Back to California Disability

Caden Turner

SDI sent to doctor for continued claim exam what to expect

So I got a notice from EDD saying they're sending my continued disability claim out to a doctor for some kind of exam or review. I'm still out of work because of my back and my own doctor has been certifying everything but now EDD wants their own examination? I honestly didn't know this was even a thing. I've been on claim for a few months and payments have been coming in okay but now I'm kind of panicking about what happens next. Does this mean they think I'm faking it or something? Will my payments stop while this is going on? Has anyone else gone through this kind of review mid-claim and what actually happens at that appointment?

Payments don't automatically stop when EDD sends you to an exam. The exam is just EDD getting a second opinion on whether your condition still prevents you from doing your regular work. Go, be honest about your limitations, and bring any notes your own doctor has given you about restrictions.

0 coins

Okay that makes me feel a little better. I was convinced they were about to cut me off. Do I need to bring my actual medical records or just show up?

0 coins

Bring whatever your treating doctor gave you, even just a note with your restrictions listed. The examiner will do their own assessment but having that context helps.

0 coins

I think I read somewhere that if you don't show up they can deny the claim? Not sure about that, just want to flag it in case.

0 coins

That's right. EDD expects you to cooperate with any exam they schedule as part of evaluating your continued eligibility. Missing it without a good reason can put the claim at risk. Reschedule if you have a conflict, don't just skip it.

0 coins

Two weeks of payments showed as pending out of nowhere on my own claim and I had no idea which ones EDD actually processed. Spent four mornings trying to get someone on that disability line, every single time it cuts out before you even hit the menu. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com), which basically parks itself on hold so you end up talking to a live person instead of a recording. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me weeks 11 and 12 had been paid out but week 13 was still pending because they were waiting on something from my provider. At least I knew what I was dealing with after that.

0 coins

That whole thing reads like a marketing plant to me. Nobody actually gets through to EDD by any method, let alone some third party app. I've called that number so many times I have it memorized and I've never once reached a person.

0 coins

Thought the same thing honestly, then tried it on my own claim after three weeks of nothing. The agent pulled up which quarter of my base period they were using for the wage calculation and confirmed it matched my highest-paid quarter. That was the one piece I needed to understand why my weekly amount landed where it did. Still makes me scratch my head that it worked when every direct call just ended.

0 coins

Alright. I'm not saying I'm sold but if the line just hangs up on me one more time I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

ive been trying that number since tuesday lol every time it just rings then dies

0 coins

My knee replacement claim went through a similar mid-claim review and what I found was that the examiner was quite thorough but also very matter-of-fact. They asked me to demonstrate my range of motion, asked about my daily activities and whether I could sit or stand for extended periods. The whole appointment took about 45 minutes. My payments continued without a gap.

0 coins

45 minutes is longer than I expected. Did they ask you anything about your job specifically, like what you actually do at work?

0 coins

Yes, they did ask about my job duties. I described what a normal workday looked like before my surgery and they made notes. I think they were comparing that against what I could physically do at that point.

0 coins

That detail about describing your actual job tasks is really useful. The whole point is whether you can do your regular work, so being specific about what your job involves makes a lot of sense to bring up.

0 coins

Went through one of these on my shoulder claim. They're not trying to catch you in a lie, they just want their own doctor to assess you. Tell the truth about your bad days too, not just the good ones.

0 coins

That's the part I keep second-guessing myself on. Some days are worse than others and I don't want to seem inconsistent.

0 coins

Be consistent by being honest. If Tuesday was rough and Thursday was okay, say that. That's just how injuries work and any doctor knows it.

0 coins

My extension request on my wrist injury claim took longer than I expected to process and I wasn't sure if the DE 2525XX had even been received by EDD. Tried the disability line across five different mornings and got nowhere, so I used Claimyr to reach an agent. The agent checked and told me the DE 2525XX was in their system and the extension period was under review. That got me off the ceiling, at least I wasn't waiting on something that had vanished.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about how the extension review relates to any exam EDD might schedule, or were those treated as separate processes?

0 coins

She said the extension review and any independent exam are handled separately. The exam is about current functional capacity and the extension certification is about the treating provider's opinion. Both can be active at the same time.

0 coins

been trying to reach that line for going on three weeks now. morning afternoon doesnt matter. good to know there are options.

0 coins

My clients who've been through these exams always come back saying it was way less scary than they built it up to be. The doctor isn't your enemy. Just don't push yourself to seem more able than you are just because you're nervous.

0 coins

I think that's exactly what I'd do, try to seem fine because I'm anxious about being there. Good reminder.

0 coins

Totally normal reaction. Just remember they're evaluating your limits, not grading your toughness.

0 coins

This helped me too. I kept worrying about how I'd come across.

0 coins

Sorry had to scroll back up. The payments continuing thing, so they keep paying while the exam result is pending? Or is there a gap? Asking because I've got rent due and I can't absorb a gap right now anyway.

0 coins

Generally payments continue while the review is pending. If EDD makes a determination that changes your eligibility they'll send you a written notice. That notice will have an appeal form and you have 30 days from the date on it to appeal if you disagree.

0 coins

Okay 30 days to appeal if something goes wrong. Got it. That's at least some runway, anyway.

0 coins

30 days sounds like a lot until you're the one waiting on rent. I'd keep checking SDI Online so you're not caught off guard.

0 coins

Has anyone had the exam result come back and their doctor disagree with it? I'm wondering what happens if EDD's doctor says one thing and your own doctor says another.

0 coins

My understanding is that if the exam leads to a denial or reduction, you receive a Notice of Determination and can appeal. Your own doctor's records and certifications would be part of the evidence in that appeal. EDD's examiner's opinion isn't automatically the final word.

0 coins

That's accurate. The appeal goes to an administrative law judge and both sets of medical evidence would be considered. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and the deadline is on the notice itself.

0 coins

Okay now I'm actually relieved there's a formal process if things go sideways. I didn't realize you could push back with your own doctor's records.

0 coins

EDD has been scheduling these exams more than they used to. Not a sign of anything specific to your claim. Just how they verify ongoing claims past a certain point.

0 coins

How long into a claim does this usually happen? Mine is about three months in and I'm wondering if I should expect one.

0 coins

No set timeline. It varies. Could happen, could not. Keep certifying through your doctor and respond to anything EDD sends you.

0 coins

Three months in and no exam here. Just keep your paperwork clean and don't miss any certifications.

0 coins

The claim start date on my SDI Online was showing something that didn't match what my doctor's office submitted as the first day I was out. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line and she confirmed the date EDD had on file, which was actually two days off from what I expected. Gave me the information I needed to sort it out with my provider.

0 coins

The notice of computation on my claim has an amount that seems off and I keep wondering if the start date is part of why. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when you call?

0 coins

Have your SDI Online claim ID, your Social Security number and the specific date or amount you're questioning ready before the agent picks up. The more precise you are the faster they can find what you need.

0 coins

start date being wrong sounds like a nightmare to fix. glad you caught it

0 coins

The best thing you can do before the exam is write down your worst day in the past few weeks and read it before you go in. Not to perform it, just to remind yourself what your actual limits are so you don't understate them in the moment.

0 coins

Writing it down before I go in is a great idea. I always blank when I'm put on the spot.

0 coins

Seconding this. People forget their real limitations when they're trying to stay composed in a clinical setting. Having something written means you don't have to rely on memory.

0 coins

December 4th my own doctor submitted the extension certification and I didn't see any change in my claim status for 11 days. Eventually the payment for that period posted and I realized the review had just been running in the background the whole time.

0 coins

Eleven days of nothing on the screen sounds awful. How did you keep from going crazy?

0 coins

Checked SDI Online every couple of days rather than every hour. Helped to have a rough sense of EDD's processing window rather than expecting something to happen overnight.

0 coins

The not knowing is the hardest part honestly.

0 coins

If you don't understand something the examiner asks, say so. Don't guess. Doctors doing these evaluations ask in clinical language sometimes and a confused answer can read wrong.

0 coins

I would have never thought to ask for clarification. I'd have just tried to answer and probably said something that didn't make sense.

0 coins

Exactly. It's okay to say you don't understand the question. Any competent examiner will rephrase.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my account listed a weekly benefit amount that I had questions about, so I reached an EDD agent through Claimyr. She confirmed which base period quarters were used and told me the Notice of Computation figure was final for that claim period. Having the actual numbers confirmed in writing on the notice helped me understand what I'd receive each pay cycle.

0 coins

The base period piece is exactly what had me confused on my own claim. Used Claimyr too after that and once the agent walked me through the DE 2593 I realized I'd waited too long to return it, which had paused things. Sent it back the same day.

0 coins

ive been trying to get through on that line for literally two weeks straight. every single morning

0 coins

Two weeks on that line with nothing is brutal. The DE 2593 thing bit me because I didn't even know what it was until after the fact.

0 coins

If EDD sends you to an exam and you're on automatic payment, keep an eye out for the DE 2593 around the 10-week mark. That form has to go back within 20 days or your payments pause. The exam and that form are two different things and both need to be handled.

0 coins

Wait the 20-day thing on the DE 2593, does the clock start from when they mail it or when you receive it?

0 coins

The 20 days runs from when it's sent, so return it as soon as you get it rather than waiting. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

Okay sending it back the day it arrives. Got it.

0 coins

My occupational therapist tried to submit my continued certification and I later found out EDD doesn't accept certifications from occupational therapists, only from licensed physicians and certain other practitioners. Almost cost me a payment period. Worth double-checking who is submitting yours.

0 coins

That list matters. EDD accepts certifications from physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, licensed midwives and certain others. An occupational therapist is not on that list. Your treating provider needs to be one of those.

0 coins

Mine is my actual physician so I think I'm okay but I would not have known to check that.

0 coins

This is one of those things that derails claims quietly. Glad someone said it.

0 coins

Not sure if this is related but I keep seeing 'pending' on my claim and I'm two weeks post-surgery. Does the exam thing happen to everyone or just some people on longer claims?

0 coins

Not everyone gets one. Shorter claims usually don't see it. Two weeks out is way too early for that to be the issue. Pending that early usually just means EDD is still processing.

0 coins

After the medical certification is submitted EDD typically contacts you about the claim's status within 14 days. If your provider submitted recently, give it that window before worrying.

0 coins

Okay 14 days. My doctor submitted six days ago so I'm still inside that window I guess. I'll wait.

0 coins

Bring photo ID to the exam and arrive a few minutes early. Some examination centers are strict about paperwork at check-in and being late can complicate things.

0 coins

Good practical point. I'd have shown up with nothing but my appointment confirmation.

0 coins

Confirmation, ID, and any restriction notes from your treating doctor. That's the minimum. Some people also bring a list of their current medications in case the examiner asks.

0 coins

EDD's independent exam doesn't override your doctor. It's input, not a verdict. Too many people come out of these thinking EDD's examiner had the final say and they just accept it.

0 coins

That's actually the most reassuring thing in this whole thread. I went in thinking their doctor automatically wins.

0 coins

Appeal rights exist for exactly that reason. Use them if the outcome doesn't match your situation.

0 coins

Exactly. Notice comes, read it, 30 days to appeal. That's the process.

0 coins

Does going to the exam mean your claim gets extended automatically or does your own doctor still have to submit the DE 2525XX?

0 coins

Your own provider still needs to submit the DE 2525XX for any extension. The exam EDD schedules is their own review and your provider's extension certification is a separate step that your provider handles on their end.

0 coins

Two different things running in parallel basically. Don't assume one covers the other.

0 coins

I'm going to make sure my doctor knows to submit that form regardless of what happens at the exam. I don't want to assume anything at this point.

0 coins

my doctor submitted everything on time and i still waited almost three weeks for my first payment. the exam thing is probably just another wait on top of a wait

0 coins

Three weeks isn't unusual for the first payment. Most go out within two weeks of EDD having the full claim, but it's not a guarantee.

0 coins

yeah i know now. at the time i was losing my mind though

0 coins

First claim is always the longest wait somehow.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure