Back to California Disability

Isabella Costa

Using employer short term disability insurance and SDI at same time — how does this actually work?

So my back finally gave out enough that my doctor pulled me from work, and HR mentioned I might have coverage through the company's short term disability plan on top of SDI. I filed my SDI claim through SDI Online a few days ago but I'm honestly confused about whether I can collect both at the same time or if one cancels the other out. The HR packet is like 12 pages and I can't find a straight answer anywhere. Has anyone actually dealt with both at once? Do I just file SDI normally and let the company plan run separately, or does EDD need to know about the employer plan? Really need to figure this out before my first week is up anyway.

Filing SDI through myEDD is the right move regardless of what your employer's plan does. The two are separate systems, and EDD handles its own side independently. That said, the interaction between them depends heavily on how your employer's plan is written, so the HR department or the plan administrator is really the place to get the specifics on their end. EDD decides what SDI pays based on your wages and your base period, full stop.

0 coins

HR keeps pointing me back to the plan documents and those are genuinely impenetrable. I'll call the plan administrator Monday and ask directly.

0 coins

Plan administrators are usually more helpful on the phone than the paperwork suggests. Worth a try.

0 coins

The SDI side is worth understanding on its own first. Your weekly benefit amount comes from the highest-paid quarter inside a 12-month base period that ended several months before your claim started. EDD's benefit calculator on their site gives an estimate, and the real number shows up on the Notice of Computation once EDD processes the claim. That document does not mean you've been approved, just that EDD ran the numbers on your wages.

0 coins

Haven't gotten the Notice of Computation yet, still waiting. My SDI Online account just shows the claim as pending.

0 coins

How long does pending usually last before the notice comes? I think mine has been sitting there for about a week and I'm not sure if that's normal.

0 coins

After EDD gets both your part and the medical certification from your provider, most payments go out within two weeks. The notice usually shows up in that window too.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was confusing me for a while and I kept getting the automated line with no real answer. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what finally got me to an actual EDD agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and told me the exact date my first payment was issued, which was something the automated system just wasn't giving me clearly.

0 coins

Three mornings I tried that disability line before 8:30 and got the recording every time. I'll be real, a service that handles the hold sounds useful but I'd want to know it's actually EDD picking up and not some third party. How did that work on your end?

0 coins

The person I spoke with was an EDD employee, looked up my claim number and walked me through the payment screen. No third party involved there.

0 coins

Tried Claimyr for my own claim when I couldn't sort out which weeks had been paid and which were still pending. Agent confirmed the two specific weeks that had gone through and the ones still being processed, so I knew exactly where the gap was.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone. The automated line has not been useful for me either.

0 coins

Your employer's plan and SDI are two different pots of money. File SDI, let your doctor submit the certification, don't skip that step. What the company plan does on their side is their business. EDD doesn't ask you to report your employer's private plan on the SDI claim form.

0 coins

That's actually the clearest answer I've gotten. I was worried I had to somehow coordinate them through EDD.

0 coins

EDD's form asks what it asks. It doesn't have a box for your employer's private insurance.

0 coins

Nobody told me about the seven-day waiting period when I filed. I thought it was just slow processing, so I called in frustrated about a missing payment. Turns out those first seven days just aren't payable, full stop, every new claim. First payable day is the eighth. I felt a little dumb but also wish someone had said it plainly upfront.

0 coins

Wait so the first week is always just gone? That's a week of wages I was counting on.

0 coins

Yeah, every new SDI claim. Not a glitch, not a delay, just how it works.

0 coins

Does that waiting period apply even if you're also getting paid by the employer's short term plan during that week?

0 coins

The SDI waiting period is EDD's rule and it applies to the SDI side regardless of what any private plan pays in that same window.

0 coins

Worth double-checking that your doctor has the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A. Providers find the claim in SDI Online using that number to submit the medical certification. If they search without it or use the wrong one the certification can end up unmatched and the claim just sits.

0 coins

My doctor's office said they'd handle it but I never gave them a receipt number. I'll check my SDI Online account for it and call them.

0 coins

The receipt number shows in SDI Online right after you submit Part A. It's on the confirmation screen and also in the claim details.

0 coins

Does the doctor have to file online or can they mail it in?

0 coins

For a paper claim on the DE 2501 the provider completes Part B and mails it. For an SDI Online claim the provider submits through SDI Online with that receipt number. They shouldn't do both.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely unprepared on my previous claim. After five automatic payments EDD mails that questionnaire asking if you're still unable to work, and you have 20 days to send it back or benefits stop. I used Claimyr to reach an agent when I wasn't sure if mine had been received, and she confirmed it was in the system and that my next payment was processing.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on EDD's phone line in your place until a real agent picks up, then your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is actually what I'd need to ask about. My claim's coming up on that point and I've been bracing for how to actually confirm EDD got it. Might try it.

0 coins

Return that questionnaire the moment it arrives. Don't wait until day 18.

0 coins

I had a client go through this with a back injury last year, employer plan plus SDI running at the same time. She said the employer plan paid first and faster, then the SDI payments started coming in after the waiting period was done. She never had to report one to the other. But honestly she did say her plan had some offset language in it, so it's worth asking the administrator specifically whether their plan offsets against SDI.

0 coins

Offset language. That's the phrase I needed to search for in the plan documents. Thank you.

0 coins

Ask HR what their offset provision says. Some plans reduce their payout by whatever SDI pays, others just stack. You need to know which yours is.

0 coins

Can I ask a related question? My employer's short term plan pays out for 12 weeks but SDI can go up to 52 weeks. If the employer plan runs out before I'm cleared to go back, does SDI just keep going on its own? Or do I have to file something again?

0 coins

SDI runs on its own timeline based on your medical certification. When the employer plan ends, SDI doesn't restart or reset. It keeps paying as long as your provider continues to certify your disability and you've been approved, up to 52 weeks from your claim's start.

0 coins

That's a relief actually. I didn't want to have to start over with EDD paperwork.

0 coins

The 52-week limit is on the SDI side. What your employer's plan does separately has no effect on when EDD's clock starts or stops.

0 coins

The employer plan offset question matters more than most people realize. Some plans are written so they pay the difference between their benefit and SDI, not the full amount plus SDI. Read the offset clause before you count on both checks adding up.

0 coins

Found the clause. It says they reduce their benefit by any SDI I receive. So it's not both full amounts, it's their plan topping up whatever SDI doesn't cover.

0 coins

That's the typical setup. You end up at roughly the plan's benefit level total, not stacked on top of SDI.

0 coins

That's actually pretty common. The employer plan bridges to their ceiling and SDI fills part of the gap. Still better than SDI alone if the plan ceiling is higher.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail after I had an issue on a previous claim and I had no idea what I was looking at. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and she read off exactly what the determination said and confirmed the appeal deadline was 30 days from the date printed on the notice. I didn't know I could appeal until she said it plainly.

0 coins

Tried Claimyr for my own situation too, honestly was not expecting much. Agent told me which quarter of the base period they used to calculate my benefit, which explained why my weekly amount looked lower than I expected.

0 coins

Did the agent say how that quarter is selected? I've been trying to figure out if EDD picks the highest one automatically.

0 coins

She said it's the highest-paid quarter in the base period. Didn't go into the mechanics beyond that.

0 coins

Good to know the Notice of Determination has an appeal window. I'll keep that in mind if anything on my claim comes back wrong.

0 coins

My coworker filed SDI while her employer's plan was also running and she said the main thing that tripped her up was the medical certification taking longer than expected to get into EDD's system. Her doctor's office kept saying they submitted it but it wasn't showing in SDI Online for days. Turned out they had the wrong receipt number. Once she gave them the right one it matched up fast.

0 coins

This is the second time receipt number has come up. I'm going to give the office a copy of my confirmation screen so there's no guessing.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move. Paste the receipt number into an email to them so it's in writing.

0 coins

employer plan or not you still gotta do the sdi part yourself, they dont talk to each other, just file both and see what happens

0 coins

Filing both is right. Just know the offset clause in the employer plan might mean you're not collecting two full checks.

0 coins

yeah fair point i didnt know about that offset thing

0 coins

been dealing with this same situation for two weeks now. sdi pending, employer plan approved but i still havent gotten anything from either one. the waiting period ate week one and now im just sitting here.

0 coins

Two weeks is right at the edge of when things usually start moving. If your doctor's certification is in and matched, it should process soon.

0 coins

certification is in, confirmed with the office. so i guess i wait.

0 coins

Check SDI Online daily. Payment status usually updates before anything arrives in the mail.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right place to ask but does SDI count as taxable income? I've been trying to figure out if I need to set aside money for taxes while I'm out.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits. The federal side depends on your situation and EDD's tax information page covers what they report. For anything beyond that a tax professional is the right call, not a forum.

0 coins

Okay that's helpful, didn't know California had its own rule on it.

0 coins

EDD's site has a tax information section under disability. That's the place to start before asking a professional.

0 coins

If your employer's plan has a waiting period too, they might overlap with SDI's waiting period which is actually kind of lucky timing! Check whether the employer plan's waiting period starts on the same day as your disability.

0 coins

The employer plan has a 7-day waiting period too so they do overlap. That's one less gap than I was afraid of.

0 coins

Exactly! Both clocks run at the same time so you're not doubling up on waiting.

0 coins

Payment method is worth setting up in SDI Online if you filed there. Direct deposit is available on online claims and gets funds to you faster than waiting for a card to arrive. The Money Network prepaid card is the default if you don't select direct deposit.

0 coins

Just logged in and set up direct deposit. It was actually pretty easy to find in SDI Online.

0 coins

Is it too late to switch to direct deposit after the claim is already filed?

0 coins

You can update your payment method in SDI Online before the first payment processes. After that it may apply to subsequent payments, but check your account to confirm it took.

0 coins

Extensions are something nobody thinks about upfront but if your recovery runs longer than your doctor originally estimated, your provider can submit the DE 2525XX to extend the claim. You don't start over, same claim continues. EDD sends that form with the final payment notice.

0 coins

Good to know. My doctor said six to eight weeks but honestly my back has surprised me before in the bad direction.

0 coins

Keep your provider in the loop as you get close to the end of the certification period. They need to submit the extension before benefits lapse if possible.

0 coins

One thing I'd push back on slightly in this thread: someone said the employer plan doesn't affect SDI at all. That's true from EDD's side. But if your employer plan has an offset and you don't report SDI to them, you might end up overpaid on their side and have to pay it back. That's a plan-side problem, not EDD, but worth watching.

0 coins

This is the thing I was actually most worried about. I'll make sure to report what SDI pays to the plan administrator so the offset math is right on their end.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD doesn't care about the private plan. The private plan cares about SDI. That's the direction the reporting flows.

0 coins

Does the employer short term disability plan need a separate medical certification or does the same one the doctor sent to EDD cover both?

0 coins

They're separate systems with separate requirements. EDD's certification goes through SDI Online, and the employer's plan has its own forms and process. Your doctor's office may handle both, but they are not the same submission.

0 coins

Okay so I need to make sure the office submits to both places separately. Good to know before I assume one filing covers everything.

0 coins

Ask the plan administrator exactly what forms they need and whether they accept the same clinical information or have their own paperwork. Don't assume.

0 coins

Update: doctor's office had the wrong receipt number, just like a few people warned about. I emailed the confirmation screen to them this morning and they resubmitted the certification this afternoon. SDI Online still shows pending but I'll check again tomorrow. Plan administrator confirmed the offset clause applies so the checks won't stack fully, but between the two I should be close to my normal take-home. Thanks everyone, this thread answered more than the HR packet did.

0 coins

Glad the receipt number fix worked. Keep an eye on SDI Online over the next few days and the Notice of Computation should come through soon.

0 coins

Document every date, what you submitted, when the office confirmed, when each notice arrives. That paper trail matters if anything gets disputed later.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation arriving doesn't mean the claim is approved. It just shows the wage calculation. Approval comes through payments or a determination notice.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure