Back to California Disability

Oliver Schmidt

SDI denied insufficient wages base period alternative base period appeal pregnancy — what I'm doing now

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying my SDI claim was denied for insufficient wages in the base period. I'm 28 weeks pregnant and completely panicked. My situation is a little complicated because I only started this job about seven months ago after leaving a longer-term position, so the standard base period they used barely captures any of my earnings. A coworker mentioned there's something called an alternative base period that uses more recent wages but I have no idea how to even ask EDD to look at that instead. And then there's the appeal on top of everything. The notice says I have 30 days from the date it was issued to file the Appeal Form DE 1000A and I'm already five days in. Has anyone actually appealed a denial like this and won using the alternative base period? I don't know what documentation to pull together or how to even explain my situation clearly on the form. My doctor already submitted the medical certification and that part went fine, it's purely the wage calculation. I'm trying not to spiral but this is really stressful with the due date getting closer.

The notice itself is the most important document right now. The DE 1000A appeal form should have come with it, and if you can't find it, a detailed letter sent to the return address on the notice works just as well. You'll want to explain clearly that you believe your more recent wages weren't captured in the base period EDD used, and that you're requesting consideration of the alternative base period. Attach anything that shows your earnings from the period you think should count, like pay stubs or a W-2.

0 coins

The notice did come with the DE 1000A, I still have it. So I write directly on the form why I think the alternative base period applies and attach my pay stubs? I want to make sure I'm not leaving anything out.

0 coins

Exactly. Write your explanation as specifically as you can, which months you worked, what you earned, and why you think those wages weren't included. The pay stubs are your evidence. Keep a copy of everything before you mail it.

0 coins

Worth adding that the standard base period looks at wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim started, so if you began the new job more recently than that, those earnings would have been missed entirely. The alternative base period captures more recent quarters. That's the whole argument you're making in the appeal.

0 coins

SDI Online showed two weeks paid out of my claim and then nothing for weeks after that, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to find out what happened. Video on reaching a live EDD disability agent: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and told me exactly which weeks had actually been paid and which were still sitting unprocessed, which at least gave me something to work with instead of just staring at the screen.

0 coins

How do you even get anyone to pick up on that line. I tried something like nine mornings in a row and kept getting cut off before I ever reached a person. Hard to believe anything gets through on a line that bad.

0 coins

Tried the same thing for weeks before I found Claimyr. With that, my phone rang and an actual EDD employee was on the other end. That's the whole thing, it handles the hold so you don't have to and your phone goes off when someone picks up.

0 coins

Used it for my own claim too. Called in the first week of October and the agent confirmed which quarter of my base period EDD had used for the wage calculation. That cleared up why my weekly amount came out lower than I expected from the online calculator.

0 coins

Alright I'll look into it. Nine mornings is about my limit for hitting redial before work.

0 coins

EDD's site says the base period is the 12-month period made up of the four quarters that ended about five months before your disability began. So if your claim started mid-pregnancy, the wages counted are from well before that. If your recent job started after that window closed, almost none of those earnings show up. The alternative base period uses the four most recently completed quarters instead, which is exactly the fix for a situation like yours.

0 coins

That explains everything. I started the new job about seven months ago and my claim started two months ago, so almost all of what I earned at this job fell outside the standard window. The alternative base period would pull all of it in.

0 coins

And you need at least 300 dollars in wages subject to SDI deductions during whatever base period they use, so if the alternative base period captures enough of your recent earnings to clear that, the appeal has a real shot.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but do you know whether your new employer was taking the CASDI deduction out of your checks? I think that's what determines whether those wages even count toward SDI at all. I'd double-check the pay stubs before you file the appeal just to be safe.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast. Mail that appeal form certified, so you have proof of when it went out. Administrative law judge handles the hearing and they'll look at the wage documentation you send in.

0 coins

Certified mail, got it. I hadn't thought of that. I was just going to drop it in a mailbox.

0 coins

Don't. You want a postmark and a tracking number both. If there's any dispute over timing you'll be glad you have it.

0 coins

Mailing it to the return address on the notice is also important. Claim forms go where the form says, not to EDD's general address.

0 coins

Denied for wages when you clearly worked and paid into SDI. The whole base period setup is designed for people who've been at the same job for years. Anyone who changed jobs or took time off recently just falls through the gap. The alternative base period exists to fix that but EDD doesn't exactly advertise it.

0 coins

literally no one told me about the alternative base period when i filed. found out from a forum post like this one. the whole thing should be automatic

0 coins

It's not automatic because EDD uses the standard base period first. You have to appeal and specifically request the alternative base period calculation. That's the only way to get them to run it.

0 coins

Which puts the burden entirely on people who are already stressed and running out of time. Great system.

0 coins

My pregnancy claim got held up for different reasons but I remember that waiting feeling so well. The medical certification side being done is actually a huge relief because that's the piece that trips a lot of people up. At least you know that part went through and the whole thing really is just about the wages.

0 coins

That's true, I keep reminding myself the certification is done. It does help a little to know the problem is specific and not some mystery.

0 coins

Specific problems have specific solutions. You know exactly what to argue in the appeal. That's actually a better spot than a lot of people are in.

0 coins

Agree with this completely. A denial with a clear reason is so much more workable than one of those vague pending situations where you can't figure out what EDD even wants!

0 coins

Talked to a live EDD agent about my extension through Claimyr after weeks of that line cutting me off. The agent looked up my claim and said the DE 2525XX my doctor submitted was in the system but hadn't been matched to the right claim ID yet. Got that sorted out on the call.

0 coins

What's Claimyr, never heard of it. Is that something you download or how does it work.

0 coins

No download. It waits on hold with EDD's disability line for you, your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's about it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. I need to ask about whether my extension request went in correctly, been trying to figure out if the DE 2525XX even showed up on their end. Might try that.

0 coins

For an extension question the agent can at least confirm whether the form is in the system and matched to your claim. That's the useful thing to get confirmed before anything else.

0 coins

For anyone far along in pregnancy, benefits can start earlier than delivery if the provider certifies that your condition restricts work, reduces your hours, or makes conditions unsafe. Worth knowing for future reference, but it doesn't affect the appeal. The appeal is still the right move.

0 coins

My doctor did certify my start date, so that part is fine. The denial really is just the wage question. I didn't realize EDD could start benefits early with a note from the doctor, good to know for understanding how this whole thing works.

0 coins

My provider certified me about five weeks out because I was on modified duty. The early start option saved me a lot of guessing about timing.

0 coins

Five days into a 30-day window is not bad. File the appeal, include every pay stub from the new job, write one clear paragraph explaining the base period gap, and ask EDD to calculate using the alternative base period. That's the whole appeal.

0 coins

One paragraph. I've been overthinking this into a ten-paragraph essay. That's actually reassuring.

0 coins

The form has limited space anyway. Clear and specific beats long every time. Date you started the job, what you earned, what period EDD used, why the alternative period would change the result.

0 coins

Keeping it focused like that also makes it easier for the administrative law judge to follow your argument. A wall of text often buries the actual point.

0 coins

Does the alternative base period automatically kick in if the appeal succeeds, or do they recalculate from scratch and you could still be denied even if you win on the base period question? Not asking to scare anyone, just not sure how the process works after the administrative law judge rules.

0 coins

If the appeal succeeds on the base period question, EDD recalculates using the alternative base period wages. Whether that calculation meets the minimum to qualify is a separate question, which is why showing you earned at least 300 dollars in wages with SDI deductions during those quarters matters.

0 coins

The administrative law judge rules on whether EDD applied the right base period. EDD then does the wage math from there. So yes, two steps, but if the recent wages are significant the second one usually resolves itself.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I was picturing one decision that settled everything but it sounds more like the judge handles the base period question and EDD runs the numbers after.

0 coins

my situation was different but the base period thing got me too when i first filed. had to explain my whole job history and it felt like so much. hang in there the form is not as scary as it looks

0 coins

Genuinely helps to hear from people who got through it. The form looks overwhelming but I think once I sit down and just write it out it'll be okay.

0 coins

yeah once you start it goes faster than you think. just get the pay stubs out first so youre not hunting for them while youre writing

0 coins

The Notice of Determination has the date it was issued printed on it. That's the date the 30-day clock runs from, not the date you received it. If mailing time cost you a few days, you're working with less than 25 days on that window.

0 coins

Checked the notice. Issue date was six days ago and I got it four days ago. So I have 24 days left by that count. Filing this week.

0 coins

Good. That's enough time to do it right. Don't hold the appeal waiting for more documentation you don't have. File with what you have now.

0 coins

If you get more evidence after you file, you can usually submit it before the hearing. The appeal gets you the hearing, the evidence fills it in.

0 coins

Talked to an EDD agent about my claim's start date through Claimyr after the SDI Online screen showed something that didn't line up with when I stopped working. The agent confirmed the actual start date in the system and what period EDD was treating as my disability start. Mattered for figuring out which weeks I was owed.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for a DE 2593 question. The agent confirmed EDD had received the form and what the response deadline showed in their records. Good to have that confirmed in writing after.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about whether the form had been processed or just received? That distinction matters for whether payments continue.

0 coins

Received is what they confirmed. Processing is EDD's side and the agent didn't go into it, just said to watch for a notice if anything changed.

0 coins

Is the alternative base period something you can ask for before you appeal, or only through the appeal process? Just wondering if there was an earlier step that got skipped.

0 coins

EDD uses the standard base period by default when processing the initial claim. If your wages there don't qualify, the denial triggers the appeal process, which is where you raise the alternative base period argument. There isn't a separate earlier step to request it.

0 coins

EDD's guidance says to request alternative base period consideration in the appeal. That's the designed path for this exact situation.

0 coins

Okay so the denial is actually the trigger for being able to raise it. That's counterintuitive but good to know it's built into the process.

0 coins

Noticed the Notice of Computation question keeps coming up in these threads. Used Claimyr to get through on mine. The agent told me what weekly benefit amount EDD had on record and confirmed which wages went into the calculation. Helped me understand why the number was different from what the online estimator showed.

0 coins

Feels like a lot of people are saying they got through that line, which I'd want to believe but it sounds like the kind of thing you see in every comment section about EDD. What am I missing here.

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Then my DE 2593 sat with no update for two weeks and I tried it out of frustration. Ended up talking to an actual EDD employee who told me which payment method was on file for my claim, because I'd changed it and wasn't sure the update had gone through. It had.

0 coins

Alright, that's specific enough that I believe it. I'll probably try it, the line has ended my calls three times this week alone.

0 coins

The number on the Notice of Computation was lower than the online estimator because a different quarter was used, that was what the agent explained. Helped me decide whether to follow up further.

0 coins

28 weeks and dealing with a denial appeal sounds exhausting but you are so clearly on top of it! The fact that you identified the base period gap, have your medical certification done, and are tracking your 30-day window already puts you way ahead of where most people are when they get that notice.

0 coins

Thank you, that actually means something to hear. It doesn't feel like being on top of it from the inside but I guess I do have the pieces figured out.

0 coins

Preparing for a baby while navigating EDD paperwork is a lot. Give yourself credit for handling it.

0 coins

What happens if the administrative law judge denies the appeal too. Is there another step after that or is it over.

0 coins

There are further levels of appeal within EDD's system, and beyond that the courts. For most pregnancy wage situations the first appeal hearing is where it gets resolved if the documentation is solid.

0 coins

Most of these don't go past the first hearing if the wage records are clear. The gap in the base period is a documented fact, not an interpretation argument.

0 coins

Got it. So it's not a one-shot situation, there are options. Good to know before anyone panics about the first outcome.

0 coins

For the appeal letter or the DE 1000A, it helps to be explicit that you're invoking the alternative base period specifically, not just saying you have more wages somewhere. Something like noting the standard base period EDD used, the quarters it covered, and then stating clearly that your wages in the most recent completed quarters should be used instead. The administrative law judge reads a lot of these and specific language helps.

0 coins

Should I look up the exact quarter dates EDD used? The Notice of Determination might show that.

0 coins

Check the Notice of Computation if you got one, it usually shows the base period quarters. If not, the Notice of Determination may reference the period or you can ask EDD directly through the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online is good for exactly this, pick the claim, go to that option, choose the right request type and ask which quarters were included. Keeps a record of the question and EDD's response.

0 coins

One thing that tripped up a friend of mine on a similar situation was that she assumed her employer's HR office could help speed things along. HR doesn't have any role in the SDI appeal process, that's between you and EDD. Just flagging it because a lot of people assume otherwise.

0 coins

Good to know. I was actually thinking about asking HR if they had any records I could use. I can still get records from them, just for my own documentation.

0 coins

Pay stubs and any employment verification letter they can give you are useful as evidence. Just HR themselves can't intervene in the EDD process.

0 coins

the waiting period thing confused me when i got my notice. thought the seven days they dont pay was why i was denied but it was actually the wage question. different issues entirely.

0 coins

Worth clarifying for anyone reading this, the waiting period is the first seven days of the claim that are non-payable by design. It's not a processing delay and it's definitely not a denial reason. The denial is a separate thing and in this case it's specifically about which wages EDD counted.

0 coins

Correct. The waiting period is built into every new claim. It's the reason the first payable day is day eight. A denial comes from a separate determination, not from the waiting period.

0 coins

yeah once i sorted that out it made more sense. two different things happening on the same notice was what confused me

0 coins

For what it's worth, the wage documentation approach works. Filed an appeal for a different reason, lost the first attempt, refiled with cleaner documentation, and the second hearing went better. The administrative law judge wants specific evidence, not general arguments about what you think you earned.

0 coins

You appealed twice? Did you have to file a new DE 1000A for the second one or was it an extension of the first appeal?

0 coins

New appeal form, new hearing. Each denial gets its own notice and its own 30-day window. Keep every notice you get with the date it was issued marked.

0 coins

That's why keeping copies of everything matters. If the first appeal produces a new notice, that notice has a new appeal window attached to it.

0 coins

Filing the appeal tomorrow, certified mail. I have eight pay stubs from the new job showing the CASDI deduction on every one of them, and I wrote up two paragraphs explaining the base period gap and specifically requesting the alternative base period calculation. Thank you all so much, this thread helped me understand what I was actually dealing with instead of just panicking at the notice.

0 coins

Eight pay stubs with CASDI deductions on each one is exactly the right evidence. That directly addresses the wage requirement and ties your earnings to SDI-covered work.

0 coins

Two paragraphs is the right length. The administrative law judge can follow that in one read. Hope the hearing goes well.

0 coins

Certified mail tomorrow. Good. You've got this in order.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure