Back to California Disability

Axel Far

Should I file SDI paid family leave first after having a baby — which one do you start with?

So I'm about 6 weeks away from my due date and I'm already confused about the order I'm supposed to file things. My coworker said I should file for Paid Family Leave right away after the birth but then someone else told me SDI comes first because of the pregnancy itself. I honestly don't know if those are even the same thing or two different claims. I've been on EDD's site and I keep going in circles. Can someone walk me through which one to file first and when? I don't want to mess up the timing and lose benefits.

The order matters and your coworker has it a little backwards. Disability Insurance, what most people call SDI, covers you during pregnancy and recovery from the birth itself. That part typically starts about 4 weeks before your due date and continues 6 weeks after a vaginal birth or 8 weeks after a C-section. Paid Family Leave is completely separate, a different claim, and it kicks in after your SDI recovery period ends, for bonding with your baby. So SDI comes first, always.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

So I'd be filing two totally separate claims at different times? I didn't realize they were different programs at all.

0 coins

Exactly two separate claims filed at different times. File your SDI claim through SDI Online in myEDD, and then when your recovery period wraps up, you file the PFL bonding claim separately.

0 coins

Worth adding that the SDI claim needs your doctor or midwife to submit a medical certification after you file your part. Without that piece the claim just sits there.

0 coins

Weeks 1 through 10 on my SDI I never knew which had paid out and which hadn't, so I ended up reaching out through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to talk to someone at EDD's disability line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks were paid and which were still pending. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. She also confirmed my doctor's certification had come through fine, which was the thing I was most worried about.

0 coins

I used Claimyr too and I'm so glad I did. The agent I spoke with checked which quarter of my base period EDD had on record for my calculation, turns out it was the highest-earning quarter from about a year before I went out, which is exactly what my Notice of Computation said. Good to have someone confirm it out loud though. How long had your claim been open when you phoned?

0 coins

Mine was about seven weeks in when I called. The agent was clear and had everything right there.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

Did you have to do anything special before the call, like have your claim ID ready?

0 coins

Claim ID, your Social Security number, and the first day of your disability. That's what I had on hand and it was enough.

0 coins

File the SDI claim around 4 weeks before your due date. Your ob or midwife submits the medical certification side. Don't wait until after the birth to start that.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

My midwife mentioned she can file through SDI Online directly. Is that how most providers do it now?

0 coins

Yes, providers file through SDI Online using the receipt number you get when you submit your part. Give it to them right away.

0 coins

I'm not sure if a midwife counts for SDI or if it has to be an actual OB. Does anyone know for certain?

0 coins

Licensed midwives, nurse-midwives and nurse practitioners are all on EDD's list of providers who can certify a pregnancy claim. A midwife is fine.

0 coins

Nobody told me any of this with my first kid and I filed PFL before my SDI was even done. EDD sorted it out eventually but it took forever and I had a gap in payments. File SDI first. ALWAYS. Do not let anyone tell you otherwise.

0 coins

How long was the gap? That's the part that scares me for my wife's claim.

0 coins

About two and a half weeks before things lined up. Not the end of the world but we had bills due so it stung.

0 coins

The good news is EDD does sort it out, it just takes more back and forth when the order gets mixed up. Getting it right from the start saves a lot of that.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the timeline in numbers: SDI typically starts 4 weeks before the due date, runs 6 or 8 weeks after birth depending on delivery type, and your provider can extend beyond that if there are complications. The PFL bonding claim picks up where SDI leaves off. The two programs are funded differently and filed separately even though both live in SDI Online.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

The 4 weeks before the due date part is what I needed to hear. So I should be starting my SDI claim right around now?

0 coins

Pretty much, yes. Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online to file your Claimant's Statement. Then give the receipt number to your midwife so she can submit the medical certification.

0 coins

Just to put a point on the timing: the medical certification has to be submitted no later than 49 days from your disability start date. Keep track of that date.

0 coins

Both programs are real and both pay, just at different times. SDI for the pregnancy and birth recovery, PFL for bonding. Don't skip SDI thinking PFL covers it. It doesn't cover your recovery.

0 coins

Is the PFL bonding amount the same as what you get from SDI?

0 coins

Both are based on your wages but the actual amount comes from your Notice of Computation for each claim. Check the numbers there.

0 coins

EDD's benefit calculator on their site gives an estimate before you file if you want a ballpark.

0 coins

My partner's C-section claim needed extra weeks beyond the standard 8, so the doctor had to fill out the DE 2525XX form to extend it. Had no idea that form existed until payments stopped. Tried calling EDD for days, the line just rang or cut me off. Ended up using Claimyr and the agent confirmed the extension form had been received and was under review for her claim. Total relief because I had no idea where it stood.

0 coins

Honestly I'm a little unsure whether a service like that is actually for real or if it's just marketing. I've seen so many things that promise to help with EDD and they never do anything.

0 coins

i thought the same thing but then i tried it after my own claim got stuck and the person i talked to actually worked for edd and found what was missing on my file. answered questions about my DE 2593 that i had to return and told me the deadline. it was a real edd agent, not some third party.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps. If it's a real EDD agent answering then maybe I'd try it for my own extension question.

0 coins

That's exactly it, you're talking to EDD's own staff. I had all my claim info ready and it went quickly.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me at first too. The first 7 days of your SDI claim are unpaid no matter what. That's not EDD dragging its feet, it's just how the program works. Day 8 is when benefits can actually start.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

So even if my doctor submits everything perfectly on day one, those first 7 days are just gone?

0 coins

Yep, gone. It's written into the program. Plan for that gap in your budget ahead of time if you can.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period only applied if you hadn't worked long enough. Didn't realize everyone had to sit through it.

0 coins

Every new SDI claim has the 7-day waiting period regardless of work history. It's the first seven days of the claim, non-payable, end of story.

0 coins

From a paperwork standpoint: when you file Part A of your claim in SDI Online you get a receipt number. Write it down and give it to your provider that same day. They use it to find your claim and file the medical certification. EDD's target is to respond within 14 days of getting both parts.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

Part A is just my portion, right? The claimant statement?

0 coins

Correct, Part A is what you fill out. The provider completes the medical certification separately through SDI Online using that receipt number.

0 coins

my midwife didnt know what a receipt number was at first. had to send her a screenshot.

0 coins

people keep asking about the bank of america debit card for edd payments. that card doesnt exist anymore, edd switched to money network. just a heads up so nobody's looking for the wrong thing in their mailbox

0 coins

Didn't know that. I still see people on other forums saying to watch for the BofA card.

0 coins

yeah its outdated info. money network card now, or you can set up direct deposit through SDI Online when you file.

0 coins

Direct deposit is the move. I never trusted a card I didn't ask for.

0 coins

Automatic payment is set up for most pregnancy claims and after 10 weeks EDD sends the DE 2593, the Continued Eligibility Questionnaire. Return it within 20 days. Missing that deadline is a fast way to have payments stop.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

20 days feels short. Does EDD mail it with enough notice or does it kind of sneak up on you?

0 coins

It arrives with the final automatic payment notice. Put the return deadline on your calendar the day it shows up.

0 coins

EDD also sends the DE 2525XX extension form with the final payment notice if your provider still has you out. Your doctor fills that out to continue benefits past the initial period.

0 coins

my sister told me to file pfl first because she said sdi is only for like injuries. dont listen to that. sdi covers pregnancy and birth recovery, its not just injuries. file sdi first always

0 coins

That's a really common mix-up. SDI covers any non-work-related illness, injury, or pregnancy. Pregnancy claims make up a huge chunk of what goes through the program every year.

0 coins

yeah i wish i had known that before i asked her lol

0 coins

Start date on my claim got flagged as the wrong date because I listed my last day of work instead of the first day I couldn't do my job. Spent too long trying to figure out why my payment math looked off. Tried phoning EDD maybe a dozen times over two weeks and never got a person. Eventually went through Claimyr and the agent told me the claim's start date that was on file, confirmed it was one day off, and said to watch for a notice about correcting it. Got that straightened out.

0 coins

When you reached the agent, did you need to have the original paperwork with you or just your claim ID?

0 coins

Claim ID and my Social Security number. Had the confirmation email from when I filed too, just in case. Agent had everything on their end.

0 coins

ive been trying that phone number for three weeks. mornings, afternoons, doesnt matter. never once got through.

0 coins

For pregnancy specifically, if you have work restrictions before the due date, your provider can certify you for SDI before the standard 4-week window. So if your doctor pulls you from work at 30 weeks because of complications, that's when your SDI clock starts, not at 36 weeks.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

My midwife mentioned modified duty restrictions starting around 32 weeks. Would that count?

0 coins

If your provider certifies that you can't do your regular work, yes it can count. Talk to your midwife specifically about what she'd put in the certification. That's what EDD goes by.

0 coins

Provider's certification language matters. Unsafe conditions or inability to do regular duties, certified by the provider, is what starts the clock.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is basically theater. I've tried it at every hour on every day and gotten through maybe twice in two years. Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online if you need a status and you can't get anyone live.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update at least shows you something. Better than listening to that hold music for an hour and then getting disconnected.

0 coins

To use it: in myEDD, open SDI Online, pick your claim ID, then Request Claim Update, choose your request type and type out your question. Not instant but it works.

0 coins

If EDD denies the claim or the amount looks wrong on the Notice of Computation, is there a way to push back? I keep hearing about appeals but I don't know how that actually works.

0 coins

A denial comes with a Notice of Determination and an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to file the appeal. Send it to the return address on the notice with a written explanation of why you disagree.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not the date I receive it?

0 coins

From the date printed on the notice, yes. If you're close to the deadline, send it and note in your letter if there was a mail delay.

0 coins

If the actual form gets lost you can write a detailed letter instead. The key is getting something in within that 30-day window.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had an amount that looked lower than I expected based on what I earned. Tried the EDD line probably eight mornings straight, nothing. Went through Claimyr and an agent told me the base period quarter EDD used for my calculation and confirmed the weekly benefit amount on the notice was what the system showed. Turned out I'd just misjudged which quarter they'd pull from.

0 coins

The base period thing is exactly what I've been trying to sort out for my own claim. I'll try Claimyr for it. Should I have my pay stubs from the base period with me when I call?

0 coins

Have your Notice of Computation in front of you, your claim ID, and if you have earnings records from about 5 to 18 months before your claim started, bring those too. The agent can tell you what quarter is on file.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

I didn't even know there was a calculator on EDD's site. I should probably run my numbers through that before I file so I have an idea what to expect.

0 coins

EDD's benefit estimator is on their site. Just a ballpark, the real number is whatever the Notice of Computation says when it arrives.

0 coins

My wife's claim sat pending for almost three weeks and nobody could tell us why. Eventually the Notice of Computation showed up and the first payment hit about two days later. Seemed like it all moved at once.

0 coins

That's pretty typical. The notice and first payment often come close together once EDD finishes processing everything.

0 coins

Would've been nice to know that going in. We were stressed for nothing during that wait.

0 coins

The pending stretch is the hardest part. Nothing looks like it's moving and then everything lands at once.

0 coins

Don't forget the payment for PFL bonding is a separate Notice of Computation. Some people expect their SDI amount to carry over and then get surprised when PFL shows a different number.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

Why would they be different? Isn't it based on the same wages?

0 coins

Both are based on your earnings but the base period for each claim might end up being slightly different depending on when each claim starts. Check each notice separately.

0 coins

Run both through EDD's calculator with the right quarter for each claim start date. The estimates will show you if there's a difference.

0 coins

Does the SDI waiting period apply to Paid Family Leave too or just the disability part?

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. The 7-day unpaid stretch is only for SDI disability claims. PFL bonding benefits can start from day one of that claim.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I had assumed both had it.

0 coins

A lot of people assume that. The two programs really do work differently even though they're both filed through SDI Online.

0 coins

just want to say this whole thread answered questions i didnt even know i had. filing sdi in a few weeks and was going to do it completely in the wrong order

0 coins

File your part first, hand the receipt number to your provider right away, and let the medical certification follow. That sequence keeps everything moving.

0 coins

Axel Far

Author

Same here honestly. When I first posted I thought SDI and PFL were the same thing. Very glad I asked.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure