Back to California Disability

Fatima Al-Farsi

SDI denied because job assignment ended no wage loss — what does that even mean?

Got a denial notice from EDD last week and I'm still trying to make sense of it. I was out for a back injury starting mid-October, went to my doctor, filed on SDI Online, got my doctor's certification in. Then the Notice of Determination shows up and says my claim was denied because my job assignment ended and there's no wage loss. I don't understand that. I was working full time at a distribution center on a temp assignment when I hurt my back. I wasn't let go, I was physically unable to work. The injury happened before the assignment was set to end. Has anyone gotten a denial like this and appealed it? The notice says I have 30 days from the date on it to appeal. I still can't work, my doctor has me out another three weeks at least.

Notice of Computation came through on my own injury claim about a month ago and I finally got a real answer on what it was showing, so let me tell you what helped. SDI Online kept showing numbers I didn't recognize and I couldn't figure out which quarter they used. I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an EDD disability agent who pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter of the base period they calculated from and what the weekly amount would be. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability if you want it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For the denial in your situation, the appeal is what matters. You file the DE 1000A, that's the Appeal Form that came with the denial notice, and you write out in detail why you disagree. The key point to make is that the injury happened while you were actively employed and that you had an actual wage loss because you were unable to do your work.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself a few weeks back and it was great. My own claim had the waiting period question and the agent confirmed the first seven days of a new claim are non-payable no matter what, so the first day you can actually get paid is day eight. Cleared up so much confusion for me.

0 coins

The waiting period piece is something a lot of people get tangled up with. Can I ask, when you spoke with the agent, did they say anything about whether the waiting period counts toward the 52-week maximum or just sits outside of it?

0 coins

The agent said the waiting period days are part of the claim period, so they do eat into the 52 weeks. That's what I was told on my call anyway.

0 coins

This is helpful. My denial notice did have the DE 1000A attached. I'll fill that out and explain that I was actively on shift when the injury happened and that I lost wages because I physically couldn't go back.

0 coins

The denial language about no wage loss tied to a job assignment ending is a specific determination EDD makes. What matters for your appeal is the timeline. If your injury happened before the assignment was scheduled to end, and you can show that, the wage loss argument gets much stronger. Your employer's records of when the assignment was supposed to end versus when you were injured are worth getting in writing.

0 coins

The assignment wasn't even close to ending. I had at least six more weeks on that contract. I'll ask the temp agency for documentation.

0 coins

Does the temp agency count as the employer of record for SDI purposes, or is it the company where you were actually placed? I've always wondered how that works with temp workers and EDD claims.

0 coins

For SDI contributions the temp agency is usually the one taking the CASDI deduction from your check, so they're the employer on record. What you want from them is documentation showing your assignment term and that it was still active when you were injured.

0 coins

EDD pulls this denial reason all the time with temp and contract workers. They see the job has an end date somewhere in the system and assume the wage loss is because of the assignment ending, not the injury. It's infuriating. The burden falls on you to prove it was the injury.

0 coins

That explains it. The assignment had an end date in the contract but I was nowhere near it when I got hurt.

0 coins

Is this something the temp agency should be helping with or do they wash their hands of it once EDD gets involved?

0 coins

In my experience the temp agency does the bare minimum. You have to go get the paperwork yourself. They won't volunteer anything.

0 coins

The Appeal Form, DE 1000A, was included with your denial notice. Fill it out and write a clear explanation of the facts. Include the date of your injury, the date your assignment was scheduled to end, and the fact that you were actively working when the injury occurred. Mail it to the address printed on the notice, not to EDD's general address.

0 coins

Is there a word limit on the explanation part of the DE 1000A? I have a kind of similar situation and I'm worried about not having enough space to explain everything.

0 coins

There isn't a strict word limit that I know of. If your explanation runs long, write it on a separate sheet and attach it to the form. The form itself will have space for a brief statement.

0 coins

Do you need a lawyer for this or can you handle the appeal on your own? I'm in a different situation but also dealing with a denial and the whole process feels really overwhelming.

0 coins

You can file the appeal yourself. Many people do. An attorney is not required, though for complicated situations some people do consult one. The important thing is meeting that 30-day deadline.

0 coins

edd does this with temp workers constantly its so frustrating. appeal it and get that paperwork from the agency showing your assignment wasnt over yet

0 coins

Yeah getting that documentation is the first call I'm making tomorrow morning.

0 coins

good luck man they tried the same thing with my buddy on a warehouse gig

0 coins

Your doctor's certification is already in, which helps. For the appeal, a letter from your physician confirming you were unable to perform your regular work starting on the injury date would strengthen your case. Medical records that document the injury date align with what you're claiming.

0 coins

My doctor already has me on work restrictions. I'll ask the office for a letter that specifically ties the work restrictions to the injury date.

0 coins

Does the doctor need to submit anything extra to EDD for the appeal or is that separate from the medical certification they already filed?

0 coins

The medical certification is a separate process from the appeal. Your doctor already did that part. A supporting letter for the appeal is something you would submit yourself along with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Weeks eleven and twelve on my own injury claim went into this weird limbo where SDI Online showed them differently from the earlier weeks, and I had no idea which ones had actually paid out. I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line who went through my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and which were still open. For the wage loss denial thing: even if you get the appeal moving, keep certifying with your doctor through the whole process so there's no gap in your documentation.

0 coins

Something about getting an agent on the line through a third-party service when EDD's own phone line is a whole mess doesn't sit right with me. How do you know it's not just someone collecting your info?

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Used it anyway when my claim showed a payment date that didn't match what actually hit my account. The person I talked to was an EDD agent, gave me my claim ID back and walked through the specific date the payment was issued. Straightforward.

0 coins

Alright. If the agent is actually EDD's own staff I'd consider it. I've been redialing that disability line since Monday and getting nowhere.

0 coins

That's exactly what it is, the agent who picks up works for EDD. I had the same week-by-week question and they resolved it right there on the call.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast. Don't sit on that appeal form waiting for the temp agency to get you paperwork. File the appeal now with what you have and then supplement it. A late appeal needs reasons for the delay and they're harder to argue.

0 coins

Filing this week. I'll note in the explanation that I'm still gathering supporting documents from the agency.

0 coins

Can you add stuff after you've already mailed the appeal form or is it locked in once it's sent? Just asking because I'm in a sort of similar boat with timing.

0 coins

You can send additional supporting materials in. Keep the case number from your notice on everything you mail in after the initial appeal.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If EDD said no wage loss, does that mean they think you got paid during your time off? Or that they think the assignment ending is what caused the income stop, not the injury? Those seem like really different problems.

0 coins

The determination is that the income loss came from the job ending, not from a medical inability to work. EDD is saying the reason you stopped getting paid was the assignment completing, not the injury. The appeal has to show the injury is what actually kept you from working.

0 coins

Okay that makes a lot more sense now. So the medical evidence is key because it shows the injury would have prevented work even if the assignment hadn't ended.

0 coins

Exactly what I need to prove. The assignment had weeks left and I was injured before it would have wrapped up.

0 coins

Temp worker denials are honestly their own category of frustrating lol. I've seen people go through this and win on appeal as long as they have the dates locked down. The clearer the timeline, the better.

0 coins

Makes sense. EDD seems to assume the worst when the employment situation is complicated.

0 coins

Pretty much. Anything that isn't a standard W2 nine-to-five and they reach for the easy denial.

0 coins

The base period wage question might also be worth looking at. If your wages from the temp assignment are what EDD is using to calculate the potential benefit, and they're saying there's no wage loss, it might be worth asking in the appeal whether EDD is correctly identifying which wages are subject to SDI contributions.

0 coins

CASDI is deducted from temp agency paychecks just like any other W2 wages. If the OP was having SDI taken out, those wages count for the base period. The denial is about causation of the wage loss, not about whether the wages are covered.

0 coins

That's a useful distinction. So the wages are there, the issue is just what EDD thinks caused the gap.

0 coins

appeals take a while but you have a solid case if you have documentation. get the temp agency letter and don't wait on it.

0 coins

Reaching out to the agency today. The assignment manager there should have everything on file.

0 coins

My cousin went through a temp worker denial a couple years back, different reason but same appeal path. She won. The administrative law judge actually read everything she submitted. Anyway just saying it's not hopeless.

0 coins

That's good to hear. Gives me more confidence to put together a thorough explanation.

0 coins

The judges do seem to look at these case by case from what I've read.

0 coins

DE 2525XX was sitting in my stack of EDD papers and I had no idea what to do with it. My doctor's office said they submitted the extension but SDI Online wasn't reflecting anything. I finally reached an EDD agent and they confirmed the form had been received and told me the claim's current end date. If you end up needing an extension after the appeal resolves, that's the form your doctor fills out.

0 coins

When you got through to the agent, did they say anything about how to track the extension status going forward or just that it had been received?

0 coins

They said the form was received and the end date on my claim had updated. They told me to watch for the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification for the final payment notice. That was really all I needed to know honestly.

0 coins

EDD's disability line has been ending my calls before I get to anyone for three weeks straight. Good to know there are ways to actually get through.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reverse a denial outright without going all the way to a hearing, or does it always end up in front of a judge?

0 coins

An appeal can be resolved at different stages. Some are resolved before a hearing if EDD reviews the new information and changes the determination. Others do go to an administrative law judge. The process depends on the specifics of the case.

0 coins

Okay so it's not automatically a full hearing. That's less intimidating than I thought.

0 coins

One thing I want to flag on the timeline: the 30-day appeal window runs from the date printed on the denial notice, not the date you received it. If you've been sitting on it for a few days already, count from the notice date.

0 coins

The notice is dated the 14th. I've got time but not a lot of it. Filing this week for sure.

0 coins

Good. Don't cut it close. Mail it with tracking so you have proof of when it went out.

0 coins

Does the medical certification your doctor already filed stay on record for the appeal or does EDD treat the appeal as a fresh start requiring new documentation?

0 coins

The medical certification is part of your claim record and stays there. The appeal reviews the full record. You're not starting from zero, you're adding your explanation of why the denial was wrong.

0 coins

That's really helpful to know. I was picturing having to redo everything.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for disability is brutal. I've tried early mornings, mid-week, all of it. No consistent way through.

0 coins

same i gave up and just submitted through the ask edd form online. slower but at least it went somewhere

0 coins

Ask EDD is fine for simple stuff. For a denial situation you really want to talk to a person.

0 coins

the ask edd responses I've gotten have been pretty generic honestly

0 coins

If the temp agency drags their feet on that documentation letter, ask them specifically for a written confirmation of your assignment start and end dates and your work schedule. Even an email from HR can be useful as a supporting document.

0 coins

Good point. I'll ask for something in writing from HR even if it's just an email, and keep a copy of everything.

0 coins

HR at temp agencies can be slow. If you have your own contract paperwork from when you started the assignment, that works too.

0 coins

I have the original contract. That has the assignment end date on it, which is weeks after I got hurt.

0 coins

Keep a copy of the DE 1000A and everything you mail with it. If the appeal does go to a hearing, your records of what you submitted and when will matter.

0 coins

Photographing everything before it goes in the envelope. Already learned that lesson the hard way with another EDD form earlier this year.

0 coins

Scanners are worth it just for EDD paperwork alone honestly, anyway good luck with it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure