The wrong way to date sub 20 on your California EDD disability claim
Filed my SDI claim about three weeks ago and I genuinely did not know what date to put for when my disability started. I had been told by someone at work to use the date I stopped showing up, which was a Monday. But my last actual workday was the Friday before, and I'd already been struggling for a few days before that. My doctor's office ended up putting a different start date on the medical certification than what I had on my claim form, and now everything is a mess. SDI Online shows the claim as pending and I have no idea if the mismatch in dates is what's causing the holdup or if I'm just in normal processing time. The reason this matters so much is the waiting period — if my start date is wrong, those seven unpaid days might be counted from the wrong point, and I could end up losing payable days I'm actually entitled to. Has anyone dealt with a date mismatch between their own statement and what the doctor submitted? Did EDD sort it out on their own or did you have to call and get it fixed?
68 comments

CosmicCaptain
The start date on the claimant side and the medical certification side being different is actually one of the more common reasons a claim sits in pending longer than expected. The question to ask EDD is which date they're treating as the official disability start date on your claim, because that's the date your seven-day waiting period runs from and the date your payable weeks count from. If the doctor's date is earlier than yours, EDD will typically use the earlier one, but if they don't match at all, a reviewer may need to look at it manually.
0 coins
Malik Johnson
49 days from whichever date EDD lands on is also the deadline for getting the medical certification in, so if there's confusion about which date is the start, that clock question matters too
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorThe 49-day deadline is making me nervous — my claim is already three weeks old and I want to make sure I haven't accidentally created a problem for myself by using the wrong date initially
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Weeks 3 through 6 on my claim showed paid in SDI Online but I had no idea which calendar weeks those actually corresponded to, because my start date had been entered incorrectly and the whole schedule shifted. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which week-ending dates had been paid and which were still pending. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I had those dates I could see the mismatch myself and knew which week to ask my doctor's office about.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Knowing the exact week-ending dates the agent gave you would have made everything so much clearer — I've been staring at SDI Online for days trying to figure out what 'pending' even means for my specific weeks
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorHaving that list of paid week-ending dates is exactly what I need to compare against what my doctor submitted. I'm going to look into getting through to someone who can read that off to me
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
SDI Online does show payment dates eventually but it doesn't always make it obvious which benefit weeks map to which calendar weeks, so talking to someone directly makes sense
0 coins
Omar Zaki
Ask yourself whether the date you used was the first day you couldn't do your regular job, not just the first day you didn't go in. Those two things aren't always the same. EDD cares about when your condition actually stopped you from working, and if your doctor is certifying that you were unable to work starting on a date that's a few days earlier than what you put on your claim form, that earlier date is probably the medically correct one. The rule is that your disability start date is the first day you're unable to perform your regular or customary work.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorThat distinction between 'didn't go in' and 'couldn't do the job' is really clarifying. I was thinking about it in terms of attendance, not in terms of when I was actually impaired
0 coins
AstroAce
My doctor told me the same thing when I was filling out my claim — she said she'd certify from the date I first came to her office unable to work, which was two days before I actually told my employer
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Went through almost this identical situation last year. The mismatch didn't stop my claim from paying — EDD just went with my doctor's earlier date, which actually worked in my favor because it pushed the end of my waiting period earlier. The pending status cleared up around day 11 or 12 from when my doctor submitted.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorDay 11 or 12 from submission — okay, so I'm right at the edge of that now. I'm going to give it a couple more days before I panic
0 coins
Diego Rojas
EDD processing times vary a lot, what happened on one claim doesn't always predict the next one, especially if there's a manual review triggered by the date mismatch
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
My claim also cleared without me having to do anything, but I had a simple situation with no date discrepancy, so I can't say for certain whether that made a difference
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Something that tripped me up early on was thinking the seven-day waiting period was just EDD taking time to process my paperwork. It's not — it's a fixed non-payable period built into every new claim, no matter how fast EDD moves. So even if your claim gets approved tomorrow, those first seven days from your start date don't get paid. That's not a penalty or a delay, it's just how the program is structured. First payable day is day eight.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
The waiting period thing confused me too at first. I thought EDD was just slow and kept waiting for those first days to suddenly get marked as paid. They never do because they were never going to.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorI understood there was a waiting period but I didn't realize it was specifically the first seven calendar days from the disability start date. That changes my mental math on when my first payment should appear
0 coins
StarStrider
Whether the waiting period runs from the date you put or the date your doctor put also matters here, which is why getting the start date sorted out first is the right move before worrying about payment timing
0 coins
Luca Esposito
If EDD needs clarification on the start date, you don't have to wait for them to reach out first. You can go into SDI Online under your claim and use the Request Claim Update option to send a message explaining what happened and asking them to confirm which date they're using. Put the receipt number in there and keep the message specific — something like 'my form shows date X, my doctor's certification shows date Y, please confirm which is on record as my disability start date.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorI didn't know the Request Claim Update feature let me send that kind of message. I've been treating SDI Online as read-only but it sounds like there's a way to actually communicate through it
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
The Ask EDD form on EDD's site is another option if you want a written record of the question and you don't hear back through SDI Online in a reasonable timeframe
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Request Claim Update is what I used when my doctor's office submitted under the wrong receipt number — it took EDD a few days to match everything up but it worked without a phone call
0 coins
Diego Rojas
DE 2525XX situation from my own claim: my doctor submitted the extension form after my final payment notice came, but my SDI Online showed no update for almost two weeks. Got through to an EDD disability agent through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the extension had been received and was sitting with a reviewer. I went back to work before the review finished so I withdrew it, but at least I knew EDD had it.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorKnowing EDD actually has the form versus it being lost somewhere in transit is the kind of confirmation I'd want too — the uncertainty is the worst part
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
The DE 2525XX being received but not yet processed is surprisingly common from what I've read here. Good to know there's a way to verify it was actually received rather than just hoping
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
The doctor's submission date is separate from the disability start date, and new claimants often mix these up. Your start date is when you became unable to work. The certification just confirms it medically. EDD is not going to disqualify a claim because the certification came in a few days after the start date, as long as it comes in within 49 days of that start date and the licensed provider certifies the right period.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
49 days from the disability start date, not from the filing date — that's the part I always want to confirm. My doctor's office asked me which deadline to meet and I wanted to make sure I gave them the right one
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Correct, the 49-day clock for getting the medical certification in runs from the disability start date, not from when you filed the claimant's portion in SDI Online
0 coins
NeonNova
Can I ask a dumb question — does the date on the medical certification have to exactly match what the claimant put on their form, or just fall within the same period? My doctor's office has been asking me which date to use and I told them to use whatever date they had in their records, now I'm second-guessing that.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
Telling your provider to use the date in their own records is actually the right instinct — the medical certification should reflect the date your condition actually began affecting your ability to work, based on clinical judgment, not what you guessed when you filed
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
If the two dates are different and you want EDD to use the earlier one, the safest path is to use the Request Claim Update feature or Ask EDD to flag the discrepancy so a reviewer knows to look at both
0 coins
NeonNova
That's a relief. My provider's date is a few days earlier than mine, so it sounds like it might just work in my favor the way the other person described
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Filing date and start date are two entirely different things and the form makes it easy to confuse them. The question to ask yourself when you're uncertain about your start date is: what was the first day you could not do what your job normally requires? Not the first day you called in, not the first day you saw your doctor, not the first day your employer processed your leave. The day the disability itself stopped you is the one EDD cares about.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorThe day the disability stopped' you is a cleaner way of thinking about it than anything'I d heard before. My employer processed my leave paperwork a full week after I actually stopped being able to work, and I think I was anchoring to thatdate
0 coins
Malik Johnson
Employer leave paperwork dates are almost always administrative and trailing — EDD's disability start date has nothing to do with what HR puts in their system
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
BEEN THERE WITH THE DATE CONFUSION and it cost me days at the front of my claim. EDD went with the date I put on my form even though my doctor had an earlier date, and I ended up having my waiting period run from the later date. By the time I figured out what happened it was past the window where it was easy to fix. If you catch this early you are in much better shape than I was. Get someone at EDD on the phone or use the written request feature as fast as you can.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorHow did you eventually find out EDD had used your date instead of your doctor's? Did it show up on a notice or did you figure it out from the payment schedule?
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
The Notice of Computation showed a start date I recognized as mine, not my doctor's, and when I did the math on the waiting period end date it was clear I'd lost payable days at the front end
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
The Notice of Computation is the first place to look for the start date EDD has on file — if yours is wrong it shows up right there and that's your documentation for the correction request
0 coins
Andre Laurent
My claim took almost three weeks to move out of pending even with a clean submission and no date problems. EDD processing time is just slow sometimes. Don't assume the date mismatch is definitely the reason your claim is still pending — it might just be the queue.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Three weeks pending with no date issue is wild. Mine cleared in nine days and I thought that was slow
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorWhether it's the date mismatch or just the queue, I'd still rather know which one it is so I can stop guessing
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Claim start date on mine was entered wrong when I first filed — I realized it after the fact because my own paperwork and the SDI Online timeline didn't line up. Claimyr put me on with an EDD agent who looked at the claim and told me the exact start date EDD had on record. It matched my form, not my doctor's earlier date, so I knew right away what needed to be corrected.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Having the agent read off the exact date EDD has on record cuts out all the guessing — you know specifically what you're dealing with and can go from there
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorThat's the confirmation step I've been missing. I want to know what date EDD actually has, not what I think they should have
0 coins
Liam Mendez
My cousin went through something similar and she said EDD just fixed it on their own without her doing anything. I'm not sure that's always how it works but it happened for her.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
Whether EDD catches a date discrepancy on their own depends on what the difference is and whether a reviewer flags it. It happens sometimes, but counting on it without following up is a risk — the safer move is to use the written request option to put the question on record
0 coins
Liam Mendez
Yeah she was pretty lucky about the whole thing, I definitely wouldn't tell someone to just wait and hope
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Notice of Computation on my claim showed a weekly amount that looked lower than I expected, so I got to an EDD agent through Claimyr and asked which quarter they'd used for the base period calculation. The agent told me which quarter had been used and confirmed the wage total from it. The number on my notice came from a quarter that wasn't my highest because of when my disability started, so the calculator on EDD's site was what I used to run the numbers myself first.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Using the calculator on EDD's site before calling is smart — you go into the conversation with EDD knowing what to ask about rather than just saying the number seems off
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorI haven't gotten to the Notice of Computation stage yet but now I know to look at which quarter they used when I do
0 coins
AstroAce
Physical therapist at my rehab center told me she could certify my SDI claim and I was relieved because it would have been faster than getting back to my surgeon. Someone at EDD told me PT isn't on their list of providers who can certify a disability claim. I lost about 10 days waiting for a certification that EDD couldn't accept.
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of authorized providers for SDI certifications, unfortunately. The list includes physicians, osteopathic doctors, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, licensed midwives, and authorized medical officers at government facilities — but not PTs
0 coins
AstroAce
I wish I had known that before I waited. My surgeon's office did it in two days once I went back to them
0 coins
Luca Esposito
This is a really common mistake — a lot of people assume any licensed healthcare provider can certify. EDD's list is specific and PT not being on it surprises almost everyone who finds out the hard way
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
The whole waiting period concept confused me for so long because I thought it meant EDD was reviewing my claim for seven days before releasing payment. Someone finally explained it's just seven unpaid days at the start of every claim, no matter what. It's not about EDD's speed at all.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Seven calendar days from your disability start date, non-payable, every claim — once you understand it that way it stops feeling like something went wrong
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
Exactly, I spent a week being anxious about those days thinking EDD was dragging their feet and then I found out they were never going to pay them regardless
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Has anyone had a situation where the start date mismatch triggered an actual denial rather than just a longer pending period? I'm asking because my situation sounds similar to the original post and I want to know how bad the worst case actually is.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
A date mismatch by itself doesn't typically trigger a denial — a denial comes through a Notice of Determination, and you'd have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal using the DE 1000A form. A mismatch is more likely to cause a delay while someone reviews the two dates than an outright denial
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
If you do get a Notice of Determination and disagree with the decision, the appeal process is there for exactly that — the form comes with the notice and the 30-day window is from the date the notice was issued, not the date you receive it, so open it right away
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Good to know there's a formal path if it goes sideways. I'd rather fix it now than deal with an appeal later, but knowing the appeal option exists is reassuring
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
EDD's general mailing address is not where claim forms go — I see people say this sometimes. Whatever address is on your specific form or notice is the one to use. The form itself tells you.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Correct, and for anything you're submitting related to a claim already filed in SDI Online, the online route through SDI Online or Ask EDD is usually faster than mailing anything
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
The mailing thing tripped me up with a continuation form once — sent it to a general address and had to resubmit to the right one, which added delay I didn't need
0 coins
Isabella Brown
Have you checked whether EDD has actually received both parts of your claim? You can request a claim update through SDI Online to see the status. The pending status you're seeing doesn't necessarily mean there's a problem — it might just mean both parts came in and EDD is working through the queue.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorI've looked at the status screen several times but I honestly don't know what I'm looking for beyond it not saying 'approved.' I'll try the Request Claim Update path and see if I can get more specific information
0 coins
StarStrider
The status showing 'pending' after both parts are in usually means it's in the review queue, which is normal. If only one part was showing, the status would likely say something about the missing piece — pending typically just means processing is happening
0 coins