Back to California Disability

Micah Trail

What workers compensation letter does SDI require when you have both claims?

Got hurt on the job back in September, shoulder injury, been off work since. Workers comp has been paying but it's not covering everything and my foreman said a few guys on our crew filed SDI alongside it. Now I'm trying to figure out what workers compensation letter does SDI require before they'll even look at your claim. Called the number three times this week, got a recording every single time. SDI Online doesn't say anything useful about it either. Anyone been through this and know what EDD actually wants from you on the workers comp side before they process the claim?

The start date on your claim took me a while to sort out on mine, so I know that piece of this can get complicated fast. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after the disability line either rang endlessly or cut me off four mornings running. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the claim's start date they had on record, which was off by two days from what I'd entered. Worth having your injury date, your first day out of work, and your workers comp paperwork in front of you before any call. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The start date piece is exactly what I need to sort out on mine. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I get through?

0 coins

Have your claim receipt number, your injury date, and the date your doctor first took you off work. The agent can tell you what date EDD has on file and whether it matches.

0 coins

I've been dialing that disability line since Tuesday. Hits a busy signal or drops me after the menu every single time. No idea how anyone actually gets through.

0 coins

EDD notes that it is not common to receive workers compensation and disability insurance for the same days, though there are exceptions. Asking EDD directly how your own case counts is the right move, since the rules on that overlap are not straightforward.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD specifically what documentation they need for your workers comp situation, because what they require can depend on the overlap between the two. EDD's own site says receiving both for the same days is not common, and that there are exceptions. They don't publish a single named letter that covers every case, so the agent is going to be your best source on what your specific claim needs.

0 coins

So there's no standard form they always want? That's what I was hoping someone could nail down.

0 coins

Not a single published requirement I could find on EDD's site. The overlap rules exist but the documentation piece seems to depend on your claim. An agent can tell you exactly what your file is missing.

0 coins

EDD rarely makes this easy to find out without calling.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If workers comp is already paying you, can you even file SDI at the same time? I thought they were the same thing basically. Or is SDI only if workers comp doesn't cover the full amount?

0 coins

They are separate programs. Workers compensation covers work-related injuries through your employer's carrier. SDI is a state program funded by the CASDI deduction on your paycheck. EDD says receiving both for the same days is not common but there are exceptions, and they decide that on a case-by-case basis.

0 coins

Okay so they can run at the same time sometimes, I didn't realize that. Does the SDI claim still have the seven-day waiting period even if you're already getting workers comp?

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period applies to every new SDI claim. Those first seven days are non-payable no matter what else you have running. The first day SDI would pay is day eight of your disability period.

0 coins

Ugh, so even if workers comp is already covering me, those seven days are just gone with SDI too. Good to know before I assume I'd get paid from day one.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is an absolute nightmare right now. I've tried before 8, right at 8, midmorning, nothing works. You just get the same recording over and over. How is anyone supposed to get answers about something this complicated?

0 coins

Tried for a week straight on mine. Mornings were worse than I expected, honestly.

0 coins

It's been rough for a while. The Request Claim Update option in SDI Online at least gets something in writing to EDD, even if it takes a few days to hear anything.

0 coins

I tried that too. Still waiting on a response from three days ago. For something like this where they might need a document from me I'd rather just talk to someone.

0 coins

My chiropractor submitted my medical certification and I had no idea there was a receipt number my doctor needed from me first. Had to go back to the office and give it to them. If you're filing SDI, make sure they have your receipt number from when you filed, or the certification won't attach to your claim right.

0 coins

Good heads up. I haven't even gotten to the medical certification part yet, still trying to figure out the workers comp piece first.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me with the receipt number. Took almost two extra weeks.

0 coins

To add to that, EDD contacts you about your claim's status usually within 14 days after the medical certification is received. If the receipt number wasn't used, the certification may not have attached, which is why the delay happens.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right thread to ask, but does SDI even cover injuries that happened at work? I thought SDI was only for like, non-work stuff. If it was a job injury wouldn't that always be just workers comp?

0 coins

EDD defines SDI as covering non-work-related illness or injury, but also says there are exceptions where both workers comp and SDI could apply. The specifics of a work injury claim are something EDD decides individually. The person above is right to be asking EDD directly.

0 coins

Yeah that's basically where I'm at. Crew guys said it can work but nobody could tell me exactly what EDD needs on paper to allow it.

0 coins

Okay so it's not automatically disqualifying. I was going to say don't even bother filing but I guess it depends on the case.

0 coins

Filed my own SDI claim after a knee surgery last year, unrelated to work. The Notice of Computation came about ten days after EDD got my medical certification. It showed my potential weekly benefit amount based on my highest-earning quarter in the base period. Didn't mean I was approved, just showed what they'd calculated.

0 coins

Wait the Notice of Computation isn't an approval? I've seen people say it is online and I was going to assume that meant everything was fine.

0 coins

Not an approval. It shows the potential weekly amount EDD calculated from your wages. You still need to wait for payments or a determination notice to know if the claim is actually payable.

0 coins

Learned that one the hard way. The notice came and I thought I was done waiting. Was not done waiting.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on mine came and the weekly amount looked wrong to me. Way lower than I expected based on what I was making. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr after getting nowhere on that phone line and the agent pulled up which quarter of my base period they used. Turned out the quarters they calculated from were earlier ones when I was working fewer hours. Nothing wrong with how they ran it, just not the quarters I would have guessed. Had my pay stubs out when I called and that helped me follow along.

0 coins

The base period quarters thing happened on my claim too. I used Claimyr as well and once the agent answered I had them check whether my medical certification had come in, because my doctor's office wasn't sure it went through. Agent confirmed EDD had received it and the date it was processed. Went back to waiting after that but at least I knew it wasn't lost.

0 coins

been trying that disability line since monday. four attempts, same recording, same dead end every time.

0 coins

The base period quarters thing trips a lot of people up. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate before you call so you have something to compare against.

0 coins

The estimate on EDD's site is actually pretty helpful for that. At least you go into the call knowing what number you're questioning.

0 coins

For the original question about workers comp paperwork, the overlap between workers comp and SDI is one of those areas where EDD's site is intentionally vague. They acknowledge both can apply in some cases but they don't list a specific letter or form by name for the workers comp piece. Your best move is probably getting to an EDD agent and asking them to tell you what your file needs.

0 coins

That's the frustrating part. Every answer leads back to 'call EDD' and then you can't get through.

0 coins

Yep. The Request Claim Update in SDI Online is slower but puts your question in writing. For something that might require a specific document, though, talking to someone is probably worth the effort.

0 coins

EDD's site really could just list the forms plainly. Not sure why this has to be a mystery.

0 coins

My sister went through a workers comp claim AND tried to file SDI at the same time and EDD asked her for documentation from her workers comp carrier showing the amount she was receiving! So there might be a specific letter involved after all, it just depends on what EDD's looking at for your case.

0 coins

That tracks with EDD deciding overlap cases individually. They'd need to know the workers comp payment amount to figure out how the two interact. What EDD asks for can vary, which is why getting to an agent and asking about your specific claim is the right path.

0 coins

Okay so a letter showing the comp payment amount is at least one thing they might want. That's something concrete I can get from my carrier.

0 coins

Exactly! Get it from the carrier and have it ready. Couldn't hurt to have it even if EDD ends up not needing it.

0 coins

cant believe nobody just answered this straight, they want a letter from your workers comp carrier saying how much youre getting paid, thats it, so they can see if theres an overlap. at least thats what my buddy got asked for

0 coins

That may be what happened in that one case, but EDD doesn't publish a single named document requirement for every workers comp situation. The carrier letter showing payment amount is plausible, but what EDD asks for can vary. Asking them directly about your own file is still the safest move.

0 coins

fair enough, was just going off what he told me

0 coins

To answer the medical certification side of this since it comes up in every SDI thread, your doctor needs your claim receipt number to find your claim in SDI Online and submit their part. Without that number attached, the certification floats and EDD can't match it to your file. Give the number to your doctor's office as soon as you file.

0 coins

Where do you find the receipt number after you file? Is it emailed to you or do you have to go back into SDI Online?

0 coins

SDI Online shows it right after you submit your claim. Write it down or screenshot it because you'll need to give it to your doctor.

0 coins

Okay writing that down. I haven't filed yet so at least I know to grab it right away when I do.

0 coins

My doctor's office lost mine the first time I gave it to them. Had to go back in person. Worth confirming they actually recorded it.

0 coins

Seven years filing SDI claims across a few different injuries. The workers comp overlap question always ends the same way: EDD decides it themselves and what they ask for varies. Never seen a single definitive answer on what letter they want because it's not always the same one.

0 coins

That's kind of what I figured after getting nowhere online. Just wanted someone who'd been through it to confirm it's not just me missing something obvious.

0 coins

Not missing anything. It's genuinely unclear until you ask them about your specific claim.

0 coins

Paid out of that phone hold music for two hours one morning and still didn't get through, anyway. Got to wondering about which weeks on my claim were actually marked paid versus pending because SDI Online wasn't updating. Ended up getting through to a live agent through Claimyr and asked them to pull up my payment history. Agent went through it week by week and told me which ones had been issued and which were still pending, so I finally knew where things stood instead of just staring at the same screen.

0 coins

I've dialed that disability number so many times in the last two weeks, usually get dropped or hit the busy signal. How did your call actually go once you got through? I keep wondering if the line just never actually works.

0 coins

Claimyr handled the hold part and I got a live agent. The agent was straightforward, went through my claim week by week. It wasn't a long call once I actually had someone.

0 coins

I had the same pending weeks situation. EDD's automated line at 1-800-480-3287 gave me the payment info for my most recent week but not the full picture. Had to get to an agent to see the whole list. And once the agent confirmed the receipt number on file matched what my doctor used, the pending weeks cleared up pretty fast after that.

0 coins

Okay so the receipt number matching matters for the pending status too. That's one more thing I need to double check on mine.

0 coins

For anyone still unclear on the waiting period, the first seven days of an SDI claim are non-payable. That is EDD's rule and it is not the same as processing time. The eighth day is when the claim can first begin paying. Even if your doctor certifies quickly and EDD processes everything right away, those first seven days simply do not pay.

0 coins

So those seven days just don't exist for payment purposes at all? They don't get made up later or added to the end?

0 coins

Correct. They are gone. The benefit period begins on day eight, and there is no provision to recover those seven days later in the claim.

0 coins

my coworker told me edd pays you back the waiting period if the claim goes long enough, thats not right?

0 coins

Not right for a standard DI claim. The waiting period is non-payable and stays that way regardless of how long the claim runs. Paid Family Leave is different and has no waiting period, but that is a separate program entirely.

0 coins

been dealing with edd for three months on a back injury. still havent figured out the workers comp letter question myself. if anyone finds out what exactly they want please post back here

0 coins

Will do. Going to try to get an agent on the line this week and ask them point blank what document they need from my carrier. I'll update if I get through.

0 coins

appreciate it. three months of guessing is too long

0 coins

Does anyone know if a physical therapist counts for the medical certification? My PT has been seeing me more than my actual doctor lately and I wondered if they could submit it instead.

0 coins

Physical therapists are not on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim. The list includes licensed physicians, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and licensed midwives for pregnancy-related conditions. Your PT cannot submit the certification, but the physician overseeing your care can.

0 coins

Oh I had no idea about that. I would have asked my PT to do it and been so confused when it didn't work. Thank you.

0 coins

Same mistake I almost made. Ended up going back to my orthopedist for it.

0 coins

My extension request is the piece I'm stuck on right now. Doctor says I need more time and I wasn't sure if I was supposed to file something new or if the doctor handles it. Ended up using Claimyr to get through to the disability line and asked the agent about the DE 2525XX. Agent confirmed EDD had sent it out with my final payment notice and that my doctor needs to complete and submit it, not me filing a whole new claim. Good to know before I went and started from scratch.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it in this thread.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's disability line until an agent picks up and then your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Hm. My extension question is basically the same as yours, the DE 2525XX. Might try it.

0 coins

The doctor submitting that form is the right track. EDD sends it with the final payment notice, so if your doctor hasn't gotten it yet, they may not have received the notification from EDD's end. Worth confirming the form got to the right office.

0 coins

For the original question, one practical thing: get a letter from your workers comp carrier on their letterhead showing your weekly payment amount and the period it covers. That's the kind of documentation EDD would likely need to see how the two claims interact. You may still need to ask EDD exactly how to submit it, but having it ready will save you a step.

0 coins

That's a solid starting point. I can call my carrier and ask for a summary letter. At least I'd have something in hand before I finally get through to EDD.

0 coins

Exactly. And note the dates on it, the start of comp payments and the current period being paid. Those details matter when EDD is figuring out the overlap.

0 coins

The part about EDD saying it's not common to get both workers comp and SDI at the same time kind of spooked me when I first read it. I thought it meant they'd just deny the SDI automatically. But exceptions are real, it just means you need to let EDD sort out your specific situation.

0 coins

Yeah that phrasing worried me too at first. 'Not common' isn't the same as 'never,' which is what I had to remind myself.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD uses that language because every overlap case is different. They look at the actual amounts and dates involved for each claim rather than applying a blanket rule.

0 coins

Makes sense that they'd have to look at each one. Hopefully getting the right documentation together and actually reaching an agent gets this moving.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure