece is exactly what I need to understand better for my own situation. Good to know there's a way to actually confirm which one they used.

0 coins

You filed the appeal yet? Don't sit on it.

0 coins

Pulling pay stubs tonight and sending the appeal by the end of the week.

0 coins

Good. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

If the appeal goes through and they determine you do have enough qualifying wages, the claim would go back to your original disability start date, so you wouldn't lose those weeks just because the initial decision was wrong.

0 coins

That's how it worked for a coworker of mine. The appeal covered the full original period once it was approved.

0 coins

That's really reassuring. I was worried I'd lose the weeks leading up to the denial.

0 coins

EDD's site has a benefits calculator that lets you estimate what your weekly amount should be based on your highest-paid quarter. Running your CASDI-taxed wages through it before the appeal might help you understand whether you're above or below the threshold.

0 coins

Agreed. Even a rough estimate from the calculator tells you what you're working with before you write the appeal letter.

0 coins

I didn't know that calculator existed. Going to use it tonight after I pull the stubs.

0 coins

If you're still uncertain after looking at the stubs and the calculator, the SDI Online message center in myEDD lets you send a written question to EDD directly. Sometimes a written response is easier to work from than trying to reach someone by phone.

0 coins

I've used the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online for exactly that. You pick the request type, write out your question, and they respond there.

0 coins

Between the stubs, the calculator, the appeal, and that message option I actually feel like I have a plan now. Thank you all.

0 coins

Appeal sent with documentation is the whole play here. EDD has reversed wage-eligibility denials when the claimant showed stubs with CASDI deducted that the original review missed.

0 coins

Assuming the wages are actually there. If they aren't, the appeal won't fix a math problem.

0 coins

True. That's what the stubs tell you before you write a word.

0 coins

Doctors can certify through SDI Online and the claim goes to EDD automatically. If you're ever in doubt that the certification was received, the Request Claim Update option in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is the right place to ask without having to reach someone by phone.

0 coins

I didn't know the message center was an option for that. Good to file away.

0 coins

The certification matching piece is easy to miss. Even a small discrepancy in how the name appears can stall things, so confirming it went through is worth doing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure