Back to California Disability

Sophia Gabriel

Sedgwick short term disability vs California EDD SDI — do you file both or just one?

So I've been out of work for about three weeks now after a back procedure and my HR department keeps saying I need to go through Sedgwick for short term disability. Fine, I did that. But then a coworker mentioned I should also be filing with California EDD for SDI. I honestly had no idea these were even two separate things. Is Sedgwick handling the state disability piece too, or do I need to go into SDI Online and file a whole separate claim with EDD? My doctor already submitted something to Sedgwick but I don't know if that counts as the medical certification EDD needs. I'm already three weeks out and kind of panicking about whether I've missed a window to file with EDD at all.

Filing with Sedgwick and filing with California EDD SDI are two completely separate processes. Sedgwick manages your employer's private short term disability plan, but that has nothing to do with EDD's state program. You need to go into SDI Online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and file your own claim there. The doctor's paperwork sent to Sedgwick does not transfer to EDD. Your provider will need to find your EDD claim using the receipt number you get when you submit Part A, then certify it separately through SDI Online. The good news about your timeline: EDD gives you 49 days from when your disability started to file without getting disqualified, so if you're three weeks out you still have time, but move on it today.

0 coins

49 days from the start date, not from when I started feeling better or anything like that? So I count back to the actual first day I couldn't work?

0 coins

Exactly from that first day you were unable to do your regular work. And your doctor certifies based on that same start date, so make sure you and your provider are using the same date when you file.

0 coins

My HR also made it sound like Sedgwick handled everything and I didn't find out about the separate EDD filing until week five, almost missed the 49-day window entirely. File on SDI Online first thing.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up for me after my initial claim ran out and I needed more time off — that's the extension form my doctor had to submit when I wasn't ready to go back. Getting EDD to confirm they'd received it was a nightmare because the phone line just rang endlessly. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through; it holds the line with EDD so you end up talking to an actual agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2525XX had come in and was matched, which was all I needed to know. If you're ever waiting on something like that and can't get anyone on the phone at 1-800-480-3287, that's worth knowing about.

0 coins

Okay so I need to know about the extension form too eventually. Right now I'm just trying to get the original claim in. But saving this for when I get there.

0 coins

The 1-800-480-3287 number is real but getting through is genuinely rough. Early mornings on a Tuesday or Wednesday worked better for me personally, though it's still not guaranteed.

0 coins

The agent also walked me through which weeks were still pending on my end, so it wasn't just about the extension form. Worth getting a real person for anything time-sensitive.

0 coins

About the medical certification piece — your provider can't just call it done by sending something to Sedgwick. EDD's certification has to go through SDI Online specifically. You file Part A yourself, you get a receipt number, you give that receipt number to your doctor's office. They log into the provider side of SDI Online and submit the certification tied to that receipt number. Without that number matching, EDD has no way to connect the medical piece to your claim. The office may push back and say they already submitted it somewhere — just be clear that EDD's system is completely separate from whatever Sedgwick uses.

0 coins

My doctor's office actually told me this morning they'd never submitted anything to EDD. At least now I know what to tell them.

0 coins

Same thing happened at my provider — they were confused about whether EDD and Sedgwick shared a system. They don't. Receipt number is the whole key to getting the certification matched correctly.

0 coins

And once it's matched, EDD typically reaches out about the claim status within around two weeks. Not a guarantee, but that's the general window they describe.

0 coins

Quick sanity check on the waiting period because a lot of people mix this up with processing time. The first seven days of your EDD disability claim are just not payable. EDD calls it the waiting period. It doesn't mean EDD is processing your claim for seven days — it means those seven calendar days are simply not covered, and your first payable day is day eight. So even once your claim is approved, you won't see anything for that first week. It tripped me up when I expected payment from day one.

0 coins

Wait so that's separate from however long it takes EDD to actually process the claim? So I lose a week on top of processing time?

0 coins

Correct. The seven days are just gone regardless — not a delay, not something that gets paid later. Processing happens on top of that.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period only applied if you hadn't worked the full quarter before. Had to look it up and no, it applies to every new claim. Good to know before you're counting days.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind about Sedgwick and EDD running at the same time: some employers coordinate the two so that your Sedgwick short term disability offsets what EDD pays, meaning your total doesn't stack above your normal salary. How that actually works is between you and your employer. EDD decides your SDI benefit amount on its own based on your wages, and your Notice of Computation will show your weekly benefit amount. For an estimate before that notice comes, EDD has a calculator on their site.

0 coins

HR kind of glossed over this part. I'll ask them directly how the coordination works on their end. I just want to make sure I'm not accidentally double-dipping in a way that causes problems later.

0 coins

Asking HR is exactly right. EDD pays what EDD pays based on your base period wages — anything about how your employer's plan interacts with that is on them to explain.

0 coins

My employer's HR was completely useless on this question and I ended up with an overpayment notice from EDD six months later. Document everything your HR tells you about how the two plans coordinate.

0 coins

Claim start date was the thing that almost wrecked my filing. SDI Online asked me for the first day I was unable to work, and I put the date of my procedure rather than the day before when I'd actually stopped working. The agent I reached told me the start date on file was different from what my doctor had certified, and that mismatch was holding things up. I'd used Claimyr to get to someone at EDD because I'd been trying the disability line for days. The agent found that my claim's start date and the medical certification date were off by one day and told me how to request a correction through SDI Online.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of thing I would have gotten wrong. So the start date should be the first day I actually couldn't do my job, not the date of the procedure itself?

0 coins

For me it was the day before the procedure when I stopped being able to work my normal shift. Your situation might be different — your doctor can help clarify based on when you were medically restricted. The key is that your date and your doctor's date have to match.

0 coins

Mismatched dates are more common than people think. I've seen it come up a lot in threads like this. Getting that corrected early saves a lot of back-and-forth with EDD.

0 coins

About the 49-day filing deadline — once you file within that window, you're not on the clock anymore. The deadline is just for getting your Part A in. After that, your provider has their own window to get the medical certification submitted, also 49 days from your disability start date. So if your start date was three weeks ago and you file today, your doctor still has about four weeks to get their part in. Don't let the office assume they have more time than they do.

0 coins

I had no idea the doctor had their own deadline separate from mine. Calling the office today.

0 coins

Tell them you need the receipt number from your EDD filing first — they need it to find your claim in SDI Online and submit their part. Without that number, they can't attach the certification to your claim.

0 coins

My doctor's office actually has a whole person who handles SDI certifications. If your provider is a large practice, ask to be transferred to whoever handles disability paperwork — they'll know the SDI Online process better than the front desk.

0 coins

Once your claim is filed and the certification is in, the Notice of Computation is usually the first real communication you get from EDD. It lists your potential weekly benefit amount and your maximum. It doesn't mean you're approved — just that EDD has calculated what the benefit would be if you qualify. I remember freaking out thinking it was the final approval and then realizing I still needed to wait on the actual payment.

0 coins

So I should not interpret that notice as 'you're getting paid' — it's more of a 'here's what you'd get if everything checks out'?

0 coins

Right. If something is off and your claim isn't payable, EDD sends a different notice, the Notice of Determination, which also includes appeal instructions. The Notice of Computation is just the math piece.

0 coins

Payments usually start coming within about two weeks after EDD has both parts of the claim — your statement and the doctor's certification. The Notice of Computation often arrives before the first payment.

0 coins

My Sedgwick claim and my EDD SDI claim had completely different forms, different timelines and different definitions of what 'disability' meant. Sedgwick's threshold for my employer's plan was different from EDD's standard, which is basically whether you can do your regular work. I qualified for Sedgwick before I qualified under EDD's rules, which surprised me. Just know the two systems are evaluating your claim independently.

0 coins

That's a really useful framing. So I shouldn't assume that because Sedgwick approved me, EDD will automatically agree.

0 coins

Exactly. File with EDD on your own merits and let EDD make the call. Don't mention the Sedgwick approval in your filing as if it proves eligibility — EDD has its own criteria.

0 coins

There's also no shared database between Sedgwick and EDD that I know of. What one system holds about your claim doesn't flow to the other automatically.

0 coins

Payments from EDD go to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you switch it to direct deposit in SDI Online. If you remember hearing about an EDD card being from Bank of America a few years ago, that changed — it's Money Network now. Setting up direct deposit through SDI Online is usually faster if you want it in your bank account directly.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll set up direct deposit when I file. I'd rather not deal with a prepaid card.

0 coins

You can set it up during the filing process or after in your SDI Online profile. Either way works.

0 coins

The Money Network card took a few days to show up in the mail after my first payment was issued. If you don't set up direct deposit, factor in that delay.

0 coins

Coming from someone who was in a totally different situation — I went out on leave for a pregnancy and also had Sedgwick through my employer. The question of which weeks EDD covers as disability vs. when PFL kicks in confused me for a long time. EDD disability covers the period you're physically unable to work, including before and after the birth. The bonding time after that is Paid Family Leave, which is a completely separate EDD program with its own claim. Don't file them as one thing.

0 coins

I'm not in a pregnancy situation but I know others reading this probably are. So disability ends, PFL starts, and you have to file PFL separately?

0 coins

Exactly. Two different claims in SDI Online. EDD actually sends a notice toward the end of the disability claim explaining the PFL option. Some people miss it and think their benefits just stop.

0 coins

EDD disability for pregnancy is typically about 4 weeks before the due date and either 6 or 8 weeks after depending on the delivery. The provider certifies how long each phase lasts.

0 coins

Notice of Computation numbers confused me completely when mine arrived because I expected one weekly figure but the notice showed a range tied to different income amounts. Had been trying to get a straight answer out of EDD for days. DE 2500E was also sitting in my stack and I wasn't sure if it was related to the computation. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr after the phone line kept cutting out — the agent pulled up my specific base period quarter and confirmed which wages fed into the calculation and what my weekly benefit amount actually was. It matched the notice once I understood which quarter they'd used.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation is based on a specific quarter of my wages? Not my salary right now?

0 coins

EDD looks at your highest earning quarter within a base period of four quarters, roughly five to eighteen months before your claim starts. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate before the notice arrives.

0 coins

The base period math trips a lot of people up. If you recently got a raise or changed jobs, the base period might pull from wages before that change, which can affect your benefit amount. Worth running the estimate on EDD's site.

0 coins

Workers' comp came up when I was asking around about my situation, and I want to flag the difference clearly. If your injury happened at work or is work-related, that's workers' comp territory, not California EDD disability. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time, though there are exceptions. If your situation is a non-work injury or illness, EDD disability is the right path. Getting the distinction wrong can cause problems with both claims.

0 coins

Mine is definitely not work-related, it's a back issue that just happened, so I should be fine with the EDD SDI route. But good to know the line.

0 coins

In that case you're in the right place. Workers' comp is for injuries caused by or happening during work. EDD disability covers everything else that keeps you from your regular job.

0 coins

The workers' comp vs. SDI distinction also matters because they're handled by completely different agencies. Workers' comp goes through your employer and the Division of Workers' Compensation, not EDD at all.

0 coins

About going back part time — when you do eventually return, even partially, you need to report that to EDD. EDD decides how to handle payment for a partial week, and it's not just automatic. Don't assume that because you're still out more days than you're in, you don't have to report anything. Failing to report earnings when you go back is what leads to overpayment notices down the road.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the partial return scenario at all. If I go back two days a week before I'm fully cleared, I report that to EDD?

0 coins

Every time. EDD handles the math on what you receive for that week. What you need to do is make sure you're not certifying as fully out of work when you're actually putting in some hours.

0 coins

The overpayment notice situation is not fun. Had one after I went back part time and thought I was reporting correctly. Keep records of exactly which days you worked and what you earned for each week.

0 coins

To bring it back to the original question about Sedgwick vs. EDD: file with EDD through SDI Online regardless of what Sedgwick does. They are parallel systems. You are entitled to file for SDI benefits if you paid into SDI through your CASDI deduction on your paycheck. That deduction funds the state program, not your employer's plan. Many workers don't even realize they've been contributing the whole time.

0 coins

I checked my pay stubs and yes, CASDI is definitely on there. So I've been paying into this whole time and had no idea.

0 coins

Almost everyone in California who works as an employee has that deduction. It funds EDD's disability and paid family leave programs. You've earned the right to file.

0 coins

This is what HR should be explaining to employees upfront but rarely does. Sedgwick handles the employer's piece, but EDD SDI is the state program and completely separate.

0 coins

Unemployment also sometimes comes up in these threads as an option, so I'll clarify the boundary. EDD disability and unemployment cannot be collected for the same days. Unemployment requires you to be ready, able and available for work every week you claim it. If you're out on disability and can't work, unemployment is not available to you at the same time. Once you're medically cleared and able to work again, that's when unemployment becomes relevant if you're also out of a job.

0 coins

Someone at work actually suggested I file for unemployment while on disability and I'm glad I didn't. So I'd have to repay that if I had?

0 coins

Collecting both for overlapping days would likely result in an overpayment on one side. The programs are mutually exclusive for the days you can't work.

0 coins

The key phrase is 'same days.' If your disability ends and you're cleared to work but don't have a job to return to, you can file for unemployment at that point. Sequential is fine, simultaneous is not.

0 coins

Continuation of your EDD claim after the initial approval period also isn't automatic for everyone. If you're on automatic payment, after ten weeks EDD sends a form called the DE 2593 — the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire — and you have 20 days to send it back or your payments stop. Easy to miss because by then people assume everything is running on its own. If you're not on automatic payment, EDD sends a different form every two weeks that you fill out to keep certifying.

0 coins

I had no idea about the DE 2593. So at week ten I need to watch for that form in the mail?

0 coins

In the mail, yes. Fill it out and return it within 20 days. It just confirms you're still unable to work. Missing it is one of the most common reasons payments unexpectedly stop.

0 coins

Setting a reminder for around week eight to check your mail is smart. By then you're usually feeling better and not watching for EDD correspondence as closely.

0 coins

About the automatic payment setup — when you file through SDI Online, there's an option during the process to enroll in automatic payment. If you do, EDD issues payments for two-week periods without requiring you to certify each one manually, up to that ten-week point before the DE 2593. If you don't enroll in automatic, you get the DE 2500A form every two weeks and have to return it. I'd recommend automatic just to reduce the amount of paperwork you're managing while recovering.

0 coins

Automatic sounds like less stress. I'll make sure I select that when I file today.

0 coins

Just stay alert at week ten for the DE 2593 like the comment above mentioned. Automatic doesn't mean permanent — EDD still checks in at that point.

0 coins

Direct deposit plus automatic payment was my setup and it worked well. Payments appeared in my account without me doing anything for the first ten weeks, then the DE 2593 arrived and I filled it out the same day I got it.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about taxes on SDI benefits — California does not tax them, but whether there's any federal tax situation depends on specifics I'd point you toward EDD's tax information page or a tax professional for. Some people are surprised to get any kind of tax document related to SDI. Not the place for me to call it one way or the other on the federal side.

0 coins

Good to know California doesn't touch it at least. I'll look at EDD's site for the federal question.

0 coins

EDD's site has a section on taxes and SDI that's worth reading before you do your return. A tax professional can give you a clear answer based on your whole situation.

0 coins

I had a CPA handle my taxes the year I was on SDI just to make sure I wasn't missing something. Worth it for the peace of mind.

0 coins

Last thing on the SDI timeline that might help frame expectations: EDD typically issues most benefit payments within about two weeks of having a complete claim — meaning both your Part A and your provider's medical certification are in and matched. So the clock on that two-week window doesn't start until your doctor submits their part. File your end today, give your doctor the receipt number immediately, and follow up with the office in a few days to confirm they've submitted.

0 coins

Filed about an hour ago. Got the receipt number. Texting the doctor's office right now. Thank you all, seriously — I had no idea any of this existed before today.

0 coins

Two weeks from when the certification lands is roughly when to start watching for the Notice of Computation and then the first payment. Keep the receipt number saved somewhere you can find it easily.

0 coins

Good luck with the recovery. The system is confusing but once the two parts are matched EDD moves reasonably quickly. You did the right thing by not waiting any longer on the filing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure