Back to California Disability

Sofia Morales

Unemployment notice of determination overlap with SDI claim — what happens?

So I'm in a situation I didn't expect and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I filed for unemployment back in August because my hours got cut and my employer said it might be a layoff. Then about three weeks in I had a medical thing happen and my doctor pulled me out of work entirely. I filed an SDI claim right away and my doctor submitted the medical certification. Now I got a Notice of Determination from EDD on the unemployment side that covers some of the same weeks my SDI claim covers. I don't know if I'm supposed to have both running at the same time or if one cancels the other or if I'm going to owe money back. Has anyone dealt with an unemployment Notice of Determination overlapping with an active SDI disability claim? I'm not sure what to do with the unemployment determination while my disability payments are still pending.

Payment method on my own claim took a while to sort out, so I know how it feels when EDD paperwork starts overlapping and nothing is clear. I ended up speaking to a live agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to figure out what card or account my payments would actually go to. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my payments were set for the Money Network prepaid card since I hadn't switched to direct deposit in SDI Online. Worth knowing for anyone whose claim is pending and they're not sure where the money lands when it finally moves.

0 coins

Claimyr showing up in the first reply here — does that read as a marketing plant to anyone else? Genuine question before I take any of this seriously.

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it. Tried it myself when my Notice of Determination came in and I needed to know whether the determination affected my DI weeks. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which weeks were still pending on the disability side. It was an EDD employee, not a service rep.

0 coins

Alright, that's enough for me. I'll give it a look if the phone line keeps stonewalling me.

0 coins

EDD does not pay both for the same days, full stop. You can't collect unemployment and disability on the same week. If your SDI claim covers weeks your unemployment was also paid, one of those will be clawed back. The Notice of Determination is EDD telling you something about the unemployment side, so read it carefully for which weeks it's approving or denying.

0 coins

Which weeks does the Notice of Determination actually spell out? Mine lists a date range but I can't tell if it's the weeks I was still able to work or the ones after I went out.

0 coins

The range on the determination is the period EDD evaluated. If your disability start date falls inside that range, that's the overlap you need to flag with EDD.

0 coins

EDD rarely catches these things cleanly on their own. Don't wait for them to sort it out. Contact them.

0 coins

Had a foreman on my crew deal with this last spring. He filed unemployment when the project shut down, then hurt his back two weeks later and went on SDI. EDD sorted it out but it took them sending him a repayment notice first. He had to show them the SDI start date to get it straightened out.

0 coins

How did he show them the start date, just a screenshot from SDI Online or did they want something official?

0 coins

They wanted the claim confirmation from SDI Online and his doctor's certification date. Had both, so it got resolved.

0 coins

Good to know there's a path through it even if it starts ugly.

0 coins

Okay so I went through something kind of similar and I had no idea that unemployment requires you to certify that you're able and available to work every single week you claim it. When I went out on disability I was definitely not able to work, so those weeks I was certifying for unemployment while actually being unable to work were a problem. The rule is basically if you can't work because of a medical condition, unemployment isn't the right program for those weeks, disability is.

0 coins

Were you certifying for both at the same time or just unemployment when you should have been on SDI?

0 coins

Just unemployment, because I hadn't filed for SDI yet. The minute I understood the difference I stopped certifying for unemployment and got the SDI claim going. Way less headache than trying to fix an overlap after the fact.

0 coins

So if I already certified available for a week when I was actually out sick, does that mean I lied to EDD? I'm worried that looks really bad on my account.

0 coins

You didn't necessarily lie if you misunderstood the question at the time. But you should contact EDD and tell them your disability start date. That's the cleaner path.

0 coins

The thing that tripped me up early on was thinking the SDI waiting period was just processing time. It's actually a real non-payable chunk at the front of the claim, the first seven days. No payment for those days no matter what, it's just how the program works. I mixed that up with how long EDD takes to review and I thought my claim was stuck when it was just in the waiting period.

0 coins

Does the waiting period overlap with the unemployment weeks on the determination, or does it sit before all of that?

0 coins

Depends on your disability start date versus when your unemployment claim started. If your SDI start date is after your unemployment period ended, the waiting period might not touch the unemployment weeks at all. But if they're in the same stretch, that first week of SDI is still non-payable, and unemployment can't fill it either.

0 coins

This clarification about the waiting period is actually really useful, I kept telling my wife it was just a processing lag, anyway.

0 coins

Medical certification on my claim sat unmatched for over two weeks because my doctor's office used the wrong claim number. I'd been burning through the EDD phone line every morning with nothing, so I tried Claimyr to reach the disability line and talk to someone. Agent checked my file and confirmed the certification was in their system but linked to a different claim ID. Got the receipt number to my doctor that afternoon and they resubmitted it.

0 coins

What did you need to have ready when you got on with the agent, claim ID and what else?

0 coins

Claim ID, the receipt number EDD gave when I first filed, and my doctor's name and office address so they could locate the cert. Having all three made the call fast.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday, four mornings in a row, nothing. good to hear someone actually got through somehow.

0 coins

The original question here is worth spelling out for others who search this. EDD's own language is that you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. So an overlap isn't a gray area. If the unemployment Notice of Determination approved weeks that your SDI claim also covers, one of those periods has to give. Usually EDD will net it out and you'll get a notice about the difference.

0 coins

What does 'net it out' look like in practice — do they send an overpayment notice on the unemployment side or on the SDI side?

0 coins

Typically the overpayment notice comes from whichever side paid first, and it'll have an appeal form. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal if you think something is wrong.

0 coins

Knowing the 30-day window on that appeal is important. Easy to let it slide if you're stressed and recovering.

0 coins

my roommate had this exact problem, unemployment paid him for like 3 weeks and then his sdi kicked in for the same weeks and edd sent him an overpayment notice. he just paid it back because he didnt know he could appeal

0 coins

He didn't have to pay it back automatically. If the SDI weeks were legit and the unemployment ones were the error, an appeal might have fixed it.

0 coins

yeah he found that out after. too late for him but useful info for anyone reading this

0 coins

I'm kind of in a panic reading all this because I think I might have the same situation starting. I filed for unemployment three weeks ago and now my doctor is saying I should file for SDI because I'm not going to be able to go back for at least another month. Does filing for SDI automatically stop my unemployment, or do I have to call and tell them?

0 coins

Filing for SDI doesn't automatically stop your unemployment certifications. You need to stop certifying for unemployment for the weeks you're out on disability and report your situation to EDD. The two systems don't talk to each other in real time.

0 coins

So I should stop certifying for unemployment starting the week my doctor says I'm out, and then just file the SDI claim?

0 coins

Exactly. Your disability start date is the dividing line. Unemployment for the days you were able and available, SDI for the days you weren't.

0 coins

And file the SDI claim as soon as your doctor gives you the green light. You have 49 days from your disability start date to get everything in.

0 coins

My SDI claim started the week after my unemployment benefits ran out, so I didn't have an overlap issue. But I was nervous about it and read a lot of this kind of thread while I was waiting. The Notice of Computation came about ten days after my doctor submitted the certification and that was when I felt like the claim was real.

0 coins

Ten days after certification, is that pretty typical? I'm on day eight and nothing yet.

0 coins

It varied for people I spoke with. EDD says most payments come within two weeks after they receive a complete claim. The Notice of Computation isn't your payment, though, it just shows the weekly amount they calculated.

0 coins

Day eight is still inside that window. Try not to spiral yet.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation can feel like an approval but it really isn't, it just tells you what your weekly amount would be! Actual eligibility is a separate thing and EDD communicates that through payments starting or through a Notice of Determination if they deny something.

0 coins

Does a denial always come as a Notice of Determination, or can EDD just not pay and leave you guessing?

0 coins

A denial comes as a Notice of Determination, and it'll have an Appeal Form attached. If you get one of those, don't ignore the date on it because you only have 30 days to file an appeal.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and the Notice of Determination are two separate documents doing two separate jobs. Easy to mix them up when you're new to the system.

0 coins

EDD sent me a DE 2593 about five months into my claim. I didn't know what it was and set it aside. Big mistake. That form is a continued eligibility questionnaire and you've got 20 days to return it or they cut your benefits.

0 coins

Twenty days sounds like a lot until you're dealing with doctor appointments and kids and you forget about a form in a stack, anyway, good reminder.

0 coins

Open every piece of EDD mail the day it comes. I learned that the hard way.

0 coins

The form number is DE 2593, worth remembering because it shows up in the mail without a lot of fanfare.

0 coins

Waiting period question was the thing I actually needed to get straight before my claim made sense to me. I ended up using Claimyr to reach the disability line because the hold times were making me miss shifts I could've taken. Agent looked at my claim and confirmed my waiting period had been counted from day one of my disability start date, which is what I needed to know before I understood why the first week showed no payment.

0 coins

My claim's Notice of Computation showed an amount I didn't expect and I want to get a straight answer about how they calculated it. I'll try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have your Notice of Computation in front of you, your base period dates if you know them, and your claim ID. The agent can pull the wage quarter they used and walk you through the number.

0 coins

Is the base period something EDD assigns automatically or do you get to choose which quarter they use?

0 coins

EDD assigns it. It's a specific 12-month window based on when your claim starts, and the highest-earning quarter inside that window is what sets your weekly amount.

0 coins

my manager went through an overlap like this and ended up with an overpayment notice on the unemployment side, the whole appeal process was stressful for her but she did win it because she had documentation of her SDI start date and her doctor's certification. keep your paperwork

0 coins

What kind of documentation won her appeal — just the SDI confirmation from EDD or did the doctor have to write something?

0 coins

EDD's own confirmation of the SDI claim start date was the main thing. The doctor's cert date helped too because it matched the disability start date she'd given EDD.

0 coins

Appeals that have clean documentation generally go better. Vague or missing paperwork is where people run into trouble.

0 coins

Base period question on my own claim had me stumped, so I used Claimyr to get through to the disability line after three mornings of nothing. Agent found that my highest-earning quarter was from about eight months before my claim start date, which I hadn't expected because I assumed they'd use my most recent pay. Good to have that confirmed before I got the Notice of Computation in the mail.

0 coins

The quarter thing matches what I found on my own claim, highest wages in the base period, not the most recent. I ended up talking to an EDD agent too and once they confirmed my start date, I understood why my amount came out the way it did. I'd been calling for days before that.

0 coins

been hitting that line every morning for a week and a half with nothing. maybe time to try another approach.

0 coins

Get your claim ID and your SDI Online confirmation ready. That's what the agent needed to find my record quickly.

0 coins

Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work. SDI is for when you can't. If there's a week where your doctor says you're medically unable to work, that week should be SDI, not unemployment, regardless of what the determination letter says.

0 coins

So even if the unemployment Notice of Determination says a week was approved, EDD can still take it back if it turns out I was on SDI for that week?

0 coins

Yes. A determination approving weeks doesn't lock those weeks in if another benefit applies to the same days. Overpayment notices exist precisely for that situation.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination is EDD's finding at the time, based on what they had. If new information comes in like a disability claim, it changes the picture.

0 coins

Question about reporting going back to work part time — if you're on SDI and you pick up a few hours here and there before you're fully cleared, do you just tell EDD in SDI Online or is there a specific form, anyway I keep seeing conflicting stuff.

0 coins

Any return to work, even partial, gets reported to EDD. How a partial week gets paid is EDD's call, not something you calculate yourself. Report it promptly and let EDD sort the amount.

0 coins

Got it, so don't guess at the math, just report it.

0 coins

Report it. EDD finds out anyway and it's cleaner if you told them first.

0 coins

Extensions are something I didn't know were even a thing until I was near the end of my approved period and my doctor said I still wasn't ready. You don't file a whole new claim. Your doctor submits the DE 2525XX, which is the supplementary certificate, and EDD sends that form to your doctor along with your final payment notice.

0 coins

What if the doctor doesn't get the form in time and your payments stop before the extension is approved?

0 coins

Contact EDD as soon as you know you need more time. Don't wait for the payments to stop before your doctor submits the extension.

0 coins

EDD mails that DE 2525XX form out with the final payment notice, so it's coming either way, the trick is making sure your doctor's office knows to expect it and submits it fast!

0 coins

the overlap question comes up a lot and i never see a simple answer. the simple answer is: same days cant be both. pick one, whichever one fits your situation medically and work-wise, and report the other one to edd.

0 coins

wish someone had just said that in plain words when i was trying to figure this out months ago

0 coins

EDD could put that on their site in large text and save everyone a lot of confusion.

0 coins

Coming back to update: I called the EDD disability line this morning and finally got through. Told them my SDI disability start date and they noted it on my file. They said I'll likely get a notice about the overlapping weeks and to read it carefully and appeal within 30 days if I disagree. I'm going to hold onto every document I have from both claims just in case.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move. Keep the SDI claim ID, the Notice of Computation, the unemployment determination, and your doctor's certification date in one place.

0 coins

Glad you got through. The notice, when it comes, will have an appeal form attached, so don't throw it away even if the news isn't great.

0 coins

Having all those documents together when you talk to EDD makes a real difference. Learned that on my own claim.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure