Back to California Disability

Chloe Martin

SDI not deducted from paycheck — can I still get pregnancy disability benefits?

So I'm about 32 weeks along and just starting to look into filing for pregnancy disability through EDD. I pulled out my last few pay stubs to get my information together and I noticed the CASDI deduction is completely missing. Like, every single stub going back almost a year. My HR department said I'm classified as a salaried exempt employee but couldn't really explain why there's no SDI deduction. Now I'm panicking because I was counting on this to help cover my bills while I'm out before the baby comes. Has anyone dealt with this? Does not having SDI withheld from your checks mean I just don't get the benefits at all when I need pregnancy disability leave?

Those weeks SDI Online showed as pending were the reason I ended up talking to an EDD agent at all. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through after trying the number for days. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which weeks had actually been paid out versus which ones were still sitting. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The weeks question is exactly what I need answered on my own claim right now. Did the agent give you any specific form reference for the weeks that were still pending, or just the status?

0 coins

Just the status and dates for each week. No form number. She confirmed which ones had gone through and which were still being processed.

0 coins

37 days trying that line before 8 a.m., after 4 p.m., Fridays. Never made it through to a person once.

0 coins

Your HR department may have enrolled you in a Voluntary Plan, which is a private plan an employer can get approved instead of contributing to the state SDI fund. If that's the case, your pregnancy disability claim would go through that private plan, not EDD. Ask HR directly whether the company has a Voluntary Plan and who the administrator is.

0 coins

I didn't even know that was a thing. So I might still be covered, just through a different channel? I'll go back to HR with that specific question.

0 coins

The Voluntary Plan explanation above is right. Some employers also just have an error or misclassify workers. Worth getting it in writing from HR either way before your due date.

0 coins

Another angle: sometimes payroll vendors drop deductions during a system switch and it goes uncorrected for months. HR might not even know it happened. Push them to check the actual plan enrollment, not just your pay stub.

0 coins

no CASDI on the stub for a whole year is not a small oversight. Either a voluntary plan or somebody in payroll messed up. EDD disability line is useless to call, they let you sit there forever and then the line just drops. If its a payroll error your employer might owe you but thats their problem to fix, not yours.

0 coins

Payroll error is on the employer. They'd have to sort out back deductions with EDD. You personally shouldn't be the one penalized for it.

0 coins

Assuming EDD sees it that way. I wouldn't count on anything until you have it confirmed in writing from someone who actually knows.

0 coins

Hang in there! The Voluntary Plan thing is a real possibility. I had a coworker whose company had one and she got her pregnancy disability paid through the private plan no problem. Definitely worth asking HR to send you the plan documents!

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually reassuring to hear it worked out for someone. I emailed HR this morning asking for the plan documents.

0 coins

Good move asking for the documents. If they can't produce them quickly, that tells you something about how organized their benefits team is.

0 coins

Wait, I'm kind of confused. So if there's no SDI taken out and there's no voluntary plan either, does that mean you're just completely out of luck for pregnancy disability? Like there's no other way to qualify? That seems really unfair given how close you are to your due date.

0 coins

Eligibility for DI depends on having wages subject to SDI tax in the base period, at least $300 worth. If the wages weren't subject to SDI, there may not be a path through EDD's state plan. That's exactly why figuring out the voluntary plan question first matters most right now.

0 coins

EDD's FAQ spells out the base period wage requirement. If the wages aren't in the SDI-covered pool, the state claim may not be there to file. The voluntary plan is the other door to try.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense now, thank you. So the voluntary plan is kind of the backup hope here. I hope HR responds fast for the original poster.

0 coins

My extension request through the DE 2525XX took longer than expected to process, so I ended up calling EDD about it. Tried the number on my own for three mornings in a row and never reached anyone. Eventually I got through to an agent using Claimyr, and she confirmed they had received the form from my provider and told me my claim's extension period.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX is exactly what I'm waiting on right now. Provider submitted it over a week ago and nothing has updated in SDI Online. Going to try Claimyr for that. Is there anything specific to have ready when you call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID number and the date your provider submitted the form. The agent pulled things up fast once I had those two things ready.

0 coins

Good to know about having the claim ID handy. I keep forgetting to write that down and then I'm scrambling when I actually need it, anyway.

0 coins

The extension piece is something a lot of people don't think about until the final payment notice shows up. Good that you got it sorted.

0 coins

my employer never took out casdi either and i just assumed i couldnt get anything. now im reading this and wondering if my job had one of those voluntary plans the whole time. gonna ask monday

0 coins

Ask HR to send you the actual plan document, not just a verbal answer. Sometimes the person at the front desk doesn't even know what voluntary plan means and you end up getting the wrong answer.

0 coins

yeah good call ill ask for it in writing so theres no confusion

0 coins

Before assuming it's a voluntary plan, check whether your employer is a public agency or a nonprofit. Some entities are exempt from mandatory SDI participation for certain employee categories. That changes where the claim would go, or whether one exists at all.

0 coins

Mine is a private company, so probably not that. But I hadn't thought to check. Good thing to rule out.

0 coins

Public school employees are one example where SDI participation can vary by district. For private employers without a voluntary plan and no CASDI deduction, that really is a payroll coverage question that HR has to answer, not EDD.

0 coins

Ask HR for the name of the plan administrator and a plan number. With a voluntary plan, you file your pregnancy disability claim with them directly, not SDI Online. Don't miss your filing window waiting for HR to get their act together.

0 coins

Filing window is what worries me. I'm 32 weeks, so I don't have a lot of runway. If the answer takes two weeks from HR I'll already be close to needing to file.

0 coins

Don't wait two weeks. Send a follow-up email tomorrow if you haven't heard back. Put in writing that you need the information before your planned leave date.

0 coins

32 weeks goes fast. HR at my job took forever to send me basic plan docs and i ended up filing late. push them now.

0 coins

Also worth knowing: even if you do end up filing through EDD's state plan, you'd typically want to file about 4 weeks before your due date. So if the CASDI question gets resolved in your favor you still have time, but not a ton of it.

0 coins

Four weeks before the due date is what I'd been reading too. That gives me maybe 4 to 5 weeks to get this sorted out before I really need to have filed. Not much buffer.

0 coins

Exactly. If HR drags their feet, go over the HR person's head to the benefits director or whoever signs off on plan documents. Don't let this sit.

0 coins

And if something comes up earlier, like your doctor puts you on reduced hours or restrictions before your due date, you can file for DI sooner than 4 weeks out. Worth knowing just in case.

0 coins

Spent the whole week wondering if EDD even had the right start date on my claim. Tried calling mornings and afternoons with no luck. Claimyr got me to an agent who looked up my claim and confirmed the date they had on record matched what I submitted.

0 coins

Start date was the same thing I needed confirmed on mine. Used Claimyr too, once I'd been at the number for two weeks with nothing. After the agent confirmed the date, I went straight into SDI Online and checked the base period quarter it landed in, made sure the right wages were being counted.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying the line and nothing. I'm at like a week and a half right now and starting to feel like I'll never reach anyone.

0 coins

Keep at it. Or try another way in like SDI Online's Request Claim Update if you can't get the phone to work.

0 coins

EDD's site does say you need wages subject to SDI deductions in the base period. If your wages weren't subject to SDI, the state plan claim may not be available to you, which is why the voluntary plan question is the most important thing to resolve right now. The base period covers about a year before your claim's start date.

0 coins

That's the part that worries me for the original poster. If payroll just quietly stopped deducting and there's no voluntary plan, she's in a rough spot at 32 weeks.

0 coins

If payroll made the error, the employer may have liability on that side, but that's between them and EDD. The poster can still file, and EDD will determine eligibility based on what wages were actually covered. Getting HR's written answer is still step one.

0 coins

I was in a similar situation once where my CASDI looked weird on my stubs. Turned out my employer had switched payroll systems and the deduction label changed and I'd missed it. So sometimes it's not actually missing, just labeled differently. Worth double-checking the deduction descriptions line by line.

0 coins

Oh that's a good point, I only looked at the CASDI line. I didn't look for alternate labels. I'll go through the full deduction list again tonight.

0 coins

California SDI deductions can show up as CASDI, CA SDI, or sometimes just SDI depending on the payroll platform. If you have a paystub total for all deductions, compare it against your W-2 box 14 or box 19 when you get it, that sometimes shows the SDI paid for the year.

0 coins

Great point about the W-2. I didn't even think of that.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on a pregnancy disability claim confused me more than I expected. The weekly amount didn't match what I'd mentally calculated. Used Claimyr to reach an agent who walked through which quarter of my base period they used and confirmed the number on the notice was what the system had.

0 coins

The number on my own Notice of Computation was lower than I thought it would be too. I've tried that disability line four times over three days and never gotten past the hold music. How did you even verify the agent was looking at your actual claim and not just reading you the same thing from a script?

0 coins

She gave me the exact quarter and the wage figure they used. Those matched my own records, so I knew she was looking at the real file.

0 coins

My DE 2593 came up during my own call through EDD! The agent told me the return window and what to watch for on the form. Super helpful to have that confirmed directly.

0 coins

Okay, the quarter and wage figure matching your records is a solid check. I might give it a try.

0 coins

Regardless of what the deduction situation is, file the claim when the time comes. EDD makes the eligibility call, not your HR department. You file, you let EDD decide. Don't talk yourself out of filing before you even try.

0 coins

That's actually the most direct advice I've gotten. I think I've been so focused on the HR mystery that I forgot I can just file and let EDD determine eligibility.

0 coins

Filing and finding out beats guessing and not filing. Worst case you get a denial and then you have an actual answer to work with.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you get a denial, you get a Notice of Determination with an appeal form. 30 days to appeal if you disagree.

0 coins

To sum up where things stand: check with HR for a voluntary plan and get it in writing, double-check your pay stub deduction labels, and file through EDD anyway when the time comes. EDD determines eligibility, not your employer's payroll department. You have enough time if you move on this now.

0 coins

HR got back to me this afternoon. No voluntary plan. They said it was a payroll configuration error going back about 14 months. They're working with their payroll vendor to correct it and said they'll submit the correction to EDD. No idea what that means for my claim yet but at least now I know what happened.

0 coins

14 months is significant. That's worth getting confirmed in writing from HR, with the specific period and their plan to correct it. When you do file, note in your claim that you believe wages were subject to SDI but not properly deducted, so EDD has that context.

0 coins

Payroll error affecting SDI eligibility is something EDD handles. File your claim, include a note about the error, and let EDD sort out the coverage question with your employer. You did the right thing by pushing HR for an answer.

0 coins

14 months of missing deductions is wild. glad they at least admitted it. hope the correction goes through before you need to file

0 coins

Me too. HR said they'd keep me updated but I'm going to follow up weekly at this point. Not leaving it to chance at 32 weeks.

0 coins

good instinct. document every conversation with HR about this in writing from here out

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: the answer to whether you can file for pregnancy disability without CASDI deductions really depends on whether your employer has a voluntary plan or whether the missing deduction was an error. Anyway, hope the original poster gets her answer from HR before her leave starts.

0 coins

Also worth adding that if complications come up before the due date, a provider can certify the disability earlier than 4 weeks out. The original poster should loop her doctor in on the timeline.

0 coins

My OB already knows I'm trying to sort this out. She's ready to submit the medical certification as soon as I file. That part at least feels organized.

0 coins

For the base period question specifically: if the payroll correction goes through and EDD recognizes those wages as SDI-covered, your base period should still have enough to meet the $300 minimum. That said, your Notice of Computation is what will show the actual weekly benefit amount once EDD processes everything. The calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough idea once you know which quarter they'd use.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a calculator on EDD's site. I'll try that. Would I use the corrected wages or the wages as they appear now on my stubs?

0 coins

Use what's on your stubs for now to get a rough floor number. If the correction goes through, the amount would potentially be higher. The Notice of Computation will be the real answer once EDD processes the claim.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site is a good planning tool. It won't lock in anything, but it gives you something to work with while the payroll situation gets sorted out.

0 coins

One more thing: when you do file on SDI Online, save your receipt number and get it to your OB right away. She'll need it to submit the medical certification. If she doesn't have that number, the certification and your claim don't link up and things slow down.

0 coins

Okay, receipt number to the OB immediately after filing. Got it. I didn't realize the certification wouldn't match without it.

0 coins

Yeah the medical certification goes in through SDI Online too and EDD matches it to your claim using that number. Easy step to miss when you're already stressed.

0 coins

So important. I told all my clients during their pregnancies to text the receipt number to their doctor's office the same day they file. Don't let it sit in your email.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure