Back to California Disability

Ethan Clark

SDI claim disqualified for receiving unemployment after waiting period completed — what now?

So I'm kind of panicking right now and hoping someone here has dealt with this. I was out for a back injury starting about six weeks ago and filed my SDI claim pretty quickly after. My doctor got the medical certification in, everything looked fine. Here's the mess though — before I knew the SDI was going through, I also filed for unemployment because I was scared about money and honestly didn't fully understand the difference between the two. I certified for unemployment for the first week or so, which turned out to overlap with my SDI waiting period and then some. Now EDD sent me something saying my disability claim is disqualified because I was receiving unemployment. I had no idea you couldn't do both at the same time. Has anyone gotten through this? Is there any way to appeal or fix it? I'm still not back to work and I really need these benefits.

Weeks SDI Online showed as paid versus what actually posted to my account were different, and I spent three mornings on the phone getting nowhere before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got an agent. The agent pulled up my claim and read me exactly which weeks had issued and which were still pending. For the disqualification question here: EDD's own language is that you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. If you certified for unemployment for days that overlapped with your SDI claim period, that is the conflict EDD acted on. The notice you got should be a DE 2517 with an Appeal Form DE 1000A attached. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The Claimyr mention reads like a paid placement to me, honestly. Forum threads recommending a specific service for navigating a government line give me pause. I'd want to know whether that actually resulted in useful information from EDD or just a long wait on a different line.

0 coins

I thought the same thing about Claimyr at first, totally fair! But I tried it after two weeks of zero progress and an agent told me which quarter of my base period EDD had used to calculate my amount. That was exactly what I needed to know. It was a real EDD agent, not a third party.

0 coins

Alright, that is more concrete than I expected. I'll look into it for my own extension question that's been sitting unresolved.

0 coins

The DE 2517 detail is the important part here. Check the date on that notice, the appeal window matters a lot.

0 coins

Wait, so the waiting period days can still cause a disqualification even though SDI doesn't pay you for them? That's what I'm confused about. I thought the first seven days were just unpaid, not that they counted as days you can't have unemployment either?

0 coins

The waiting period is not a grace window where anything goes. Those seven days are part of the SDI claim period, they're just non-payable. If you certified for unemployment on any of those days, EDD sees it as overlapping benefit receipt for the same days.

0 coins

Okay so even though SDI paid nothing for those days, unemployment money received on the same days still creates the conflict. That is way harder to navigate than I realized.

0 coins

Exactly. The waiting period being unpaid does not make those days neutral for purposes of collecting another benefit.

0 coins

The EDD phone line for disability is basically decorative at this point. I called at 8:01 on three different Mondays and got the recording that the queue was full every single time. I finally sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online just to have something in writing while I figured out next steps.

0 coins

Same result every morning I tried. Eventually sent the message through SDI Online too. At least there's a record of when you asked.

0 coins

Queue full before 8:05. That line has been that way for years.

0 coins

I've been doing the SDI Online message route too but haven't heard back yet. Getting desperate about the timeline here.

0 coins

The appeal is the move. Thirty days from the date on the notice, not from when you got it in the mail. If that clock is ticking, that's the first thing to deal with.

0 coins

The date on the notice, not the date you received it. That trip a lot of people up.

0 coins

What if the 30 days is almost up and you haven't been able to reach anyone at EDD yet? Do you send the appeal form without talking to anyone first?

0 coins

You send the appeal form. Don't wait for a phone call that may not happen in time. Mail it to the return address on the notice, with your explanation attached.

0 coins

The form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the DE 2517. If you lost it, the instructions say you can send a detailed letter instead to the same return address.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing last year, except my overlap was only two days. I argued in my appeal that I hadn't understood the two programs couldn't run at the same time and that I had stopped certifying for unemployment as soon as I found out. The administrative law judge took that into account.

0 coins

That is really encouraging to hear. Did you need any documentation of when you stopped certifying for unemployment, or was your written explanation enough?

0 coins

I included a printout of my unemployment certification history showing the dates I stopped, alongside my written explanation. Having the specific dates lined up helped a lot.

0 coins

The fact that you stopped as soon as you learned about the conflict seems like it would matter. An honest mistake handled quickly is different from knowingly doubling up.

0 coins

I'm in a similar boat and not sure if I stopped certifying for unemployment fast enough once I realized. I'm going to gather everything with dates before I write the appeal explanation.

0 coins

The extension piece of my own claim was stuck in limbo, so I used Claimyr to get through to an agent about whether my provider had submitted the DE 2525XX yet. The agent confirmed the form was in and told me which date EDD received it. On the disqualification issue: the appeal form really is your fastest path forward here, sending it in does not close any doors.

0 coins

What did you have to give the agent to pull up your extension status, just your claim ID or more than that?

0 coins

Claim ID and the last four of my Social. The agent had everything on screen in about a minute.

0 coins

been trying that disability line since october. every single morning. never once got past the recording.

0 coins

The extension situation is a real gap, because a lot of people don't even know the DE 2525XX exists until their last payment is about to issue.

0 coins

you cant get unemployment when you cant even work right, unemployment requires you to be available and looking for a job which you cant do when youre on disability leave so they kind of cancel each other out automatically in that sense

0 coins

That's right on the basic rule. The conflict EDD flags is specifically receiving benefits from both programs for the same calendar days, which is what creates the disqualification.

0 coins

ok yeah so it wasnt about whether you were looking for work it was about the actual dollars paid on the same days

0 coins

Correct. The dollar receipt on the same days is the trigger, not intent or job search status.

0 coins

The appeal explanation should lay out the timeline clearly. Date the injury started, date you filed SDI, date you filed unemployment, date the medical certification came in, and date you stopped certifying for unemployment. Presenting that as a coherent sequence tends to be more persuasive than a general statement about confusion.

0 coins

Writing mine out now and this structure is exactly what I needed. I had everything scattered across notes and emails.

0 coins

Attaching copies of the certification receipt and your unemployment certification printout to the appeal makes the timeline verifiable, not just asserted.

0 coins

Absolutely, anything you have in writing from EDD's own systems carries more weight than what you describe from memory.

0 coins

Is it worth contacting your doctor's office about any of this or is it purely between you and EDD at this point? Asking because my wife's claim had a weird overlap issue too and I'm trying to figure out who to loop in, anyway.

0 coins

The doctor's office isn't part of a disqualification appeal. That's a claimant-to-EDD matter. The medical certification just establishes the disability, not the benefit overlap question.

0 coins

That makes sense, I figured as much but wanted to confirm before she spent time chasing her provider down.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared to ask this but, does the disqualification wipe out the whole SDI claim or just the overlapping days? Because if it's the whole claim that's gone I don't know what I'd do.

0 coins

The notice will tell you exactly what period is disqualified. It's not always the whole claim. Read the DE 2517 carefully, it specifies the dates EDD is acting on.

0 coins

If only specific days are cited in the notice, the appeal can be narrowly focused on just those days. You don't have to argue the whole claim from scratch.

0 coins

I pulled mine out and the disqualification dates listed are only the first two weeks. So it sounds like the rest of the claim may still be intact, which is at least something.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine was entered wrong in the system somehow, an extra week got added before my actual first day out, and I tried the online message form twice before I called through Claimyr to sort it out. The agent found the discrepancy and noted which date was recorded as the claim start. On this thread's question: if the disqualification is tied to a specific date range, the appeal can be narrowly targeted at those weeks only.

0 coins

My claim has a question about the payment method I want settled before anything else moves. I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get the agent?

0 coins

Have your claim ID, the last four of your Social, and the specific form or letter you're asking about. If it's about your payment method, know whether you set up direct deposit through SDI Online or if you're on the default card.

0 coins

Good to know the claim start date can even be wrong in the system. I just assumed whatever SDI Online showed was definitive.

0 coins

Targeted appeal on the specific disqualified dates is a smarter approach than re-litigating the whole claim, anyway.

0 coins

Sent an appeal on a disqualification once. Wrote one page, attached two documents, mailed it to the address on the notice. That was it. Didn't call anyone.

0 coins

What two documents did you attach?

0 coins

Benefit certification printout showing the dates. And my doctor's note confirming I was out that whole period. Kept it simple.

0 coins

Short and documented beats long and anecdotal every time with appeals.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the amount looked lower than I expected based on what I'd read about the 70 to 90 percent estimate, so I went through Claimyr to get an agent to explain what was on mine. The agent told me which quarter they'd based it on and what wages showed in that quarter. On the overlap issue in this thread: even one day of overlapping receipt is enough for EDD to flag a disqualification, so the appeal needs to address each overlapping day specifically.

0 coins

The quarter they used matches a part of my employment history that was lighter on hours, so my Notice of Computation showed less than I expected too. I tried Claimyr for the DE 2593 question I had, got the agent, and found out EDD had already sent the form to my address on file. The agent told me how many days I had left to return it. Went to the mailbox and found it that same afternoon.

0 coins

been calling since before the notice even showed up. the line just ends the call. every day.

0 coins

Knowing the specific quarter EDD used helps if you think the wrong period was chosen.

0 coins

For anyone confused about why unemployment and SDI can't both be collected: unemployment specifically requires that you be available and actively able to work every week you certify. SDI is for when you can't work at all. So technically you're certifying opposite things at the same time, which is why EDD flags it!

0 coins

yeah when you put it that way its like certifying you can and cant work on the same day which obviously wouldnt fly

0 coins

That's the clearest way I've seen it explained. The certifications are factually contradictory, not just administratively in conflict.

0 coins

The appeal window being 30 days from the notice date, not the received date, is the detail that catches people most often. If the notice sat in the mail for a few days before you opened it, those days are already gone.

0 coins

Mine was dated four days before I opened it. I did not realize until I read this thread that I'd already burned those days. Filing the appeal today.

0 coins

If you miss the 30 days, the late appeal requires an explanation of the delay. An administrative law judge reviews whether the reason was valid. Don't skip it just because you're late, file anyway with an explanation.

0 coins

Is a few days of postal delay a valid reason for a late appeal? Or does that not count?

0 coins

That's EDD's call, not ours. Write it in the explanation and let the ALJ decide. It's better than not appealing.

0 coins

the thing nobody tells you is that the first week of your disability claim, the waiting period week, isn't free money time where you can double dip. found that out the hard way too.

0 coins

That is exactly what happened to me. I genuinely thought because SDI wasn't paying for that first week I could keep the unemployment payments without it being an issue.

0 coins

The waiting period being non-payable doesn't make it outside the claim. That's the distinction EDD draws.

0 coins

yeah i know that now lol. appeal took care of it eventually but it took a while.

0 coins

Appeal the disqualification and stop certifying for unemployment now if you haven't already. Those are the two moves. Everything else is secondary.

0 coins

Both done. Appeal is drafted and I stopped unemployment certifications the day I got the disqualification notice.

0 coins

Then you've done what you can do. Mail the appeal and wait for the hearing notice.

0 coins

Just want to make sure I understand the payment side correctly. If the appeal succeeds for the disqualified days, does EDD automatically issue the SDI payment for those days or do you have to do something to trigger it?

0 coins

EDD issues payments based on the appeal outcome. You don't file again or resubmit the medical certification. The determination from the administrative law judge goes to EDD and they act on it.

0 coins

The notice after the hearing will explain what EDD owes if any. You'll see it in SDI Online or receive it by mail.

0 coins

Okay, so I don't need to do anything extra to trigger the payment once the appeal is decided. That's one less thing to worry about.

0 coins

One thing that helped me keep the appeal on track was printing the EDD calendar on the disqualified weeks and marking exactly which days I had also certified for unemployment. Having that visual made it easy to write about each day specifically instead of talking in general terms.

0 coins

Doing this tonight. I have the unemployment certification dates from my records and I'm going to map them against the SDI claim period day by day.

0 coins

Side question, anyway, does the unemployment money already received have to be paid back even if the SDI appeal wins?

0 coins

EDD handles that separately. The SDI appeal is about your disability benefits, not about the unemployment side. What happens with those payments is EDD's determination, and they'll send a notice if they find an overpayment on the unemployment end.

0 coins

Makes sense that they'd treat those as two separate determinations. Thanks.

0 coins

Hope the appeal goes well. Update when you hear something.

0 coins

Will do. Mailing the DE 1000A tomorrow with the full timeline attached. Fingers crossed.

0 coins

The fact that you stopped certifying for unemployment right away and have your dates organized is a genuinely strong start for the appeal!

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure