SDI denied insufficient wages but W-2 shows SDI withheld — what do I do?
So I got a denial notice from California EDD saying I don't have enough wages in my base period to qualify for disability benefits. The thing is, my W-2 clearly shows CASDI deductions every single pay period last year. I was paying into the system the whole time. How does EDD say I had insufficient wages when I was clearly contributing to SDI? Has anyone else run into this disconnect? I filed my DI claim through SDI Online after my back surgery and was expecting some help while I'm out, not a denial letter. The notice says I can appeal within 30 days but I want to understand what went wrong before I do anything.
86 comments

Kelsey Hawkins
The waiting period on my own claim tripped me up before I finally got answers. Filed end of October, and by November 12th I still had no payment and kept seeing my claim sitting there. Claimyr (claimyr.com) was how I actually reached a live person at EDD disability — not a recording, not a hang-up, an agent who pulled up my claim. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my seven-day waiting period ran through November 7th and that the first payable day was the 8th, so my payment would process on that cycle. Worth knowing that the waiting period isn't the same as processing time — EDD counts those seven days as simply non-payable, not a delay.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
I've used Claimyr too and was honestly relieved it worked. The agent on my call found that my first payment had been issued on a specific date I hadn't seen in SDI Online yet — it just hadn't updated. So I stopped panicking. Can I ask — did they say anything about whether the payment date shifts if the waiting period straddles two pay cycles?
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
The agent didn't get into cycle mechanics, just confirmed the date it was issued. I took that and checked SDI Online the next day and it was there.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
That date thing matters a lot when you're counting on rent. Good to know an agent can at least confirm what's actually been issued versus what SDI Online is showing.
0 coins
Harper Collins
The denial notice is a DE 2517, right? It came with an Appeal Form DE 1000A. I want to appeal but I genuinely don't know what argument to make yet.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Yes, that is the correct form. When you appeal, write a detailed explanation of why you believe the denial is wrong. You'll want to attach anything that supports your case — your W-2, pay stubs showing the CASDI deductions, whatever you have. Mail it to the return address printed on your notice, not a general EDD address.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThank you, makes sense. So the W-2 showing CASDI withheld is actually useful evidence to include?
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Absolutely include it. It shows contributions were taken from your wages, which goes directly to the question of whether you had SDI-covered earnings in the base period.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Wait, does the W-2 by itself prove the wages though? I'm worried EDD might say the W-2 isn't enough. Would pay stubs be stronger?
0 coins
Sydney Torres
Both together are better than either alone. The W-2 shows the annual total, the pay stubs show individual pay periods and the CASDI line on each. Together they make a clearer picture of your earnings and contributions.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I've redialed that number before 8am four mornings in a row and either got the 'too busy' recording or sat on hold until it cut me off. How is anyone supposed to get answers?
0 coins
Caleb Bell
Same problem here. No way in without spending half your morning trying.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
And the whole time your claim is just sitting there with no explanation. Frustrating doesn't cover it.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
The base period is the part worth looking at closely here. EDD calculates your benefit from wages in a 12-month window that isn't the same as last calendar year — it's four calendar quarters ending roughly five to eighteen months before your claim start date, and the highest-paid single quarter is what sets your weekly amount. If your biggest earnings fell outside that specific window, the CASDI on your W-2 could reflect contributions that happened before the base period EDD used.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThat's a really useful framing actually. My surgery was in September, so when exactly would my base period have started and ended?
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
For a September claim start, the base period typically looks at wages from roughly April of the year before last through March of this year — but check EDD's calculator on their site and your Notice of Computation if you got one. Those will tell you the exact quarters EDD used.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorI did get a Notice of Computation, I just didn't connect it to the denial until now. I'll look at which quarters it lists.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
yeah the quarters thing tripped me up too. had a ton of wages but they were from like two years before so they didnt count
0 coins
Abigail Patel
I had a client go through almost this exact thing. Tons of CASDI on her W-2 but EDD said her wages in the specific base period quarters were too low because she'd taken unpaid leave for a few months right before her claim.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThat's similar to my situation actually — I had some slow months. Did she appeal?
0 coins
Abigail Patel
She did file the appeal and sent in her pay stubs for every quarter they listed on the Notice of Computation. Ended up getting an alternate base period reviewed. Worth asking EDD about that option.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Wait there's an alternate base period? I didn't know that was a thing.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
There is a provision for an alternate base period, yes. The details of how it's applied go beyond what I can say here, but it's worth raising in your appeal and asking EDD directly whether your claim qualifies.
0 coins
Daniel White
Don't sit on that appeal deadline. Thirty days from the date on the notice, that's your window. Miss it and you're in a much harder spot.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorAlready noted that date in my calendar. I want to file within the first two weeks so I have room.
0 coins
Daniel White
Good. Get your paperwork together now, don't wait for the last few days.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Which quarter of my base period EDD actually used was the thing I needed to get straight before I could figure anything out about my own claim. The numbers on the Notice of Computation didn't add up to what I expected, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to sort it out. The agent pulled up my file and told me exactly which quarter they'd pulled wages from and what figure they had on record. Turned out EDD had a different quarterly total than my pay stubs showed, so now I have something concrete to work with before the deadline.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
That whole Claimyr thing reads like marketing to me. How would some third-party app even get you to a real EDD agent?
0 coins
Tasia Synder
I had the exact same reaction, figured it was just another thing that wouldn't work. But then I actually tried it on my own claim — been trying that line for two weeks, anyway — and the agent confirmed which weeks were actually paid versus which were still pending. So it's real, whatever it is.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
Hm. I've been redialing since Monday and getting cut off every time. Maybe I'll give it a shot then.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
I'm so stressed reading this thread because I might be in the same boat. Filed my claim three weeks ago for a knee issue and still pending, no payment. What if I get denied for the same reason?
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Pending isn't the same as denied, so try not to spiral yet. EDD typically takes up to 14 days after they receive both the claimant's part and the medical certification from your doctor. Have you confirmed your doctor submitted theirs?
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
I think so? My doctor's office said they sent it. How do I actually verify EDD got it though?
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Log into SDI Online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and check your claim status there. If the medical certification is showing as received, that's your confirmation. If not, give your doctor's office the receipt number you got when you filed so they can locate the claim in their system and resubmit.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Oh I didn't even know to give them the receipt number. I'll do that today.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
CASDI on your W-2 means your employer was withholding, but it doesn't tell EDD what your actual wages were in each quarter. Those are reported separately. If your employer messed up their quarterly wage reports to EDD, your earnings might not be on record even though the deduction happened.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThat's a scenario I hadn't even thought of. If my employer's quarterly reports are wrong, is that something I'd raise in the appeal?
0 coins
Selena Bautista
Yes. You'd include your pay stubs showing the gross wages by pay period, so EDD can see the actual amounts regardless of what the employer reported. The burden is on you to show it in the appeal.
0 coins
Daniel White
Employer reporting errors happen more than people think. Had a guy on my crew go through that — took a few months but it got sorted once he had his own records in hand.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
Hang in there! The appeal process sounds scary but people do win these when they have solid documentation. Your W-2 and pay stubs together make a real case.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorAppreciate that. Trying to stay focused on gathering everything before I write the appeal letter.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
Organized records make such a difference. You've already got the right instinct pulling everything together first!
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
my coworker just told me if you paid sdi taxes you automatically qualify, is that true
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Not quite. Paying into SDI through the CASDI deduction means you contributed, but EDD still checks whether you had enough wages in the specific base period quarters to meet the minimum threshold. The contribution alone doesn't guarantee eligibility.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
oh that makes sense. so its not just about paying in its about how much you made in those specific months
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Exactly. At least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period is the floor, but it also has to fall in the right quarters that EDD uses for your particular claim start date.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Not sure if it matters but my denial said something about 'insufficient base period wages' and I just assumed it meant I didn't earn enough ever. I didn't realize it was just about those specific quarters.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
That phrasing trips a lot of people up. 'Insufficient base period wages' means EDD didn't find enough in those four specific quarters — it's not a statement about your lifetime earnings or your overall employment history.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
So someone who made decent money could still get that denial just because of when they earned it?
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Yes, that's exactly right. Timing relative to the claim start date is everything for which wages EDD counts.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThis thread has been genuinely clarifying. I kept reading 'insufficient wages' as EDD saying I basically didn't work, which felt insulting on top of everything else.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
My payment method question came up partway through my claim and I ended up reaching an EDD agent to sort it out. The agent confirmed the account on file for my direct deposit and that the next payment would go there. For anyone wondering, EDD's card program is through Money Network now, not Bank of America. Claimyr was what I used to actually get someone on the line — that line had been impossible for me personally. The agent also noted which payment cycle my claim was on, which answered a secondary question I had about timing.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
How long had you been trying that number before you used Claimyr? Just wondering what we're talking about in terms of days.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
About nine mornings. Sometimes got the 'high call volume' message immediately, sometimes sat for a while and got cut off.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
nine mornings. yeah that tracks. been at it for six myself and still nothing.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
The employer quarterly wage reporting angle is worth pushing on in your appeal. EDD gets your wages from what your employer files with the state, not from your W-2 directly.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorSo my W-2 and what EDD has on record could genuinely be different numbers?
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
They can be. If your employer filed a report with an error, or filed late, the number EDD sees might not match your actual earnings. That's exactly what pay stubs by quarter are useful for — they show what you actually earned regardless of what the employer filed.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThis is making my appeal strategy a lot clearer. I need to show my earnings quarter by quarter for the base period, not just the annual W-2 total.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
lol the first time I got that denial notice I literally thought EDD had lost my entire file. turns out they had my wages, just from the wrong quarters
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorDid you appeal and get it reversed?
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Yeah submitted the pay stubs with the appeal letter and they looked at it again. Took a while but it worked out.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorThat's encouraging to hear. What did you actually write in the appeal letter itself?
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Basically just explained the quarters I worked, that my CASDI was deducted every check, and that I thought EDD had the wrong wage totals. Kept it simple and let the stubs do the work.
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Medical certification timing is something I want to flag for people reading this thread who are still in the filing stage, not yet denied. My own claim had the certification arrive late from my doctor's office, and I had to track it down with my receipt number. Ended up talking to an EDD agent to confirm they'd received it — tried that phone number for days with nothing, then used Claimyr and got through. The agent said the certification had come in and was matched to my claim already, which I couldn't see clearly in SDI Online on my end. Such a relief to know rather than just waiting and wondering.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
The receipt number thing is exactly what I need to sort out on my own claim — my doctor's office says they submitted but EDD's side isn't showing it. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I actually have ready when the agent picks up?
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Have your claim ID number, the receipt number you got when you filed, and your doctor's office name and fax or submission date if you have it. That's what the agent pulled up on mine.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Confirming the certification is matched before you've been waiting three weeks is the move. Much easier to fix a mismatch early than after the pending status has dragged on.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
This is making me want to call and check right now. I've been assuming no news is good news.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Sorry tangent but — can I work part time while on disability? My situation is a bit different than OP's but curious. Anyway, wondering if that affects the base period calculation at all.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Part-time work during your claim is separate from base period questions — if you go back part time while on disability, you report it to EDD and EDD determines how that partial week gets paid. The base period was set when you filed and doesn't change based on what happens during the claim.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Got it, so the base period is basically locked in at filing. That makes sense anyway.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Appeal letters work best when they're specific. Don't just say 'I had sufficient wages' — say which quarters you worked, what your gross pay was each quarter based on your stubs, and where the CASDI deduction shows on each check. EDD needs to see the specifics, not the general argument.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorQuarter by quarter breakdown, got it. I'll organize my stubs that way before I write anything.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
And note which quarter the Notice of Computation lists as your highest-paid quarter. That's the one that matters most for your weekly benefit amount, so if EDD has a wrong figure there, that's your most important correction.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
been dealing with a denial myself. filed in august, got the DE 2517 in september. started the appeal and its slow going but im moving through it.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorAugust to now is a while. Have you heard anything back from the appeal yet?
0 coins
Ellie Perry
nothing yet. they say an administrative law judge reviews it but no word on how long that takes.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
The waiting is genuinely hard. Keep records of everything you submit and when. If EDD does request anything additional, respond promptly to avoid any further delays on your end.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
Before you mail the appeal, make a copy of everything. The form, the letter, the stubs, the W-2. Keep the whole packet. If EDD says they didn't get something, you need to show exactly what you sent.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorGood call. I'll photograph everything before it goes in the envelope.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
Dated photos with your phone work fine. Just make sure you can read every line in the image.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
30 days sounds like a lot until it isn't. Count the days from the date printed on the notice itself, not the day you received it.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorYeah the date on the notice is earlier than when I actually got it in the mail, so the window is tighter than I thought.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Exactly. Mail it with enough lead time. Certified mail doesn't hurt if you want proof of when it left your hands.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Certified mail is a good habit for anything time-sensitive going to EDD. It gives you a postmark and delivery confirmation both.
0 coins