Back to California Disability

Amelia Martinez

SDI claim denied sent to appeals, can I file a new claim while waiting?

So my disability claim got denied and I already sent in my appeal with the DE 1000A form. The denial notice said something about not meeting the wage requirements in the base period, which honestly I still don't fully understand. My doctor submitted the medical certification and everything, so it wasn't that. Now I'm sitting here with no income and I don't know if I'm allowed to file a completely new SDI claim while the appeal is still going, or if that would mess up the appeal somehow. I've been out of work since my back procedure and I genuinely cannot afford to wait months for this to resolve. Has anyone been through something like this? Can you even have an appeal and a new claim open at the same time?

Denied on wages means EDD looked at your base period and didn't see enough SDI-taxable earnings in it. Filing a new claim right now would pull from the same base period, so you'd hit the same wall. The appeal is probably your better move here.

0 coins

That makes sense, hadn't thought about it being the same base period. So the new claim wouldn't fix the problem anyway?

0 coins

Not if the wages didn't change. The base period is set by when you filed, not when you got hurt.

0 coins

Okay. So I really have to just wait on the appeal then.

0 coins

Went through a denial myself two years ago, also wages. Appealed it and won. Gather every pay stub from the year before you got hurt, and if any SDI deductions show on them that EDD might have missed, bring those up in writing when you go before the judge.

0 coins

Wait, there's actually a judge involved? I thought it was just like, reviewing paperwork.

0 coins

There is an administrative law judge who reviews it, yeah. You can request an in-person hearing or submit written stuff, I did written and it worked out fine.

0 coins

To add to what she said, the appeal form asks you to explain why you disagree with the denial. Be specific there, the more detail the better for the judge reviewing it.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what my doctor's office submitted, and the whole thing sat in limbo for two weeks before I figured it out. I tried calling EDD's disability line to sort it out and couldn't get a person for three days straight. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach an agent, and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my provider used was off by one digit. Video on getting a live person at EDD's disability line if that's useful: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I gave the right number to the office and they resubmitted, things moved.

0 coins

The receipt number issue is exactly what caught me too. Phoned EDD the same way and the agent told me my Notice of Computation had already been generated but was sitting there because the certification hadn't matched yet. Knowing that at least told me what step I was actually on.

0 coins

My problem is different, the base period wages, but I appreciate knowing there are ways to actually reach someone. Three days of busy signals would break me right now.

0 coins

While your appeal is in, you can still certify if EDD asks you to. Don't stop doing what they tell you to do on your end just because there's a denial sitting there.

0 coins

Even with the denial? They can still ask me to certify?

0 coins

The appeal keeps the claim alive. Keep responding to anything they send.

0 coins

This is the part people miss and it costs them.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline on the appeal matters. The date on the denial notice is what you count from, not when you received it. If you already sent the DE 1000A you're fine, just make sure you kept a copy.

0 coins

I sent it certified mail so I have tracking. Good call keeping a copy, I did that too.

0 coins

Certified mail was smart. If there's ever a question about whether it arrived on time, you have proof.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke. Called nine times one week trying to ask a simple question about my denial. Never got through. The whole system makes you feel like you're supposed to just give up.

0 coins

Yep. That's pretty much the design.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online does work for some things if you can't get through by phone. Not as fast as talking to someone but it's something.

0 coins

Tried that too. Response took forever and didn't actually answer what I asked.

0 coins

One thing about filing a second claim that hasn't been said yet: if your disability period is the same, EDD will likely see both and treat the second one as duplicative. Appealing the first is cleaner.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of, that it would just confuse things. Appeal it is.

0 coins

Yep. Two claims for the same injury at the same time is a mess you don't want.

0 coins

Payment date on mine came up wrong after my claim finally moved forward, showed issued but nothing hit my account for days. I tried that disability line a few times and the mornings I called were useless. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and she told me the payment had been issued on the 14th and to wait through the weekend before worrying. It had posted by Monday.

0 coins

That line has been unusable in my experience too. I've tried from 8:05 am on three separate Tuesdays and hit the same wall every time. How did you know the payment date without getting through first?

0 coins

Waiting on a payment that shows issued but hasn't appeared would be so stressful. Glad that worked out.

0 coins

On the base period wage question: EDD looks at a 12-month stretch broken into four quarters, and your weekly amount is calculated from whichever of those quarters had the highest wages. If your earnings were thin across all four, that's where the denial comes from. The appeal is the place to show if EDD miscounted any of it.

0 coins

This actually helps me understand what happened. My highest quarter was okay but not great. Would the appeal let me show earnings they maybe didn't count?

0 coins

Yes. If you have pay stubs showing CASDI deductions that weren't reflected in EDD's calculation, that's exactly what to bring up with the administrative law judge.

0 coins

Any W-2s from that period would help too. The CASDI line is the one that matters.

0 coins

Former coworker went through a wage-based denial and her appeal actually won! She had a quarter where her employer filed the wage report late and EDD initially didn't see it. Once that showed up the math worked out. Worth double-checking whether all your quarters got reported.

0 coins

Oh that's a really good point. I had a weird overlap with two employers that quarter. That could be it.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of thing to raise in writing at the hearing. Bring documentation from both employers.

0 coins

cant you just refile once ur back to work and use different dates? like make it a new injury period

0 coins

If you're still out with the same condition, it's the same disability period. EDD would tie a new claim to the existing one.

0 coins

oh okay that makes sense then

0 coins

There's also the question of timing. EDD says you need to file within 49 days of when the disability starts. Same condition, same start date, so a new claim doesn't reset that clock.

0 coins

DE 2593 came in the mail after I'd been on automatic payments for a while, and I nearly missed the 20-day window to return it. Phoned the disability line several mornings in a row and couldn't reach anyone. Ended up trying Claimyr to get through, and when I finally had an agent, she confirmed the form was in my file already, I'd actually mailed it in time and EDD had it. Knowing that saved me a week of worry.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

20 days to return that form is not a lot of time, especially when you're not feeling well. Good to know it exists though.

0 coins

To answer the original question more directly: California EDD's rules don't stop you from filing a new claim while an appeal is pending. The issue is whether a new claim would succeed. For a wage-based denial, the base period on a new claim filed now would overlap heavily with the first one, so you'd likely face the same result. Appealing the first claim is the logical path if the wages are the issue.

0 coins

This is the clearest answer yet. So it's not against the rules, it just probably wouldn't help me. I'll stay focused on the appeal.

0 coins

That's the right read. A new claim would only make sense if something material changed, like a new injury starting after a gap of full recovery.

0 coins

my coworker's claim got denied for the same reason and she kept filing the same claim over and over trying to fix it, lol. EDD finally told her to appeal the first one. don't do what she did

0 coins

Ha, I appreciate the warning. I went straight to the appeal so hopefully I'm already on the right track.

0 coins

yeah you're doing it right. she wasted like 6 weeks before figuring that out

0 coins

Does the appeal hearing cost anything? Like is there a filing fee or something?

0 coins

No fee to appeal. The DE 1000A is free and you don't need a lawyer, though you're allowed to bring one.

0 coins

No fees. The administrative law judge hearing is part of the process EDD lays out in the denial notice itself.

0 coins

Okay good. I was nervous about that.

0 coins

Late appeal is worth knowing about too. If you missed the 30-day window for some reason, you can still file and explain why you were late. An administrative law judge looks at the reason. Not guaranteed, but it's not automatically rejected either.

0 coins

Mine went in on time but good to know that's not a hard cutoff for everyone.

0 coins

That detail is in the appeal instructions on the denial notice. EDD says to include an explanation for the delay if you're past the deadline.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in and I couldn't tell what it was actually saying, the language in those things is dense. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent because I had been redialing that line most of the morning and nothing. Agent told me the notice was a denial, that I had 30 days from the date on it to appeal, and confirmed which form I needed. Anyway filed the DE 1000A the same day.

0 coins

Nice work getting it in same day. Those notices are written badly.

0 coins

The notice language thing is real. Mine used terms I had to look up.

0 coins

Just to clarify something from earlier in the thread: the waiting period is seven days at the start of a new claim and it's not payable. It's not processing time, it's a built-in unpaid stretch. If a denial gets overturned on appeal and EDD reopens the claim, that waiting period already happened at the beginning.

0 coins

wait so those 7 days are just gone no matter what

0 coins

For the original claim, yes. First seven days of disability are never paid out.

0 coins

Okay so even if I win the appeal, those first 7 days aren't part of what they'd pay me. Got it.

0 coins

Hope the appeal goes your way. Wage denials are worth fighting.

0 coins

Thank you. I've got all my pay stubs pulled already.

0 coins

That prep work is exactly what helps at the hearing!

0 coins

Keep the denial notice somewhere safe. The date printed on it, not the date you got it, is the one that sets your 30-day appeal window. If you need to contact EDD during this time, SDI Online's Request Claim Update is the most reliable way to get a written record of what you asked and when.

0 coins

I didn't realize the date I received it doesn't count. I'll double check that the date on my DE 1000A references the notice date.

0 coins

That's exactly right. And certified mail records you already have will back you up if anything about timing gets questioned.

0 coins

EDD denies a lot of valid claims on first pass. The appeal exists for a reason. Use it.

0 coins

This. Don't treat the denial like it's final.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring to hear from people who've been through it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure