Back to California Disability

Yuki Sato

SDI disqualified capable of doing customary work after recertification — how to appeal

So I've been on disability since late September after a back issue that kept me from standing at my register for more than a few minutes. My doctor certified me and payments were coming in fine. Then last month my doctor submitted a recertification and apparently checked something that EDD interpreted as me being capable of returning to my regular duties. I got a Notice of Determination in the mail saying I was disqualified because I was found capable of performing my customary work, but that's not what my doctor meant at all — she says she was noting improvement, not full clearance. Now I have no idea how to appeal this or what I'm supposed to send in. The notice says I have 30 days from the date it was issued. Has anyone been through this? What do I actually need to include to have a shot at getting this reversed?

Quarter two of my base period looked wrong on my claim, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone on the disability line and walked through the figures with an agent. She pulled up my record and confirmed which quarter they'd used and what wages were in it. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ On your situation: the Notice of Determination (DE 2517) has an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) attached. File it within 30 days of the date printed on the notice, not the date you got it. Write a clear explanation of what your doctor intended and get a signed statement from her to send with it.

0 coins

Claimyr worked the same for me. The agent pulled up my DE 2593 and confirmed EDD had received it and the return date they had on file. I'd been afraid to assume it went through.

0 coins

Wait, what's the DE 2593? I keep seeing that number and I'm not sure if I need to worry about it.

0 coins

It's the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire. EDD sends it after your first ten weeks on automatic payment. You have 20 days to send it back or benefits can stop. The agent confirmed mine was in and cleared.

0 coins

Oh wow okay, I'm on week eight so I guess I'll be watching the mail. Thanks for explaining that.

0 coins

The 30-day window is firm. Count from the date printed on the DE 2517, not the postmark and not the day it arrived in your mailbox. If that date has already passed you can still file, but you will need to give the administrative law judge a written explanation for the delay.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

The notice is dated the 4th and I got it on the 8th. So I have until the 4th of next month? I want to make sure I'm counting right.

0 coins

Yes, 30 days from the 4th. I would not wait until the last day — mail it with a few days to spare so a postal delay doesn't cost you.

0 coins

Does it have to be certified mail or is regular mail okay? I'm not sure if I need a tracking number for proof.

0 coins

EDD doesn't require certified mail, but having a receipt with the date gives you something to point to if there's ever a question about when you filed.

0 coins

EDD's appeals page spells this out: the DE 1000A is the form to use, or a detailed letter if you can't find it, mailed to the return address on the notice itself. Don't mail it to EDD's general address.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

The DE 1000A was attached to the back of my notice. So I fill that out and also include my doctor's letter?

0 coins

Exactly. The form plus any supporting documentation you have — the doctor's statement saying what she actually intended with that certification, any medical notes showing you're still restricted. Put it all in one envelope to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything before you send it.

0 coins

EDD's whole system for recertifications is a mess. One checkbox your doctor marks and they flip the whole claim without anyone calling to verify. I've been through two of these disqualifications in three years and the system is designed to make you give up.

0 coins

Frustrating, sure. But the appeal process does work. Got one overturned last year with a letter from my doctor.

0 coins

Good for you. Mine took months both times and I still got shorted on weeks I should've been paid.

0 coins

What documentation did your doctor send the second time? Trying to figure out what actually helped.

0 coins

For the appeal letter itself, your doctor's written clarification is probably the most important piece. Have her specifically say that the recertification was documenting partial improvement, not clearance to return to full duty at your job. The more specific she is about your actual physical restrictions, the better.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

She already told me she'd write something. Should it be on her office letterhead or does it matter?

0 coins

Letterhead helps because it looks official and has her license info on it, but what matters most is that it's signed, dated, and addresses exactly what EDD flagged — that you are still unable to perform your customary work duties.

0 coins

My doctor did the same thing for me. It made the difference.

0 coins

In your appeal letter, name your job duties specifically. If standing for a full shift is part of your customary work, say that. If lifting over a certain weight is required, say that. Give the administrative law judge something concrete to compare against your restrictions.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

That's really helpful. I'm a cashier so standing for the full shift is literally the job. I'll put that in writing.

0 coins

Good. And get your doctor to put the same thing in her letter — that standing for a full shift is what's required and that you still can't do that.

0 coins

This is what won ours. Specific job duties matched against specific restrictions. Vague letters don't do much, anyway.

0 coins

My payment method on file was showing the old card and I wasn't sure if my direct deposit switch had gone through, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent about it. The agent confirmed my direct deposit was active and told me which account number ending was on file. I found Claimyr got me to that agent when the line alone wasn't doing it for me. For your appeal — definitely include that doctor's clarification letter. The more she spells out your actual restrictions the better.

0 coins

Finding the name Claimyr in a disability forum feels like it belongs in a sponsored post, not a real thread.

0 coins

i thought that too at first but i tried it myself when my DE 2525XX extension wasnt showing in my claim. agent confirmed EDD had received the form and what date they logged it. wasnt marketing, just worked.

0 coins

All right, that's useful to know. I may look into it for a question I have about my own claim.

0 coins

The direct deposit switch is worth double-checking. Mine took an extra week to show as confirmed.

0 coins

Just to add — EDD's appeals go to an administrative law judge, so it's a real hearing, not just someone at EDD reviewing it again. That's actually in your favor because you get to present your doctor's clarification directly.

0 coins

Wait, is it like an in-person hearing? That sounds really intimidating.

0 coins

It can be in person or by phone depending on what they schedule. Either way you can bring documentation and the judge will read the medical records. Doesn't have to be scary.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

The thought of an actual hearing is stressing me out but knowing my doctor will write something helps.

0 coins

Ask your doctor to be explicit about what her recertification actually said versus what she intended. EDD reads those forms literally. If her language was ambiguous, a clarifying letter that addresses the specific wording is your best evidence.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

She said she marked that I was showing improvement in mobility. She did not mark that I was cleared for full duty, but I guess EDD read it as capable of customary work?

0 coins

That's a common problem. Have her write exactly that — improvement in mobility does not equal clearance for full shift standing. She should spell out what you still can't do.

0 coins

This is exactly the gap that creates these disqualifications. The form doesn't always capture nuance, so the letter has to.

0 coins

my doctor did a recert last spring and i had the same thing happen. i sent the appeal with a letter from her and it got overturned about six weeks later. dont give up on it

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Six weeks — okay, that's not as long as I feared. Did you have to do a hearing or did it resolve before that?

0 coins

mine resolved without a hearing. they just reviewed the letter and reversed it. not saying thats guaranteed but it happened for me

0 coins

Good to know that some do resolve at the review stage without going all the way to a judge.

0 coins

Pull together everything before you mail the appeal: the DE 1000A, your doctor's letter, and if you have any medical notes from appointments during the period they're questioning, include those too. Send it all together.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Should I also include a copy of the Notice of Determination itself or do they already have that?

0 coins

EDD has it, but including a copy doesn't hurt — write your claim ID on everything so it all gets matched to your file.

0 coins

Writing the claim number on each page is a smart habit. Offices deal with high volume and loose papers get separated.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot — not a disqualification yet but my doctor's office mentioned they're submitting my recertification this week and now I'm nervous reading this. Is there anything I can check in SDI Online to see what EDD actually receives from the doctor?

0 coins

SDI Online will show your claim status. If the medical certification is received it should update. Watch it over the next few days after the office submits.

0 coins

Okay. And if it doesn't update, do I call EDD or ask the doctor's office first?

0 coins

Start with the doctor's office to confirm they submitted and get the receipt number they used. Then if SDI Online still hasn't updated after a few more days, contact EDD through the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online.

0 coins

The receipt number matching is the part that trips people up. Worth confirming the office used yours.

0 coins

The medical certification received date showed up on my SDI Online claim but the status still said pending, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it. The agent confirmed EDD had received the certification and told me exactly what date it was logged — and that the form from my provider's office had come in under the right receipt number. For the appeal in this thread: dates matter. The agent mentioned that if a determination notice has been issued, the 30-day window runs from the date on that notice, not when you read it.

0 coins

What number did you give them to pull your record — was it the claim ID or something else?

0 coins

Just the claim ID and my identity info. The agent had the certification date on screen right away once she pulled the file.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for nine days straight. never gotten through once.

0 coins

The 30-day rule from the notice date — that's the piece people miss. Good to have it confirmed.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reach out to the doctor directly to verify what was intended, or does it all go through the appeals process?

0 coins

In my experience EDD goes by what's on the form. They don't typically contact the provider to clarify. The appeal is the mechanism for introducing that clarification.

0 coins

So basically the appeal is the only way to fix a documentation issue after the fact. Good to know.

0 coins

Yep. The notice is EDD's decision. If you disagree, appeal is the path.

0 coins

ours was a pregnancy claim and the doctor's recert after delivery got misread the same way, anyway we filed the appeal and had the doctor write that she hadn't cleared my wife for her full warehouse duties yet. overturned.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Pregnancy and a warehouse job — that's a lot to deal with. Glad it got overturned.

0 coins

took about seven weeks from when we mailed the appeal. rough financially but it came through.

0 coins

Seven weeks is a pretty typical window from what I've seen. Painful to wait but good to know it resolved.

0 coins

Might be worth filing through SDI Online's Request Claim Update to flag the issue in writing while the appeal is in process. Doesn't replace the appeal but it creates a record of you contesting it.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Can I use that even though a Notice of Determination has already been issued?

0 coins

Should still work for submitting a note. The formal appeal on the DE 1000A is the main thing, but a written message in SDI Online is on record.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option is in myEDD once you're in SDI Online. Worth using to document your position in writing alongside the appeal.

0 coins

the notice i got didn't have the appeal form attached. is there somewhere to get the DE 1000A separately

0 coins

EDD's site has it listed under forms. You can also write a detailed letter if you can't locate the form — EDD accepts that in place of the DE 1000A as long as it's detailed and mailed to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

ok a letter works, that's easier anyway

0 coins

If you go the letter route, include your name, claim ID, the date of the notice, and a clear statement that you are appealing and why. The more detail the better.

0 coins

For anyone trying to reach EDD while the appeal is pending, the SDI Online Request Claim Update is slower but it creates a paper trail. I used it to flag a question about my claim status and got a response within a couple of weeks.

0 coins

Two weeks for a response through that system is better than the phone line, honestly.

0 coins

Agreed. It's not fast but at least it doesn't just ring forever and then disconnect.

0 coins

yeah i'll try that. the phone has been impossible for me.

0 coins

You mentioned your doctor said she was noting improvement, not full clearance. Get that in writing from her before you do anything else. That letter is the whole case.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Calling her office first thing tomorrow morning. I want to make sure the letter specifically says I cannot stand for a full shift yet.

0 coins

Good. The more specific the better. Vague letters don't move the needle.

0 coins

Ask her office if they can turn the letter around quickly. The 30-day window doesn't stop while you're waiting on paperwork.

0 coins

Have you confirmed the date on your notice yet? The 30-day window goes fast when you factor in getting the doctor's letter, pulling your documents together, and mailing time.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Yes, it's dated the 4th. My doctor's office said they can have something ready by the end of the week, so I should have about two weeks to spare.

0 coins

That's enough time if the letter comes through as promised. Write a draft of your own explanation now so you're not scrambling when the letter arrives.

0 coins

Two weeks is plenty as long as the doctor's office follows through on schedule.

0 coins

Even if the appeal takes a while, keep any other documentation you get from your doctor during treatment. If the judge asks why you weren't back at work, medical visit records showing ongoing restrictions are hard to argue with.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

I have records from every appointment. Good to know I should hang onto all of them.

0 coins

Physical records, notes from the doctor, any work restriction slips — keep all of it. Appeals can go in unexpected directions.

0 coins

The more you have documented the less can be disputed. Learned that one the hard way, anyway.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure