Back to California Disability

Paolo Ricci

Why is my SDI payment less than my weekly benefit amount?

Okay so my Notice of Computation came in and it showed a certain weekly benefit amount, and I was excited because it seemed like it would cover most of my bills while I'm out recovering. Then my first actual payment hit and it was noticeably lower than what that notice said. Not like a few dollars off, but a real difference. I'm a hairstylist so I work some weeks more than others and I honestly don't totally understand how EDD calculates any of this. Did they make a mistake? Has anyone else had their payment come in lower than what the Notice of Computation said?

The Notice of Computation isn't a guarantee of what every payment will be, it shows the potential weekly amount for a full week of disability. If your first payment covered fewer than seven days, say you hit the end of the waiting period and EDD only paid you five or six days in that first check, they'd prorate it. The full weekly amount only shows up for complete payable weeks.

0 coins

Wait, so the waiting period affects the first payment amount too? I thought the seven days just meant I didn't get paid for those days at all.

0 coins

Exactly right, those seven days aren't paid, but the first payable period after them might not be a full seven days either depending on when your claim started. So that first check can look smaller than your weekly amount even when everything is correct.

0 coins

That actually makes sense now. So once the payments are in a regular rhythm it should match the notice amount for full weeks?

0 coins

For complete payable weeks with no work, yes, the amount should match what your Notice of Computation says.

0 coins

There's also the question of whether you reported any work during that period. Even a few hours back at the chair, if you logged any earnings, EDD adjusts that week's payment downward. It's not a mistake, it's how partial week pay works under SDI.

0 coins

I didn't work at all those weeks, I've been completely out. So that one doesn't apply to me but good to know for later.

0 coins

Yeah partial week stuff trips people up a lot. Especially in jobs where hours vary week to week anyway.

0 coins

November 4th showed in SDI Online as the payment date on my own claim but nothing landed in my account until the 7th, and the amount was off too. Took me a while to figure out the first payment window was split across the waiting period end. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get it sorted out. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which exact dates were included in that first payment and that nothing was missing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

November 4th and you still had to wait until the 7th AND the amount was off, I'm skeptical anything on that phone line actually reaches a person. I've tried mornings, afternoons, the line just drops me after the recording. How did you actually get through?

0 coins

Claimyr holds the line until EDD picks up, then your phone rings. That's the whole thing. Agent confirmed dates November 4 through 10 were in the first payment and the lower amount was just the prorated days after my waiting period ended.

0 coins

used claimyr for my own claim, agent told me week of october 13 and october 20 had both been paid out already, i thought one was missing but it wasn't. just landed later than i expected.

0 coins

Okay that's actually useful to know. The drop call thing has been my whole experience so I might look at it.

0 coins

December 2nd and December 9th are the two dates I always check in SDI Online when a payment looks short. Sometimes two weeks get combined into one deposit and it looks like a single smaller amount until you read the detail. Log in to myEDD, open your claim, and the payment history breaks it down by week.

0 coins

Oh I hadn't thought to look at the breakdown by week. I'll do that tonight.

0 coins

The payment detail view in SDI Online really is the clearest place to check. Each week is listed separately there, which makes it much easier to see if something is off versus just looking at the deposit total.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the same thing but I'm kind of worried because my benefit amount on the notice looked right but the payment was about sixty dollars less and I don't know if I should call EDD or just wait and see if the next one is correct. I don't want to get in trouble for asking about it if it's normal.

0 coins

Calling EDD to ask about a payment amount is completely normal. You won't get in trouble. If the second payment is the full weekly amount, the first one was probably just prorated.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring. I'll wait for the next one and see if it's the full amount.

0 coins

Had the same thing. Second payment was the full amount, first one was just the short first week.

0 coins

EDD's formula is 70 to 90 percent of your wages from the highest quarter in the base period, so if the notice says one number and your check is less, either it's the proration thing people are describing or there's something off with which quarter they used. The notice should show the base period quarter. Check it.

0 coins

My highest quarter was definitely a good one for tips and booth rent, so I'd want to make sure they used the right one.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation lists the base period quarters and which one was used for the calculation. Worth reading that section carefully because the base period is set when the claim starts and you can't change it after.

0 coins

Always read the whole notice. People toss it and then wonder why the numbers don't add up.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox after my fifth automatic payment and I almost missed the 20-day return window, nearly lost benefits over it! Once I got that sorted I used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask an agent whether my payments were back on track after returning it late. Agent told me the DE 2593 had been received and my next payment was already issued.

0 coins

Pardon me for asking, but what is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I haven't been able to reach a live person about my own DE 2593 situation.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on EDD's line in your place and rings you once a real agent is on. That's really all it does. Saved me from days more of busy signals.

0 coins

That's very helpful to know. My question is about whether my DE 2593 was received in time, which is exactly the kind of thing I'd want to ask an agent directly.

0 coins

The 20-day window on that form is real and strict. Mail it as soon as it arrives, don't set it aside.

0 coins

Base period math threw me off on my own claim. My hours are all over the place in construction and I assumed EDD would average everything out, but they just take your best single quarter. Had a solid spring quarter and that ended up being the one they used.

0 coins

Same kind of thing in warehousing. Overtime one quarter makes a big difference.

0 coins

So if I had a really good quarter with a lot of clients that might actually help my benefit amount? That's kind of good news.

0 coins

If it falls in your base period, yeah, it counts. The notice shows you exactly which quarter they picked.

0 coins

my wife had the same question when her payment came in, anyway she just checked the weekly breakdown in SDI Online and one of the weeks was only four payable days because of when the waiting period ended, that was the whole difference

0 coins

This is what I'm starting to think happened to me too. Going to look at that breakdown right now.

0 coins

yeah once she saw the breakdown it was obvious, next payment was the full amount

0 coins

edd doesnt just send you the full amount every time, the first one is almost never the full weekly amount because of the waiting period math, happened to everyone i know who filed

0 coins

That's roughly right but it's not because of anything random. The waiting period ends partway through a week and EDD pays the remaining days of that partial week, which is less than a full week.

0 coins

yeah thats what i meant, first check is just the leftover days after the 7

0 coins

Can I ask a maybe dumb question, does the waiting period count as days EDD is calculating or is it literally the first seven calendar days no matter what? Because my doctor certified me starting on a Wednesday and I don't know if weekends count or what.

0 coins

Calendar days, all seven of them, including weekends. Starting on a Wednesday means your waiting period runs Wednesday through the following Tuesday, and the first payable day is that Wednesday eight days later.

0 coins

Oh okay so weekends absolutely count. Good to know, thank you.

0 coins

Yep, all seven days straight through. No skipping weekends.

0 coins

The waiting period is per claim, not per year. If you file a new claim for a different disability later, there's another seven-day waiting period for that one too.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on my claim last spring saying I wasn't eligible, which was a shock because I thought everything was filed right. Used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line and asked what was showing on my claim. Agent read me back what was on the notice, confirmed I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal using the DE 1000A, and that was the step I needed to know.

0 coins

Got through EDD with Claimyr on my end too, asked the agent which quarter of the base period they used for my claim. Turned out they had my Q3 from last year, which wasn't my highest, and I wanted to understand why before I decided anything.

0 coins

Which quarter ended up being the right one for your situation?

0 coins

Agent said the base period is set by the claim start date and that Q3 was correct for when I filed. Wasn't what I hoped to hear but at least I understood it.

0 coins

30 days on the appeal goes fast. File the DE 1000A as soon as you know you're disputing it.

0 coins

Payment method matters here too. Direct deposit lands faster than the Money Network card in some cases, and if the deposit shows before EDD's payment detail updates in SDI Online you might see the amount without the breakdown yet. Check the detail view after the full day, not the morning the deposit hits.

0 coins

I have direct deposit set up so the timing might be part of why I saw a number before seeing the full breakdown.

0 coins

Exactly. Give it until end of day and the weekly breakdown usually populates.

0 coins

Hairstylists and booth renters sometimes have the wage reporting question too, worth making sure your W-2 wages or reported income actually had the CASDI deduction taken out or your base period wages might not be what you think.

0 coins

I do have CASDI on my paystubs from the salon, yes. I'm an employee there not renting a booth so that should be fine.

0 coins

Good, then your wages are in the system. You're in the clear on that part.

0 coins

the notice amount is just the ceiling, what you actually get depends on the week. learned that the hard way first claim.

0 coins

Ceiling is a good way to put it.

0 coins

And it's your ceiling for full weeks. Partial weeks at the start and potentially at the end of a claim can both be less than that amount.

0 coins

Honestly I thought the Notice of Computation was like an approval letter the first time I got one lol. It's not, it's just showing you the math. Actual approval comes through when payments start or if you get a Notice of Determination.

0 coins

Wait I thought the same thing! So the Notice of Computation doesn't mean you're approved?

0 coins

Nope, it's just the calculation of your potential amount. You know you're approved when money actually shows up or when EDD sends a determination letter.

0 coins

That's correct. The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts based on your wages. It doesn't confirm eligibility. A denial comes as a Notice of Determination with the appeal form attached.

0 coins

Follow-up worry: if EDD paid me less than the notice amount for a week where I definitely didn't work, should I do something to flag it or does EDD catch their own errors?

0 coins

EDD doesn't automatically fix payment amounts on their own if something's off. Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online or call the disability line at 1-800-480-3287 to ask what that specific week included.

0 coins

Okay I'll check the SDI Online breakdown first and then call if the numbers still don't match up.

0 coins

The disability line is 1-800-480-3287 and good luck getting through before lunch. I've sat on that number three mornings in a row and been dropped every time before even getting to hold.

0 coins

Afternoons aren't better. I've tried both.

0 coins

It's the same recording and then nothing no matter when I try.

0 coins

took me six tries over two days to get a person, anyway once I did they answered the question in like two minutes

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the base period, the Notice of Computation lists those quarters by date. EDD takes the highest-paid quarter from a 12-month period that started 5 to 18 months before your claim began. The estimate tool on EDD's site can help you check the math before you even file.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site is really useful for this. You put in your quarterly wages and it shows you the estimate.

0 coins

I'll run my numbers through that to see if what the notice says matches what I'd expect.

0 coins

If the notice amount and the calculator don't match up closely, that's a good reason to call EDD and ask which quarter they used.

0 coins

20-day window on the DE 2593 is not a suggestion, I want to repeat that. Missing it can suspend your payments and then you're chasing EDD to get them restarted. Return it immediately when it arrives.

0 coins

Where does it even come from, mail?

0 coins

Yes, EDD mails it after your fifth automatic payment. Watch for it around that mark.

0 coins

we almost missed it too, anyway it was sitting under other mail on the counter

0 coins

Update: I looked at the payment detail in SDI Online and it shows the first payment covered five days, not seven. Those are the days after my waiting period ended through the end of that first week. So the lower amount is exactly right for five days. Second payment shows the full weekly amount. I feel so much better knowing it wasn't an error. Thank you all!

0 coins

Five days at the prorated daily rate, that's exactly how it's supposed to work.

0 coins

Glad the breakdown made it clear. Full amount from here on out for complete weeks.

0 coins

The SDI Online detail view is underused. Most payment questions get answered right there if you know where to look.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure